Unfair of DGJS interview

Ben2003

>投訴這是否對非其小學的考生不公平!

真係咁都有....

原帖由 KK07 於 09-10-17 14:57 發表
想起幾年前參加一直資一條龍學校中一收生briefing, 該校講明會預留大部分學位給自己小學,只招收40-60外來生, 當中竟有家長向校長發問, 投訴這是否對非其小學的考生不公平!    聽後不禁覺得'公平'兩字被濫用! ...

nicolemummy

其實, interview係點, 間間學校大同小異, 不外乎, 問下小朋友一些問題(叫咩名, 喜歡D咩), 讀下書, 問下感想. 學校根本不會在乎家長知唔知面試程序.

大家都明白, 收唔收小朋友, 面試係一項分數, 但不是全部.

GROUP埋一齊係係學校內部行政容易D.......行政容易D....

原帖由 circleda 於 09-10-17 10:49 發表
唔係化, DGJS有無唔咁蠢, 驚人唔知interview係點要group埋同校o既一齊前後腳咁去in?

KK07

想起幾年前參加一直資一條龍學校中一收生briefing, 該校講明會預留大部分學位給自己小學,只招收40-60外來生, 當中竟有家長向校長發問, 投訴這是否對非其小學的考生不公平!    聽後不禁覺得'公平'兩字被濫用!

circleda

唔係化, DGJS有無唔咁蠢, 驚人唔知interview係點要group埋同校o既一齊前後腳咁去in?

原帖由 nicolemummy 於 09-10-11 22:08 發表
我不是這年的考生. 但我知道, 前年面試的安排, 是按幼稚園的名稱作次序. 例如: 浸大附幼(BUkinder), 基督堂幼(CCKG), 培正(Pui Ching) 等, 就是以B,C,P等去排. 所以, CCKG的小朋友擠在某1,2天面試不為奇. ...

candietweety

i agree with shwamy

原帖由 shwamy 於 09-10-15 14:29 發表
穿校服較穿全身名牌好!

heison

我個係仔， 所以無留意DGJS 既收生情況，但我好同意Sindy 所講， 係呢個時候，Mud野法寶都要出架LA

shwamy

穿校服較穿全身名牌好!

ahtan

原帖由 childrenfirst 於 09-10-11 13:25 發表
I think all of us should admit the fact that it's no real fairness in this world and as a private or DSS school, the head of the school will has the sole power to select the student that she/he or the ...

My kids are not in CCKG but I feel that if your kid is smart enough to get into CCKG, parents should be proud to show it. Besides, I have seen many other kids wearing other kindergarten's uniforms ( like St. Paul's Convent Nursery, Kai See etc) going for interviews last year. I don't see why people just point out about CCKG. Don't get jealous just because kids in CCKG are generally smart and well prepared! Even so, there are many smart kids who can't get into their desired schools every year. There is really NO guarantee. Therefore I don't think it's a big deal that kids are wearing school uniforms to interviews.

charwes

據理力爭其實冇問題，最怕係輸打贏要。

原帖由 chuyuencheung 於 09-10-11 22:49 發表
近年越來越多香港人奉行投訴文化，相信在投訴後便會獲得特別處理，相信任職服務業的站友一定有所感受，而近其中大少女因投訴而在 youtube 及高登討論區聲名大燥，更是此種文化的最佳實例。 ...

chuyuencheung

近年越來越多香港人奉行投訴文化，相信在投訴後便會獲得特別處理，相信任職服務業的站友一定有所感受，而近其中大少女因投訴而在 youtube 及高登討論區聲名大燥，更是此種文化的最佳實例。

G-Ma

如果學校本身鍾意收某間幼稚園既學生, 佢著唔著校服結果都係一樣, 平常心啦, 無謂太介懷.

nicolemummy

我不是這年的考生. 但我知道, 前年面試的安排, 是按幼稚園的名稱作次序. 例如: 浸大附幼(BUkinder), 基督堂幼(CCKG), 培正(Pui Ching) 等, 就是以B,C,P等去排. 所以, CCKG的小朋友擠在某1,2天面試不為奇.

JKTL

我覺得你講的對

原帖由 Sindy 於 09-10-10 18:59 發表


有個媽咪話,讀基督堂又唔係收硬.......駛乜咁介意人地係點啫,做好自己盡左力咪得囉.....

charwes

冇錯，我覺得入得 CCKG 個目的都係想入 DBSPD or DGJS，父母想顯示呢點少少優勢真係無可厚非喎。

原帖由 mango22 於 09-10-11 15:44 發表

Totally agree...!

ShinTeresa

照計著咩對個ｉｎｔ　ｒｅｓｕｌｔ既影響應該不大　你一報時佢都知你讀邊間　始終都係睇個小朋友既林埸表演　

原帖由 PhdJessiema 於 09-10-10 18:21 發表
Heard that most of the CCKG girls were in school uniform when attending the interview. They knew that the game rule has changed. Thus they want to show their school uniforms to get some sort of benefi ...

mango22

原帖由 childrenfirst 於 09-10-11 13:25 發表
I think all of us should admit the fact that it's no real fairness in this world and as a private or DSS school, the head of the school will has the sole power to select the student that she/he or the ...

Totally agree...!

childrenfirst

I think all of us should admit the fact that it's no real fairness in this world and as a private or DSS school, the head of the school will has the sole power to select the student that she/he or the school may prefer. I think it's part of the game rule. Not only their preference on CCKG's student but also many other preferences behind.
Do you think these kinds of interviews will achieve any fairness?  Come on, from day one, i don't dream that these interviews can make a 100% fair judgement on my kid! Like the interview of SPCC, the questions were so general, how can they select the right ones out of 2000 applications? 10 mins interview and they would know the kid? It's a joke. Therefore, they must have their preferences.
If parents can admit this cruel fact, both the child and the parent can enjoy the process more and feel happier ...The fact is - We can never beat with the ones with connection or related. But what's the matters? I think the whole process is a kind of life exposure and after all there must be a school who will appreciate our children's  potential. It's not the end of the world to be rejected by these top schools. Of course, I would be extremely excited if those schools accept my application, that means our kids are much out perform than those who are related/connected!

My feeling is - I don't feel offended by the CCKG uniform issue (my kid is not at CCKG) as it's normal for the parents to do what they can for their kids!

CFaHB

有風度

原帖由 Sindy 於 09-10-11 00:59 發表


有幸兩年去面試,撞啱轉堂,小朋友係音樂室/操場上課室,個個都係happy face架...又有自信......雖然佢都唔收我個女,但都唔會踩佢