KV vs 學之園

意粉媽媽629

希望大家俾d意見:1) 小兒宜家讀緊學之園N, 好開心, 已經學緊phonics同中文字, k1會有net同native 普通話老師, 眼見校內小朋友都係好開心同好有自信, 好presentable, 好自由, 升小一 6 成直資/私立
2) KV offer(K1), 但對KV 了解不多, 朋友意見都是中數強, 自律性高, 多功課, 英文要外補, 無net/native老師...希望讀緊既媽媽俾d意見及提供一下升小一既情況
Thank you Thank you好頭痛, 萬分感激...

ho_yan2406

原帖由 lukimama 於 11-12-4 21:16 發表
ho_yan2406, btw which LH campus is your kid studying?

really thanks for your time on explaining the LH situation for us!

tsing yi

lukimama

ho_yan2406, btw which LH campus is your kid studying?

really thanks for your time on explaining the LH situation for us!

ho_yan2406

原帖由 lukimama 於 11-12-2 15:03 發表
你個比喻講得好好呀!

而家D小學大部份都係傳統教學, 都唔係我可以想點就點, 我個仔好好動, 我覺得LHK啱佢,但佢有時都幾naughty, 冇哂紀律, 阿媽阿爸叫佢都唔踩你, 會唔會KV教到佢乖d定d呢?咁我同c6就唔駛咁勞氣. ...

LH都可以教到小朋友乖,我個仔自己讀左k1後,乖左,成熟左,大膽左,禮貌左

lnp

They are all good.
Why make a change?

lukimama

Very appreciate of your detailed comments, hoihoimam, thanks!

for my kid, maybe it is too early to draw a conclusion yet, since the school just started for 3 months, maybe my kid will show improvement in discipline. Do you observe any worst disciplined students in LHK? I hope the school not just emphazie on language development, but also the discipline.

小韋寶

Then i wanna ask those kids who go to LH, do they speak eng as if they are native speaker, or their level are as good as int'l school??  my niece is going to look for a kinder next yr, so wanna get more info about the eng level of those students in LH.   Thanks a lot.

原帖由 hoihoima 於 11-12-2 17:59 發表
It seems that I forgot to say that my kid is in LH.

hoihoima

It seems that I forgot to say that my kid is in LH.

hoihoima

My son is in K3 PTH/ENG class.  I can say the lanuage environment in school is excellent and this is what I want.  

The teachers encourage students to share their opinion, go out to present in front of classmates and small group discussions.  As you said, the students are generally presentable.  

The Chinese and English levels are both good, learn a lot of words, have dictation from K3 1st term, will have weekly journal from K3 2nd term.  The Maths syllabus emphasizes on understanding of Maths concept and the school has not yet put much focus on training the speed and accuracy of addition and subtraction.  I let my kid study Enopi Math to improve Math skills.

In terms of homework, K2 and K3 students have 3 homework everyday.  In K3, 3 homework includes writing one page of Chinese words, one page of English words and a worksheet - language or Maths.  Making sentence in Chinese & English every week (this is what my kid likes most).  During weekend will have some more homework.  During long holiday has a special exercise book to complete.

The school provide excellent support for P1 interview, they provide altogether 20 lessons free of charge interview class to K2 (2nd term) and K3 (1st term) students.  The interview class is held on Satuaday and is 1.5 hour per lesson.  Each lesson includes mock interview by teachers that the students are not familar with and the mock interview is conducted in Cantonese, English and Madarin in different weeks, group game, exercise, etc.  In addition to the interview class, the school provide a lot of interview type exercises for students to practice at home with parents, such as listening, reading comprehension, games, creative drawing, game cards to tell story, etc.  These exercises are done on a voluntary basis and do not need to submit to school.  Really is many and sometimes we don't have enough time to finish at home......

My kid got several primary school offers so far - WKF, Pui Kiu, TSL, ICQM, TT.  Still have some more interviews for other schools.

wchow10

DEL

lukimama

你個比喻講得好好呀!

而家D小學大部份都係傳統教學, 都唔係我可以想點就點, 我個個好好動, 我覺得LHK啱佢,但佢有時都幾naughty, 冇哂紀律, 阿媽阿爸叫佢都唔踩你, 會唔會KV教到佢乖d定d呢?咁我同c6就唔駛咁勞氣.

Christi

very true !

wchow10

DEL

lukimama

多謝大家既COMMENT, KV收左PM班, LHK收AM英普, 擔心完PN, 又要擔心K1, 到而家又要擔心小學, 會唔會係我諗得太多呢?

Christi

其實小囡只是一位蛀書蟲而已.

yes,PN 都要學認成30幾個中文字. 咁我覺得一啲都唔簡單. 而今日又見到個高班的LH學生的閱讀習作,佢係用英文寫(題目:踏單車須注意事項): I need to make sure I have a helmet. 仲有另外3個points,都係啲要留意車軚有冇氣等等. 係成句英文自己寫的.
actually,串字練習/造句練習...都係呢條題目中反映出來.

[ 本帖最後由 Christi 於 11-11-30 16:12 編輯 ]

ho_yan2406

原帖由 lukimama 於 11-11-29 22:06 發表
意粉媽媽, KV收左你AM定PM?
我都想比較呢2間.
LHK真係好好, 唔捨得走, 但KV平D, 講真, 如果我決定KV, 我又唔會比$出去學PHONICS/ PTH, 如果唔係不如留係LHK.
我個寶貝較為ACTIVE, 都有D擔心KV會否合適, 但又會唔會 ...

active的話LH岩d...我覺得LH學術都唔差,教d字都幾深,我差不多日日都要同個仔溫d字,因為2,3星期就評估一次

ho_yan2406

原帖由 porporchi 於 11-11-29 23:58 發表
我都覺得LH o係language 既exposure 會好過KV, 不過出去考小學kv個名又大過LH好多

LH學費41XX, kv2488, 我反而覺得出去Playgroup 係就係會辛苦d, 不過我先生認為出去playgroup class size細好多，專注好多, 又可以問 ...

但有樣野要考慮既就係佢地放左學再去playgroup會唔會好累?
我仔下午仲要nap,所以乜都冇學...
但如果只係星期六日去playgroup,功效又唔大...

ho_yan2406

原帖由 Christi 於 11-11-29 23:32 發表
我會覺得,在LH係每星期5日日日都有英/普(仲要係佔各半時間,which is around 1.5hrs), 但出去補英/普,最多一周2次每次1小時. 如果我係重視語文的,就會選前者,如果唔計屋企影響,前者學英普的效果一定比去返補習大(反正 ...

k1已識寫咁多字?你囡囡好叻呀...

porporchi

我都覺得LH o係language 既exposure 會好過KV, 不過出去考小學kv個名又大過LH好多

LH學費41XX, kv2488, 我反而覺得出去Playgroup 係就係會辛苦d, 不過我先生認為出去playgroup class size細好多，專注好多, 又可以問番老師小朋友情況, 所以都係一個好Option!

多考慮一樣野就係如果而家小朋友係LH讀ENG+CHI 而唔係ENG+PTH, 咁樣我會揀KV for sure, 如果係ENG+PTH 咁樣就多左吸引力, 可以再諗諗!

Christi

我會覺得,在LH係每星期5日日日都有英/普(仲要係佔各半時間,which is around 1.5hrs), 但出去補英/普,最多一周2次每次1小時. 如果我係重視語文的,就會選前者,如果唔計屋企影響,前者學英普的效果一定比去返補習大(反正學費包埋,而且唔駛周車勞頓).

而且,學phonics係呢個年紀的小朋友掌握英文(even spelling)的最好工具,如果學校有教係最好的. 我囡在LH K1,今日先自己係張紙上寫 Do you know you are naughty 畀我  (大細楷撈到亂晒). 囡囡為人幾靜,但我都覺得LH好啱佢,從來冇考慮過KV.