今季的Trinity GESE

helenli

Trinity HK office 說今次三四月份很少人拿A, 因為今次是最後一次沒有年齡限制，很多考生根本未達標就報考。其中grade 3拿A的人更是少之又少。

ma1015

我都想反影下當天考試的環境有吵耳的裝修嘈音，我向在埸的大人講話也差點聽不到，那麼小朋友又怎能得到合理成績呢？

Harrietyee

回復 roybee103 的帖子

支持!

roybee103

原帖由 helenli 於 12-05-08 發表
回復 Harrietyee 的帖子

咁都得? 不過我幫朋友個女打去問點解咁低分時, 佢都係咁同我講, 話攞C就一定係個 ...

但今次係有太多不滿既聲音
就連英語為母語既小朋友可以fail。事件反映考試有漏洞！要認真跟進。我而家已經收到大概10個投訴，必要時我會去信媒體反映

helenli

回復 Harrietyee 的帖子

咁都得? 不過我幫朋友個女打去問點解咁低分時, 佢都係咁同我講, 話攞C就一定係個小朋友準備唔夠, 呢個考試係要出去CENTRE學, 唔係你地家長係屋企教就得, 我馬上同佢講我個仔都無出去學喎, 三次都攞distinction(剛剛呢次三月考grade 3), 佢就話咁你仔仔水準一定好高嘞, 然後就講其他嘢, 唔評論會唔會係考官評分標準不一致.  不過好老實我相信今次大家就算集體投訴, 佢最多只會叫你比錢appeal, 佢地內部會聽返錄音, 唔會就某位考官而個別調查.  就好似校際音樂比賽, 間中都會出現啲騎呢評判, 口味與別不同, 賽果幾唔公平都好難投訴.

Harrietyee

回復 helenli 的帖子

之前打去COMPLAIN,  個Angie Lee仲話你學間CENTRE可能不OK, 足5 AGE你去ENGLISH EXCEL 學完再考啦!
指到明要去個間學先A, 我都對這考試全沒信心了!

roybee103

原帖由 healthybaby 於 12-04-25 發表
收到成績我都有d唔開心, 阿仔4歲,考G2得pass, 之前考G1都distinction. 所以以為佢表現唔好,聽完你地講後,或 ...

Healthy baby : I will help if u wanna get a fair result.

roybee103

原帖由 helenli 於 12-05-03 發表
回復 Harrietyee 的帖子

我朋友女兒(六歲)無出去學, 但準備得好好, 因我同佢練習過, 雖發音不是十分地道,  ...

Helen, let me know if u want a fair result. I will fight for our right.

roybee103

原帖由 Harrietyee 於 12-05-03 發表
我女女AUG2011都考了Grade 1 distinction(A), DEC2011考Grade 2 佢太眼訓,哭住入去考, 結果only pass(C),  ...

Tell me if u wanna complain about it

roybee103

原帖由 Joyce.Wong 於 12-05-03 發表
我小朋友四歲考Grade1, 得Merit, 我也很失望。我們是美國人，在家是用英語溝通, 不過我只用了一個月去準備 ...

Joyce, wonder if u wanna complain about it. If so, I m happy to be the one who speak out for all the parents.

roybee103

既然有那麼多家長不滿及對此考試成績有懷疑。我願意做代表為大家爭取重考。如果有需要的家長可以在這裡回覆你的名字，我會pm你們資料
我們要一個公平公正的考試

teletubby

To be fair, my daughter got G1 and G2 A.( we prepared it at home just with the information of the website and the video on website, no sylbs.or no exercise)
After coming out from Sheung Wan, I didn't even ask her one question because the school told us don't ask questions about the exam for preparing the P.1 interview, I was really curious how good the GESE. But she said she likes it and enjoy it very much and ask for the third times, it means G3.I said I won't appy for her, it was too expensive and for the P.1, few certs and cups enough.

Then one day, she told me about the content of the exam. She said the examinar asked her whether she has pet. Of course this question we well prepared. Then she asked back the examinar. so...do you have pets? He said I have a cat. My girl asked back, what colour of it. .....blah...blah... then suddenly the examinar talked about his mother has a hen. My daughter asked whether it is white or red. I suprised she asked this question, in my mind, white or brown hen, haha.... However, I think about of Oxford Reading Tree there is a Phonic book. The red hen...sth like that.

The examinar didn't ask about time, luckily, otherwise, I won't sure how she will answer a quarter to three or a quarter pass three...

The examinar did ask her age, but my girl will answer more than that...she was 4 years old. When is her birthday? we prepared both parents birthdays information and even grandma(the one sometimes who takes care of her)

What I wanted to say, to be fair, you really didn't know how good or bad when they were inside. Unless they told you everything. To be relaxed. It is just an exam. You may appy it second or third times, the certificates won't show how many times you did.  

Give yourself a break.
More important is preparing the P.1 face to face interview.

Joyce.Wong

我小朋友四歲考Grade1, 得Merit, 我也很失望。我們是美國人，在家是用英語溝通, 不過我只用了一個月去準備。只有5歲再考多次啦, 不過不會放Merit在portfolio了。

strawberry11

我覺得1個4、5歲小朋友去考grade 3 ，有幾多真的明白 天氣 absolute freezing / boiling， 看日歷、 學校subjects ，乜叫chemistry、geograhy 又或city 、 town  分別... 仲要形容 historic / Industrial ，加上 職業 乜叫 accountant / secretary    我覺得是父母對小朋友要求 / 期望過高， 不是考官的問題   (不喜勿插)

helenli

回復 roybee103 的帖子

請問你是在邊個CENTRE考? 我朋友的女兒在大角咀一間學英文的地方考, 考官個名是Mr B Milward, 她的成績都係低於預期好多.

helenli

回復 Harrietyee 的帖子

我朋友女兒(六歲)無出去學, 但準備得好好, 因我同佢練習過, 雖發音不是十分地道, 但有問有答, 句子完整清晰, 但今次考G2也只有C, 我地都覺得好訝異, 我代朋友打去TRINITY問Angie Lee, 她說準備呢個考試係要出去學, 唔係我地家長自己在家練下就得, 我馬上表示唔同意, 因為我個仔(六歲)自舊年起至今次四月連續三次考G1-G3都拿A, 都無出去學的, 李小姐就解釋了好多考試準則, 又說今次考試好多小朋友年紀細, 程度未夠, 並唔係因為考試標準提高左. 而今次攞到A的人就好少, Grade 3考官比左好少好少個A.  另外一提係我上星期去上環攞CERT, 見到張list, Grade 3合格有CERT的人真係好少, 大約只有三四十個.

Harrietyee

我女女AUG2011都考了Grade 1 distinction(A), DEC2011考Grade 2 佢太眼訓,哭住入去考, 結果only pass(C), 自行報考
於是我比錢上COURSE, 加自己在家操，　MARCH2012 再考G2 & G3 TOGETHER, 老師話G2佢DISTINCTION沒問題, G3可能ONLY (B OR C) as she is only 4YR 3ＭＯＮＴＨＳ　 when she takes the exam
考試當日佢笑住出來很有自信說答得非常完整,考官說她WELL DONE, 她還完整地告訴我們考了什麼,她答了什麼但結果是G2 PASS ONLY(C agian), G3 FAIL,
我們都很不開心, 全間CENTRE本來90 %考生取A, 但今次一個A 都沒有, G1 只有 2 個B, 很多C, G2全是C, G3 只有一人PASS,
結果我第二天打去TRINITY問,為什麼今次評分這麼不同, 我個小朋友哭住不太出聲和笑住答完整句子都是同樣分數，張分紙完全沒評語，我想上訴聽回錄音，但佢地話要全ＣＥＮＴＲＥ的考生都認為有問題先可以經ＣＥＮＴＲＥ上訴，我怎會有能力叫全ＣＥＮＴＲＥ　的ＭＵＭ　ＡＮＤ　ＤＡＤ陪我上訴呀，而且錄音是ＴＲＩＮＩＴＹ自己聽，如果加分先話你聽，　但要先收錢
我問她是否因為今次最後一次比５　ＡＧＥ　以下小朋友考，所以突然提高要求？佢話晤是，但考官考晤見意小朋友太小考，希望ＡＧＥ　５考Ｇ１，　ＡＧＥ　６考Ｇ２，　ＡＧＥ　７　先考Ｇ３，　考官認為ＡＧＥ　４　太小了，　所以真的很生氣，點解報考前不說，浪費我們的心血和時間，跟本一入去第二條句問題問ＨＯＷ　ＯＬＤ　ＡＲＥ　Ｕ？已經決定了你的分數

teletubby

回復 roybee103 的帖子

roybee103

我和大家情況很相似，我的兒子於半年前考獲Gese grade 1 distinction。但在上月的grade 2 竟然failed！我覺得根本沒可能，因為小兒從小就以英語溝通，而我亦是一名英語教師。看見這個成績非常詫異及不忿。因為以我所知，考官Mr Bernard 很不認同考生五歲前考這個試，而評分也十分緊。據我所知我的考場不止我一個拿到這麼差的成績。有起碼三個考生在Grade1是亦是distinction但考Grade2是failed。
我覺得grade1和2根本無可能差距那麼大。於是打電話去投訴！要求補考。職員說不可補考 ，唯有是等到兒子五歲時再自費重新考！我現在很想各位受害家長聯名投訴！這是一個很不公平的考試！

healthybaby

收到成績我都有d唔開心, 阿仔4歲,考G2得pass, 之前考G1都distinction. 所以以為佢表現唔好,聽完你地講後,或者真係嚴左!
如果做portfolio,你地會放 G1 DISTINCTION, OR G2 PASS 呢?