我的小朋友係细B,下年9月剛好2.8歲,想請教...

kfytbb

我的小朋友係细B,下年9月剛好2.8歲,想請問是否很多幼稚園都不會收細B讀K1呢？是否有名氣的幼稚園一定都不會收细B。我本人住香港區，請問大家知否有沒有好的幼稚園而又肯收2.8個月的學生呢？有努各位幫忙！

Boxingbaby

Can you pls tell me which one are  SKH, VCB and LLC ??  I know SKH is Sheng Kung Hui, which one is your son in, what's good and what's bad about it ?  I want to apply this one too.  How about the other two that you have applied.  Can  you give me any views ?   Many many thanlks.

原文章由 bbone 於 07-9-20 12:44 硐表
Hi all,

My son was born in November. He is now 2 yrs 10 months and is going to K1.

What we did last year was we applied 3 KGs that we really liked and just let him try. He suceeded in all 3 applica ...

Boxingbaby

Radiomama

I totally agree with you, having said that I do not have real experience yet as I am still looking for PN for my boy for 2008.  However, I think all mama needs to consider not just the knowledge wise, interview successfulrate but the psychological side of the kid is also vital.

I have a friend where his son goes in K1 as a small boy and he made him repeat in K1 as he saw that his knowledge is able to catch up but like you say, not socially.  When he repeat in K1, his son was not happy for a long while as he sees his same year friend all go in K2.  Before that he was active in speaking but after repeat K1, he shows unhappy and speak very very little.

Radiomama

My boy was born in Nov too.  Last year, I applied 4 kindies and he got all offers.  I have never realised that it would be a problem.....
Then, he goes to K1 now and my hubby says, our boy is not as confident & independent as the others.  He could perform well knowledgably but not socially.  Some classmates are older than him almost for 1 year!  They are smart in all the ways! (Just 2-3 small kids in his class)

So, don't hurry to get into K1!  That's meaningless!  If I were you, I would let the kid try one whole year in pre-nursery...find a good one, has backup for K1, or try international pre-nursery/playgroup to train his language!

Moreover, I don't agree to force the child to repeat in K1/K2.  It will hurt his feeling.  Even if you find a new kindergarten, the curriculum will make him feel boring.  And be realistic, not many kindies will let you repeat in K2 & K3.

Putongren

原文章由 kfytbb 於 07-9-5 14:15 硐表
我的小朋友係细B,下年9月剛好2.8歲,想請問是否很多幼稚園都不會收細B讀K1呢？是否有名氣的幼稚園一定都不會收细B。我本人住香港區，請問大家知否有沒有好的幼稚園而又肯收2.8個月的學生呢？有努各位幫忙！ ...

Hi, kfytbb
幾時都系做大B著數過做細B。我有兩個B，大的7月出生，差不是全班最細的，普遍都是蝕底D。反而細的是11月出生，做了大B，樣樣醒目D。一般來說，男仔發展慢一點，都是做大B好。當然，世事無絕對，如果你的寶寶得嘅話，就唔駛理呢d理論。香港區我就推薦香港真光中學幼稚園（大坑道）：以下是我在另一題目的答問，希望幫到你。
***********************
1.請問你地覺得真光的優點 &缺點係咩呢?
先此聲明：我兩個孩子都在真光由幼稚園讀到小學（現在仍在小學）。作為真光家長，當然不會覺得有缺點啦！其實學校沒有優劣之分，只有適合與否，及你是否認同她的教學理念。如果你是親自到校報名，當天(2007/11/17) 及幼兒面見當日(2007/12/1)會有家長義工在場，你可以問到更多。你會見到家長幼兒是很愛真光；幼兒是在開心快樂的環境下成長，所謂「愉快學習」，就是這個道理。真光是沒有書本的，全由老師設計不同的課程，讓幼兒透過探索、體驗去學習；最終是讓孩子「學會學習」。全年又有不少親子活動，讓家長也一起學習；另每級一年最少有四次家長講座，令我們學會不少與孩子相處及迎接他們成長之道。環境得天獨厚，校舍有大遊戲場；雖然附近較多地盤，但香港哪裡沒有工程？不過，最重要還是軟件，老師有愛心、有耐性。你也可到幼稚園的網站，看看我們「家校合作」的雙月校訊〈真光之聲〉，你會明真光點解有咁多好似我D咁嘅fans。
2. 學校較著重德育還是學術?
幼稚園何來學術？這也許就是一般家長認為她的最大缺點：「太淺了」
3. 小朋友英文水平怎樣?
這是相對的問題。不過，近年已提高不少；當然，就不要同那些聖乜維物相比。但不覺升讀其它小學會有銜接上的問題。
4. 有沒有教普通話?
少許啦！不過請勿抱過高期望。還是那一句，看家長要求甚麼？
5. 收生會視乎家庭背景/ 大細B / 其他..?
沒有。但很正常的賽果是大B，見其它文章也有談到面見詳情，應可知老師只是在與孩子在遊玩中觀察；當然有何準則，我們就不知啦。

aylau

Most of my elder daughter's classmate were borned in Oct to Nov, they preform well. So, I am prepared to send my little girl who was born in Nov 2005 to K1 in 2008-2009.  Just let her try.  In case she is far behind from the others, I will let her repeat the class.

waiwing

我個仔都係細b, １１月中出世,　今年９月K1開學個陣都係只得２歲１０個月，interview個陣都未夠２歲，而家阿仔入左KV, 所以比較出名既幼稚園都未必唔收細b, 我見好多細b都入左KV & St. Cat......
　
你想報邊間幼稚園呀？

bbone

Hi all,

My son was born in November. He is now 2 yrs 10 months and is going to K1.

What we did last year was we applied 3 KGs that we really liked and just let him try. He suceeded in all 3 applications. Those 3 were good KGs: SKH, VCB and LLC. We finally picked SKH. Note that we didn't have any connections or religious background.

Rumors say famous KGs usually don't take small children but with my first hand experience, I don't agree.

kfytbb,


Why don't let apply this year for your son the KGs that you like. If he can make it, that means he's capable of doing K1 as a small child. If he can't, then at least you'll have some ideas what the interviews would be like, and you'll be better prepared next year.

Hbaby

my son 係11月尾出世, 我2 years old 已返nursey, 今年讀 k1, 但我會同佢 repeat k1,做大仔, 我覺得在幼稚園k1-k3大仔及細仔是會有差別(但相信都可應付到), 但主要係上小學, 大仔及細仔真的會差很遠, 尤其做抄寫及理解方面, 不過不是所有的細仔都是這樣, 一定有smart的細b, 但 repeat 一年, 我k3要自己full pay la.

原文章由 kfytbb 於 07-9-5 14:15 硐表
我的小朋友係细B,下年9月剛好2.8歲,想請問是否很多幼稚園都不會收細B讀K1呢？是否有名氣的幼稚園一定都不會收细B。我本人住香港區，請問大家知否有沒有好的幼稚園而又肯收2.8個月的學生呢？有努各位幫忙！ ...

rainchan

以我覺得, 如果人地都Set左兩歲八個月就可以入學
咁就係無問題

如果仲欠幾日先到兩歲八個月, 你想入都無得入啦, 係未?
但係如果夠年齡, 唔入學, 就會比人大, 咁當然都有好處既
身體都強D啦, 但係學野係未快D, 就真係唔太清楚, 個個小朋友都唔同既

如果我係你, 我會有差D既想法, 萬一個小朋友唔好彩留班...
而佢本身比人大一年, 再留班, 比人大成兩年...
好似相差大左DD
我自己就偏向諗好同壞既, 同長遠計

graceshumwy

坦白講細b真係比較難收, 大部份有名氣學校都唔會選細b, 除非有人仕關係啦.
有無打算過遲一年先讀呢? 又或者到時真係你想入的學校唔收, 咁遲一年考過k2都係一個好辦法. 因有時真係好難講, 細b一來細, 二來老師問野未必會答. 反而大一年就唔好得多喇. 試吓考慮以上兩個方法啦.

Yau_Cheung

原文章由 kfytbb 於 07-9-5 14:15 硐表
我的小朋友係细B,下年9月剛好2.8歲,想請問是否很多幼稚園都不會收細B讀K1呢？是否有名氣的幼稚園一定都不會收细B。我本人住香港區，請問大家知否有沒有好的幼稚園而又肯收2.8個月的學生呢？有努各位幫忙！ ...

hi kfytbb,

Your child is 2 years old and 8 months?  That means he born in Jan?

My child also born in Jan.  Most of his classmates are younger than him.  I found that "big child" is better than "small child" in all aspects.   But it is not absolutely.

Shirley_

janju...如果係我..我會比佢番k1...因為小朋友學野真係好快架

原文章由 JANJU 於 07-9-6 13:46 硐表
我個仔都係細仔，2008年9月有2歲8個月，而家我們心大心細，唔知比唔比佢出年讀K1好。佢平日好似識好多野，但硬係唔多肯講，問佢叫咩名佢只係識笑，間唔中彈一些詞語、字出黎，叫佢再講又唔肯。請問大家的小朋友是否這樣呢? ...

Shirley_

我個女今年都k2 架啦...佢依家讀緊太古城既..聖安娜中英文幼稚園....其實我個女2歲係呢度番n 班..之後k1 考左去st. paul church...不過係果邊番左2個月之後我都轉番黎呢間...

因為我覺得呢間學校好多野學..加上佢有國際班..有好多講英文既小朋友...咁佢地自由時間..我個女都可以學到英文....

原文章由 kfytbb 於 07-9-6 01:09 硐表
[quote]原文章由 Shirley_ 於 07-9-5 15:36 硐表
我個女係細b黎架...果時我2歲開始都比佢番學...之後未夠3歲讀k1.  今年讀k2...佢學野都好快...仲識好多野tim ...

JANJU

我個仔都係細仔，2008年9月有2歲8個月，而家我們心大心細，唔知比唔比佢出年讀K1好。佢平日好似識好多野，但硬係唔多肯講，問佢叫咩名佢只係識笑，間唔中彈一些詞語、字出黎，叫佢再講又唔肯。請問大家的小朋友是否這樣呢?

beatriceyung

Hi all,
I'm facing the same question.  My son is a super small bb also.  My plan is to apply K.1 (2008-09) for him.  And at the same time, I will try to secure N1 second term classes for him (Feb 2008) since I find him a little bit boring in attending the playgroup.  The ideal case is that if he could be recruited into N1 and K1 respectively, he will try N1 first and change to K.1 (of course ideal school) in Sept. 08.  If he could not catch up with the study in K.1, the worst case is to apply for ideal K.1 school in 2009-2010 again.  What I think is why not letting him to try.  If he really need to 'repeat' K.1, find another school for him.....
That's what I think.....

kfytbb

原文章由 小冬至 於 07-9-5 18:33 硐表
我仔仔都係細b黎~出年就要讀k1~但我認為唔洗到佢3歲幾先開學~

Hi 小冬,
你揀咗學校未呀？我都仲未知揀边間好，我唸出名嘅學校都唔會收細B，去interview或者都係浪費時問。除非真係特別醒嘅小朋友啦。

kfytbb

[quote]原文章由 Shirley_ 於 07-9-5 15:36 硐表
我個女係細b黎架...果時我2歲開始都比佢番學...之後未夠3歲讀k1.  今年讀k2...佢學野都好快...仲識好多野tim...其實比佢早d 返....學野都會多d 架.....講真..好多幼稚園都會想收d 大b..因為大d 唔洗睇咁緊ma..覺得大 ... [/quote
Hi Shirley,
多謝你的意見。想問你個女間學校d老師好唔好呀？介唔介意講边間學校呀？如果係我都要幫我個女報Nursery先。因為我個女講嘢唔叻，所以好擔心interview 唔得無學校收。但係都想比佢試吓，如果唔得嘅，就學QE話齋遲1年先比讀K1啦。你個女讀全日or半日嘅Nursery呀？

小冬至

我仔仔都係細b黎~出年就要讀k1~但我認為唔洗到佢3歲幾先開學~

Shirley_

我個女係細b黎架...果時我2歲開始都比佢番學...之後未夠3歲讀k1.  今年讀k2...佢學野都好快...仲識好多野tim...其實比佢早d 返....學野都會多d 架.....講真..好多幼稚園都會想收d 大b..因為大d 唔洗睇咁緊ma..覺得大既自理能力好d...起碼唔洗用片ma....不過我就唔應同lor...因為我個女都係細b..佢既自理能力都好好...依家仲識好多野....佢認字呀..英文呀....數學呀..都好好架.......我都係住香港區架...

原文章由 kfytbb 於 07-9-5 14:15 發表
我的小朋友係细B,下年9月剛好2.8歲,想請問是否很多幼稚園都不會收細B讀K1呢？是否有名氣的幼稚園一定都不會收细B。我本人住香港區，請問大家知否有沒有好的幼稚園而又肯收2.8個月的學生呢？有努各位幫忙！ ...