我女下年讀國際學校3歲班,小學可否考本地小學

娜娜媽.

讓她讀is原因係想佢英文好, 有開心的幼年學校生活, 其間e2年, 我會自己比功課佢做,好似普通幼稚園咁, 到第三年我會睇下比唔比佢上is的Year1or在耀中讀5歲班, 如果入, 我可唔可以到5,6歲時比佢考本地小學

TINGMUM

PurpleSea,
1) TSL got much cheaper school fee.
2) Want to let my son try local school and see if he can fit into local school or not.
3) My daughter is in TSL so that two kids can go to school together every day.
4) Want him to have a better Chinese standard.

I can say I like both schools even though they have totally different syllabus.  For my son, he always claim that he likes RC more.

PurpleSea

Do you mind to tell me why you switch your son from RC to TSL?

TINGMUM

Eh-oh,

I don't know much english primary schools in HK.  I only know three schools, that is TSL, CKY and St. Margaret. My kids are in TSL. I can say this is a good school with high english and chinese standard.  If you want to stay in an international school with certain chinese standard, I would  recommand RC.  My son was there last year.  RC is also an excellent school we do really like it.

Eh-oh

原帖由 TINGMUM 於 09-1-15 13:06 發表
娜娜媽,

好明白你的想法.  其實好講你小一是打算入什麼學校, 如果是傳統+中文為主的小學, 到時娜娜會跟得辛苦. 你要有心理準備.  如果是某幾間活動英文小學, 即除中文科外,大多學科用英文教的小學, 到時娜娜除中文 ...

Hi, can suggest any "活動英文小學" in HK? Many thanks!

mark2006

原帖由 壞女孩 於 09-1-16 07:18 發表
始終if target本地小學,我個人覺得國際幼稚園並不是一個good choice,好多媽咪想小朋友英文好都咁做,但佢哋英文叻(oral English)呢個優勢,入到本地小學P.1根本作用不大,因本地小學英文著重spelling, grammar, 做paper ...

No matter how you have been immersed in 100% English environment before, children studying in  local schools will communicate with Cantonese unless the school policies and incentives of using English have educated them enough to  use English ....right?
On the other hand, if their Chi is not good enough, their lang development is not 'healthy' as local schools foster Bilingualism and Triliteracy .....Quite annoying

[ 本帖最後由 mark2006 於 09-1-16 13:35 編輯 ]

meipo28

Wanna get some advice.  I am still at the cross road: IS vs local school.  Both has its own pros and cons. And my son is now only 15 months and it might be too early to decide which type of school system fits him the best.  In that case, what kind of kinder/nursery should I look for.  Do you think Victoria and Tutor Time would be a choice?

壞女孩

始終if target本地小學,我個人覺得國際幼稚園並不是一個good choice,好多媽咪想小朋友英文好都咁做,但佢哋英文叻(oral English)呢個優勢,入到本地小學P.1根本作用不大,因本地小學英文著重spelling, grammar, 做paper,而本地小學小朋友喺學校全以廣東話交談,不出半年小朋友就會轉晒channel,英文大大退步,我有幾個朋友嘅小朋友都有咁嘅情況,你要有心理準備.

娜娜媽.

多謝你回覆, 我地會努力架lar~~~

原帖由 TINGMUM 於 09-1-15 13:06 發表
娜娜媽,

好明白你的想法.  其實好講你小一是打算入什麼學校, 如果是傳統+中文為主的小學, 到時娜娜會跟得辛苦. 你要有心理準備.  如果是某幾間活動英文小學, 即除中文科外,大多學科用英文教的小學, 到時娜娜除中文 ...

TINGMUM

娜娜媽,

好明白你的想法.  其實好講你小一是打算入什麼學校, 如果是傳統+中文為主的小學, 到時娜娜會跟得辛苦. 你要有心理準備.  如果是某幾間活動英文小學, 即除中文科外,大多學科用英文教的小學, 到時娜娜除中文成績較差外, 其他其實都沒有問題.

如你想自小中英都叻, 讀講都容易達到, 但書寫方面, 特別是中文閱讀理解,如讀開國際學校, 到本地小學時真是不容易追. 你一定要有足夠心理準備去付出很多時間同心機.

娜娜媽.

本地同is的幼稚園教法真係分別咁大?????

Cherishvalue

I don't think kids from IS kinder will have significant problem in DSS P1 interview.  For example, story-telling should be one of the strong points for IS kids.

However, I do agree that it might be difficult for kids coming from IS kinders to go for the local P1 syllabus.

原帖由 birdbird 於 09-1-12 22:35 發表
小朋友本身讀 IS, 到適齡, 是可以考本地小學的小一. 不過, 本地小一interview所要求的, 讀開 IS 的小朋友就未必應付得到.

birdbird

小朋友本身讀 IS, 到適齡, 是可以考本地小學的小一. 不過, 本地小一interview所要求的, 讀開 IS 的小朋友就未必應付得到.

birdbird

原帖由 娜娜媽. 於 09-1-12 15:47 發表
我係比佢在耀中讀幼稚園, 但耀中係有2條隊, 一. 係讀3-5歲班, and then 耀中y1, 二係3-4歲班, 到5歲班就入耀中for本地學校的5歲班即k3班, 我想其實想問, lee2條路線, 邊條會好d, 這2條路都唔算轉來轉去掛?????
我都 ...

小朋友的中文, 家長本身不是教師的話,
其實好難話好有系統咁教小朋友讀書寫字.
據聞耀中幼稚園有教小朋友普通話/中文,
相信小朋友的中文能力應該不會是大問題.

娜娜媽.

原帖由 娜娜媽. 於 09-1-12 15:47 發表
我係比佢在耀中讀幼稚園, 但耀中係有2條隊, 一. 係讀3-5歲班, and then 耀中y1, 二係3-4歲班, 到5歲班就入耀中for本地學校的5歲班即k3班, 我想其實想問, lee2條路線, 邊條會好d, 這2條路都唔算轉來轉去掛?????
我都 ...

係3-4歲斑先岩~~~~~~

娜娜媽.

我係比佢在耀中讀幼稚園, 但耀中係有2條隊, 一. 係讀3-5歲班, and then 耀中y1, 二係3-4歲班, 到5歲班就入耀中for本地學校的5歲班即k3班, 我想其實想問, lee2條路線, 邊條會好d, 這2條路都唔算轉來轉去掛?????
我都係想佢開開心心的過一個學習的生活, 但又想佢學好d英文, 所以比佢讀耀中law.而中文我就可以教佢law(在佢好小的時候以開始教她 ,所以中文的係唔擔心的)
咁即係一定二路線會好d呢??????(對日後佢考私小同直資)

唔該大家, 又多謝yyyy的意見

原帖由 yyyy 於 09-1-12 10:33 發表
轉來轉去其實不是最理想,is跟local是兩個不同的教育理念,父母的責任是知道什麼對自己的小朋友比較適合,提供一個比較安定的學習環境給他,同時要堅持自己私教育理念,遇到困難時才可一起去解決
...

yyyy

轉來轉去其實不是最理想,is跟local是兩個不同的教育理念,父母的責任是知道什麼對自己的小朋友比較適合,提供一個比較安定的學習環境給他,同時要堅持自己私教育理念,遇到困難時才可一起去解決

原帖由 娜娜媽. 於 09-1-10 18:43 發表
讓她讀is原因係想佢英文好, 有開心的幼年學校生活, 其間e2年, 我會自己比功課佢做,好似普通幼稚園咁, 到第三年我會睇下比唔比佢上is的Year1or在耀中讀5歲班, 如果入, 我可唔可以到5,6歲時比佢考本地小學 ...