請問九龍塘THINK的老師好不好??

jcmchan

請問九龍塘THINK的老師好不好??

小兒在嘉德麗讀N班,回家常說不愛上學,他說老師好大聲叫同學"收聲","坐低","唔準"..有一日我請假去求証,人還沒進學校已經聽到老師的聲音,似街市賣菜,一點"現代人愛心"也沒有..好傳統學校!!!所以幫仔仔報了九龍塘THINK,已收!!本來都放心了,因為心想此校一定不傳統!!誰知今天有同事說她的小朋友在馬鞍山就讀THINK,老師也會向小朋友大細聲的!!請問真的嗎??九龍塘THINK老師也會嗎???我個人不是很欣賞傳統叫罵叫打的方式對小朋友,我想我小朋友是在愛及講道理的環境中長大....請大家多多指教!!!

samsam88

原帖由 pollybell 於 10-3-24 12:04 發表
唔好意思,我真係好想同大家分享,都屈住好耐,但小朋友重讀緊真係唔方便講太多,因為呢件事我一講佢地一定知道我係邊個學生既家長.不過小朋友離開呢間學校既時間我一定同大家講返呢間學校如何差勁. ...

Hi Pollybell,

Can you pm me about the incident ?  My son was accepted to attend the K1 class in coming sept.

ellen_l

Pollybell,
可唔可以PM我知係邊間呢 ?

原帖由 pollybell 於 10-3-24 12:04 發表
唔好意思,我真係好想同大家分享,都屈住好耐,但小朋友重讀緊真係唔方便講太多,因為呢件事我一講佢地一定知道我係邊個學生既家長.不過小朋友離開呢間學校既時間我一定同大家講返呢間學校如何差勁. ...

luiflora

原帖由 twinsstar 於 10-3-24 13:18 發表
Can u pm me what had happened ar ?

I understand you might be very angry at the moment ... hope this can be settled asap. Though I don't know the details. However, I bet it might be due to the practic ...

放心,她所說的不是9龍塘學校!!!

twinsstar

Can u pm me what had happened ar ?

I understand you might be very angry at the moment ... hope this can be settled asap. Though I don't know the details. However, I bet it might be due to the practice of an individual teacher in another branch only (not kln tong think) right? Or some misunderstanding etc?

Anyway, I hope your kid can enjoy the rest of the school life in LC THINK ... My kid 's experience there is super positive and hope your kid will experience the same too... may be at least from now on.

Cheers!

原帖由 pollybell 於 10-3-24 12:04 發表
唔好意思,我真係好想同大家分享,都屈住好耐,但小朋友重讀緊真係唔方便講太多,因為呢件事我一講佢地一定知道我係邊個學生既家長.不過小朋友離開呢間學校既時間我一定同大家講返呢間學校如何差勁. ...

pollybell

唔好意思,我真係好想同大家分享,都屈住好耐,但小朋友重讀緊真係唔方便講太多,因為呢件事我一講佢地一定知道我係邊個學生既家長.不過小朋友離開呢間學校既時間我一定同大家講返呢間學校如何差勁.

原帖由 ellen_l 於 10-3-24 11:56 發表
校長都冇解決問題就真係求救無門, 究竟咩事咁嚴重 ?  可唔可以分享下 ?

ellen_l

校長都冇解決問題就真係求救無門, 究竟咩事咁嚴重 ?  可唔可以分享下 ?

原帖由 pollybell 於 10-3-19 17:44 發表
絕對同意,轉校都係我唯一選擇,連校長都去逃避問題,唔去解決或者解釋,當無事發生既態度,呢些咁既學校唔洗錢都唔好讀,對小朋友好大影響.

twinsstar

Poision,

May I know how you comment THINK and SC?
Do you think it is worth repeating K1 if my kid was a small kid? I'm afraid it is even more competitive in P1 later as birth rates keep increasing ....

Sorry for asking so many ques.

原帖由 poison 於 10-3-21 01:06 發表
Hi jcmchan,
我的小孩也曾在嘉德麗讀N班。她初時返學哭了四個月，之後情緒較穩定，但仍然不喜歡上學。整年N班的過程，都為着她不喜歡上學而十分頭痛。最後讓她轉校讀K1，新學校卻適應十分良好，不用兩星期，她除了沒有哭着上學，更 ...

[ 本帖最後由 twinsstar 於 10-3-23 16:02 編輯 ]

siupeg

原帖由 red888 於 10-3-20 01:18 發表
Hi,
My daughter is studying in N1 @ Kln Tong THINK.  All the local & native english teachers r v caring & kind.  Her classteacher calls me occasionally to discuss about my girl's progress in school.
N ...

red888, I have PM you pls check

luiflora

[quote]原帖由 poison 於 10-3-21 01:06 發表
Hi jcmchan,
我的小孩也曾在嘉德麗讀N班。她初時返學哭了四個月，之後情緒較穩定，但仍然不喜歡上學。整年N班的過程，都為着她不喜歡上學而十分頭痛。最後讓她轉校讀K1，新學校卻適應十分良好，不用兩星期，她除了沒有哭着上學，更 ... [/quo

是的,有事真的要講緣份!!!我小朋友也在該學校讀,佢也是成日講不喜歡上學,比幾間學校佢選擇,佢懂得說no1 km , no2 think , no3 boxhill , no10 嘉德麗. 起初以為佢亂講,因為佢返學好少好少哭,之後又再問佢幾次佢的答案也如此!!問佢知不知邊間是KM,佢說有香蕉樹,問佢知不知邊間是THINK,佢說有好多車車,問佢知不知邊間是BOXHILL,佢說XXX姐姐(因為之前返PALYGROUP).....所以我都心報口報!!佢真係知道自己LIKE邊間,只不過佢不懂得表達為什麼.....

poison

Hi jcmchan,
我的小孩也曾在嘉德麗讀N班。她初時返學哭了四個月，之後情緒較穩定，但仍然不喜歡上學。整年N班的過程，都為着她不喜歡上學而十分頭痛。最後讓她轉校讀K1，新學校卻適應十分良好，不用兩星期，她除了沒有哭着上學，更喜歡上學呢！
小孩子不懂得用說話表達他們的感受，他們的情緒及不願意上學表現，則表示他們不喜歡這學校。不同類型的學校適合不同的孩子，所以選校時亦可以把孩子的感覺加入考慮。
我的孩子在N班時，可以算是遇到好老師，但奈何她不太適合這學校吧。

原帖由 jcmchan 於 2010-3-18 12:25 發表
請問九龍塘THINK的老師http://das.baby-kingdom.com/www/delivery/avw.php?zoneid=37&bannerid=109&cb=11224479&n=a136fd19好不好??

小兒在嘉德麗讀N班,回家常說不愛上學,他說老師http://das.baby-kingdom.com/www/ ...

twinsstar

To jcmchan,

Would like to share my experience with you.

If you define "大細聲" as "罵" already. I'm afraid that the foreigners will also "罵" students. My son is now doing a sports course in an international school (out-source) and his coaches are all foreigners. They are very firm too. You know the coach insists every students to quiet down before he explains something. If someone screams, he does shout to them and asks them to keep quiet and of course with a very long and serious face too. Likewise, when a kid is hitting others, he does the same too (look even more serious and fierce) so that the kid will stop his distructive behaviour immediately. But of course, he won';t have the same measurement standard to all kids. For example, if a kid doesn't really understand English, he would "tolerate" him more. Also, he praises them a lot too when they're behaving well. The point that I want to tell here is ..., never think that foreigners will not "scold" kids, esp if you define 大細聲 as 罵 already.

However, I do agree that "至少大細聲之後也一定要講返道理比小朋友知" My son's coach will do that but when time is limited, he might have skipped it too.  


Sorry jcmchan, I don't mean to challenge you, just want to share my experience with you. :)

原帖由 jcmchan 於 10-3-20 08:50 發表
其實我好明白,大家所講的"有時需用大聲來控制場面",不過對N班來說,小朋友還太細,可以用另外一些方式去指引而不需要大細聲(外國教育從不打不罵,又不見得人地比我地中國人差??),至少大細聲之後也一定要講返道理比小朋 ...

[ 本帖最後由 twinsstar 於 10-3-20 17:37 編輯 ]

jcmchan

其實我好明白,大家所講的"有時需用大聲來控制場面",不過對N班來說,小朋友還太細,可以用另外一些方式去指引而不需要大細聲(外國教育從不打不罵,又不見得人地比我地中國人差??),至少大細聲之後也一定要講返道理比小朋友知,可是此老師無......我不想我小朋友日後以為學校就等於沒人愛的地方!!!

[ 本帖最後由 jcmchan 於 10-3-20 09:15 編輯 ]

red888

Hi,
My daughter is studying in N1 @ Kln Tong THINK.  All the local & native english teachers r v caring & kind.  Her classteacher calls me occasionally to discuss about my girl's progress in school.
No worry about this school

pollybell

絕對同意,轉校都係我唯一選擇,連校長都去逃避問題,唔去解決或者解釋,當無事發生既態度,呢些咁既學校唔洗錢都唔好讀,對小朋友好大影響.

原帖由 jcmchan 於 10-3-19 11:42 發表


謝謝你的細心分析,我想當時那一位老師的態度及小孩回家的不滿,以至我想進一步向學校反應時(校長的態度),我已經決定離開此校,它或者不是不好,只是不是我們要的那一杯茶而已!!我覺得你要人家對你好愛你,你必須先去愛 ...

[ 本帖最後由 pollybell 於 10-3-19 17:54 編輯 ]

twinsstar

If you are talking about the general attitudes of teachers in THINK, from my experience and observation, they won't shout to students for "trival" matters e.g. ask them to sit down / keep quiet. But they may still ask them to quiet down so as to control the class. You know, my son always immitates what the teachers did at school ..... no rude behaviours learnt from teachers so far.

Anyway, can see that you are a good parent who wants to give the best for your kid. :) Hope you can find a suitable school for your kids :)

原帖由 jcmchan 於 10-3-19 11:42 發表


謝謝你的細心分析,我想當時那一位老師的態度及小孩回家的不滿,以至我想進一步向學校反應時(校長的態度),我已經決定離開此校,它或者不是不好,只是不是我們要的那一杯茶而已!!我覺得你要人家對你好愛你,你必須先去愛 ...

[ 本帖最後由 twinsstar 於 10-3-19 17:07 編輯 ]

jcmchan

原帖由 twinsstar 於 10-3-18 22:34 發表
To jcmchan,

Honestly... whether a teacher can "suit" your kids or not is sth very personal and subjective. Different parents would have different expectation on teachers too. Sometimes I think a tea ...

謝謝你的細心分析,我想當時那一位老師的態度及小孩回家的不滿,以至我想進一步向學校反應時(校長的態度),我已經決定離開此校,它或者不是不好,只是不是我們要的那一杯茶而已!!我覺得你要人家對你好愛你,你必須先去愛人,大家在自然的感覺上建立感情,才是永恆!!如果只用傳統打打罵罵,小朋友頂多是口報心不報,現在的小朋友已經不是我們小時候那麼笨蛋了......他們的腦筋比我們當年成熟及聰明!!所以我好希望盡自己能力為小朋友找一所有愛心的學校!!不過看來真的可遇不可求.....