關於集團
集團品牌
presslogic-logo
廣告查詢
工作機會
用戶登入
用戶名稱:
密      碼:
搜索
教育王國 討論區 幼校討論 St. Cat vs 培正
查看: 4449|回覆: 44
go

St. Cat vs 培正 [複製鏈接]

Rank: 3Rank: 3


174
1#
發表於 07-1-15 16:00 |只看該作者

St. Cat vs 培正

我好幸運,第一志願培正同第二志願st. cat 同時取錄小女。但培正是pm,而st.cat是am!我正煩惱選那一間呢?有冇媽咪可以俾d意見我!


Rank: 3Rank: 3


174
2#
發表於 07-1-15 16:18 |只看該作者

Re: St. Cat vs 培正

有冇人可以俾d意見呀!

Rank: 5Rank: 5


1449
3#
發表於 07-1-15 17:33 |只看該作者

Re: St. Cat vs 培正

If I were U, i will choose 培正, as primary and secondary school is also 名校, but if you can ENSURE your child can get famous primary then secondary school, then choose S.C..

Unfortunately, my son is "small" baby, cannot apply 培正......

Rank: 3Rank: 3


174
4#
發表於 07-1-15 17:35 |只看該作者

Re: St. Cat vs 培正

annienorman,

Thanks for your advice.

Which kindergarten you chose for your kid?

Anyway, even though I choose 培正,I will try to apply st. mary & 油麻地天主教 as well!

annienorman 寫道:
If I were U, i will choose 培正, as primary and secondary school is also 名校, but if you can ENSURE your child can get famous primary then secondary school, then choose S.C..

Unfortunately, my son is "small" baby, cannot apply 培正......

Rank: 5Rank: 5


1449
5#
發表於 07-1-15 17:49 |只看該作者

Re: St. Cat vs 培正

enyay,

He ?????????????????????          your child can get in st. mary & 油麻地天主教, do U know how many applicants per year?  I think you already go through the "hard time" of applying KG for your child.  My 姑姐's son is graduate from S.C. and K.V., but both of them can't get famous primary school,  as 小学派位is mostly by "luck", If I were U, at least 有培正做backup,到時再考其他心水都得啦

Rank: 5Rank: 5


1449
6#
發表於 07-1-15 17:57 |只看該作者

Re: St. Cat vs 培正

enyay,

Also, I think you are no need too care about a.m or p.m, as S.C K2 MUST P.M., and K3 is A.M.

For myself, now my son studying in Yew Chung p.m., he get up around 9:00, play and see English material until 11:00, then start eat lunch.....wear uniform....Its more easy to manage his time.  Don't worry  your child need take nap in the afternoon, they will adjust their time and habit gradually.

Rank: 5Rank: 5


1969
7#
發表於 07-1-16 10:31 |只看該作者

Re: St. Cat vs 培正

enyay

但培正是pm..................k3 一定係am class
like st.cat k3 一定係am class

該用戶已被刪除

8#
發表於 07-1-16 10:38 |只看該作者

Re: St. Cat vs 培正

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽

Rank: 3Rank: 3


474
9#
發表於 07-1-16 11:16 |只看該作者

Re: St. Cat vs 培正

Nobody knows this answer better than you.  Obviously, you are not compare apple to apple, so it is difficult to judge.  I believe AM or PM is not such a big deal as our little ones can adjust themself quickly.

Ask yourself:
1. Do you want 學券?
2. Do you prefer "one dragon school"?
3. Do you know you can only have one chance to apply St. Mary or YMT天主教?  Hence you can only submit your application to other schools in the first round but if you fail and once you put your application into the lucky draw=you agreed to forfeit the seat in PC.
4. Lastly, are you willing to pay for the primary school fee in the upcoming years?  Or you prefer 9 years free education?

Think about that and I think you can get your own answer.  No one can help you la.

Your girl must be a smart one as both SC & PC are very good schools!  My daughter....... , cry in the interview room ah!!!   And of course, we received a rejection letter yesterday la.  :cry:

Rank: 3Rank: 3


174
10#
發表於 07-1-16 11:33 |只看該作者

Re: St. Cat vs 培正

annienorman,

Thanks for your advice and I agree with your opinion.

I discussed with my husband last night and we eventually choose 培正. But I will also join the lucky draw see whether we can get st. mary or油麻地天主教 luckily!

Rank: 3Rank: 3


174
11#
發表於 07-1-16 11:35 |只看該作者

Re: St. Cat vs 培正

wensi,

I just found out yesterday.  No problem.  I already made a decision -培正!

Rank: 5Rank: 5


1875
12#
發表於 07-1-16 11:44 |只看該作者

Re: St. Cat vs 培正

enyay,

你要lucky draw  - st. mary or油麻地天主教, 係咪你天主教 or 你地係舊生, 如果你要第二輪的lucky draw  ,你要放棄培正的p1位!

我係路過, 見到答吓嘴!希望你唔好介意!

Rank: 3Rank: 3


174
13#
發表於 07-1-16 12:15 |只看該作者

Re: St. Cat vs 培正

bobomegan,

Many thanks for your advice.

1.)        Of course I want education voucher.  Well...everybody wants it.

2.)        I think “one dragon school” is the best selling point for Pui Ching.

3.)        I was very astonished to hear that if I join the lucky draw = agree to forfeit the seat in pui chung.  Are you sure??

4.)        Actually, I planned to apply st. mary or油麻地天主教 in the first round, if she is not able to make it, then join the luck draw, then put pui ching as back up.  But now, I have to discuss with my husband again.

Lastly, I dont think my girl perform that good during interviews.  You know what, she was eating the candy during Pui Ching interview, my husband tried to take back from her, then she cried loudly in front of the teacher and the teacher eventually allowed her to bring the candy along with her.  I really don’t know why they take her.


bobomegan 寫道:
Nobody knows this answer better than you.  Obviously, you are not compare apple to apple, so it is difficult to judge.  I believe AM or PM is not such a big deal as our little ones can adjust themself quickly.

Ask yourself:
1. Do you want 學券?
2. Do you prefer "one dragon school"?
3. Do you know you can only have one chance to apply St. Mary or YMT天主教?  Hence you can only submit your application to other schools in the first round but if you fail and once you put your application into the lucky draw=you agreed to forfit the seat in PC.
4. Lastly, are you willing to pay for the primary school fee in the upcoming years?

Think about that and I think you can get your own answer.  No one can help you la.

Your girl must be a smart one as both SC & PC are very good school!  My daughter....... , cry in the interview room ah!!!   And of course, we received a rejection letter yesterday la.  :cry:

Rank: 3Rank: 3


474
14#
發表於 07-1-16 12:39 |只看該作者

Re: St. Cat vs 培正

enyay:

Regarding your query about lucky draw, I'm 100% sure because my colleague sitting next to me confirm about this, just like what "EvaFong88" said.  My colleague's son is studying in PC since K1 and now is F1 la.  So, she knows the rules of this game very well.  

No lucky draw but you can still apply either St. Mary or YMT in the first round.  Hope this clarify la. :

Rank: 3Rank: 3


174
15#
發表於 07-1-16 12:46 |只看該作者

Re: St. Cat vs 培正

EvaFong88,

我先生是基督教,我本身是沒有宗教信善仰!但會打算帶個女去信天主教!

原先,自行派位,我打算揀st. mary, 如果唔得,我想看看luck draw會唔會抽到st. mary或油麻地天主教!如果通通唔得,就讀培正!當初,我搬到尖沙咀都係想阿女讀st.mary.

我並不知道如果我去報考其它學校,培正會release我小一個位!我本來想用培正來做後備!

現有問題出現了,講程度,那間會好些!到時去考小一,學校會較喜歡那一間?

Rank: 3Rank: 3


174
16#
發表於 07-1-16 12:49 |只看該作者

Re: St. Cat vs 培正

Thanks a lot..

Rank: 5Rank: 5


1875
17#
發表於 07-1-16 13:30 |只看該作者

Re: St. Cat vs 培正

enyay,

如果你講考私校, 一定係st.cat 的名氣大, 培正一向都係讀得舒服(雖然今年開始深d ), 但係你唔好諗住lucky draw,因為冇得食回頭草.

請不要怪我多事, 如果係我會讀st.cat另外比佢返Play group, 係K1開始返"道慕班"

第一輪:20分睇吓好唔好彩
第二輪:睇地址
第三輪:叩門係睇成績, 同埋睇吓有嘜cert.

但係你唔好心急, 留住兩間位, 再諗清楚!
我上年係民幼讀完 k1,跟住同個仔轉校, 我就係唔想比佢限制!

最緊要係你兩公婆要有共識, 其他人講你只可以當意見,OK!

Rank: 5Rank: 5


1405
18#
發表於 07-1-16 13:57 |只看該作者

Re: St. Cat vs 培正

enyay

如果你一心一意諗住上 pc 小學, 就 sure pc 啦, 如果 pc primary 唔係你杯茶, 就 st. cat 啦, 程度上, 應該 st. cat 深 d, 雖然讀 st. cat 不= 一定考到好學校
**************************************** 芍妤bb 10/11/2004 在聖保祿醫院出世,體重 2.6Kg。 ****************************************

Rank: 3Rank: 3


474
19#
發表於 07-1-16 14:21 |只看該作者

Re: St. Cat vs 培正

Just got back from lunch and continue my comments, sorry to be that long air:

If I were you, I will choose PC!

PC school fee is approx $600 per month (after 學券) !!!! vs SC approx $3300.... huge difference (information from 幼稚園概覽, might have minimal difference). You can save $27000 per annum if you study in PC and use that sum of money for other resources, e.g. English playgroup, Phoenix, Piano, others....

PC can still allow you to join the first round 派位! If you are not able to get into any of the dream schools, you still have PC for backup. But of course, you can't get everything at the same time as you have to forfeit about the lucky draw.

SC strong in English, other private schools like their students very much, maybe because of their English standard. But, SC got no relations to the lucky draw 派位. The computer will not give additional marks to SC graduates so that the probability is the same as other students not studying in SC unless if you are old girls or you have the same religious to your dream schools.

唔好意思,講多

Rank: 3Rank: 3


377
20#
發表於 07-1-16 14:35 |只看該作者

Re: St. Cat vs 培正

EvaFong88

我上年係民幼讀完 k1,跟住同個仔轉校.....

咁你個仔轉左邊間呀 !   


[quote]
EvaFong88 寫道:
enyay,

如果你講考私校, 一定係st.cat 的名氣大, 培正一向都係讀得舒服(雖然今年開始深d ), 但係你唔好諗住lucky draw,因為冇得食回頭草.

請不要怪我多事, 如果係我會讀st.cat另外比佢返Play group, 係K1開始返"道慕班"

第一輪:20分睇
‹ 上一主題|下一主題
返回列表
發新帖