Victoria (KH) vs St. Cat

KJC

請問點揀好呢?

oooray

原帖由 wootaitai 於 10-6-8 15:45 發表
well, Victoria is usually quite controversial on BK ga la..

why and how controversial?

Christi

所以要讚一讚D VIC家長...

brrbaby2007

原帖由 oooray 於 10-6-7 14:16 發表

第一身經驗當然值得參考；
我仍然覺得；除非你做過晒兩間學校既家長；否則冇資格批評某一間學校crap；點crap法，最後只會以罵戰告終。
(即使有人做過晒兩間學校既家長，話自己唔鍾意個間學校crap仍然係無修養o既行為) ...

大家懷著謙卑的心自然看到事物的兩面，有獨立思考的人自然會辯別分析。最終呢個post亦冇罵戰:loveliness:

granddelsol

agreed not anymore!

oooray

原帖由 brrbaby2007 於 10-6-7 10:33 發表


Understand, 不過果位家長都好樂意分享SC同教導小孩的方法，讓struggle於SC及VIC既家長有多d info去決擇邊種教學更適合小朋友又滿足到家長需要。

第一身經驗當然值得參考；
我仍然覺得；除非你做過晒兩間學校既家長；否則冇資格批評某一間學校crap；點crap法，最後只會以罵戰告終。
(即使有人做過晒兩間學校既家長，話自己唔鍾意個間學校crap仍然係無修養o既行為)

brrbaby2007

原帖由 oooray 於 10-6-5 10:04 發表

2個字"修養"
(brrbaby2007:唔係話你；係係話你轉述o個d自以為是的家長矣。)

Understand, 不過果位家長都好樂意分享SC同教導小孩的方法，讓struggle於SC及VIC既家長有多d info去決擇邊種教學更適合小朋友又滿足到家長需要。

tcbobo

很好的總結!

原帖由 Christi 於 10-6-5 23:22 發表
:)

當我見到呢個'crap'字,就已經估計到會惹來好多現在有仔女在VIC讀緊的家長既不滿.不過,睇完咁多VIC家長既反駁,我諗VIC家長睇野既闊度同埋清晰度都好好,會令我諗多一重:呢班家長考慮完一大輪,都仍然選VIC,所以VIC ...

Christi

:)

當我見到呢個'crap'字,就已經估計到會惹來好多現在有仔女在VIC讀緊的家長既不滿.不過,睇完咁多VIC家長既反駁,我諗VIC家長睇野既闊度同埋清晰度都好好,會令我諗多一重:呢班家長考慮完一大輪,都仍然選VIC,所以VIC一定有一啲嘢好吸引的.講真,聽完crap論之後,我都對VIC懷疑咗少少時間,不過,多謝咁多VIC家長分享你地的睇法.對VIC VS其他KG的+ve同-ve side,我明白多咗.

都話嘞,到底一個只識得背誦及死串100個英文字的小朋友能力強啲,抑或一個好熟phonics但只係識70個英文字的小朋友能力強啲?冇絕對答案,睇吓小朋友要讀邊類小學而已.

其實,話邊間KG係crap都唔公平,除非有親身而且確實的經驗.就算樓下那些屋村KG,都總有其優點.

oooray

原帖由 granddelsol 於 10-6-4 17:14 發表
I can't judge SC but I am sure Vic is not "crap".  Anyway, 我其實真係唔明d人的意見點解可以去到咁盡, 一間學校比人話到係"垃圾"對好多讀緊的人好唔公平....不過人地講咩我地無權過問, 不過做人說話真係要留有餘 ...

2個字"修養"
(brrbaby2007:唔係話你；係係話你轉述o個d自以為是的家長矣。)

swbaba

非常同意, 最要緊的是小朋友喜歡學習, 我認為維記在這方面做得很不錯, 女兒在日常生活中主動學習所得的, 會比在課堂學的多

維記的k2小朋友, 會去pn和k1班朗讀自己喜歡的書, 不知sc有沒有這樣的安排?

原帖由 granddelsol 於 10-6-4 17:14 發表
I can't judge SC but I am sure Vic is not "crap".  Anyway, 我其實真係唔明d人的意見點解可以去到咁盡, 一間學校比人話到係"垃圾"對好多讀緊的人好唔公平....不過人地講咩我地無權過問, 不過做人說話真係要留有餘 ...

granddelsol

I can't judge SC but I am sure Vic is not "crap".  Anyway, 我其實真係唔明d人的意見點解可以去到咁盡, 一間學校比人話到係"垃圾"對好多讀緊的人好唔公平....不過人地講咩我地無權過問, 不過做人說話真係要留有餘地lor.

原帖由 brrbaby2007 於 10-6-4 16:55 發表


係呀，我睇個blog個學生好有興趣愈寫愈長及好，所以之前有家長話Vic係crap話SC Eng勁過Vic我都有d confuse了

littlea

I think that SC is a traditional HK style KG. It probably emphasizes on how many words, how difficult the words and correct spelling and grammer. This is what main stream local primary school and their parents concern. Whereas, the teaching in Victoria emphasizes on free flowing of ideas and encouragement. It is more a IS style.
This is what I guess. ? correct

brrbaby2007

原帖由 wootaitai 於 10-6-4 16:44 發表
are you talking about victoria?

yes ar. But its more about encouraging free flowing ideas in the form of writing . EG the teacher will not correct the spelling etc but instead would praise the kids " ...

係呀，我睇個blog個學生好有興趣愈寫愈長及好，所以之前有家長話Vic係crap話SC Eng勁過Vic我都有d confuse了

littlea

wotaitai, what you describe that should be the way of how the international school teaches English. Isn't it ?They encourage students write by phonics and do not correct the spelling. I heard my friend who has a child studying in IS also learns in this way. A K3 student (ie year I in IS) can write out a whole essay.

granddelsol

hi, yes my kid is studying at HMT PN now and teachers are very good.  Honestly, I can't guarantee all the teachers are good in one school, so have to see our luck, but in general are good I observed.  

原帖由 littlea 於 10-6-4 16:09 發表
Dear granddelsol, I share the same opinion as yours.
Same as your case, I have given up KV also.
I also prefer my child to have a better environment for learning Eng and Man, in particularly in this ...

brrbaby2007

原帖由 oooray 於 10-6-4 16:17 發表

k2-k3要寫英文日記?我個衰仔響第間K1讀完都未識揸筆...

唔知係咪真，所以問吓你地，而且果d唔一字係成句句子，中間有插圖，學校只時encourage學生一步步做