有D奇怪？今日收到教育處的信要我確認參加大抽獎

wkpapa

請問大家有冇 收到一封由教育處出的信, 內容係話記錄顯示，某私校(有埋個名的) 已經取錄咗我個仔，要我 "明確表示" 仲參唔參加大抽獎，要寄回回條。
我知一向教育處都會向私學提供名單, 目的係係想學校有個泡, 預算有人大抽獎後可能會唔要個學位, 不過因為我的朋友去年也有私校offer, 但冇 收過呢封信....最後抽到第一志願
信入面仲話 --- 請注意，為免浪費小一學位, 佢會把獲得私立學校取錄而繼續參加大抽籤的人的名單交比私校....
想問下係唔係有私校offer 係手的人有冇 收到呢封信呢？唔知係唔係我地係 net41 先出信?定係因為呢間私校上報教育處先出信(學校本身又冇話唔比我地大抽獎...) ?
成日聽人講, 如果有私校係手, 大抽籤結果冇咁好，所以有D擔心...
希望大家可以分享一下, 有冇 收到信, thanks!

thomasha

I received a similar letter, but it is related to the discretionary place, not central allocation ("lucky draw"):

QUOTE

Our records indicate that the private primary schools listed above have offered a P1 place to your child...Since you have also registered your child for a P1 place in an aided or goverment primary school, I would be grateful if you would kindly inform me whether your child will give the P1 discretionary place...

...a name list of those children who have been offered a P1 place in a private school and yet do not withdraw from the Primary One Admission System will be sent to the private primary school concerned.

UNQUOTE

The "Primary One Admission System" above should refer to both discretionary stage and "lucky draw" stage.

I wonder whether sending such letters is a new practice or it has been a common practice of EDB in the past.

In any case, I will send the reply slip soon so that the discretionary place can be released ASAP.

原帖由 wkpapa 於 10-12-18 21:06 發表
請問大家有冇 收到一封由教育處出的信, 內容係話記錄顯示，某私校(有埋個名的) 已經取錄咗我個仔，要我 "明確表示" 仲參唔參加大抽獎，要寄回回條。
我知一向教育處都會向私學提供名單, 目的係係想學校有個泡, 預算有人大 ...

Erco

Mandy2005,
Thanks a lot !

原帖由 Mandy2005 於 10-12-20 11:42 發表
我岩岩打去"禮賢"問, 講明我已交留位費 & 會參加大抽獎, 個職會話無影響, 現階段交左留位費就唔會取消個學位.

chingchingb.ma

Once you registered with the 4th school, EDB will issue another letter to include the 4th school on the list and ask you for the decision again.

原帖由 snow05 於 10-12-21 18:16 發表
Dear Parents
I am rather puzzled by this government letter also.

My daughter got accepted by three private schools (but the letter only stated two of them??) and today we also got an offer today fro ...

juliehkbb

但唔係註冊咗先算咩? 我哋都有幾間私小收咗, 而封信只mention註冊咗嗰間私小。

原帖由 chuppy 於 10-12-21 09:46 發表
我收到嗰封仲奇，話聖心私小收咗我個女，但學校都未send信，如果係真真係好開心，早咗知個好消息，但唔肯定學校係咪比註冊後大抽獎呢？比封信嚇一嚇tim，唔知有無人知呢？不過我都會打去學校check吓穩陣D！ ...

snow05

Dear Parents
I am rather puzzled by this government letter also.

My daughter got accepted by three private schools (but the letter only stated two of them??) and today we also got an offer today from the fourth school (our dream school!) , which the government did not know yet. At the same time, we got the offer from a good government aided school in the first round (the second best on our list) , I will give up the first three private school but need some time to choose between the fourth school and the aided school, having to reply by end of the month is too rush. We wont hold the place for long, but just want to spend some time to think about it, any advice please?

Thanks a lot

wkpapa

你實在講中哂我想講既野！

原帖由 limehouse 於 10-12-21 16:05 發表
政府做嘢就係咁莫名奇妙，出呢封信嘅目的爲何？係幫私校？但人哋辦得好洗咩驚，而在商言商，我相信私校都知好多家長都係搵間優質嘅私校做backup,大抽獎有時難過登天，特別要誇區！而家政府咁做，好似我係香港公民有病去睇公去醫生，爲 ...

hotchat

Anyone got the letter with 2 school names on it?
or they usually just state one of the schools?

yeemelody

So strange.
Would they not issue the application form for lucky draw to us if we don't reply them?

原帖由 hokerryfan 於 10-12-21 12:36 發表

我真係好認同你的說法. I've called the Dept this morning, they replied we can reply or not reply this letter.  If so, why 政府要出這封信. Waste money waste time wast everything.  Rubbish ...

limehouse

政府做嘢就係咁莫名奇妙，出呢封信嘅目的爲何？係幫私校？但人哋辦得好洗咩驚，而在商言商，我相信私校都知好多家長都係搵間優質嘅私校做backup,大抽獎有時難過登天，特別要誇區！而家政府咁做，好似我係香港公民有病去睇公去醫生，爲咗多重保障，自己比錢睇埋私立，跟住政府威脅我會話比我個私家醫生知，搞到你同個私家醫生之間好尷尬，佢又唔諗吓派位係兒童嘅福利，比錢去考私校我哋同私校之間嘅事，唔敢compulsory，因爲言不通名不順，浪費d時間資源做d咁無謂嘅嘢,搞好個教育制度好過！

hokerryfan

原帖由 wkpapa 於 10-12-19 00:31 發表
我同你有同一個想法, 佢又唔係寄掛號, 點樣確保人人都會回覆佢呢, 唔回覆佢都唔可以唔比張FORM 我填, 可能會打電話來confirm啦！

而且又唔係間間私校都要上報, 咁呢個行政工作真係有D多餘, 教育處不如花多D 精神去捉 ...

我真係好認同你的說法. I've called the Dept this morning, they replied we can reply or not reply this letter.  If so, why 政府要出這封信. Waste money waste time wast everything.  Rubbish

hokerryfan

原帖由 wkpapa 於 10-12-18 23:56 發表
係KRS 呀, 學校冇講過參加大抽獎會取消學位架, 我會打比學校確認下.

只不過可能我多心, 收到呢封信, 個感覺好似教處要我決定, 唔好阻住個位咁, 我又真係有D擔心因為有私校收而個大抽獎no.會好後...

我又唔係果D要h ...

係 "聖母小學"
但我會參加大抽獎, 亦會回覆教育局.

hokerryfan

原帖由 wkpapa 於 10-12-18 22:09 發表
照我理解,   教育處話比私校聽都唔會取消個私校位 (有小部份學校除外, 不過應該註冊時會講...) 我個間督冇講過...
問題係其實我仲有另一間私校收我個仔, 亦已註冊 (不過已準備12月內放番個位出來) , 但封信入面只有 ...

My case as same as yours.

May_Wai

學校上個月頭己寄出哂信架啦, 您可能係後補上左呀!  恭喜您, 快d打去學校confirm 啦.

原帖由 chuppy 於 10-12-21 09:46 發表
我收到嗰封仲奇，話聖心私小收咗我個女，但學校都未send信，如果係真真係好開心，早咗知個好消息，但唔肯定學校係咪比註冊後大抽獎呢？比封信嚇一嚇tim，唔知有無人知呢？不過我都會打去學校check吓穩陣D！ ...

wkpapa

咁又眞係好開心呀！

原帖由 chuppy 於 10-12-21 09:46 發表
我收到嗰封仲奇，話聖心私小收咗我個女，但學校都未send信，如果係真真係好開心，早咗知個好消息，但唔肯定學校係咪比註冊後大抽獎呢？比封信嚇一嚇tim，唔知有無人知呢？不過我都會打去學校check吓穩陣D！ ...

w_y

哈哈, 咁都得! 恭喜你!

原帖由 chuppy 於 10-12-21 09:46 發表
我收到嗰封仲奇，話聖心私小收咗我個女，但學校都未send信，如果係真真係好開心，早咗知個好消息，但唔肯定學校係咪比註冊後大抽獎呢？比封信嚇一嚇tim，唔知有無人知呢？不過我都會打去學校check吓穩陣D！ ...

kpbb

我都收到信,亦是"聖三一堂"

原帖由 taboyan 於 10-12-20 11:18 發表
我都收到信,不過只是列出聖三一堂.......剛致電學校, confirm 了不會有影響私校的學位.

kochiman2004

原帖由 busybusymami 於 10-12-20 23:03 發表

Do you know when the said registration confirmation letters will be sent to you?

You may call them tomorrow, the staffs (both HK & Kln TL) are very polite to answer you the questions.  It's no need to mention your kid's name or registration no. during the enquiries.

[ 本帖最後由 kochiman2004 於 10-12-21 06:13 編輯 ]