急問: 中學網作為揀小學的考慮

PVC

如果睇理將來中學網，因本人希望小女將來讀官津女子英中，如有此考慮，你地認為九龍塘、深水埗或係油尖旺好Ｄ，我成日諗九龍塘或油尖旺嘅著名英中已有直系小學，分配出嚟嘅中學學位比其他嘅小學會唔會少，噤深水埗區會唔會較穩陣?

kermitan

It is a powerpoint file, so you have to PM me your e-mail such that I can send it to you.

regards,

kermitan

原帖由 christineyhng 於 09-12-18 16:15 發表
Could you also pls PM me?

Thanks!

christineyhng

Could you also pls PM me?

Thanks!

原帖由 kermitan 於 09-12-17 18:26 發表
You can find it in the following link:

KL1 Net 九龍第一網（油尖旺區）

http://www.edb.gov.hk/FileManager/TC/Content_1582/ssl-kl1(ytm)-2009.pdf

Please note the "Open Places", those are the places availa ...

PVC

原帖由 kermitan 於 09-12-9 20:07 發表
我想也不算是「無用」，只是（廣東話說的）「冇乜用」，因為在中一統一派位乙部是計分區的（預設是所讀小學屬此區à
亦可改為自己住的區，但要在中一入學前的十二月申請），雖然位少都好過無。

究竟有幾少？請參考下列HK1網的資料，留意 ...

Hello Kermitan

Could you please PM me? Tks a lot!

KLCHO

hi kermitan
已PM了你,謝謝!

magiccandy

Thanks a lot

原帖由 kermitan 於 09-12-17 18:26 發表
You can find it in the following link:

KL1 Net 九龍第一網（油尖旺區）

http://www.edb.gov.hk/FileManager/TC/Content_1582/ssl-kl1(ytm)-2009.pdf

Please note the "Open Places", those are the places availa ...

kermitan

You can find it in the following link:

KL1 Net 九龍第一網（油尖旺區）

http://www.edb.gov.hk/FileManager/TC/Content_1582/ssl-kl1(ytm)-2009.pdf

Please note the "Open Places", those are the places available for Section B (District-based) of Central Allocation

原帖由 magiccandy 於 09-12-16 12:52 發表
Kermitan,

Thanks for your reply. Actually my kid is still very small and just curious to know about the issues of district concerning F1 allocation.

But where can I read the information about 油尖 ...

magiccandy

Kermitan,

Thanks for your reply. Actually my kid is still very small and just curious to know about the issues of district concerning F1 allocation.

But where can I read the information about 油尖旺 open spaces for F1 central allocation?

kermitan

It depends on whether your primary school would allow you to continue discretionary allocation / central allocation once you are accepted by your feeder school in their Form 1.

Some primary school will required that, once you accept your feeder school Form 1 place, you have to give up voluntarily discretionary allocation / central allocation. In that case, moving back your kid's school net back to KL1 would be meaningless, for only Section B of the Central Allocation is district-based.

But which primary school you kid is now in? And is he/she P.5/P.6 already?

Otherwise you are talking about a lot of variables that, without taking account of which, would be quite meaningless to infer any definite conclusion.

原帖由 magiccandy 於 09-12-16 10:23 發表
kermitan,

有問題請教，假設小學是深水埗區，有直屬中學，但住油尖旺區，如孩子成績好，中學應保險地填直屬，抑或搏一搏改自己油尖旺區的名校?如這樣轉校區，成功機會有幾多?




...

[ 本帖最後由 kermitan 於 09-12-16 12:46 編輯 ]

magiccandy

Can you also pm me please?

For F1 allocation, how can I find 油尖旺區的資料?

原帖由 kermitan 於 09-12-8 13:32 發表
In the Secondary School Allocation, 香港真光中學（小學部）belongs to HK2 Net (Net 12 is a primary school net designation).

And as for the "other" schools such as St. Stephen Girls, Ying Wa, or so (from  ...

magiccandy

kermitan,

有問題請教，假設小學是深水埗區，有直屬中學，但住油尖旺區，如孩子成績好，中學應保險地填直屬，抑或搏一搏改自己油尖旺區的名校?如這樣轉校區，成功機會有幾多?

原帖由 kermitan 於 09-12-9 20:07 發表
我想也不算是「無用」，只是（廣東話說的）「冇乜用」，因為在中一統一派位乙部是計分區的（預設是所讀小學屬此區à
亦可改為自己住的區，但要在中一入學前的十二月申請），雖然位少都好過無。

究竟有幾少？請參考下列HK1網的資料，留意 ...

fishman10hk

Dear Kermitan, would you PM to me or email to : [email protected]

thank you.

kermitan

Already sent the powerpoint to your e-mails.

Hope it will be of some use to you

原帖由 smartmatt 於 09-12-15 16:46 發表


ditto

thanks

smartmatt

原帖由 np 於 09-12-15 15:27 發表
hi kermitan
已PM了你,謝謝!
np

ditto

thanks

AugSun

Hi

Kermitan

Can you PM me the info too.

Thanks

原帖由 kermitan 於 09-12-9 20:07 發表
我想也不算是「無用」，只是（廣東話說的）「冇乜用」，因為在中一統一派位乙部是計分區的（預設是所讀小學屬此區à
亦可改為自己住的區，但要在中一入學前的十二月申請），雖然位少都好過無。

究竟有幾少？請參考下列HK1網的資料，留意 ...

np

hi kermitan
已PM了你,謝謝!
np

kermitan

我想也不算是「無用」，只是（廣東話說的）「冇乜用」，因為在中一統一派位乙部是計分區的（預設是所讀小學屬此區à
亦可改為自己住的區，但要在中一入學前的十二月申請），雖然位少都好過無。

究竟有幾少？請參考下列HK1網的資料，留意那些有小學直屬的EMI中學（School code 105, 107, 108, 111, 113），在扣除其直屬／聯繫（和不限區的自行收生階段）後，尚有幾多位(Open Places) 剩可供統一派位乙部（分區）用：

http://www.edb.gov.hk/FileManager/TC/Content_1582/ssl-hk1(cw)-2009.pdf


而有關升中機制，實較「案情複習」，建議你可先看一下「官方版本」：

http://www.edb.gov.hk/FileManager/TC/Content_1579/sspa%202008-2010(cweb).ppt

若仍看不明白的話，我日常工作的一部份便是向小六家長及同學講解有關機制，如您有興趣可PM您的e-mail給我，我可以send一個我們準備的簡化版給您

原帖由 np 於 09-12-9 13:31 發表
請問是否意思是, 住址同區對多直屬中學的區域係無幫助, 因為直屬中學都收番自己小學的學生?

我想問下中學的派位方法與小學有咩唔同? 是否都係分2輪? 咁住址同區定係小學同區對選中學有幫助?

...

np

請問是否意思是, 住址同區對多直屬中學的區域係無幫助, 因為直屬中學都收番自己小學的學生?

我想問下中學的派位方法與小學有咩唔同? 是否都係分2輪? 咁住址同區定係小學同區對選中學有幫助?

原帖由 kermitan 於 09-12-8 13:32 發表
In the Secondary School Allocation, 香港真光中學（小學部）belongs to HK2 Net (Net 12 is a primary school net designation).

And as for the "other" schools such as St. Stephen Girls, Ying Wa, or so (from  ...

chunheimama

12 綱好D

kermitan

In the Secondary School Allocation, 香港真光中學（小學部）belongs to HK2 Net (Net 12 is a primary school net designation).

And as for the "other" schools such as St. Stephen Girls, Ying Wa, or so (from HK1 net), HK 2 net girls, just like ALL OTHER GIRLS from every other district nets throughout Hong Kong, Kowloon and NT, can apply for it through the Discretionary Stage of admission, which is "NOT" district-based, through interviews.

And again they can do so during Stage I of the Central Allocation, which again is "NOT" district-based.

Only Stage 2 of the Central Allocation "is" district-based.

And a word of reminder to all those who think "net" is the best indicator of primary school selection. There are many major exceptions, especially for HK2 net:


Now, for the look of it HK2 do have a bit more prestigous schools. But even this seemingly advantage is offset by the fact that many of those prestigous schools, such as St. Paul's Secondary, Marymount Secondary, etc. are themselves 直屬中學of their own primary schools!

So by the time they have finish with the feeder-school mechanism and the discretionary stage admission (which has no district restriction and can be apply from any other net throughout HK, Kowloon or NT), usually less than a dozen (for Marymount) or 2 dozen (for St Paul secondary) vacancies are left for part B (district-based) central allocations. While those other EMI schools which are not 直屬中學themselves in HK2 net are roughly the same academically comparing with many other school nets in Hong Kong or Kowloon.

I understand the whole system itself is a bit complicated, but it has to be examine in this realistic manner and not oversimplified to just viewing the school lists from this 2 districts, or else you will miss a whole lot of opportunity when making choices.

原帖由 lovelygal 於 09-12-8 12:07 發表
Yes, True Light is under net 12. In fact, in addition to net 12 secondary schools, there are few other good secondary schools (eg Ying Wah Girls, St Stephen's Girl, etc) are available for selection un ...

[ 本帖最後由 kermitan 於 09-12-8 13:33 編輯 ]