培正 vs SPK

beautyan

培正 AM K1 及 SPK PM K1 都收了囡囡, 現正煩惱緊點選擇.

有老師的意見認為, SPK 屬於天主教學校, 會比較嚴謹一些, 服從性的要求亦高一些.  而培正是基督教學校, 相對上對小朋友的要求比較包容一些.  而我囡囡比較被動, 所以應該是培正適合一些.

另外, 聽說 SPK 不喜歡收細妹 (我囡囡是家姐), 而培正收細妹的機會就高一些.

煩請各位給些意見, 例如還有那些方面我未考慮, 還有那些其他資料我需要注意的呢?

我知兩間都是好學校, 所以想為囡囡做個最好最全面的決定.

謝謝!

tanglulu

nowadays maybe not 1% but is around 10 %!
but is much better than other school already!

eschung

As a parent of SPK, here are what I can share.  Hope they help you make your choice.

1) In my days, almost 99% from SPK (girls only) were promoted to primary. As long as the primary students can pass all subjects, ie Chinese, Maths, English, General Studies, they will be promoted to secondary school.
2) There are  only two exams and two tests in each primary year.  There is no pressure in study and your kid will have plently of time for reading and participating in extra-curricular activities.  
2) The school will not discriminate  small sisters.  It all depends on their capabities in order to be accepted.
3) The Principal of primary section is very kind to her students.  Those who fail in the exam are usually given the second chance unless they have poor conduct.
4) School life is happy.

I would suggest you visit both schools and their websites before you make your final decision.  

ceriselung

我會選近屋企，因2個都係好學校

Sumin

有朋友講過

beautyan

我都正在考慮搬近一點。

另外我想請問, 有無聽聞 SPK 會將它們認為不適合學校教學模式或教學要求的學生讙退?

siden

For kindergarten stage you can still travel between shatin and cwb without too much disturb on child's daily routine.

In primary travel time is too long. Unless you can find a good schoolbus with few pick up points.

hayley1328

如果考慮SPK的可能要搬屋好點，每日沙田到灣仔實在太辛苦了

MrMrsEast

beautyan 發表於 12-3-9 16:59
謝謝意見.  我是住沙田的.  請問知否 SFK 有無校車到沙田?

另想請問, 不是傳統的幼稚園及小學都是用中文教 ...

Shatin... an hour or more per trip, that is, 2 - 2.5 hrs on transportation everyday.
When primary, the situation is worst as it will be a full day school for St Paul.
Seems PC is better for your kid

MrMrsEast

SPK, for sure, they dont "buy" the idea of accepting siblings. Child got it only becoz their own performance (many of my fds has 2 daughters studying in diff school.... so tedious)

For PC, has to have other ppl giving opinion on this

323

beautyan 發表於 12-3-9 16:59
謝謝意見.  我是住沙田的.  請問知否 SFK 有無校車到沙田?

另想請問, 不是傳統的幼稚園及小學都是用中文教 ...

無校車去沙田, 不過有褓母車.

唔熟培正, 不過SPC小學部好似中英數合格已經可以升班, 而且中學部係直資, 壓力應該比培小細D?

可以參考下SPC中學既成績, 又或者去兩間學校既網址參考下往年既annual report

click

iantsang

培正 is indeed 英書中教.  In fact, this is not strange at all before EDB intervene the medium of instructions on each aided secondary school.  It was a common thing in most of HK schools.

The importance is it provide a choice, a choice for parents and children who are suitable for this method of learning.  Not all kids are the same and they will need different teaching methods to make their learning effective.

Ian

（純粹個人分享）

wonderland07

英書中教的中文中學？這麼奇怪？而且是唯一一間？

beautyan

我在網上看到的資料是：培中雖然是中文中學，但它是全港唯一一間獲教統局批准英書中教的中文中學。請問是否屬實？

個人認為中書中教會令將來銜接大學的課程有問題。而英書英教則會增加大部份學生在理解上的困難。所以英書中教才是比較好的方案。

beautyan

仲想問 SPK 是否不承諾直升小學?  是否只會說收大部份 SPK 的學生?

培正在入學須知信上是清楚寫明 "幼稚園畢業生可直升本校小一年級" 的.

wonderland07

培中好似是中文中學； 中書中教！

LL222

I vote for SPK
But why SPK 不喜歡收細妹 (我囡囡是家姐)???