請教灣仔華仁小學

babych

請教各位高人, 現在華仁小學好嗎?  可否幚忙分析下這所小學好與壞? 謝謝大家 !

meipo28

清楚哂, 多謝.

原帖由 brian61950 於 10-7-29 10:51 發表
有分上午校及下午校但好公平每人都要讀3年上及3年下,因上午同下午係各有各計分同抽,故少d人揀個晝著數好多.
通上當六年級時輪到上午個晝會多三份一人揀,如不清楚最好留空到時問清楚,另門口亦有怖告版列明各晝的申請 ...

KK07

Interesting, you are challenging the whole primary one allocation system in HK.  This system applies to all govt subsidized primary schools. So, you are not questioning Wah Yan, but also LaSalle, St Jo, Hennessy Govt, Maryknoll, St. Mary, Sacred Heart.....  it will be more effective to start another topic to discuss the current primary schools allocation system.

BTW, I don't really agree that primary schools' principals should pick the 'best' students, how do you judge a 5-6 years old is smart or not?  It should be principal's responsibilities to think of the ways to develop and train the children to become good students.   And I'd rather evaluate a school is good nor not from her 'output', not 'input'.

原帖由 Ving 於 10-7-28 08:10 發表
Also, I just wonder how traditional schools like Wah Yan can get the best student to study.

1. No interview required
2. No language or aptitude required. Means if you have enough marks, then even you ...

brian61950

有分上午校及下午校但好公平每人都要讀3年上及3年下,因上午同下午係各有各計分同抽,故少d人揀個晝著數好多.
通上當六年級時輪到上午個晝會多三份一人揀,如不清楚最好留空到時問清楚,另門口亦有怖告版列明各晝的申請人數.

原帖由 meipo28 於 10-7-28 22:31 發表
"只可揀一晝" - 此話何解?是否選PM機會較大D?



Thanks again.

meipo28

"只可揀一晝" - 此話何解?是否選PM機會較大D?



Thanks again.

原帖由 brian61950 於 10-7-27 15:44 發表
1. 20分有機會,但只可揀其中一晝.
2. 成績好好,唔會最top,但一定係好好.
3. band 1尾個d中學
4. 大多數不會,平民較多.

didikoko

I think Wah Yan is not a cup of your tea, you don't need to challenge its system or academic performance... unless ur son is one of students studying in Wah Yan.... otherwise, you won't understand why wah yan is so famous in Wan Chai district even a thousand explainations to you.

原帖由 Ving 於 10-7-28 08:10 發表
Also, I just wonder how traditional schools like Wah Yan can get the best student to study.

1. No interview required
2. No language or aptitude required. Means if you have enough marks, then even you ...

babych

非常同意. 我囝囝P1是返上午班, 放學食完lunch 2點, 休息一下2:30開始做功課,之後溫書,補習班,學琴, 沖涼…… 下午時間非常好用, 他們習慣6點前絕不開電視. 一天要做既事情下午可以輕輕鬆鬆全部做好. 今年囝囝學校轉全日制,我到現在還未定時間,我想,他們放學回家已經4點有多, 又要休息一下,又要做功課………點算?? 我放工返到屋企都7點, 我唸連傾下計都無時間

原帖由 brian61950 於 10-7-28 10:37 發表
其實除番吃飯時間,全日比半曰多個零鐘之嘛.至於玩和睇電視,關父母和小朋友自己多d,全日或半曰反而好次要.
1.叩門同插班可以揀.
2. 肯為小朋友付出的家長,他們的小朋友差極都有個譜.
3. 物以類聚,你身邊的朋友仔個個 ...

[ 本帖最後由 babych 於 10-7-29 09:26 編輯 ]

brian61950

其實除番吃飯時間,全日比半曰多個零鐘之嘛.至於玩和睇電視,關父母和小朋友自己多d,全日或半曰反而好次要.
1.叩門同插班可以揀.
2. 肯為小朋友付出的家長,他們的小朋友差極都有個譜.
3. 物以類聚,你身邊的朋友仔個個又叻又勤力,自然會激發或感染讀書的習慣.
你身邊的朋友仔個個20-30分,你好快會為拿40分而滿足.

成績不好或未如理想的,老師會個別補課.

Ving

Also, I just wonder how traditional schools like Wah Yan can get the best student to study.

1. No interview required
2. No language or aptitude required. Means if you have enough marks, then even you peform far worse than other students, you get a place
3. The entry marks is only depending on parents/brother graduation status and religion. However these two are nothing related with the student potential

So, that's I wonder how they maintain the level of P1 students?

原帖由 brian61950 於 10-7-27 15:44 發表
1. 20分有機會,但只可揀其中一晝.
2. 成績好好,唔會最top,但一定係好好.
3. band 1尾個d中學
4. 大多數不會,平民較多.

Ving

If it does not go to tutor either am or pm, then do you think the academic is good or bad than those full day school. I  just wonder the boys will play game or watch TV either am or pm in the weekdays

原帖由 brian61950 於 10-7-27 15:44 發表
1. 20分有機會,但只可揀其中一晝.
2. 成績好好,唔會最top,但一定係好好.
3. band 1尾個d中學
4. 大多數不會,平民較多.

brian61950

1. 20分有機會,但只可揀其中一晝.
2. 成績好好,唔會最top,但一定係好好.
3. band 1尾個d中學
4. 大多數不會,平民較多.

原帖由 meipo28 於 10-7-27 13:02 發表
請指教:
1. 20分有無機會入到?
2. Wah Yan 是否學業成績好?我不要求最top,但係唔可以太差.
3. 若不能升上Wah Yan Sec.多數派去邊?
4. 家長會否安排好多好多活動以填補下午或上午的空檔?(我好驚呢種風氣)

謝.





...

meipo28

請指教:
1. 20分有無機會入到?
2. Wah Yan 是否學業成績好?我不要求最top,但係唔可以太差.
3. 若不能升上Wah Yan Sec.多數派去邊?
4. 家長會否安排好多好多活動以填補下午或上午的空檔?(我好驚呢種風氣)

謝.

原帖由 brian61950 於 10-7-27 11:25 發表
走動空間都有既.小息可踢波,打籃球,乒乓波,睇書,小食部.....
足球課外活動係要比錢.
星期六下午課外活動後自己接.
英文好,係有好多人出去補.

brian61950

走動空間都有既.小息可踢波,打籃球,乒乓波,睇書,小食部.....
足球課外活動係要比錢.
星期六下午課外活動後自己接.
英文好,係有好多人出去補.

Ving

Is there anyone know the ECA facilities of Wah Yan against St Joseph against Henessy Gov? Which one is better and which one is the worst.

原帖由 珀珀,慧慧媽 於 10-7-25 13:18 發表

唔好意思~~
想問下學校細咁小朋友在小息時咪冇咩活動空間走動LOR~~
小朋友在小息時通常有咩可以做呢??
另外比錢既課外活動係咪會在星期六放學後進行??是否全都要家長自行接送呢?? ...

珀珀,慧慧媽

原帖由 brian61950 於 10-7-23 15:53 發表
基本野佢都齊既,灣仔唔少學校都係咁細.
因學校都有介紹一d要比錢既課外活動,故好多時某些活動好多華仁仔,有d全部都係添(eg.踼波).

唔好意思~~
想問下學校細咁小朋友在小息時咪冇咩活動空間走動LOR~~
小朋友在小息時通常有咩可以做呢??
另外比錢既課外活動係咪會在星期六放學後進行??是否全都要家長自行接送呢??

Ving

Sorry, do you mean kicking football also need to pay for money?

Also, someone say that although only teach English in english lessons and other subjects in chinese. But english level in Wah Yan is good. Is it due to parents bring them to english tutor after schools or really very very good english teacher(foreigner english teacher??) at school. Can anyone suggest?

原帖由 brian61950 於 10-7-23 15:53 發表
基本野佢都齊既,灣仔唔少學校都係咁細.
因學校都有介紹一d要比錢既課外活動,故好多時某些活動好多華仁仔,有d全部都係添(eg.踼波).

brian61950

基本野佢都齊既,灣仔唔少學校都係咁細.
因學校都有介紹一d要比錢既課外活動,故好多時某些活動好多華仁仔,有d全部都係添(eg.踼波).

原帖由 Ving 於 10-7-23 15:44 發表
So is this reasonable ECA facilities compared with other schools?

If most of the ECA is arranged from parents themselves, then this point should not be credit to the school, is it fair?

Ving

So is this reasonable ECA facilities compared with other schools?

If most of the ECA is arranged from parents themselves, then this point should not be credit to the school, is it fair?

原帖由 brian61950 於 10-7-23 12:40 發表
多數都出去攪. 放學後大部份人都係坐校車即走(偏辟),未走個d踼下波,打籃球或乒乓波等人接.
另童軍好出名.

brian61950

多數都出去攪. 放學後大部份人都係坐校車即走(偏辟),未走個d踼下波,打籃球或乒乓波等人接.
另童軍好出名.

原帖由 Ving 於 10-7-23 12:25 發表
So, does it mean that parents need to develope ECA for the boys themselves with extra resources rather than from the school?

If so, what the boy do in school after school, will it go back home straig ...

Ving

So, does it mean that parents need to develope ECA for the boys themselves with extra resources rather than from the school?

If so, what the boy do in school after school, will it go back home straight? And how about the sense of belonging?

原帖由 brian61950 於 10-7-23 11:38 發表
只得星期六長週才有課外活動或比錢出面個d.
真係好細但運動好勁,尤其足球,排球同游水.