【女拔】是否會踼人出校 ?

chumamma

我朋友A個囡游泳好多獎, 成績麻麻一般, 她前年已升讀女拔中學, 還是免費不用交學費的。

家長B 同我講 : 如果 A 同學不能在校內繼續攞獎, 女拔中學會勸喻  A 同學 轉校。

請問學校是否會如此做法, 因為我不相信會是這樣無情。 我又懷疑 家長B 的講法, 所以想求證一下, 謝謝。

ANChan59

Quite the same as DBS....

yumommom

My daughter is also in DGS and in Form 5 now. Base on my experience and learned from my daughter, I don't think that DGS will kick out a student because she is underformed in sports(even though she was admitted because of her sports achievement). Rather, DGS will ask you to repeat if you really cannot catch up academically. That means if you did OK in academic perfermance, even though you refuse to participate in sports competition, the school will allow. My daughter is the case. So pl don't blind guess.

My advice to those parents who have girls got talent in sports but poor at academic performance is that they should have second thought to send their girls to DGS. Since the girls there are very smart, some of them can got 100 marks in exam but some can got 10 marks. You can see the range. Some of them can never catch up and simply cannot enjoy school there. Learning is basic for a student, not simply enjoy the vanity as a famous school student.

navigator

所說甚是啊！

most

我覺得現在大部份的出名學校，已經本末倒置。
學校只期望從學生身上攞到幾多嘢（校外獎項，幫學校推高band 1 百份比，喺會考、高考幫學校攞多D A，入大學率幾高)。
學生期望從學校到，又會攞到D乜呢？
成個香港的教育文化，已經被扭曲。

navigator

呢個就當然啦！但依家樓主嘅困擾喺指響「課外活動」，例如游水跌晒watt，攞唔到牌為校爭光嘞...... 咁爭抝點喺學校喺咪可以咁無情無義藉詞佢功課唔得踢佢走先？！不如就直接改為: 游水唔好就會踢 ，作為家長嘅我們會buy嗎？！

caeme

讀得唔好就會踢 間間都會

fungsingma

大家不要針對女拔, 成績不好的, 再堅持也無謂, 個女只有成績更差, 找一間令她有信心讀好的吧

chaselam

..周一嶽指醫生不應以商業角度行醫
商業電台 – 2011年10月29日星期六上午10:00.
...寄給朋友列印......醫管局招聘海外醫生到公立醫院工作，引來不少業界、特別是私家醫生的反對，食物及衛生局長周一嶽在本台節目中表示，理解工會有自己的立場，擔心有競爭及專業水平受影響，但強調醫生不應只顧個人利益。周一嶽指出，不少應聘的海外醫生都是到海外讀醫的香港人，亦需經考核才可在港執業，認為業界毋須過份譴責，醫生應團結，為病人著想。周一嶽說，醫管局已有不同措施挽留人才，包括在不影響其他年輕醫生晉升下，續聘部分已屆退休的資深醫生，目前已有六十多名資深醫生留任。
周一嶽又說，留意到部分醫生當行醫是商業，認為是很大問題，強調病人與醫生關係，不應以商業角度處理，醫生應有醫德、有愛心及責任感、要以病人為先。

周一嶽做左衛道之士，點解醫生要有社會責任？
辦學團體可以套用周一嶽理論嗎？

[ 本帖最後由 chaselam 於 11-10-30 13:39 編輯 ]

ANChan59

原帖由 hingmami 於 11-10-30 00:48 發表
女拔好似唔俾果D因游水叻而收的學生唔肯再游水？！
但學生唔游水，女拔又會點逼佢地游或退學？

Understand your rationale now.

Sorry, I don't know the details of DGS in swimming, my friends' daughters got in DGS via academic results with other ECA achievements.

hingmami

女拔好似唔俾果D因游水叻而收的學生唔肯再游水？！
但學生唔游水，女拔又會點逼佢地游或退學？

ANChan59

原帖由 hingmami 於 11-10-29 21:14 發表
女拔好似唔俾游水入去的，唔再游水？！
但唔游又點逼？

????????

hingmami

女拔好似唔俾游水入去的，唔再游水？！
但唔游又點逼？

catcatmom

以前資訊唔係O甘發達, 網上討論係這幾年既事, 以前係不達標便留班, 勸走OR轉校不是0甘多(轉校好多係家長唔想個小朋友比人笑), 講起abt10年前, 中三又西一班人走, 中6又換血, 以前學校邊冼搞甘多野!

男/女BUT都係這幾年轉直資, 多了話事權.
所以以前情況跟現時不同.

原帖由 panbaby 於 11-10-27 14:53 發表
在出名一些甚至好普通的學校, 如果學生成績差, 學校會留佢班或勸學生找間程度淺些的學校, 這些做法以前大大多數人都覺得合理, 唔會上網上線大鑼大鼓罵學校冇人性, 沒有宗教愛心, 失去有教無類的原則.  

但到今時今 ...

ANChan59

原帖由 ok_ko 於 11-10-27 17:06 發表
都話係鮮魚行校長說的.:D

I still remembered when we discussed about Chan Fei Yeung in EK.... The basketall coach stated in his fb that the guy got the scholarship from DBS (between two principals) and not a basketball scholarship, his standard may only a bench warmer in DBS team.

Outsiders in EK just said DBS headhunted him...... it's not true from day one...

ok_ko

都話係鮮魚行校長說的.:D

samuel89

原帖由 ha8mo 於 11-10-27 15:32 發表
張乜祥返左D乜S之後
佢咪做返一間Band 1英中囉

沙田入面唔只一間搞體育的中學
林大西同董之英我估仲熱心添
但D學生在體育以外係咩質地
留返俾D日日果頭出入既街坊講好喇 ...

其實就算入左港隊,體育在香港從來都冇出路.....所以家長在D乜S同體藝揀, 都一定「當埋條底褲都要讓他念到男拔。」<---by ok_ko
最低限度都叫做"名校出身"啦.....