何文田維多利亞下午英普班, 及大坑真光下午班, 選邊間?

Janicelobby

家住九龍, 何文田維多利亞下午英普班, 及大坑真光下午班收左, 你會選邊間, 請比d 意見

Janicelobby

charlotte mom, 多謝你詳細解答, 可唔可以再幫我解答有關真幼的課程?

1. 有無教phonics?
2. 有無中英文閱書計畫?
3. 一星期幾多堂外籍老師教英文, 普通話老師教普通話?
4. k2每天功課量, 中英數各幾樣?
5. 係唔係3年一d 測驗, 默書, 評估都無?
6. k2 數學會唔會教加, 減?
7. k2 英文會唔會教認整個生字, eg. the, big, mom?
非常感激!!!!!

hihicathk

My girl was so lucky that she gained the offer from SPK...

Since we are catholic and they have school bus to our home... We finally took this offer.

Charlotte_mom

1. 你知唔知其他畢業生有去d什麼小學.
好大部分家長都打算直升, 小量連大抽獎都費事, 有d好似我咁出去考(真係唔多), 多數會留位然後抽獎, 如果抽到免費又ok(通常都係target12網果幾間女校)就會走lor, 始終3千蚊學費一個月wor
2. o甘真幼係唔係只考到活動教學的直資?
正如之前講, 唔多人出去考, 亦唔多target超級名校, 2線會多d, 我知如果最top果幾個, 都有top school offer架
而真光學生俾人印象會係自理能力高同聽教, 考傳統學校亦ok
3. 如果大抽獎抽到傳統小學會唔會跟唔上?
唔會, 真光學生中文底子強, 亦慣睇書同日日有習慣做功課, 上小學ok
4. 真小係唔係都係活動教學?
佢話係, 但唔算做得徹底, 有默有測有考, 功課同評估設計都傾向傳統
若果三年無測無考無默, 我好驚小朋友學少好多野
每日都有功課, 唔算heavy亦唔算light, 我仲記得我xmas holiday帶個女去旅行, 晚晚返到酒店都要做功課的

[ 本帖最後由 Charlotte_mom 於 10-12-31 19:56 編輯 ]

Janicelobby

原帖由 Charlotte_mom 於 10-12-31 14:17 發表
以上家長都俾左好多意見, 我又插咀先
我女係真幼畢業, 而家去左另一間直資(活動教學), 大概1/4學生黎自維記
真幼, 講老師經驗愛心, 校風純樸, 教小朋友自理, 家校合作各樣, 真係一流! 3年無測無考無默, 小朋友無壓力 ...

好開心有真幼畢業生家長比意見, 請問

1. 你知唔知其他畢業生有去d什麼小學.
2. o甘真幼係唔係只考到活動教學的直資?
3. 如果大抽獎抽到傳統小學會唔會跟唔上?
4. 真小係唔係都係活動教學?

若果三年無測無考無默, 我好驚小朋友學少好多野

Thank you very much!

Charlotte_mom

以上家長都俾左好多意見, 我又插咀先
我女係真幼畢業, 而家去左另一間直資(活動教學), 大概1/4學生黎自維記
真幼, 講老師經驗愛心, 校風純樸, 教小朋友自理, 家校合作各樣, 真係一流! 3年無測無考無默, 小朋友無壓力又上小一, 仲可以大抽獎, 呢樣係好多人都想的 (順帶一句, 真幼唔傳統的)
缺點都有的, 語文能力的確唔夠強: 中文寫同讀就非常OK, 好掂,英文同PTH的確唔夠出面D所謂名校黎, 讀PHONICS的話我敢講維記一定SYSTEMATIC好多, 我見維記既學生, 一般上到小學, 英文聽說讀都OK夠強, 寫就.....學老師話齋, 大家都係要執架喇, 但個人覺得, 真光中文學得比維記深入
真光畢業生, 俾人印象唔錯的, 考小學都OK, 不過想考超級名校.....始終程度唔夠深, 唔會特別有著數, 真光家長又好少會操到個小朋友100%FIT咁去考小一, 因為有後著掛?
真光校園係大, 係無5星級架喇....所以真係, 要睇下你要咩要求, 真光有自己室內運動場, 室外運動場, 禮堂, FUNCTION ROOM各樣, 基本上除左旅行之外, 咩都可以O係學校攪掂晒, 而維記, 坦白講, 唔少有要求既家長, 所以係好多"貴"野(無論教材, 租地方, 去遊學, 造衫做SHOW, 搵既音響攝影)一分錢一分貨, 家長願俾學校願安排咁LOR, 所以以上都講得岩既, 睇你想要咩

chowhui97

另外有個extreme的case, 我有個親戚的小朋友係維記讀, 升上傳統學校唔like, 覺得成日做啲抄寫工作無意義, 覺得唔駛用腦, 功課唔係追唔到, 但係讀得唔開心, 最尾我親人考慮咗好耐, 因為返維記讀小學好貴, 問個小朋友, 小二咋, 佢同佢爸爸媽媽講話佢唔會side佢地啲錢, 會努力讀書.  咁細個咁識諗, 於是小二就返維記讀...

chowhui97

同意同意, 我識的小朋友係維記畢業都好乖巧, 很會照顧妹妹, 自理能力呢啲嘢, 我估都好睇每個小朋友同家長的配合!

不過坊間小學對於維記出品的學生係點樣的評價我就唔知啦...

另外有人話TL的學校環境好好... 老實講我唔多覺, 佢係好大間, 但係overall啲玩具同設施都係比較舊... 不過佢係一條龍學校, 所以都係好好的選擇! 語言方面我問過現在讀緊的家長, 佢唔係日日有外籍老師教英文, 而本地老師的英文亦唔係ABC嗰種英文... 不過有學卷, 聽講讀得又開心, 所以都要取捨..

Janicelobby

原帖由 hihicathk 於 10-12-30 13:32 發表
其實舊年我0地都遇過呢個問題. 因為本身阿囡係v記讀pn, 另外大坑真光亦收0左佢讀K1...

其實兩間學校都係會令小朋友讀得開心, 因為0的老師都有愛心同好關心小朋友... 雙方0既配套亦各有所長...

真光0既校園真係無人 ...

hihicathk, 請問你指的better offer 令你放棄 true light kin 係咩 offer?

iantsang

KV will call waiting list sooner, for the case of SC, I have no ideas when they start to call the waiting list.

Just keep your finger cross for the remaining three to be interviewed.  It is quite complicated to describe the situation of each kindergarten now so I would rather leave it to a later stage when you are offered.

Assuming you don't want to hold two offers at the same time while waiting for other interviews, if you consider better language training while self-discipline is lesser an issue to you, Victoria would be a good choice.  As other parents stated and I also agree totally, TL has much better environment to teach the kids on taking care of themselves and good moral education.  Personally I would like TL more (one of 5 kinders I applied for young one this year).

Good luck!

Ian

原帖由 Janicelobby 於 10-12-29 14:51 發表


現時在手比較好的offer只有e 兩間, waiting 就係st cat 同根德，　但我預左都係落空．　要收就收，　做什麼要　waiting, 我聽 st cat 老師講，　佢地的　waiting 要等９月先知有無位．　我到時都預備定入其他幼稚園，　佢到時先 ...

hihicathk

其實舊年我0地都遇過呢個問題. 因為本身阿囡係v記讀pn, 另外大坑真光亦收0左佢讀K1...

其實兩間學校都係會令小朋友讀得開心, 因為0的老師都有愛心同好關心小朋友... 雙方0既配套亦各有所長...

真光0既校園真係無人能及. 設施及配套應有盡有... 而佢0地對小朋友0既自理要求好高. 但係語言能力就一定無V記0甘好...

另外真光一條龍學校就真係一個先決條件... 雖然V記都可以直升, 但係除非你住西九龍, 否則坐校車都幾遠...

仲有, 因為始終V記出0黎0既小朋友都係比較活躍, 腦筋轉得快, 喜歡發問, 所以如果你唔算比佢直升小學0既話, 到時佢出番去考TRADITIONAL SCHOOL, 0的傳統學校又唔係好喜歡呢類學生...始終佢0地比較難照顧...

其實當時比我CHOOSE, 我都係PREFER 真光, 到最後最大CONCERN 就係, 佢0地係無咩NANNY BUS 過番九龍0既... 而且通常住九龍0既都係編去下午班, 變0左我0地自己又唔可以自已揍返學... 因為交通問題同有另一個BETTER OFFER, 所以我0地先至放棄0左TL...

hugub

原帖由 littlecook 於 10-12-30 01:48 發表
你囡囡依家讀真小嗎? 我囡讀緊K3,明年9月先升真小
可唔可以講多D真幼及真小既課程? 真幼好淺,真小我唔知
真幼英文及普通話係咪每星期只有堂?小朋友要外出學英文及普通話嗎? 我囡有出去學普通話, 因為真小普教中文,所以我K1開始比佢學
几時開始寫字呢? K3開始每日要寫中文及英文,中文仲要配詞及造句
另,真小係教得淺定深呢?真幼學生上真小,應付到嗎? 我未知呀..我囡d同學家姐就話ok
唔好意思咁多野問!真幼收 ...

真幼係一間好warm既學校, d家長及老師好nice, 學校好盡力令到每個學生都認識對方, 我個囡3年識曬所有上午班同級既同學

littlecook

你囡囡依家讀真小嗎?
可唔可以講多D真幼及真小既課程?
真幼英文及普通話係咪每星期只有堂?小朋友要外出學英文及普通話嗎?
几時開始寫字呢?
另,真小係教得淺定深呢?真幼學生上真小,應付到嗎?
唔好意思咁多野問!真幼收左我個囡,唔知讀唔讀好!

hugub

我有1囝1囡,我都係住九龍, 囝囝讀維多利亞(PN)及St.Cat(K1-K3), 囡囡讀迦南(PN)及真光(K1-K3)

個人意見維多利亞及SC英文都幾深由其係SC, Phonics , 但維記學生(我囝囝&表弟都係)d自理能力就麻麻,反而真光真係淺但德育方面真光 , 升小學方面真光幼稚園係100%入真小

Janicelobby

原帖由 iantsang 於 10-12-29 03:03 發表
If your prefer tougher curriculum, then neither kindergartens would match your preferences since both of them have such focus.  Victoria's kindergarten has kinda adjusted towards the direction to thei ...

現時在手比較好的offer只有e 兩間, waiting 就係st cat 同根德，　但我預左都係落空．　要收就收，　做什麼要　waiting, 我聽 st cat 老師講，　佢地的　waiting 要等９月先知有無位．　我到時都預備定入其他幼稚園，　佢到時先通知好失預算

其他未　ｉｎｔ　的有聖公會，　聖心，　聖保祿，　我想都係至在參與，　無什寄望

iantsang

If your prefer tougher curriculum, then neither kindergartens would match your preferences since both of them don't have such focus.  Victoria's kindergarten has kinda adjusted towards the direction to their own primary school but since they have good language training, then there will still be some advantages for applying to some DSS.  For the case of TL, it would be recommended if you truly like their school philosophy and agree with it, and stay with the private primary school as it is guaranteed.

Frankly, all one-dragon kindergartens would not have a tough curriculum since they don't need to push students ahead while in K2, so they are already prepared for P1 interview early in K3.  The earliest that they will start to be more advance would be K3 since that's the year before transiting to P1, and for some, it wouldn't even happen like TL since their primary section is still activity approach so it will still be more relax in P1 and P2.

Do you have other options or other kindergartens yet to interview?

[ 本帖最後由 iantsang 於 10-12-29 17:59 編輯 ]

stinkyrabbit111

don't give up your hope yet, remember a lot of people were accepted by a few schools and they will have to release these seats sooner of later..

if you are so keen on getting your girl into these school, try writing them letter, show your sincerity la..

for your case, as someone had said before, Vic is only good if you target to go into their primary & secondary school , 考直資 (小學時)無mud優勢..., also sooo expensive la their tuition fee...

原帖由 Janicelobby 於 10-12-28 15:42 發表
brrbaby2007, 我囡囡都唔算係適合催谷

yaulinda, 即使St Cat 或　根德 收佢　（waiting 機會都好渺茫)，　我都要諗，　我驚梗３年後又黎一場仗，　真係好疲累，　因我出年又要為哥哥考小學駁殺 ...

Janicelobby

brrbaby2007, 我囡囡都唔算係適合催谷

yaulinda, 即使St Cat 或　根德 收佢　（waiting 機會都好渺茫)，　我都要諗，　我驚梗３年後又黎一場仗，　真係好疲累，　因我出年又要為哥哥考小學駁殺