聖羅撒 vs 聖家(九龍塘)

candykiki123

詫朋友一問, 朋友說佢有土瓜灣同九龍塘地址, 問我兩間小學邊間好d, 又要考慮埋日後升中, 佢今年9月便要幫女女幫小一, 兩間都好鍾意, 問我,我又唔係咁清楚, 請問大家有咩意見

elmolly

原帖由 belle2009 於 11-3-4 14:29 發表
According to my relative who was the headmistress of one of the Canossian schools. She just told me on the phone that St Rose, La Salle and Maryknoll are not related and they are from different 修.會. ...

how about Holy Fmaily (kln tong) vs Good Hope? what do you think?

nicolemummy

Primary school SSPA results of Holy Family (kowloon Tong) are better than St. Rose……….The Net 41 is better…more tops secondary schools in Kowloon Tong……………
.
>> St Rose and Holy Family are located in SAME SECONDARY Zone - Kowloon City (Also mentioned by miffy)
.
.
plus St Rose secondary school is only in Shatin and more secondary schools in shatin are better than St Rose ……….not so famous……….
.
>> St Rose Secondary's location is in Shatin. But the SECONDARY SCHOOL ZONE of St Rose Primary is Kowloon City. Frankly speaking, I am a graduate of a Shatin secondary school. I know SRL is not so famous in Shatin but it is all because SRL has its own primary school so not too many Shatin pupil will choose it right away.
.
.
Holy Family Canossian students have priority to apply other Canossian secondary schools like St Mary’s and Sacred Heart…………but St Rose students do not have priority at all…………….
.
>> That's fair. I have no comment on this. But St Rose and Maryknoll is also close because they are under same Catholic administrative zone (Kowloon zone of Catholic - St Teresa's Church Area). La Salle's ex-Principal (Mrs Pao) is also old-girl of St Rose and many teachers in La Salles were teachers in SRL. It shows the close relationship of schools of this zone. My sister修女 friend whose church diary shows only telephones of these 3 schools.
.
.
My friend said the academic studies and external exam results are better than St Rose……..The present headmistress of the Holy Family Canossian College was the vice-headmistress of Sacred Heart Canossian Secondary School .....she is very aggressive and wants to upgrade the school as well
.
>> SRL Secondary Academic is very strong. It gives out 2 straight-As in A-levels the year before. But of course HF is also good. I have friends who are graduates from HF and SRL too.
.
.
.
>>> But afterall, both are good schools. I don't want to struggle on which one is better than the others.

原帖由 belle2009 於 11-3-4 08:56 發表


Primary school SSPA results of Holy Family (kowloon Tong) are better than St. Rose……….The Net 41 is better…more tops secondary schools in Kowloon Tong……………plus St Rose secondary school is o ...

[ 本帖最後由 nicolemummy 於 11-3-4 14:10 編輯 ]

elmolly

原帖由 belle2009 於 11-3-4 08:56 發表


Primary school SSPA results of Holy Family (kowloon Tong) are better than St. Rose……….The Net 41 is better…more tops secondary schools in Kowloon Tong……………plus St Rose secondary school is o ...

but the so far HFCS's hkcee and university entry rate is just soso, are you sure this is the case?

nicolemummy

佢咁樣選, 我假設佢唔係SRL既幼稚園生, 同埋假設佢係15分.

首輪SRL若沒有20分不行. HF 15分卻有機會.

如以地址抽獎, 兩間放首位(假設佢肯放棄HY同MCS為首位), 前幾年暫時都係必入咁濟. 以後幾年出生率高左, 唔知.

至於叩門, SRL唔係幼園生無咁機會. HF就有好多機會.

所以報HF入既機會高好多.

但以升中來看. SRL一間升一間, HF就兩間升一間. 兩間中學都好, 成績以SRL優勝少少.

原帖由 candykiki123 於 11-3-3 17:23 發表
詫朋友一問, 朋友說佢有土瓜灣同九龍塘地址, 問我兩間小學邊間好d, 又要考慮埋日後升中, 佢今年9月便要幫女女幫小一, 兩間都好鍾意, 問我,我又唔係咁清楚, 請問大家有咩意見 ...

sheri

Holy Family should be better , they are more famous as they are one of the Canossian Schools and Net 41 is good

[ 本帖最後由 sheri 於 11-3-3 19:53 編輯 ]

busy_penny

聖家