北角聖米迦勒 vs 柴灣聖米迦勒

dadbu

本人是在北米下午校畢業的, 如選擇北米的話有25分(母為該校畢業生10+相同宗教5+適齡兒童5),  羸面應該高. 但我聽說柴米比較好, 而我住柴灣的. 其實北米都是不錯的, 是嗎?

請各路英雄比D意見, 唔該晒!

sarah1223

小女很好彩只有首名子女分都入到北米

原帖由 JustinJustin 於 08-11-27 21:31 發表
北米 今年有25分, 20分都一定收, 15分都抽到, 放心啦,邊有咁多小朋友.
柴米20分都冇問題, 但近咁多大型屋村,爭位情況,可以同LS比美,收到有3XX for自行派位.
柴米即是北米上午班,有八十九年傳統,派位當然ok,不過屋村 ...

super11mum

唔係，細仔無去二仔個間，搏一搏，因我對柴米有好好印象。

原帖由 ladykin 於 08-11-27 16:44 發表


您既意思係 25 分都衰咗

父母舊生係咪 10分嫁. 因為我個仔係首名子女, 咁加埋適齡 10 分, 係咪有 25分呀

JustinJustin

北米 今年有25分, 20分都一定收, 15分都抽到, 放心啦,邊有咁多小朋友.
柴米20分都冇問題, 但近咁多大型屋村,爭位情況,可以同LS比美,收到有3XX for自行派位.
柴米即是北米上午班,有八十九年傳統,派位當然ok,不過屋村家長會選屋企附近,馮校長話07/08年度的畢業生,對派位全滿意.

個人就喜歡馮校長10多年前教的學校.

報直資or私校, 是喜歡英語,普通話教中國語文,教學理念等等,未必一定是back-up. 對中學有很大影响,亦有一條龍.

原帖由 ladykin 於 08-11-27 10:38 發表
各位好. 好高興有人討論呢兩間學校.

我老公係北米上午舊生, 所以應該係計算入柴米. 如果出年報第一輪 (應該) 有 25分, 係咪實得呢?  仲駛唔駛幫佢報直資或私校呢?

因為今年我姪女報小一, 自行衰咗, 又冇報直資同私 ...

JustinJustin

dadbu,

I think you can have that 10 mark as the old boys, call and ask the Principal Fung directly. Sometimes, they don't like to clear cut the relationship with the old boys.   
Next year, SKH St Michael's will celebrate 90th year. You need provide the document for them.

原帖由 dadbu 於 08-11-26 16:16 發表
Hi JustinJustin,

Thank you for your information and sharing.  If you ask me to choose, undoubtedly I will choose 'Chai Rice'. It is nearer to my house and I got a lot of positive comment from the par ...

[ 本帖最後由 JustinJustin 於 08-11-27 20:55 編輯 ]

ladykin

原帖由 super11mum 於 08-11-27 16:15 發表
ladykin, 我細仔柴米自行都衰咗，因我膽大過頭唔跟二仔。不過，我會在大抽獎試過

您既意思係 25 分都衰咗

父母舊生係咪 10分嫁. 因為我個仔係首名子女, 咁加埋適齡 10 分, 係咪有 25分呀

super11mum

ladykin, 我細仔柴米自行都衰咗，因我膽大過頭唔跟二仔。不過，我會在大抽獎試過

原帖由 ladykin 於 08-11-27 10:38 發表
各位好. 好高興有人討論呢兩間學校.

我老公係北米上午舊生, 所以應該係計算入柴米. 如果出年報第一輪 (應該) 有 25分, 係咪實得呢?  仲駛唔駛幫佢報直資或私校呢?

因為今年我姪女報小一, 自行衰咗, 又冇報直資同私 ...

chingbb

Thank you very much!
我想請教, 如果我個係細佬只有10分(適齡) ~ 揀小學時是否應該揀返自己個區(14網)先比較好呢?

原帖由 曲曲 於 08-11-26 15:34 發表


小學的確是不同校網
北米是14網
柴米是16網

不過中學是同校網 - 東區
全港劃分成18個升中校網
小學位於14或16網　升中都是東區校網

ladykin

各位好. 好高興有人討論呢兩間學校.

我老公係北米上午舊生, 所以應該係計算入柴米. 如果出年報第一輪 (應該) 有 25分, 係咪實得呢?  仲駛唔駛幫佢報直資或私校呢?

因為今年我姪女報小一, 自行衰咗, 又冇報直資同私立, 宜家好驚大攪珠時唔知會派去邊?

另外, 因為柴米太新, 冇乜數據參考, 請問柴米既程度如何? 多唔多功課同中一派位好唔好呢?

唔好意思, 太多問題, 但真係殺到埋身啦 ......

dadbu

Hello rtam, ononprincess and avbee,

Thank you so...........much for your sharing.

Hi rtam, in fact I also heard about this story and I think all of us are not in a right position to comment because noone knows exactly what is the story behind and I will not on any side as well even I was graduated there.

Thanks again for your valuable advice:loveliness: .

原帖由 rtam 於 08-11-26 20:43 發表
dadbu,

Since you graduated in North Rice, you probably have heard that a gifted child's father complained about North Rice.  I don't want to mention the story here because I don't quite agree with th ...

avbee

chai wan one is better

ononprincess

Exactly, if not the location, I will also apply this school.

原帖由 rtam 於 08-11-26 20:43 發表
dadbu,

Since you graduated in North Rice, you probably have heard that a gifted child's father complained about North Rice.  I don't want to mention the story here because I don't quite agree with th ...

rtam

dadbu,

Since you graduated in North Rice, you probably have heard that a gifted child's father complained about North Rice.  I don't want to mention the story here because I don't quite agree with this father.  But what I worry... 事件會否影響老師的士氣和對學生的態度...I hope not.  

Chai Rice is so good that if it is not the location concern, I will go ahead too.

kikiboy

原帖由 曲曲 於 08-11-26 15:34 發表


小學的確是不同校網
北米是14網
柴米是16網

不過中學是同校網 - 東區
全港劃分成18個升中校網
小學位於14或16網　升中都是東區校網

曲曲講得啱, 中學係同一校網.

dadbu

Hi JustinJustin,

Thank you for your information and sharing.  If you ask me to choose, undoubtedly I will choose 'Chai Rice'. It is nearer to my house and I got a lot of positive comment from the parents here for this school.  But you know, unforunately, the marks on my hand is in 'North Rice' not 'Chai Rice'.

So I really want to know if 'North Rice' is also a good school or someone can advise me may be you better give up the marks there even you have the yellow card in 'North Rice' because it is not that good. Take the risk, go ahead to fight for a seat at 'Chai Rice' even I got a little mark there.

Please advise, many thanks!!

mimi1102

請問柴米升中通常派去邊架 ?

原帖由 曲曲 於 08-11-26 15:34 發表


小學的確是不同校網
北米是14網
柴米是16網

不過中學是同校網 - 東區
全港劃分成18個升中校網
小學位於14或16網　升中都是東區校網

JustinJustin

rtam,

Thank you for your warm caring.
With God provision, he was accepted by SSCPC three weeks before for P1. Registered yesterday.  
Next year, I don't plan to apply for SPCC P1, may be P2.  Don't know whether they have age limited for P2?

原帖由 rtam 於 08-11-26 08:23 發表
Hi JustinJustin,
Thanks.
Are you the one in SPCC topic as well?
I remember you said your child will apply S1 next year.
You have one year to consider and plan, so I am sure you will find a good schoo ...

[ 本帖最後由 JustinJustin 於 08-11-26 15:07 編輯 ]

JustinJustin

I don't know wor, I heard from the principal and the parents of 北 米. They said St Paul College (Boy's) is in the 北米's list, but not in 柴米 list.
July, Principal Fung said his students can enter all their target secondary school, he don't need to help anyone knocking door for the secondary school. 咁安安樂樂,家長亦滿意,大可放心讀. website內校長信有寫.

原帖由 曲曲 於 08-11-26 10:11 發表


北角及柴灣中學校網都屬於東區
為何說北角中學校網比柴灣好呢?

[ 本帖最後由 JustinJustin 於 08-11-26 12:14 編輯 ]