優才 vs 英華, 你會點選擇? - 小一選校

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	220

1^#

發表於 09-10-22 14:41 |只看該作者 |正序瀏覽 |打印

優才 vs 英華, 你會點選擇? 學術水平有比較嗎?

0 0 0 0

mamay

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	1521

48^#

發表於 09-10-23 16:33 |只看該作者

原帖由 acmc 於 09-10-23 14:29 發表

"The 2,222 pairs of couple are not idiots to send their sons to this school blindly." 我贊同這句的, 我個小朋友都有2nd in機會. 除gt 取錄外, 還有其它學校有2nd in, 唔考慮的有2nd in 都唔打算去, 要考慮的 ...

same thought as you.....just to know more information now. Just in case we are so luckily that being accepted by either school, we can make choice earlier.

I did not apply GT, but I have applied St. Stephen & HKUGA

Any comment to compare St STephen, HKUGA vs YW?

acmc

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	220

47^#

發表於 09-10-23 14:29 |只看該作者

原帖由 smartcar 於 09-10-23 12:43 發表

All single sex school created Homosexual?

This statement is rather irrelevant in picking a good school and factually school is one of the surroundings bring up a child. Church, Scout, tutoring c ...

"The 2,222 pairs of couple are not idiots to send their sons to this school blindly." 我贊同這句的, 我個小朋友都有2nd in機會. 除gt 取錄外, 還有其它學校有2nd in, 唔考慮的有2nd in 都唔打算去, 要考慮的只想早點聽聽別人的意見, 不至到時幸運被取錄, 留位前十五十六, 在這個平台, 大家覺得有時間又可以回應吓, 男校, 女校, 男女校的確是家長們考慮範圍之內. 如果可以用平常心去看, "all Single sex school created homosexual?"應該唔會出現這句問題吧! 何必咁敏感呢! 其實我一直以來都好多謝大家的提點, 又點會有惡意!!

[ 本帖最後由 acmc 於 09-10-23 15:06 編輯 ]

Era

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	2721

46^#

發表於 09-10-23 13:59 |只看該作者

首先聲明,其實兩間學校我都鐘意,不過c6唔鐘意gt.
唔係要幫邊間,不過想俾番少少YW第一手正確既資料,咁先可以進行討論.以下既資料係今年既情況.

1. yw係30人一班,唔係3x或以上.
2. 的確報紙上面都有登過有yw既學生係跳過班既,不過就唔知個比率係幾多.即係話呢個未一定係一個機制,但係有需要既話,唔係唔可以跳囉.
3. 我唔識教育,唔識點分傳統同活動,但係知道yw既教學一定唔係好似我地細個果時,完全單向既.佢地會有好多答問題既機會,有行與行之間既比賽,有好多時候要同學互相對問,做一d好似訪問之類既活動.好多互動,唔係齋坐響度單向咁聽書既.
4. 無論中定英,抄寫響佢地功課入面,都係佔一個非常之少既部分,平均一個星期一次,最多果次都係1x個字,每個字寫打橫既一行,即係隔埋格之後,有d詞只夠寫3次左右啦.

[ 本帖最後由 Era 於 09-10-23 14:31 編輯 ]

http://era-central.blogspot.com/

smartcar

別墅

Rank: 4


	831

45^#

發表於 09-10-23 12:43 |只看該作者

原帖由 acmc 於 09-10-23 11:01 發表
前一陣子, 有些報導話香港有部份中學男生表示, 因自己是同性戀, 會被老師呀, 學校等歧視, 當時沒有看內文, 但心裏擁出些欵問, 點解一個學生咁快會確定到佢自己係同性戀? 會唔會因為較關心d同性同學, 就以為自己係同 ...

All single sex school created Homosexual?

This statement is rather irrelevant in picking a good school and factually school is one of the surroundings bring up a child.  Church, Scout, tutoring classes, sport club and neighbours are also part of the children's life.  What made the opposite sex into children's life so difficult?

If GT already accept your children , congrate to you and it is no point to compare with other schools in fact your kid never applied.

My son did not study GT before and I am not in the position to comment their academic standard.

Certainly working parents with heavy workload should think twice in applying YW as children homework and studies are really engaging.  It is no free lunch for those hoping the school could solve everthing for you.  Parent in house tutoring is one of the core factor to bring up your kids.

For the YW English standard, it is quite challenging and student starts journal writing in P.1.  P.2 student are already doing composition.  The 2,222 pairs of couple are not idiots to send their sons to this school blindly.

gingerale

別墅

Rank: 4


	909

44^#

發表於 09-10-23 12:42 |只看該作者

acmc- If I were you, I would not spend much time thinking about the issue of GT vs YW until I know my son is accepted by YW for sure.

cmchang0927

男爵府

Rank: 6 Rank: 6


	9428

43^#

發表於 09-10-23 12:15 |只看該作者

I think what Judy meant was since it was too easy to get an A for UK GCSE and A-levels' subject, u don't need to be outstanding to get As. But I think in UK, the universities count how many As u can get in GCSE and A-levels. For example, one of my friends (we were in the same secondary school for F.1 to F.3, then we chose the same school together in UK), she got 7A*(not A, it's A*)in GCSE and 5A in her A-levels, so she got an offer from cambridge to do Architecture. But in HK, it's really hard to get As and Bs in HKCEE and A-levels. Another one of my friends (her school results in HK was really really bad already), she got 2As and 2Bs and 3Cs in GCSEs and got 1E 1B 2Cs in Alevels, she was accepted by the University of London to do Pharmacology (not the same as Pharmcy!!). So I think if you wanna get into Oxbridge, u need to get all A* in GCSEs and all As in A-levels and also doing well in the interviews.

原帖由 JT2008 於 09-10-23 11:24 發表
回應judy
依家英國考幾多A己沒太大意義，每科好象接近一半人考A。

我不是太認同, cambridge同oxford 係worldwide嚟講仲係 top ten..........點會沒意義呀!!!!!!

judy

子爵府

Rank: 7 Rank: 7 Rank: 7


	11251

42^#

發表於 09-10-23 11:53 |只看該作者

原帖由 JT2008 於 09-10-23 11:24 發表
回應judy
依家英國考幾多A己沒太大意義，每科好象接近一半人考A。

我不是太認同, cambridge同oxford 係worldwide嚟講仲係 top ten..........點會沒意義呀!!!!!!

我話灼啲A。

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	245

41^#

發表於 09-10-23 11:25 |只看該作者

我覺得以家hk都好多青少年les & gay........哎............呢d都唔知係先天定後天..

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	245

40^#

發表於 09-10-23 11:24 |只看該作者

回應judy
依家英國考幾多A己沒太大意義，每科好象接近一半人考A。

我不是太認同, cambridge同oxford 係worldwide嚟講仲係 top ten..........點會沒意義呀!!!!!!

acmc

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	220

39^#

發表於 09-10-23 11:01 |只看該作者

前一陣子, 有些報導話香港有部份中學男生表示, 因自己是同性戀, 會被老師呀, 學校等歧視, 當時沒有看內文, 但心裏擁出些欵問, 點解一個學生咁快會確定到佢自己係同性戀? 會唔會因為較關心d同性同學, 就以為自己係同性戀呢? 或是環境因素造成, 少見異性, 將所有愛心都投放去同性的同學身上?
以上純粹是閒談, 請大家不要太敏感!

judy

子爵府

Rank: 7 Rank: 7 Rank: 7


	11251

38^#

發表於 09-10-23 10:48 |只看該作者

Also, one of my friends only achieved 19 marks for her HKCEE, but u guess which university she got accepted at the end? She did A levels in UK and got all straight As and finally got accpeted by Oxford!!!! In my old UK secondary school (quite high ranked in UK), most of my classmates got 5 or 6 As for their GCSEs.

道理就象現時大陸人來香港讀書，要好高好高分才入得來，而本港人士，DDEE就入到的道理一樣。前不久鄭經漢係信報擇文，建議家長考美國私校，因私校既出名，收生又公平。本港中七生，入美國大學，應可從ニ年班讀起。

依家英國考幾多A己沒太大意義，每科好象接近一半人考A。

niseko2000

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	179

37^#

發表於 09-10-23 10:37 |只看該作者

想間边間TKO直資?

原帖由 jeremyphlam 於 09-10-23 09:15 發表

小四2班由NET做班主任，但又無分精英班？
咁NET那兩班學生點樣揀出來？
我最擔心一日未有公開試成績出，一日都唔知係咪真係得。
好似TKO某直資就死啦 ...

cmchang0927

男爵府

Rank: 6 Rank: 6


	9428

36^#

發表於 09-10-23 10:21 |只看該作者

Agreed! But I think the parents are best ones to know their kids... If your boy is quite active and doesn't enjoy to do a lot of homework after school, then you choose GT. And YW is more traditional than GT, their approaches are different. However, I would like to share my experience. I went to study in UK after F.3. When I was studying the Science subjects in HK, I had great troubles doing them. I didn't understand a word of Physics and could even get 9 marks for my exam! (I was ranked the top 20 in my year before the science subjects appeared). But my mom forced me to choose sciences in UK (the older generation thought science students can have better careers).
Guess what I got for my GCSE Physics? I got a B!!! And I got As for maths, chemistry and biology!!!!!!!!!!!! Also, one of my friends only achieved 19 marks for her HKCEE, but u guess which university she got accepted at the end? She did A levels in UK and got all straight As and finally got accpeted by Oxford!!!! In my old UK secondary school (quite high ranked in UK), most of my classmates got 5 or 6 As for their GCSEs. I knew three girls who had achieved 10A* and one of them was accepted by cambridge's medicine department finally! And the caucasians did the GCSE 2 yrs earlier than the age of we do HKCEE. So I think they are two different level of exams, u cannot compare them together.

But I was happy that the GCSEs were easier than the HKCEEs, so I didn't lose my interests on Science and can finally finish my master for a science major degree,

原帖由 fsforth 於 09-10-22 19:52 發表

明年出左會考成績就有得比啦! 大家都是中五生, 做同一份卷, 到時真真正正睇得出分別.

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	245

35^#

發表於 09-10-23 09:48 |只看該作者

都係架...所以出年會知得唔得lor..唔公開就好名顯啦...

judy

子爵府

Rank: 7 Rank: 7 Rank: 7


	11251

34^#

發表於 09-10-23 09:29 |只看該作者

原帖由 fsforth 於 09-10-22 19:52 發表
明年出左會考成績就有得比啦! 大家都是中五生, 做同一份卷, 到時真真正正睇得出分別.

都要肯公佈(或有勇氣公佈)先有得比。

jeremyphlam

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	2581

33^#

發表於 09-10-23 09:15 |只看該作者

原帖由 SumSumBB 於 09-10-23 06:33 發表
我喜歡英華：
1)有名氣；
2)歷史悠久；
3)校長演說動聽和有心；
4)學生成積不俗；
5)...

至於優才，我喜歡優才:
1) 由NET教英文，小三全級、小四2班由NET做班主任；
2) 小班教學~每班約24人，上到中學每班最多27人，但現時其他一般中學 ...

小四2班由NET做班主任，但又無分精英班？
咁NET那兩班學生點樣揀出來？
我最擔心一日未有公開試成績出，一日都唔知係咪真係得。

好似TKO某直資就死啦

[ 本帖最後由 jeremyphlam 於 09-10-23 09:39 編輯 ]

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	245

32^#

發表於 09-10-23 09:15 |只看該作者

回應粉紅虎.

有時學校行政上gei錯唔可以就話間學校唔好, 英華今年有2222個人apply, 但second in 有第2223個no. 怪怪的, 朋友打去英華先話可能打錯號碼..咁又話英華唔夠professional 咩....

優才school bus 問題..你講d 唔講d... 有誤道成份, 因為優才gei學生住gei 地方十分不集中, 所以好少校巴公司會接呢個job..上年間校巴公司係差, 但已經無左, 今年學校己找第二間校巴公司了....如果學校唔好, 就唔會特登同家長開個會討論校巴問題lar.............

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	245

31^#

發表於 09-10-23 09:09 |只看該作者

如果要話名氣傳統..英華幾時都未到dbs lar.......如果係穩陣派.為名氣, 就一定會選英華, 因為悠久歷史...

但, 優才個硬件配套係好d gei, 只不過個名唔夠英華響, 因為都只係開辦左 12年..連會考result都未看到.

再講, 兩個簡介會我都有聽, 純自己意見..我覺得professor li 對學生個explorsure大d, eg>會發展佢地gei內在潛能, g1入校己替學生做多元智能測驗.發掘佢地potential, 而英華, 林校長多著重看書, 點樣教小孩子...我覺得呢d.家長都會懂lar..............

conclusion:兩間都係好學校...但就不同type..真的要看媽媽你自己鍾意邊間

SumSumBB

Rank: 5 Rank: 5

醒目開學勳章


	3565

30^#

發表於 09-10-23 06:33 |只看該作者

我喜歡英華：
1)有名氣；
2)歷史悠久；
3)校長演說動聽和有心；
4)學生成積不俗；
5)...

至於優才，我喜歡優才:
1) 由NET教英文，小三全級、小四2班由NET做班主任；
2) 小班教學~每班約24人，上到中學每班最多27人，但現時其他一般中學每班約38人；
3) 專科專教，數年前被稱教師群隊學歷為全港之冠；
4) 少互相競爭文化，無分精英班，成績表只列出全级頭五名名次，學校強調：做最好的自己！
5) 活動教學，上課形容較活潑，着重創意的啓發，從校長的著作了解到他對啓發創意很重視和有很深的認識；
6) 重思考，少機械式抄寫練習，以有趣的方法讓學生牢記知識；
7) 程度高，學生成績不俗，有課後資優培訓；
8) P1設MI Test 多元智能測試，了解各學生的專長，加以培育。
9) 設8X個才華班如圍棋、奥數、二胡...，學生每學期可修讀2個才華班，有評估報告，費用全免；
10) 對活潑的學生較包容；
11) 創辨人和校長很有心；
12)...

其實兩間都是好學校，亦各有好處，而各家長自有不同的喜好，小朋友亦有不同的持質，每人皆有自己的理由去選擇。對於我自己的小朋友而言，優才是最理想和最適合的學校，故此，我選擇優才。

[ 本帖最後由 SumSumBB 於 09-10-23 06:56 編輯 ]