a kid at 4 years old - reading capability

leelilili

a kid at 4 years old - reading capability

could any mum share their kids reading capability when the kids are / were at 4 years old
e.g. which stage of popular readers like oxford reading tree / ladybird: read it yourself

I would like to take it as a benchmark, thx.

happyvalley

原帖由 mimi1102 於 10-11-2 16:18 發表
因為有d 書圖書館借唔到, 或借唔齊, 所以依家屋企越買越多書.

想請教大家, 自己買的書, 小朋友會唔會番睇架 ? 睇過的書, 或小朋友已經不會再睇的書, 你地會點樣處置呀 ? 掉左佢 ? 送比人 ? 賣左佢 ??

...

佢會重複睇完又睇的，對文字會加深印象，和第時搵返 d 句子出來作文。

happyvalley

原帖由 palmchristy 於 10-11-2 13:53 發表
同意呀! 所以圖書館裡的中英文的 JJ (Picture Books)書是小女兒的最愛.

為免偏食, 中英文書我也讓她看. 兩者她都喜歡. 兩種書我都會讀給她聽, 和她一起看. 她自己拿來看時, 中文書只能看圖畫, 英文書則圖畫和字都一 ...

係呀，太偏向中文書，宜家要睇返英文書，開始緊、幾好，有 d 似當年睇中文書。

weisscarton

你可以捐去圖書館，填張 form就得。暑假吉之島都可以捐。

mimi1102

因為有d 書圖書館借唔到, 或借唔齊, 所以依家屋企越買越多書.

想請教大家, 自己買的書, 小朋友會唔會番睇架 ? 睇過的書, 或小朋友已經不會再睇的書, 你地會點樣處置呀 ? 掉左佢 ? 送比人 ? 賣左佢 ??

原帖由 palmchristy 於 10-11-2 13:53 發表
同意呀! 所以圖書館裡的中英文的 JJ (Picture Books)書是小女兒的最愛.

為免偏食, 中英文書我也讓她看. 兩者她都喜歡. 兩種書我都會讀給她聽, 和她一起看. 她自己拿來看時, 中文書只能看圖畫, 英文書則圖畫和字都一 ...

palmchristy

同意呀! 所以圖書館裡的中英文的 JJ (Picture Books)書是小女兒的最愛.

為免偏食, 中英文書我也讓她看. 兩者她都喜歡. 兩種書我都會讀給她聽, 和她一起看. 她自己拿來看時, 中文書只能看圖畫, 英文書則圖畫和字都一起看.

當年家姐偏看中文, 現在英文書要急起直追.

原帖由 happyvalley 於 10-11-1 21:03 發表


4歲應該睇多點大圖像書 (Picture Books)，我當時以中文大圖像書為主，驚喜歡睇英文書但不喜歡睇中文書。直至小二暑假先開始注意英文圖書。

happyvalley

原帖由 palmchristy 於 10-10-26 22:48 發表
呢個問題, 好睇下家長幾時同小朋友開始睇書, 有幾經常睇, 睇幾多, 同埋是否選到程度合適的書. 只要肯同仔女睇, 佢地就自然鍾意睇, 同埋會成日睇, 咁就會持續進步.

我都係近幾個月先同個細女(4歲半)睇返多D書. 我都 ...

4歲應該睇多點大圖像書 (Picture Books)，我當時以中文大圖像書為主，驚喜歡睇英文書但不喜歡睇中文書。直至小二暑假先開始注意英文圖書。

palmchristy

呢個問題, 好睇下家長幾時同小朋友開始睇書, 有幾經常睇, 睇幾多, 同埋是否選到程度合適的書. 只要肯同仔女睇, 佢地就自然鍾意睇, 同埋會成日睇, 咁就會持續進步.

我都係近幾個月先同個細女(4歲半)睇返多D書. 我都無理Magic Box同ORT邊個程度, 總知就乜都同佢睇, 同佢讀. 由初時叫佢讀第一句, 到一人讀一句, 到一人一頁, 到近期程度淺的書成本書佢讀晒. 最開心就係佢開始讀出信心. 想趁幼稚園時可以得閒同佢睇多D. 希望佢小學開始可以自己睇chapter book.

反而我想請教大家選乜野書俾4-5歲小朋友讀. 好書應唔止ORT同Magic Box.

[ 本帖最後由 palmchristy 於 10-10-26 23:10 編輯 ]

happyvalley

原帖由 Hipuppy 於 10-10-18 23:50 發表
要小朋友查字典會唔會令佢覺得讀書唔再好玩? 我記得我細個o既時候唔鍾意讀課外書 , 好大原因係無人幫我 , 查字典又非常慢  , 覺得係一種折磨


...

對！所以淺 d law！

Hipuppy

要小朋友查字典會唔會令佢覺得讀書唔再好玩? 我記得我細個o既時候唔鍾意讀課外書 , 好大原因係無人幫我 , 查字典又非常慢  , 覺得係一種折磨

原帖由 mimi1102 於 10-9-6 09:29 發表
我有Isaacmommy 的同一個問題, 小女又係鍾意我伴讀, 佢就快五歲, 可以讀出好多英文字, 但係唔係個個字都識得解, 所以好多時佢即使讀晒成本書都唔知人地講咩 ..我有叫佢嘗試自己睇, 但係睇唔夠兩頁, 佢就會話唔明白,  ...

mimi1102

終於有人回覆我勒 ..多謝你呀 ~ ^_^

原帖由 happyvalley 於 10-10-5 23:40 發表


興趣來自圖畫與文字與表達情景，當特然間佢會自己睇，唔明有圖畫就自動明，唔洗問，睇下睇下就會長，會快，會明白，會吸收，會上心，慢慢睇多了，我囡八歲佢懂得睇文言文書。

最重要『大圖畫，小文字』書作開始。 ...

happyvalley

原帖由 mimi1102 於 10-9-6 09:29 發表
我有Isaacmommy 的同一個問題, 小女又係鍾意我伴讀, 佢就快五歲, 可以讀出好多英文字, 但係唔係個個字都識得解, 所以好多時佢即使讀晒成本書都唔知人地講咩 ..我有叫佢嘗試自己睇, 但係睇唔夠兩頁, 佢就會話唔明白,  ...

興趣來自圖畫與文字與表達情景，當特然間佢會自己睇，唔明有圖畫就自動明，唔洗問，睇下睇下就會長，會快，會明白，會吸收，會上心，慢慢睇多了，我囡八歲佢懂得睇文言文書。

最重要『大圖畫，小文字』書作開始。

mimi1102

我有Isaacmommy 的同一個問題, 小女又係鍾意我伴讀, 佢就快五歲, 可以讀出好多英文字, 但係唔係個個字都識得解, 所以好多時佢即使讀晒成本書都唔知人地講咩 ..我有叫佢嘗試自己睇, 但係睇唔夠兩頁, 佢就會話唔明白, 要我伴讀, 依家去圖書館的書, 越來越長, 我冇辦法可以晚晚讀咁多故事書比佢聽 .

請教其他媽咪, 你地係點樣引導佢地自己睇書架 ?

P.S. 佢地咁細個, 可以教佢地自己查字典嗎 ? 有冇邊本字典可以推介呢 ?

謝謝 ~

原帖由 Isaacmommy 於 10-7-2 23:46 發表
Can your daughter just pick up a book and read by herself (with no one pointing to the words? How do you train up your daughter? My son is capable of reading ORT stage 8-9 but I have to sit beside him ...

happyvalley

我囡四歲能力係 0 英文書 + 0 中文書，直至到七歲。

daisy17772

I believe the readability could be speed up very suddenly once the child gets used to reading more and more. Last summer, my girl could not read chapter books and could only use phonics to recognise words.  But now, she could read Magic tree house without help and is now advancing to reading more difficult books.  Making sure he/she is interested in reading is more important than measuring their capability.  Once they're interested in it, they will pick up the skill very quickly.  No worry.

Isaacmommy

Can your daughter just pick up a book and read by herself (with no one pointing to the words? How do you train up your daughter? My son is capable of reading ORT stage 8-9 but I have to sit beside him and point from word to word. Also, he prefers me reading to him rather than reading on his own.

Maybe one day, when the time comes, he can just pick up a book and read by himself.  

原帖由 wootaitai 於 10-5-9 00:09 發表


Update... my daughter went from totally illiterate 1 year ago to reading chapter books now!

Really amazing... and yes, the benchmark doesnt really matter

brima

都未必, my daughter 3.5 years old, she can read 很多生字但唔識串, 如中文佢認到D字但唔會知筆順或點寫

原帖由 Miffy-miffy 於 10-6-22 13:55 發表
如果識 "read" 本書, 即係小朋友已經識得個生字點串 ?