聖母小學 VS 德雅小學

WINLEG

兩間都是私小,學費差不多,想知在學術上,品德教育,校風上,教學方法,升中情況,學習氣氛,功課壓力各方面的比較.
你地會拺選邊間呢?

Crabtree

朋友囡囡轉了宏爵國際學校, 現讀得很開心, 雖然學費頗貴, 但她說值得, 因大家的關係比以前好了很多.  其實最重要係自已囡囡能否在壓力下成長.

原文章由 WINLEG 於 08-7-16 00:09 發表
Thanks, Crabtree

想問你朋友女兒後來轉了那間學校?

我其它實都有小小擔心,囡囡是否能在壓力較大環境下讀書,始終佢現在仍是K2學生!

fatcoco

德雅的中學派位，多是德雅中學和聖母玫瑰，不錯的。

fatcoco

德雅的英文同數學深過出面一年，校風好好，不過就功課多點。我選德雅。

WINLEG

Thanks, Crabtree

想問你朋友女兒後來轉了那間學校?

我其它實都有小小擔心,囡囡是否能在壓力較大環境下讀書,始終佢現在仍是K2學生!

Crabtree

我識朋友女兒原讀德雅小嘅, 但因小三其中一科主科不合格, 故此要留級. 但我朋友話每日放工返到屋企就好似打仗, 又有好多功課做, 又要預習, 默書又多, 最終頂唔順, 轉了校. 但轉咗之後, 母囡關係比以前好好多, 個囡又自動自覺做功課, 又主動溫書. 所以你要視乎你地如何面對壓力了?

另聖母小學已出了今年升中派位結課, 可以一看.

http://www.olps.edu.hk/index_frame.htm

WINLEG

UP

WINLEG

Thanks for your sharing.

Any mami can sharing?

charlie2002

Great! you have got one on you mind so forget anyone which is also good then.
Yes, agree different year, different student. We all knew study is all depends on kid, we are always try our best to do their assistant.

原文章由 SandyKL 於 08-7-12 00:13 發表
德雅小學既派位係唔錯架，呢個係我女幼稚園個校車姨姨話我知。以我所知，以前德雅好多功課，平時有7至8份，到週末會有12份，但近年聽人講功課量已減少。

而聖母小學讀高半級，學術方面也不差，每年中學會收番8成小學既學生。我今 ...

SandyKL

德雅小學既派位係唔錯架，呢個係我女幼稚園個校車姨姨話我知。以我所知，以前德雅好多功課，平時有7至8份，到週末會有12份，但近年聽人講功課量已減少。

而聖母小學讀高半級，學術方面也不差，每年中學會收番8成小學既學生。我今年曾問過有囡囡在此校正讀6年級的家長，佢話女兒讀得好開心。我想壓力方面，以我與此兩校家長分別傾過，感到聖母小學應該比德雅小學輕，但當然，每人面對壓力的感覺及表現都不同。

至於校風，同為修女學校，兩間都不錯，外表都企企理理，好純樸。但聖母小學的修女，俾我好平易近人的感覺，我見佢地會與學生打成一片。

我自己會選聖母小學，因為一來我喜歡聖母小學的校舍多點，二來我相信聖母小學的壓力較輕，較為適合我女兒。兩間都係好學校，可以放心俾小朋友在內讀書，但每位家長之放眼點都不同，加上小朋友有不同特質，真的要配合本身主觀條件才可以有答案。

原文章由 WINLEG 於 08-7-11 20:58 發表
兩間都是私小,學費差不多,想知在學術上,品德教育,校風上,教學方法,升中情況,學習氣氛,功課壓力各方面的比較.
你地會拺選邊間呢? ...

[ 本文章最後由 SandyKL 於 08-7-12 01:05 編輯 ]

charlie2002

It was really a hard decision, we leave in TKO so consider to bring food and near but main point is after listen to the headmaster talk of EC, we believe which is a suitable for my daughter. Hope we didn't make any wrong mistake.
TN study a year ahead of English
We also feel TN is among the top few schools in academic but always keep silent so people who don't find out TN's details, may not know.

I think you got same case as us, 8 out of 10 who will choose TN instead of EC and yours same 8 out of 10 will not choose TN.

Find one which is fit for your kid.

原文章由 WINLEG 於 08-7-11 22:41 發表
charlie 2002

Thanks for your sharing.  Any mami can give comments?

But, why you chose EC instead of TN?

WINLEG

charlie 2002

Thanks for your sharing.  Any mami can give comments?

But, why you chose EC instead of TN?

[ 本文章最後由 WINLEG 於 08-7-11 22:44 編輯 ]

charlie2002

Sorry can only tell Tak Nga, hope you don't mind. My daughter finally decided EC instead of Tak Nga. Since we got to make decision so we understood TN very well. All issues you mentioned are relatively good at TN, if you clik on TN school web site, the up to date announcement of their Secondary result for good school % is very high. TN is a school with long history but little preasure only. After we did the interview by the headmistress and we did interview at other famous 2-3schools, we felt TN is far better than other famous private school.
Hope can help bit.