為何對SMC存有 不正面的評價呢？(收到取錄通知未呀？)

littleboris

本人都是很喜歡直資學校的，但我一定會做足資料搜集和了解透徹學校的教學理念才決定是否投考的，SMC都是本人心儀的其中之一，但很多家長一聽到這學校都有很大的反應(當然是劣評)，於是也引起本人的疑惑，上星期我囝囝去該校面試，我好留意每一位教職員及每一位在操場上的老師和學生，我眼見的學生都很開心、自信、流利英語都是肯定的，雖然老師是沒有笑容，但小朋友都很服從，而小兒的面試過程老師花了45分鍾(單對單)，相比好多直資學校的1st in 好此冇噉兒嬉，anyway SMC係我心目中都是能夠令小朋友有個很愉快的讀書生涯，作為家長都是要求這點吧！人們對St.Margaret (girls)的津貼飛女學校 印象太深了，很難接受現已改革的直資SMC。
(以上只是本人的見解，唔聽的勿插)

[ 本帖最後由 littleboris 於 08-10-23 13:32 編輯 ]

chfong

I submitted the form on 27 Sep and they finally called me on 3 Nov 08 and an interview was held on 7 Nov 08.  No result up to now.

WingWingMa

我最尾一天交申請表, 但還未interview 呀?

baba_mama

我想問，有無人知道 SMC 係唔係已經停左 interview 啦？

原帖由 G-Ma 於 08-10-24 00:22 發表
其實學校咁多年都係咁安排, 先入表先interview, 覺得適合就會即收, 唔會等interview哂先揀邊d收邊d唔收.  所以早d入表就會著數d.  不過學校一定會interview哂所有小朋友, 機會仍然有.

...

G-Ma

我自己覺得呢個安排對家長同小朋友都公平d, 起碼你一合資格就收你, 唔駛等in哂所有小朋友先再揀best of the best才收, 咁既話機會仲細, 壓力仲大.

原帖由 lenmama 於 08-10-24 09:22 發表

I think that this way is fair.  They would tell you the result of your child done during interview, means that they offer the children which meet their standard.  In stead of, some of schools reject  ...

lenmama

原帖由 G-Ma 於 08-10-24 00:22 發表
其實學校咁多年都係咁安排, 先入表先interview, 覺得適合就會即收, 唔會等interview哂先揀邊d收邊d唔收.  所以早d入表就會著數d.  不過學校一定會interview哂所有小朋友, 機會仍然有.

...

I think that this way is fair.  They would tell you the result of your child done during interview, means that they offer the children which meet their standard.  In stead of, some of schools reject you under their own reason.

G-Ma

其實學校咁多年都係咁安排, 先入表先interview, 覺得適合就會即收, 唔會等interview哂先揀邊d收邊d唔收.  所以早d入表就會著數d.  不過學校一定會interview哂所有小朋友, 機會仍然有.

原帖由 baba_mama 於 08-10-23 21:25 發表
到現在都仲未收到 interview 的通知，一次都未 in，人地就話已經 being accepted，真係覺得學校的行政有好大問題。

baba_mama

到現在都仲未收到 interview 的通知，一次都未 in，人地就話已經 being accepted，真係覺得學校的行政有好大問題。

原帖由 G-Ma 於 08-10-14 19:49 發表
都有可能係學校已經收夠男生, 所以會先interview女生, 因為學校都想兩性既比例相若d.  

其實咩可能性都有, 唔駛太在意, 學校一定會見哂所有申請者, 但因為每位小朋友佢地都花好多時間(30-45分鐘), 所以會遲d先約見 ...

lenmama

原帖由 littleboris 於 08-10-23 13:20 發表
lenmama:
你好!請問你幾時1st in ?因我都等好耐，好心急同擔心，我朋友咋日收到信(不獲取緣) ，仲要等幾耐呀？

Hi Littleboris,
Our 1st interview done on 9/26.  You may call Ms Cheung at SMC office to check the queue up to now. It will be better to keep on waiting.

littleboris

原帖由 lenmama 於 08-10-23 11:15 發表
Hi,
I went to 2nd interview yesterday & saw few family came for 1st interview, they all are boys, so they do not just select boys for interview, don't worry.

lenmama:
你好!請問你幾時1st in ?因我都等好耐，好心急同擔心，我朋友咋日收到信(不獲取緣) ，仲要等幾耐呀？

lenmama

Hi,
I went to 2nd interview yesterday & saw few family came for 1st interview, they all are boys, so they do not just select boys for interview, don't worry.

yanyan0629

我相信學校收得二十大元,一定會安排面試的. 本人就十分欣賞那麼便宜的申請費用啦!
另外,我囡囡算係十分之好彩.因為我去左聽佢地的第一次簡介會. 簡介會當日已經提及如果有心的家長,就盡快喺嗰兩三日交申請表啦!於是我就拿拿聲即刻喺之後嗰個星期一通知幼稚園校長寫推薦信.但我都係遲過其他第一批的家長少少.變左第二批.
反之,其他學校,間間我都係dead-line嗰日先去交表.
我囡囡真係好好彩,因為我去左聽第一次簡介會,同埋無<合>眼訓.雖然個簡介會有d悶.我聽倒我後面對夫婦話好悶,想走.個男話想走,但個女就話坐多陣先啦!hehe!
後尾又有免費茶點.相信無咩邊間學校有做.但我嗰日趕住帶個囡之後去比賽,只係攞左支水飲.無得食  .

ftsang

Hi Mycarrie,

SMC started accepting application since July/Aug.  they had 2 seminars Aug and Sep. the admin staff will arrange your interview once recieved your application.  i submitted mine by hand and arranged interview time right away.  there were other BK moms call the school to arrange interview after the application submission.  the school interview started since Sep 1 already.  

Good luck.

原帖由 mycarrie 於 08-10-18 09:21 發表
我9月27日交表, 到而家都未收到信, 但係有d已經話收埋生, 1st IN, 2nd IN咁, 即係點ar?? 差距無理由咁大ga?

jena2468

我26/9交form ge, 我今朝打去問, 書記小姐話e+ 做到21號左右, 叫我再等下 !

mycarrie

我9月27日交表, 到而家都未收到信, 但係有d已經話收埋生, 1st IN, 2nd IN咁, 即係點ar?? 差距無理由咁大ga?

WD40

我想大家可能誤會了，昨天到學校接囝囝放學時都見到有家長帶小男孩interview。

原帖由 kyliema2006 於 08-10-16 11:35 發表
收夠男生，所以才見女生的估計，若學校真的如是，可能會觸犯性別歧視條例喎。

G-Ma

呢個只係我自己亂估, 完全唔代表學校立場, 真正原因我地大家都唔會知道.

原帖由 kyliema2006 於 08-10-16 11:35 發表
收夠男生，所以才見女生的估計，若學校真的如是，可能會觸犯性別歧視條例喎。

catcatmom

大家都係估jar!有邊個知原因喎!聖番暑收了好男仔, 女仔就好少.

原帖由 kyliema2006 於 08-10-16 11:35 發表
收夠男生，所以才見女生的估計，若學校真的如是，可能會觸犯性別歧視條例喎。

kyliema2006

收夠男生，所以才見女生的估計，若學校真的如是，可能會觸犯性別歧視條例喎。

原帖由 G-Ma 於 08-10-14 19:49 發表
都有可能係學校已經收夠男生, 所以會先interview女生, 因為學校都想兩性既比例相若d.  

其實咩可能性都有, 唔駛太在意, 學校一定會見哂所有申請者, 但因為每位小朋友佢地都花好多時間(30-45分鐘), 所以會遲d先約見 ...

WD40

Totally agreed.

原帖由 catcatmom 於 08-10-14 18:09 發表
每間學校都有準則收生, 唔同意就唔好apply, 所以我沒有apply B school.
我5覺得, 小朋友唔夠勁, 就被選唔到 ; 夠勁就去選學校. 一個5歲小朋友點樣判斷佢各方面既能力, 仲有d頂級名校, in得果幾分鐘, 何以判斷? 選家 ...