英華vs宣小

jeremyphlam

bigboy129 發表於 12-7-27 14:52
回復 jeremyphlam 的帖子

典型香港父母,總覺外國的月亮比較圓,英文比中文高級。 ...

家長的水平問題，所以大部份新進直資都是用"英語教學"為賣點，又收個滿堂紅.....
其實好多傳統名小都是中文小學。

bigboy129

回復 jeremyphlam 的帖子

典型香港父母,總覺外國的月亮比較圓,英文比中文高級。

jeremyphlam

Li'sfamily 發表於 12-7-26 05:09
聽過YW簡介會，好坦白覺得TSL好過YW, YW嘅數同常識都唔用英文教，而且普遍老師比較young, 同意林校長非常好 ...

TSL好過YW的原因竟然係YW嘅數同常識都唔用英文教........無言......

NKpa

入了YW後是甜蜜的小學童年. 不用為升中由小一起日夜操練、競爭、憂心.

sr20det_fung

We have similar situation: YW vs APS vs Pui Ching. We have chosen YW, for it's thru-train Band 1B secondary school, larger campus(no open-air playground in APS). But most important, no need to worry again 6 years later!!

wsl05

你去看看小學校際排球的水準。你就知我講的是什麼一回事。識開波等同攞了三分之一個獎

wsl05

不過有些家長會操仔女一項運動。排球是一項好選擇。想一想，你估操水易攞獎定操排球易攞。

wsl05

我個女不才，未有資格被利用，更何况我冇蚊比佢讀宣小。只不過路過此題，只帶出一點。就是宣小之所以比其他學校學生入到dbs既比率高是:可能因為運動叻，不是外界所想的派位特別好。所以不要只信人講或選擇性公佈派位結果

CF2010

又不是立志做排球運動員！這樣入到DBS讀書又如何？還又不過袛是為校增光，被利用完就算了！，對你孩子一點好處也沒有！

wsl05

所以操排球好過操成績。至少competitors冇咁多，同埋排球冇咁ＨＩＴ，易操易學。。入ＤＢＳ就係咀咁簡單。不過ＤＢＳ都係有時得７Ｘ％　入大學。因為特異功能效應

wsl05

其實大家有否想過APS兩年內入DBS學生的人數究竟係憑成績定係體育叻而入DBS呢，而我所知APS係排球和TABLE　ＴＥＮＮＩＳ係學界取得好成績。眾所周知，ＤＢＳ會收一Ｄ體育叻。所以七折八扣，其實可能靠成績入的不如大家所想的

hy2012

CF2010 發表於 12-6-16 22:32
如純APS vs YW的比較 應該是YW!

但如果是APS+Net41的大抽獎 vs YW 則要再想清楚！

Top band 1 英中應該係港島嗰間英華女校!

hy2012

CF2010 發表於 12-6-16 22:32
如純APS vs YW的比較 應該是YW!

但如果是APS+Net41的大抽獎 vs YW 則要再想清楚！

你講的才是事實，play safe既家長才揀YW , 但APS真係幾貴！

momama

英華仲要學體育'

KikiDaddy

YWPS is definitely a good school and the DSE results of YWC can only be better when the students from the feeder school start to participate in the examination.

Having said that, both APS and SFA are very good primary schools and strong in both academic and extra-curriculum activities (APS - Music, SFA - Maths). Indeed both schools win a primary school debate competition this year. Despite without a through train secondary school, secondary school allocation of APS / SFA, is probably the best in Kowloon side. Look at the historical data in their websites, you can see that 25% of the boys can be allocated to Band 1A schools like SPCoed / QC / LS / DBS. However, getting into top 25% in these school is not easy and no guarantee.

In all, choose YWPS if you don't want to take any risk. You and your kid should have a happier primary school life.

Choose APS / SFA if your kid (or you) are so desperate to get into those most elite schools. Your whole family need to work really hard to achieve this target. However, more than 50% of chance that your kid will be allocated to a school inferior to YWC.

momama

英華都要學樂器喎

hayley1328

YW:APS=>YW
TSL:APS=>APS，除非憎惡音樂

liktin

2ling 發表於 12-6-17 17:30
回復 CF2010 的帖子

是你的經驗之談，還是你個人睇法呢？

Haha, same as our situation. my son had offer from SFA, APS, Pui Ching and YW 2 years ago. we choose YW finally, I only struggled about the offer of SFA but rejected APS immediately. its totally different style between APS and YW.APS also a good school but most parents like YW style more like me.