學之園 VS Boxhill VS 翠茵

TKO_NANA

小女現有以下offers,這些KG都是我當初心目中的no. 1,2,3,而經過參觀校園和Interview經歷,排名也有些不同,各位住TKO既媽媽可否幫手給下意見? Many thanks!!!

翠茵 pm offer - 第一間interview的KG,也是離家最近的一間,步行往返只需5分鐘;
                        對這間學校的感覺是不差也不是最好,雖在商場內,但都算大,而老師和ee也親切,是TKO區
                        內口碑不錯的學校.....

Boxhill am offer - 離家有3個地鐵站,唯一的am offer,就讀後會親自送囡囡番學再上班;
                           由於interview前已in過數間其他的KG,囡囡的反應不錯,很合作,外籍老師十分親切,唱歌
                           講故事時也很生動,其他老師,ee也有禮,給家長們很受尊重的感覺,全面的英語學習環
                           境;但位於商場2樓,不算大,也不是很細,學費是3間入面最貴的一間;

學之園pm offer - 原本是最想入的KG,但Open Day參觀過學校後,覺得交通真的不便,囡囡interview時也
                           表現麻麻,老師問問題,她的回答好像有蚊子飛過般細聲,最後兩part,更因為我不肯再給
                           她零食而爆喊,原本打定輸數,想不到收到pm offer.......interview當日,老師不算很親切,
                           外籍老師的故事時間也不算生動(只是我的感覺,不喜者勿插),但學之園的課程是出了名
                           的好,升讀我心儀的直資和私立學校的比率也高,名氣也是3間入面最大......

littlepigsheep

Km school bus is so "efficient"! I am living in TKL too, KT Cannan said their school bus takes around 1 hour or more!

retriever

回復 cycream 的帖子

tks for your info.. so, it takes around 30 min. is it the same for the return journey?
btw, where is the pickup pt?

tks again

cycream

retriever 發表於 12-4-5 18:44
回復 cycream 的帖子

u got your pt.  many feel the location of lp campus is tricky...

I am living at Tiu Keng Leng.  my son studied at KM N1, school bus picked up at 8:25am, school starts at 9am. he is now studying at SC K1, school bus is much earlier, 8:00am, school starts at 8:50am.  If you drive, it is around half an hour.

retriever

回復 cycream 的帖子

u got your pt.  many feel the location of lp campus is tricky...

where r u living in tko? and which klt kg did u choose eventually?

wondering how long would it take from tko to klt kg.

we 've got an offer from york.. it would be kind of hassle if not moving home...

cycream

retriever 發表於 12-4-5 18:15
concerning the placement results of different LH campus, i discussed it with my boss... it is likely ...

I have different thought as your boss.  I think TY & TKO is different case. I think TKO parents are more willing to send their kids outside TKO district, especially to Kln Tong area.  It is very common for TKO kids to study outside TKO area.  Moreover, LP campus is not convenient (if in other area of TKO, it may be better), together with bad enivornment, I don't think it does attractive best students in TKO district.  

My elder son got K1 KM, SC & LH (LP) offers last year, I kicked out LH offer first, struggling between KM & SC.  The reason is I really don't like the location of LP campus.   

retriever

cycream 發表於 12-4-5 17:19
我覺得pn+group in好難用表現來估計入唔入, 彩數最緊要, 所以唔駛打定輸數. KM PM係國際班(E/P Class), 所 ...

concerning the placement results of different LH campus, i discussed it with my boss... it is likely that the LH in TY could attract the best students in TW, TY area where there are not many competivite kg, while LH in HH would need to compete with those kg in KLT. HH campus has the most worst placement result among LH campus, however it is still good enough for a private kg, just not as brilliant as that of TY campus.

my wishful thinking is LH LP could repeat what they did for TY campus, as there are not many famous kg in tko area or even east kowloon side.

cycream

TKO_NANA 發表於 12-4-5 16:50
我囡好慢熱,KM係Group-in形式面試,我囡當日的表現,只能用一個字形容,就係"呆"囉.....KM係九龍區最多人考 ...

我覺得pn+group in好難用表現來估計入唔入, 彩數最緊要, 所以唔駛打定輸數. KM PM係國際班(E/P Class), 所以唔一定入唔到AM班架!

今年KM,SC,LH全部唔IN細B,唔駛煩. 我細仔係confirm讀boxhill,request 咗轉AM,希望轉到,我連翠茵,得寶都無去IN啦. 壘埋心水讀boxhill, 9月再戰k1.

你就煩d, 如果AM / PM係咁concern, 就boxhill啦. 我覺得LH係好, but真係唔鍾意LP個地點,而且LP分校好新,未有P1入讀history, 係咪會好無人知(我見LH都唔係間間分校P1都考得好).  

TKO_NANA

cycream 發表於 12-4-5 12:14
如果我無記錯, 你要係想K1轉Kln Tong 既kg, right? 而加km未出result wor! 你等埋km,

如果km收就唔駛諗呢 ...

我囡好慢熱,KM係Group-in形式面試,我囡當日的表現,只能用一個字形容,就係"呆"囉.....KM係九龍區最多人考的KG之一,我們根本不可能入選,就算真係咁好彩,最多只有pm offer,如果又係pm,我更有可能選較近的LH.......

我哋暫時無意升讀IS小學,我對下午班有保留,不只因為怕囡囡無時間午睡,還有就是擔心囡囡不是太晚睡覺,就是沒有時間見面......我聽身邊朋友和同事的分享,佢哋有小朋友讀下午班,一個仔仔每晚12點先睡(可能因為回家後有小睡),已經K2了,但看上去還是很矮小;另一個囡囡放學回家後沒有小睡,晚上一早就上床睡(8,9點),我同事晚晚陪佢早睡,睡到2點就起床做自己野,然後個囡早上6,7點起床,佢又跟住醒,不用說,這樣在職媽咪當然辛苦了.......

cycream,你細仔將入讀pm class(是否已落實讀BH?),你有什麼看法?

TKO_NANA

Gerard 發表於 12-4-4 11:13
和我去年的情況一樣，我和Greenville 的老師很熟，也都放棄Greenville 改LH, 因為顧及到上K班，LH考小學越 ...

真的好叻,難怪很多家長也給予LH很高的評價......

TKO_NANA

ggsbb 發表於 12-4-4 08:49
我都有同感。我個女18個月時上咗兩個月boxhill PG,  老師唔係Net問題唔大，課堂內容有d單調，成半個鐘都係 ...

我想PG同PN的課程是不同的,呢個我都有D信心,我反而真的不太喜歡佢位於商場內,被很多食肆,商舖包圍.....

TKO_NANA

littlepigsheep 發表於 12-4-3 23:50
我都留左am 位。 仔仔一歲多少少時我上過兩個月boxhill PG, 感覺比其他PG hea， 每堂既變化不大。 我覺得老 ...

但是康城分校的校外環境也不理想,不遠處常有很多大貨車,卡車經過,夏天時開冷氣就不用開窗,不開冷氣的日子,我想也不要開窗好過,不然很擔心室外的嘈音和沙塵影響小朋友呢......

TKO_NANA

retriever 發表於 12-4-3 23:49
my 2 cent.

boxhill could provide a very good english environment. however, if u target on local sch ...

Retriever,你的分析很正確,這正正就是我在BH和LH之間猶疑不決的原因........

TKO_NANA

pekkle321 發表於 12-4-4 01:27
咁當然如果你想大抽獎，GV會冇問題！但佢私小record一般囉！

如果無其他更好的offer,翠茵當然是一個不錯的選擇,話晒有英普,又近我屋企,學費也不算很貴,應該還是3千幾吧?而且在區內口碑好像真的不錯,無論係我老公同事(住TKO),在公園玩時認識的媽咪,搭地鐵時閒聊了2句的媽咪,佢哋既小朋友都係讀翠茵的......但我都要考慮埋升小的往績,呢方面翠茵同LH比較,當然讀LH考到心儀的直資/私小的機會會高些啦!

cycream

如果我無記錯, 你要係想K1轉Kln Tong 既kg, right? 而加km未出result wor! 你等埋km,

如果km收就唔駛諗呢3間. 如果唔收, 我都會係LH同BH 2選一.  如果你有信心k1可以考到kln tong既kg, 咁LH同BH都無咩大分別, 我會選BH, AM offer, 加上我都唔係好鐘意LH既地點 (LP環境+from mtr行好遠, 除非school bus). 如果無信心考k1, 就LH可以打底升到K3. BH so far話好d人, 讀完n1, k1都走啦,  我講野assume你唔係想升int'l school既小學.  

ggsbb

回復 ggsbb 的帖子

delete

TTNCL

我個仔上左兩個月boxhill pg 又ok bor。個先生兩個月之後係地鐵見到佢仲聊佢。 不過係ft boxhill

ggsbb

原帖由 littlepigsheep 於 12-04-03 發表
我都留左am 位。 仔仔一歲多少少時我上過兩個月boxhill PG, 感覺比其他PG hea， 每堂既變化不大。 我覺得老 ...

我都有同感。我個女18個月時上咗兩個月boxhill PG,  老師唔係Net問題唔大，課堂內容有d單調，成半個鐘都係坐係地下。我都覺得佢對小朋友唔係特別有愛心，頭一二堂個女未習慣坐定，好奇咁走出去想模老師手上面既蘋果，老師既反應竟然係黑面同收埋個蘋果係身後唔俾佢掂，我感覺係老師未好有經驗應付小朋友。

不過以上都係講PG，PN係點我就真係唔清楚。

pekkle321

咁當然如果你想大抽獎，GV會冇問題！但佢私小record一般囉！