直 資 「 一 條 龍 」 拒 直 升 惹 爭 議

alicechan2006

直 資 「 一 條 龍 」 拒 直 升 惹 爭 議  

何 太 （ 右 ） 與 丈 夫 昨 表 示 ， 其 患 有 學 障 的 女 兒 曾 於 小 三 時 留 班 ， 何 太 更 特 地 為 愛 女 報 讀 本 港 及 美 國 的 心 理 學 和 學 障 課 程 。  

　　(星島日報報道)不少家長心儀「一條龍」學校，以省卻子女升中煩惱，但「一條龍」直資校亦要求學生中英數及操行及格，才可升班。有家長投訴，指南區直資校港大同學會書院，拒絕取錄其就讀結龍小學、患學障的女兒，涉嫌歧視學障生，計畫向平等機會委員會投訴。校方回應指，學生未達中、英、數及格的最低要求，但若成績進步，仍有機會於第二輪收生獲取錄。

　　柴灣港大同學會小學與港大同學會書院於○三年結龍。小學部六年級生何煥茵的父母昨召開記者會稱，去年底接獲書院通知，指女兒與其他約廿名小六生，因「尚未具備足夠條件」而遭拒收入學，當中部分為學障生。他們坦言，煥茵首學期只有中文和常識科及格，但校方拒收是違反「一條龍」

規定，打算向平機會投訴，「政府推行融合教育，學校這樣做明顯抵觸《殘障歧視條例》」。

　　兩人曾多次去信校方及教育局表達不滿，何太表示，書院校長陳鄭美珠今年初曾表示，若煥茵接受英語能力測試，便考慮取錄她，但條件是他們不能向平機會投訴，根本無誠意取錄女兒。

　　何太又指，小學部早前向首輪不獲推薦升中的家長，派發升中統一派位表格，但她堅拒參與，「學校拒收我女兒是不合情、不合理、不合法的，一定要在七月八日放榜前收她。」她續稱，若女兒入讀其他中學，須重新交代其情況，故雖擔心書院對學障生支援不足，仍堅持讓她入讀。

　　該校校董兼港大畢業生同學會教育基金執行總監馮可強回應指，書院第二輪收生結果於七月初公布，該學生於第二及第三學期成績進步，有機會獲推薦升中，亦可通過參與暑期英語特別課程或重讀小六，以達入學要求。

　　他承認，過去兩年均有不足十人不獲書院取錄，但校方要求學生於中、英、數及操行及格，屬專業決定，否則學生勉強升中，未能適應課程及英語教學也非好事。他強調，書院中一至中二亦亦取錄近二十名學障生，絕無歧視學生。

　　教育局發言人表示，局方會了解及跟進事件，但直資及私立學校的「一條龍」辦學模式，不受當局規定所限，家長須向學校直接查詢。

2008-06-23

from SingTao.com

matthewdad

dog jilt (day dream), please look down and you will find there is a small hole under your four legs.  Go immediately to hide up yourself.

Do you feel shameful of deliberately giving false information.

原文章由 daydream 於 08-7-24 12:45 發表
My poor coward and naive godson,

I have told you many times that don't chase me like a ghost.  I would only credit those good dog and I won't spare a single bone for you to lick as you are such a nai ...

matthewdad

dog jilt (day dream), please look down and you will find there is a small hole under your four legs.  Go immediately to hide up yourself.

Do you feel shameful of deliberately giving false information.

matthewdad

原文章由 daydream 於 08-7-22 14:14 發表
Oh! You dare to show up, Mr. Coward

The picture you posted exactly reflects the situation when we see your post.   

You had better to find a hole to hide yourself as you:
- lacking  ...

matthewdad

原文章由 daydream 於 08-7-22 10:09 發表
因此, 只要港同不再吹噓推行一條龍的教育便再不會惹爭議囉

chan803

原文章由 stevema 於 08-7-21 17:20 發表

算啦,

睇黎 ykk1628 連一條龍的教育理念係乜都唔知.

stevema

[quote]原文章由 ykk1628 於 08-7-17 15:49 發表

QUOTE:
原文章由 stevema 於 08-7-17 15:16 發表
那么，大公报的记者大概也是孩子考不到港同或直资，所以才有如此失实报道了。原来如此。

按你的赞美之词看来，港同真是成就卓越，难能可贵。可否请教一下具体的 fruitful results and hard effort 有些什么?

[quote]原文章 ...


sorry, I am not any staff or have a close relationship of HKUGA primary school or college. I am just only a parent.Frankly speaking, even the reporter, not tai chung po but also other newspapers  will sometimes have a partial view of the matter. I donot know why some parents always like to make prejudice criticism or use neagtive atitude against teachers and principals. Can we look the matter in a more postive way. Don't you think that is it good for miss Ho to continue study in HKUGA college if she couldnot meet the minimum entry requirement. What is the purpose of examination. why do we need the entry requirement? Don't you think that the HKUGA college or other schools still need to enroll miss Ho if she fails all main subjectsin primary six? If that is the case, no examination or minimum entry requirments are required

--------------------------------------------------------------

For education, it is not appropriate to apply such logic.  Have you heard about the story of shoes and feet?  your logic is kind of cut your feet to fit in the shoes... the shoes are made by the school.  It absolutely can equip/adjust the shoes to accommodate every single foot.  They must do that because they once claimed that they are capable to...

ykk1628

原文章由 daydream 於 08-7-18 12:21 發表
If HKUGA thinks that it doesn't have enough resources like ESF, then it has two choices:

1.  Increase the school fee to the level sufficient for it to be a REAL "thru-train" school like ESF

2.  Don' ...

rohoy2k and daydream,
I think it is wast of my valuable time and I will not respondto discuss with both of you further on the topics due to
your flimsy and prejudice views

rohoy2k

For most oridinary people, there is always a few annoying people among them try to stir up shit and make a scene. However, as the shit was stirred up, you may found some interesting fact insides that most of these people do not want to face.

Most parents, including the school management, see their school a machine to made student ready for higher education. So the scores are very important benchmark to proof their "product" quality. If their product is not accepted by higher education institution, all see it as a failure.

To reduce the "failure" you better keep an eye to their "raw materials" (admission interview) and perform quality control test. (test/exam and minimum promotion standard)

The fact is not all the kids are same in their abilities to pass these standards/hirdles. Those terms such as learning disability are just meanlingful to explain the situation of ability deviation among different kids and suggest helps, but not saying that the society should label them and set them aside from the normal system, like the retarded or recently called under-privileged.

If a school so claimed the school through-train to get the adantage of recruiting enough student so that they can get enough Govt subsidies, they should have bear what they are promised to do. Acknowledged that not all of their students will be able to proceed to higher education but these students still learn what they have to learn as a person during childhood. The school has the least right to say so that maybe another school suit you better..

ykk1628

原文章由 daydream 於 08-7-17 17:49 發表
ykk1628,

In reply to your replies:

***
(a) sorry, I am not only fous on the case of Mrs HO's kid or have any prejudice/impartial opinion on her kid. But it is Mrs HO , the reporter of tai kung po an ...

Good!. you quoted ESF schools in support of your views> Do you know what is the school fee of ESF? Not everyone can study in ESF and not all schools can have much resources like ESF schools.

chan803

原文章由 iwff 於 08-7-17 18:09 發表
Quoted from 大公報


***鄺倩萍表示，其女兒經醫管局評定患有學障，早年手眼欠協調、口吃和理解力欠佳。○二年入讀港大同學會小學，小三留讀一年外，功課迭有進步，品行獲校長肯定，今年上學期中文和常識科及格，但英文和數學未達六十分的及格線。***

該學生已係學校留了一年, 學校有不斷幫她的。據所知現在HKUGA仍有學障學生就讀, 學校不斷有幫助緊他們改進。

請DAY DREAM 不要再作出妄斷的評論。

iwff

妄斷的評論?

咁小五唔使留班, 即係夠資格升小六啦. 咁間學校在小六o個一年, 點樣 "不斷有幫助緊他改進"呢?

教咗一年, 幾科主科唔合格, 然後話佢唔夠資格升佢間中學?  間中學咁緊張收生的質素就唔好學人地話乜野一條龍啦:;pppp: :;pppp:


"不斷有幫助緊他們改進" 的結果係要佢地另外揾中學升中一?

iwff

Quoted from 大公報


***鄺倩萍表示，其女兒經醫管局評定患有學障，早年手眼欠協調、口吃和理解力欠佳。○二年入讀港大同學會小學，小三留讀一年外，功課迭有進步，品行獲校長肯定，今年上學期中文和常識科及格，但英文和數學未達六十分的及格線。***

該學生已係學校留了一年, 學校有不斷幫她的。據所知現在HKUGA仍有學障學生就讀, 學校不斷有幫助緊他們改進。

請DAY DREAM 不要再作出妄斷的評論。

iwff