Which one is more easy? - 小一選校

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	3594

1^#

發表於 10-5-12 00:18 |只看該作者 |倒序瀏覽 |打印

Is it more easy to go good DSS/private thru interview, or more easy to go good Govt/subsidy thru lucky draw?

0 0 0 0

silvia_ng

伯爵府

Rank: 8 Rank: 8


	19645

2^#

發表於 10-5-12 01:47 |只看該作者

原帖由 Ving 於 10-5-12 00:18 發表
Is it more easy to go good DSS/private thru interview, or more easy to go good Govt/subsidy thru lucky draw?

嘩...呢d冇得好講架喎, 你考邊間又唔知, 每間學校機會率都不同。如果你想知小朋友有冇抽獎命, 咁要搵個生神仙至得啦!

Charlotte_mom

王國長老

Rank: 14

醒目開學勳章王國長老


	59258

3^#

發表於 10-5-12 09:45 |只看該作者

係呀, 考私校直資都要睇下小朋友咩料得架, 如果超班既, 考10間收10間, 準備不足, 可能考十幾間一個offer都無, 而家d學校, 10個人爭一個位已經叫"少"!

至於抽獎, 好命水的話誇區都入到超名校, 唔好命, 同區都可以派間無揀既俾你, 當然住邊區同選校策略可以影響結果, 但亦有好多因素控制唔到呀 (正如私校都有d好易考, 父母想唔想要得架)

Rank: 4


	707

4^#

發表於 10-5-20 13:03 |只看該作者

原帖由 Charlotte_mom 於 10-5-12 09:45 發表
係呀, 考私校直資都要睇下小朋友咩料得架, 如果超班既, 考10間收10間, 準備不足, 可能考十幾間一個offer都無, 而家d學校, 10個人爭一個位已經叫"少"!

至於抽獎, 好命水的話誇區都入到超名校, 唔好命, 同區都可以派 ...

hi hi, i have question, why there are any parents asking about how to entry DSS/ private school? Are they really really absolutely the best choice?? i think their school fees are not cheap. Why not to choice good Govt/subsidy school which i couldn't find any different? Also no need to pay much $$?

Rank: 2


	35

5^#

發表於 10-5-20 13:27 |只看該作者

like charlotte_mom said....至於抽獎 (gov schools), 好命水的話誇區都入到超名校, 唔好命, 同區都可以派間無揀既俾你, 當然住邊區同選校策略可以影響結果, 但亦有好多因素控制唔到呀

of course, everyone wants to get into a 'good Govt/subsidy school'... BUT how much points do you have for 1st round allocation? and for 2nd round, if you are unlucky, you might not even get into 1 of your top 5 choices... are you ok with that???!!! i think alot of people hesitate to leave it to 'luck'!

原帖由 To_Ma 於 10-5-20 13:03 發表
hi hi, i have question, why there are any parents asking about how to entry DSS/ private school? Are they really really absolutely the best choice?? i think their school fees are not cheap. Wh ...

Rank: 4


	707

6^#

發表於 10-5-20 13:34 |只看該作者

原帖由 hohoho8 於 10-5-20 13:27 發表
like charlotte_mom said....至於抽獎 (gov schools), 好命水的話誇區都入到超名校, 唔好命, 同區都可以派間無揀既俾你, 當然住邊區同選校策略可以影響結果, 但亦有好多因素控制唔到呀

of course, everyone wants t ...

i see...just wonder the choices of DSS/ Private are also limited, but with unlimited admission application, even i let my son to have many extra programmes/ studies, there is still no guarantee for getting the 1st choice. The game is too hard and burn money, may be "luck" is more relax....

Rank: 2


	35

7^#

發表於 10-5-20 13:42 |只看該作者

well...
1) yes, there's no guarantee, but applying for dss and private schools only gives you more choices and a chance to choose... if you get accepted by a dss or private, you can choose whether to accept or not... or to try your luck with the gov schools

2) ec activities can be for life, not just for interviews, then will they be worth it??

3) of course, the most 'relax' way is to try your luck... IF you can accept the outcome no matter what it is.

wish you best of luck!

原帖由 To_Ma 於 10-5-20 13:34 發表
i see...just wonder the choices of DSS/ Private are also limited, but with unlimited admission application, even i let my son to have many extra programmes/ studies, there is still no guarantee for g ...

[ 本帖最後由 hohoho8 於 10-5-20 13:45 編輯 ]

Charlotte_mom

王國長老

Rank: 14

醒目開學勳章王國長老


	59258

8^#

發表於 10-5-20 13:52 |只看該作者

Agree
事實就係.........每年放榜後, 總有家長出黎喊晒, 話派得唔好唔知點算, 早知就去申請私校, 而家間間都截晒點算好
遊戲規則就係咁, 個個都係咁玩, 邊個唔想又免費又好? 父母唔通嫌錢鯹, 交左稅有免費學校唔通, 係都要俾錢?
無非都係得2個原因: 1, 鐘意果間咁岩係私校/直資 2,頂唔順個派位制度, 無可能由得派邊間就讀邊間, 所以早一步自己去plan姐, 早一步唔plan, 派得唔好到時咪失晒預算lor

原帖由 hohoho8 於 10-5-20 01:42 PM 發表
well...
1) yes, there's no guarantee, but applying for dss and private schools only gives you more choices and a chance to choose... if you get accepted by a dss or private, you can choose whether to ...

meowmeow

複式洋房

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	360

9^#

發表於 10-5-20 13:54 |只看該作者

其實選擇DSS 可能係:
1.  自己同另外一半以前讀個間小學麻麻地.
2.  冇宗教分
3.  居住地區校網麻麻或競爭好大, 而又唔容許搬屋.
4.  覺得抽獎比較被動
5.  一向冇咩抽獎命...
6.  學校既理念同家長好吻合.

另外可以俾小朋友試吓面試, 都係一個經驗, 如果冇學校收, 咁返去大抽獎都甘心啦.

DSS 都要 INTERVIEW, 咁相信小朋友程度冇咁參差, 估計係教學上會比較方便.
只係個人想法..

[ 本帖最後由 meowmeow 於 10-5-20 13:58 編輯 ]

Rank: 2


	35

10^#

發表於 10-5-20 15:56 |只看該作者

BUT... when i say alot of people hesitate to leave it to 'luck'... in reality we are the minority...

i estimate about 4000-5000 kids play the dss/private interview game last fall... for 2004, there were about 48XXX births in hk... so about 10% of the families feel that there's a need to do something more than trust in luck since financially they can support more... and there's a bunch that goes thru the international stream (who's parents have a different thinking and can afford even more!)... SO, there r MANY parents, maybe roughly 70-80% (3X,XXX) of all families DO just go by the central allocation system only, by choice or not...

for discussion only.... in the end 都係過唔過到自己果關

原帖由 hohoho8 於 10-5-20 13:27 發表
like charlotte_mom said....至於抽獎 (gov schools), 好命水的話誇區都入到超名校, 唔好命, 同區都可以派間無揀既俾你, 當然住邊區同選校策略可以影響結果, 但亦有好多因素控制唔到呀

of course, everyone wants t ...

ziyi

Rank: 5 Rank: 5

醒目開學勳章


	4330

11^#

發表於 10-5-20 16:18 |只看該作者

how to got the 4000~5000

HK have 20 DSS and 40 private, and if average is 100 per school, and totally seat for DSS/Private is over 6,000

And the top application school in the last year is TSL, over 3000 students

原帖由 hohoho8 於 10-5-20 15:56 發表
BUT... when i say alot of people hesitate to leave it to 'luck'... in reality we are the minority...

i estimate about 4000-5000 kids play the dss/private interview game last fall... for 2004, there w ...

Rank: 2


	35

12^#

發表於 10-5-20 16:31 |只看該作者

let me write again... 'i estimate'

for popular boys schools (eg yw and dbs) about 2xxx applications, and i would guess the same for girl schools (eg gh and dgjs)... of course tsl have 3XXX but it is coed! and some people (like myself) didn't applied to tsl.

and even if 6000... or 3000... we are still the minority, right?

原帖由 ziyi 於 10-5-20 16:18 發表
how to got the 4000~5000

HK have 20 DSS and 40 private, and if average is 100 per school, and totally seat for DSS/Private is over 6,000

And the top application school in the last year is TSL, over ...

ziyi

Rank: 5 Rank: 5

醒目開學勳章


	4330

13^#

發表於 10-5-20 16:51 |只看該作者

yes, you are right, both is estimate

but just 八卦 to know how to estimate only

if let you unhappy, sorry

原帖由 hohoho8 於 10-5-20 16:31 發表
let me write again... 'i estimate'

for popular boys schools (eg yw and dbs) about 2xxx applications, and i would guess the same for girl schools (eg gh and dgjs)... of course tsl have 3XXX but it is ...

easydad

複式洋房

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	170

14^#

發表於 10-5-20 16:54 |只看該作者

Going to good public school depends much on luck unless have brothers or sisters already in the targeted schools or hv those extra 20 pts due to parents connection (teacher, board).

This is why many parents go seek places at DSS/private schools first. In a way, we all hope to have more control over our kids "destiny" if chance permits.

Rank: 2


	35

15^#

發表於 10-5-20 16:55 |只看該作者

oh, don't worry about it... no unhappy feeling la... such a small thing...

do you have another way to estimate... please share :)

原帖由 ziyi 於 10-5-20 16:51 發表
yes, you are right, both is estimate

but just 八卦 to know how to estimate only

if let you unhappy, sorry

ziyi

Rank: 5 Rank: 5

醒目開學勳章


	4330

16^#

發表於 10-5-20 17:11 |只看該作者

Sorry, no ar

I only focus 3~5 DSS/Private, and my child is girl that mean I don't looking for DBS, YW ....etc

So I don't have any idea, just know total 60 DSS/Private in HK.

原帖由 hohoho8 於 10-5-20 16:55 發表
oh, don't worry about it... no unhappy feeling la... such a small thing...

do you have another way to estimate... please share :)

Rank: 4


	707

17^#

發表於 10-5-26 13:31 |只看該作者

原帖由 ziyi 於 10-5-20 17:11 發表
Sorry, no ar

I only focus 3~5 DSS/Private, and my child is girl that mean I don't looking for DBS, YW ....etc

So I don't have any idea, just know total 60 DSS/Private in HK.

...

Just getting to search if there is DSS/ private school for a back up in prior to play lucky draw, it seems difficult to evaluate what is "學校既理念同家長好吻合"??? It seems any mission/ vision can applies every kids as all aims to develope them overall life.

sampapa

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	3333

18^#

發表於 10-5-26 17:36 |只看該作者

回覆 17# To_Ma 的文章

My son is studying in DSS school.
For my case.
For P.1 place, my first choice is govt school not DSS.
My target govt school is not top or famous school, just walking within 5 min.
In Round 1, I have 15 points only.
Result is fail, I am no lunck.
On the same time, I applied some DSS before round 1, even TSL and famous school, all accepted my son.
I think, I am no luck on Round 2, and all accepted DSS is good and famous.
I told to my friend which DSS accepted my son. My friend told me, any one of these DSS is dream school for her.
My friend told me that ,If possible,
"Can I use your targeted govt school place exchanged to anyone of accepted DSS place."
My son is happy and enjoy school life in this DSS. No or less workload on homework, dictation or exam.
Other schoolmate of my son's kg,
Homework is more and heavy, use 2 hour or more daily.
Dictation is weekly for CHI or ENG.
Examination or quiz is extra workload for parent.
At the end, I think, I am lucky for failure in Round 1.

Rank: 4


	707

19^#

發表於 10-5-27 13:06 |只看該作者

原帖由 sampapa 於 10-5-26 17:36 發表
My son is studying in DSS school.
For my case.
For P.1 place, my first choice is govt school not DSS.
My target govt school is not top or famous school, just walking within 5 min.
In Round 1, I have 1 ...

Thanks for sharing. In fact, i'll let my son to try interview DSS, but wouldn't put pressure on him. As i can't control his interview performance. But want to let him have some experience to face interviewer which may useful in future.

chunheimama