心儀九龍華仁 應選那間小學？

dvdrom

本人對中學派位所知不多，只知九龍華仁是津校。如要決定小學，請問選擇九龍塘小學（KTS)或是聖方濟各（SFA)較好？

gender123

If boys decided to go on with lucky draw,  not DSS, but with band 1 results, % of students not to take WYK as first choice I believe is at the low side..those marginal case will take St Frances as 1st choice...or they totally ignore WYK, becuase very small & will get into WYK with the second or third chice.
Top band 1 in all districts will try top DSS school first...

gender123

as far as I know, some parents did chose WYK, but they said to others that they did not...as far as I know, almost 90% band1 boys at YMT will choose WYK as 1st choice or second choice. Some first choice will be LS, then second choice is WYK, very few take st France as first choice and WYK as second choice.

Be careful about what they said and what they actually did...

cellon

九華的優點和缺點都可以說是：

崇尚自由

longfung

回復 ElizaW 的帖子

係呀!而家油尖D band one小學都唔喜歡揀九華, 覺得太hea!

vincentchiu888

elmkc 發表於 12-5-5 04:04
回復 motherotk 的帖子

Wah Yan students love their schools. Although they may not study as hard as o ...

Do any Wahyanites know the public extracurricular result in these years? My son is very active, and like me, doesn't like to study hard in classroom. He likes to be surrounded by a high quality activities such as sports debate event and enjoys getting prizes through competition. Academic result is not my main concern, but a positive attitude towards life and a high EQ rather than IQ shaded through liberal education is more important during middle school age.
I have searched both academic and athletic result of WYK in the past 5 years  and it seems not very encouraging, yet  I still believe that Wah Yan's maintaining its value can nourish a whole person and the school can continue to produce a lot of high grade citizens and not bookworms.

elmkc

回復 motherotk 的帖子

Wah Yan students love their schools. Although they may not study as hard as other famous schools such as St Joseph's, Queen's, they would not let their schools and parents down. That's why they not only can enjoy their lives in school, but can also maintain good results in public exams.

motherotk

雖然我十分鍾情2间華仁, 也有孩子的母親告訴我一些不利WY的看法,例如太自由影響學習情緒, 但他們說 華仁的傳统價值觀, 例如民主, 尊重獨立自主等依然緊守, 這對孩子長遠個性發展很重要, 我想, 學習是發自內心, 不應純由外界控制, 中學生應開始摸索甚么是人生重要的東西, 太多外在的掌控, 可能數字上的成績有些看頭, 卻失卻體會自主自立下探索知譏的空間, 多可惜!

oscarmama

Pessuma 發表於 12-4-17 12:03
回復 oscarmama 的帖子

Hi Oscarmama,

Hi Pessuma

check pm please。

catcatmom

有時朋友, 同事, 又或者係三姑6婆，九舅父聽番來既野, 只要網友相信係真既, 都可以post出來與大家分享, 唔一定要自己子女讀緊先至可以講, 如果要是這樣, bk既教育版一早就"折"埋. 因好多時有負面言論, current 家長好多都唔想講, 只有一味唱好, 討論區就無曬意義. 如果講得事不付實, 一定有好多網友出來還佢一個公道.

silvia_ng

http://www.facebook.com/wyksmallclass.but.cutstudents

九華的花邊消息

Pessuma

回復 oscarmama 的帖子

Hi Oscarmama,

Already admitted to LS in Phase 1?

Congratulations!

oscarmama

回復 motherotk 的帖子

motherotk

我首選喇沙

motherotk

majacob 發表於 11-6-29 20:25
I am genuinely curious how do you arrive at that judgement? Not sure about the basis for your judg ...

I really like to see more of your opinion on the virtue of Jesuits education, I heard some from my friends, can you tell me more, are these still present in nowadays' admini of WYK, they  change a very different principal, what do you think?

hogwarts

   
Dear all,

Please read the mission statement of WYK below before sending more bomb shells.

Jesuit Vision Statement for our Education Apostolate in Hong Kong:

"We offer a holistic, liberating and transforming Catholic education within a learning community for students and staff to become progressively competent, committed, compassionate, spiritual, and ethically discerning persons with a universal heart contributing to the welfare and happiness of all, in particular the poor and the neglected."

My experience with another "sinking" school SPC is that people should know what they can get from the school, but not expect or "force" the school to deliver what they ask for.

My friend's son had graduated, Form 5, from WYK back in 2008.  He was not strong in academic but a very talent dancer, he has 8 grade dancing from the UK Associate Board.  He then enrolled an associate's degree, ha ha a solid proof of a "hea" WYK.  This is not the end of story, he then went on to Baptist U to study a BA.  He is not defeated.  Apart from the normal undergraduate study and he is also doing part-time job, using his dancing talent to help event management, to earn some extra cash for himself.

No, he is no doctor or lawyer, but a very respectable young man.  I see no wrongs in his days from WYK, and he is a vivid example of that mission statement.

I trust WYK still producing young talent doctors & lawyers but I think the Jesuit Fathers will ask for values of the mission statement first.

oscarmama

回復 motherotk 的帖子

motherotk
我囝囝今年有考港華，我揀佢都因有港華家長話學校吾會催俗學生，好靠自己努力，但可train到小朋友有自己嘅分析能力，响自己長處發揮。不過我都只係揀咗佢第二。
其實我知如果小朋友夠自律同成熟，華仁的確係吾錯嘅選擇

RabbitJump

回復 alexpang1999 的帖子

Rather risky if his school is not in Yau Tsim Mong district.  If I were you, I would register St Paul and try Wah Yan in July.

motherotk

現今社會還是放咗學業成績响第一, to a certain extend yes, but not absolute, depends on what the career expect and what the child's potentials are....

I have few experiences work with  "elite school sport or music talent youbng [people " in the university, good english and language ability, but really lack exposures or perspective in problem solving or knowing what they want, plus the attitudes on learning were really too "narrow", very "outcome" based, just meet the average or even below average, with these kinds of perspectives, will never achieve outstanding results, will never have breakthrough in life if holding the same perspectives unless with some challenges or frustrations!!

cellon

ElizaW 發表於 11-6-29 14:22
Don't go to Wah Yan
Why you want to Kowloon Wah Yan, Students and teacher are very hea, no test and little home work only , F4 students always 走堂go to Mongkok 網吧,  I have many friends stuy in Wah Yan, Becuase my son study in Yaumati Catholic Primary School, Wah Yan is  very rubbish sch, HKCEE result also very bad.
Every F1 students mother also want to change school.  But the students are studying very happy, because less testing & homework

Are you serious?

alexpang1999

Dear All,

My son got an offer from St Pual's College, in Sheung Wan (deadline 30 Mar, 2012) but I have a delimma between SPC and Kwoloon Wah Yan (wait until July 2012).  Should I take SPC and forget WKY " Government central place allocation".  Or wait for WKY until July 2012, which means I have to give up SPC.  For details, please see "中學交流 SPC page".

PS My son is doing P.6 in Sham Shui Po district.