非常失望的心橋言語治療

kinheimom

我個細仔今日去心橋做言語評估,但好失望.

由於心急細仔言語遲緩太多, 所以我個仔係1月份已經係太子協康先做個言語評估,一邊等邊度有位去做訓練,所以心目中已有一些言語評估,慨念

不計環境因素 (協康的設施,資源都比心橋好得多),因為小朋友只是在訓練室同言語治療師做治療, 但係個治療師超唔掂,

1)同小朋友玩沒有技巧

2)並沒有在遊戲中引導小朋友說話, 仲跟小朋友講朋bb話

3)玩具沒有放好,比我個仔見到火車頭連路軌,咁我個仔要玩,跟住要收車玩第2樣,咁小朋友一定不肯,就哭.又話他不合作,除車外不懂其他詞,

4)50分鐘一到即刻要我們出房,他自己在治療房寫評語, 仲係大堂當住其他家長講我小朋友的情況

5) 一方面說他是言語治療師未能評估小朋友其他方面,但在評估報告中建議我小朋友要做綜合訓練,我問他你在評估的那一部份覺得我小朋友有此需要,他不能具體答出,只說小朋友認知,指令好重要, 我說在幼兒園做不到嗎,他說他們中心有個別訓練.比我感覺他是想sell服務多個小孩的需要,起碼在溝通技巧上,這位治療師真的很差

因為我住葵興,所以本來心橋係首選,但領教過這位治療師後,才知道點解協康的知名度高咁多

zenochan128

原帖由 kinheimom 於 09-3-6 10:00 發表
Thanks!  As I live in NewTerritories side, I will try the ST offered by Heep Hong first.  If no good, then i will contact U for more info.   

Hello Kinheimom,

Can you tell me doing the test how much.
Bczs my son maybe need doing the test.
Please advise, thanks.

kinheimom

Thanks!  As I live in NewTerritories side, I will try the ST offered by Heep Hong first.  If no good, then i will contact U for more info.   

原帖由 OnEarth 於 09-3-4 14:58 發表
You may want to try Ms. Lau at professional Speech & Hearing Services Ltd, she used to teach ST students at Hong Kong University, supper nice.
Other good ones include -
Steps in Central
St. James S ...

OnEarth

You may want to try Ms. Lau at professional Speech & Hearing Services Ltd, she used to teach ST students at Hong Kong University, supper nice.
Other good ones include -
Steps in Central
St. James Settlement in Central
Anyone goes to these?

原帖由 kinheimom 於 09-3-4 14:05 發表
基本上這間中心的各方面 (包括設施,治療室,資源借用)都同協康有好大的距離,我仍然去這間心橋做評估的原因是它的位置跟我家和幼兒學校好近(10分鐘-行路),所以我諗如果個言語治療師好過協康好多,我才會考慮.因為不想小 ...

kinheimom

基本上這間中心的各方面 (包括設施,治療室,資源借用)都同協康有好大的距離,我仍然去這間心橋做評估的原因是它的位置跟我家和幼兒學校好近(10分鐘-行路),所以我諗如果個言語治療師好過協康好多,我才會考慮.因為不想小朋友花超過1小時在搭車。

既然現時的結論是無論如何我都不會考慮心橋,我又不想批評他們中心的各方面跟我預期有好大距離, 而且你同我一樣找同一個言語治療師,反應出來都不一樣,或者心橋會覺得我對他們有偏見,

Anyway, 好在可以想係呢度發洩下!!

原帖由 jenny1209 於 09-3-4 13:14 發表
May be you can talk with their in-charge, Ms. Ma, let them know your comments or concern such that they can improve.

jenny1209

May be you can talk with their in-charge, Ms. Ma, let them know your comments or concern such that they can improve.

原帖由 kinheimom 於 09-3-4 11:50 發表
yes.  very surprised.   How come my comment and yours is so extreme?   maybe she is not in the mood on my assessment date??

kinheimom

yes.  very surprised.   How come my comment and yours is so extreme?   maybe she is not in the mood on my assessment date??

原帖由 jenny1209 於 09-3-4 11:16 發表
Yes, Ms. Choi.  Same as your son?

jenny1209

Yes, Ms. Choi.  Same as your son?

原帖由 kinheimom 於 09-3-3 14:19 發表
what's the name of your ST?  Ms. Choi?

kinheimom

what's the name of your ST?  Ms. Choi?

原帖由 jenny1209 於 09-3-3 13:05 發表
My ST was very nice and patient with my daughter.  When my daughter attend the playgroup in the past few weeks, I hadn't met with the ST, may be she has left the centre already?

Don't worry, can try  ...

jenny1209

My ST was very nice and patient with my daughter.  When my daughter attend the playgroup in the past few weeks, I hadn't met with the ST, may be she has left the centre already?

Don't worry, can try other ST services.  Have confident on your son, he will pick up very soon if have treatment.

kinheimom

起碼政府(聯合)的ST有限$,我去葵興心橋,比左$600,激到一肚氣.

我之前係太子協康做評估的ST好後生,但他勝在有耐性同小朋友玩,引導小朋友在遊戲中學講野,這點是家長陪同小朋友上ST course 時,要在ＳＴ身上學到技巧,才可在家實踐,

這位葵興心橋ST連以上最基本的ST應有態度都沒有,所以這$600真是花得物無所值.:;pppp:

原帖由 Daisy媽咪 於 09-3-3 08:58 發表


絕對了解你心情, 你既情形就同我係聯合遇到果個 st 一樣, 不過我個仔之前係彩雲做, 個st 係ok 架, 可能佢自己都有小朋友, 所以好d 啦, 不過你可以係番協康做啦, 因為呢d野, quality 真係好重要架! ...

Daisy媽咪

原帖由 大鴨媽 於 09-3-2 21:17 發表
唔緊要啦,你好彩之前已經在協康做緊,那就繼續啦...

要不是現在發現心橋有問題才去排就仲慘

現在都算是不幸中之大幸啦

絕對了解你心情, 你既情形就同我係聯合遇到果個 st 一樣, 不過我個仔之前係彩雲做, 個st 係ok 架, 可能佢自己都有小朋友, 所以好d 啦, 不過你可以係番協康做啦, 因為呢d野, quality 真係好重要架!

大鴨媽

唔緊要啦,你好彩之前已經在協康做緊,那就繼續啦...

要不是現在發現心橋有問題才去排就仲慘

現在都算是不幸中之大幸啦

原帖由 kinheimom 於 09-2-28 19:08 發表
我個細仔今日去心橋做言語評估,但好失望.

由於心急細仔言語遲緩太多, 所以我個仔係1月份已經係太子協康先做個言語評估,一邊等邊度有位去做訓練,所以心目中已有一些言語評估,慨念

不計環境因素 (協康的設施,資源 ...

sharon26788

唔緊要啦,起碼你咁快就知道要選擇邊間,好事黎既