真道 or 臻美黃乾亨好, 請問如何取捨？

登錄 | 註冊

討論區

教育王國: 教育講場; 使用意見

幼兒教育: 幼校討論; 幼教雜談

小學教育: 小一選校; 小學雜談

中學教育: 升中派位; 中學交流; 初中教育

專上教育: 備戰大學; 選科選校

國際教育: 國際學校; 海外留學

知識增值: 課外活動; 教材閱讀; 公開考試; 深造進修

特殊教育: 特殊教育; 資優教育; 自閉寶寶; 智能評估

徵求專區: 二手市場; 誠徵老師; 組班專區; 徵保母車

聯絡管理員

我的中心

教育王國 › 討論區 › 小學雜談 › 真道 or 臻美黃乾亨好, 請問如何取捨？ ...

12 下一頁

查看: 3800\|回覆: 20	go 真道 or 臻美黃乾亨好, 請問如何取捨？ [複製鏈接]

thailandfans

民房

Rank: 1


	5

1^#

發表於 05-11-23 23:59 |只看該作者

返回頂部

gogoqueenie

民房

Rank: 1


	11

2^#

發表於 05-11-24 21:54 |只看該作者

Re: 真道 or 臻美黃乾亨好, 請問如何取捨？

thailandfans,

我當初同妳都有呢個煩惱，但最後還是選擇了臻美，原因主要有兩個：
1. 地點，因我家住油塘，兒子不用乘車返學;
2. 因我覺得真道發展太快，06年已收10班，擔心學校的各項配套是否應付得來

加上本人較喜歡臻美校長的踏實

返回頂部

workingmom

別墅

Rank: 4


	790

3^#

發表於 05-11-24 23:01 |只看該作者

Re: 真道 or 臻美黃乾亨好, 請問如何取捨？

thailandfans,
How much do you know about 真道 or 臻美黃乾亨? Do you know anything about the future plans (say in coming 3-5 years) or these schools?
Are you prepared that your kid may have to go to Sai Kung school cmpus in one year, Stanely school campus in other year?

返回頂部

thailandfans

民房

Rank: 1


	5

4^#

發表於 05-11-24 23:42 |只看該作者

Re: 真道 or 臻美黃乾亨好, 請問如何取捨？

Thks for your advice.

Actually I don't know much about "

egasus" as they don't have any briefing. I just learnt some of the school plan while attending the interview. I know that they have "Chinese" stream with Putongua as medium and "English" stream with English as medium. Just a little bit worried if a P.1 student can get used to "

utongua" as mediumas it is not our mother-tonque. Seems if it is started from P.2.
However, they havemore foreigners to teach English.

For "LogosAcademy", I learnt from the principal that the Sai Kung campus is for the 2007 intake only. But 2006 students do need to study in Stanley. However, I found from my 2 of my friends who have children in 'LogosAcademy" they they need to hire extra native English teachers to teach their child English as no Foreign teachers for English for P.1. i don't know. Compared in this aspect, it seems that "pegasus' seems havea better structured curriculum. Do you agree?

返回頂部

thailandfans

民房

Rank: 1


	5

5^#

發表於 05-11-24 23:50 |只看該作者

Re: 真道 or 臻美黃乾亨好, 請問如何取捨？

Thank you gogoqueenie. So, are U a parent of "

egasus" in 2005.

How's your daughter/son's study at "

egasus". Can they get used to the whole "

utongua"or "English" as medium of learning in school as a P.1 student.

How do you think their curriculum? Will the sorting of students in Chinese, English & Math according to the students standard make child unhappy or have a labelling effect. I'm quite worry about this.

However, I find that the curriculum adopted by "LogosAcademy" seem a little vit lose. So just scratching my head and difficult to make a decision.

返回頂部

kristy213

大宅

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	2065

6^#

發表於 05-11-25 09:58 |只看該作者

Re: 真道 or 臻美黃乾亨好, 請問如何取捨？

hi gogoqueenie

我都係住油塘, 請問你兒子是現在讀緊, 還是同樣06年入讀, 如果讀緊, 好想知更多意見

返回頂部

mummy2000

複式洋房

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	165

7^#

發表於 05-11-25 21:17 |只看該作者

Re: 真道 or 臻美黃乾亨好, 請問如何取捨？

My girl is also accepted by both of these two schools. For us, Logos is our 1st choice since the very beginning. So there is no problem for us in choosing.

Talking about campus. Anyone heard about the site for the secondary school of Pengasu? I think it will not be in Yau Tong.

返回頂部

pigleg

民房

Rank: 1


	9

8^#

發表於 05-11-25 22:34 |只看該作者

Re: 真道 or 臻美黃乾亨好, 請問如何取捨？

This is only my comment...not all the Pegasus parents'.
My big kid study in the Pegasus Kindergarten for 2 years ..there were 26 kids in class, only 10 kids chose Pegasus Primary School...None of a girl stayed in Pegasus. My big kid studied in Pegasus P.1 (04-05).
My small kid study in Pegasus Kindergarten for 2 years also...4 class teachers have been changed!!!?
Both of them left Pegasus in 2005.
I don't say much....please refer to the header of "

egasus" in baby-kingdom..

返回頂部

patbird

民房

Rank: 1


	3

9^#

發表於 05-11-25 23:38 |只看該作者

Re: 真道 or 臻美黃乾亨好, 請問如何取捨？

Hi, I'm a new joiner, just have some queries,
1) it seems from your tone you doesn't like the school much, how come you let your kid study it's P.1.
2) provided 1) is true, how come you let your small kid study in their kindergarten.
As my kid has registered with the school. I also concern much about the quality of the school. Pls let me know. Thanks

返回頂部

patbird

民房

Rank: 1


	3

10^#

發表於 05-11-25 23:53 |只看該作者

Re: 真道 or 臻美黃乾亨好, 請問如何取捨？

Hi, how come you didn't reply and left, but you joined the discussion. strange.

返回頂部

thailandfans

民房

Rank: 1


	5

11^#

發表於 05-11-26 00:38 |只看該作者

Re: 真道 or 臻美黃乾亨好, 請問如何取捨？

mummy2000,

I learnt from the school administrator that the secondary school for "

egasus" will be in Tai Kok Tsui.

返回頂部

pigleg

民房

Rank: 1


	9

12^#

發表於 05-11-27 11:49 |只看該作者

Re: 真道 or 臻美黃乾亨好, 請問如何取捨？

Hey, give me sometimes..I'm not always have time in front of the computer.. Sorry to the late reply..

U know actually I have so many things want to raise out..but do U watch the headers of the 'Pegasus' in the baby-kingdom.  U will find that it's strange that's two group of 'opposite' parents 'fighting'..'fighting means they have different opinion & comment from the school...and I can say they're having argument. U know.. I don't want to join them so I just want to say more..

Also, I just a passer-by of this header...and only have my own comment...but.. if U want to know..I can say something more.

I'm sorry I haven't explain it detailly:-
- My big kid studied in 'P's  Kingdomgarten in 03-04(K3), my small kid studied in 'P' (K1) on the same year.
- They all change to another school in 05-06, while my big kid (P1) & my small kid (K2).

My big boy have interviews in five primary school after 'P' ..they're normal schools not very famous schools, he failed in four which have the written exam, only 1 (St. Joseph CHOI WAN) accepted (without written exam)...but during the interview, the teacher tell him it is very hard to study here..we have dictation..test...then he cry...because he never have the pleasure from the school and parents, then the teacher gave us sometimes for consider) Another fail one they can accept my big boy to repeat P1 in the school (Tsung Tsin).

We pay the reg. fee for Tsung Tsin but  still waiting for a reply from another happy school (need someone's help..so sorry I can't said the name) they have a happy life also..something like dictation.. actually I can say it's a game. ..

I have not buy the uniform of Tsung Tsin...even on 2005-08-28, we're so worry..but fortunately we got the reply from the new school, but all the thing are in a big hurry.

We think U can stop to think about the Primary..and Secondary school after accepted by 'P' ..as I like this kind of school.  no pleasure...very happy but somethings differents from expact (the administration of school, not the way of learning....)

My advice:-
- All this kind of schools want the kids study in happy way, no pleasure.
For 'P' they have not so many homework. In kingdomgarten have only 1 paper, write about 10 times for a new word.. P1 has 1 homework, sometimes 2 or 3..but very simple..but always need parent's help (mostly finished by parent!! maybe only my case)

- They are not speciallist in writting, so don't expact they can write many words, but they can recognize the words at all.  If U ask them (P1) to spell the word of  'Blue, Black' but they can not...if U feel worry...please don't let your kids to enter this kind of schools.

- The class teacher of P.1 (also resigned) tell us the standard of 'P' is a little bit lower than others.. I can see the different even they're on the kingdomgarten.  (Actually, I emphasis not only 'P' ..is all this kind of school)  So if U find that it's not a school you're expact...change it as early as U can.  If U have faith on this kind of school just let them happy...

- My big kid's classmate changed  'P' after kingdomgarten, then he studied in LOGO for maybe 1 year...actually the same method..she think the kid can not learn very well...so change again to a traditional school...so, once U want this kind of school, stick on it...if not, don't waste the time of your kid's ...

Again..if you want to know how good of  'P' and how bad of 'P' and why I stopped the schoolling from 'P', (some are the same as the parents posted on the 'P' header) ..Sorry again, I really have not much time in front to computer, for details really read the header.. there are at least 2 headers of 'P' in baby-kingdom, read them all before your consideration.  Hope it can help.

Best Regards,
pigleg

返回頂部

gogoqueenie

民房

Rank: 1


	11

13^#

發表於 05-11-27 23:50 |只看該作者

Re: 真道 or 臻美黃乾亨好, 請問如何取捨？

Hi thailandfriends,

Sorry for my late reply as I don't have time to visit this site in these few days.

My son will join Pegasus in 2006, I can't tell you more details about Pegasus, what I said in my previous message was just my personal comments.

Before I make the decision, I was also scratching my head for 2 weeks.  Logos is also my first choice before I choose Pegasus, but at last I gave up Logos for the 2 reasons that I mentioned before.

One of my friend referred a friend to me who's daughter is now studying in Pegasus in P3, she gave me many positive points for studying in this school.  Her daughter joined Pegasus in P2, she likes this school very much, before she joined Pegasus, she was studied in a traditional school, the heavy classworks and frequent dictation and tests filled up her times.  I want my son to be a happy studuent, so I decided to get a school like Pegasus for my son.  I understand that this kind of school can not learn much in spelling, but I agreed with their concept in teaching students to read more and be a happy students.

返回頂部

libch

民房

Rank: 1


	28

14^#

發表於 05-11-29 14:08 |只看該作者

Re: 真道 or 臻美黃乾亨好, 請問如何取捨？

Hi Mummy2000,

Can you please share your opinion why you choose Logos as your first choice ? It seems to me that both schools are very similar in teaching style, assessment method,...etc. It is quite difficult to make a decision.

By the way, the principal of Logos said that 2006 intake students would stay in TKO campus( NOT Stanley) whereas 2007 intake students will study in Sai Kung campus. Is that right ?

返回頂部

mummy2000

複式洋房

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	165

15^#

發表於 05-11-29 21:31 |只看該作者

Re: 真道 or 臻美黃乾亨好, 請問如何取捨？

Hi, libch,

In fact, I learn about Pegasus in this website. I read about one of the two topics started by the two different camps of Pengasus parents a few months ago.  I was deeply attracted by that topic, the one started by "g". I read through the pages and found they are all very helpful and have deep concern for each other. They are just like a big family. Moreover, judging from what they said, their childredn should be quite happy studying there. Later on, I talked with some of my friends, and one told me the son of another friend is studying in the Secondary there. I had called this friend and asked for how his kid is going on. His reply is quite positive. In this way, I began to think it would be a good thing if my girl can go into this school. Therefore, I hand in the application form.
However, then I found something had gone wrong in that topic I've said above. The parents seemed to be trying to avoid something. I pm some of them and they gave me reply. They said the school had noticed the existance of  such topic in here. The management had put some pressure so as to stop these parents to critize school in here. Indeed it is the attitude of the school that alarm me. I hate their attitude. As a new school, there must be room for improvement, it should be grateful to the parents who give them useful comment. But instead, it just tried to press  them down. This is a very bad example to the kids. So I begin to doubt whether I shall let my girl to go this school.

Then, I heard of Logos and went to its seminar. I was deeply impressed by its vision. Eventhough somebody might say the principal looked a saleman. They should have a chance to meet the vice-principal of HKUGPS. If you meet him somewhere else, you surely will think hs is a Insurance Sale. In fact, my girl's kinter is also a christian one and the two principals know each other. I have also talked with my girl' teachers. They also recommend Logos. In one of the school activity, i also met another parent of Logos. We chatted for quite a while and this parent told me his girl is also very happy in Logos. Also she has learned much and improved quite a lot in Logos.
Talking about improvement, it is another concern of us in choosing Logos. Actually, i had read about the "視學報告" of Pegasus. Some aspects was just average. Even Logos has no such report, from what I have learned, Logos's standard is better than that of Pegasus. We are not that kind of people who press the kid hard for learning. Rathar we prefer her to have a happy childhood and a happy school life. But if both school can offer a happy learning environment, why don't we choose the one with better standard.

Have you paid for the registration fee for both school?

返回頂部

mummy2000

複式洋房

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	165

16^#

發表於 05-11-29 21:49 |只看該作者

Re: 真道 or 臻美黃乾亨好, 請問如何取捨？

Hi, libch,

In the second interview, Principal Yau told us that the Stanley campus would be used for students of "拓階"--actually according to other school, it means P.4 above. I like the idea of letting them to go there. Actually, I live in Island East, therefore, going to Stanley for a few years is no problem. Talking about change another campus, Pegasus may have the secondary school build in Kowloon West. I think the new should be quite accurate. The district i've heard is Yau Ma Tei while that Thailandfan said is Tai Kok Tsui. But they are all in Kowloon West. So traveling to Kowloon West is a big problem for me. If I will let my girl to travel so far away daily, I would rather let her to go GT's Mongkok campus.

返回頂部

Jackiesau

複式洋房

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	433

17^#

發表於 05-11-29 22:49 |只看該作者

Re: 真道 or 臻美黃乾亨好, 請問如何取捨？

mummy2000

多謝妳對我們的關注，並細閱我們每一篇的留言。

對於妳說，聽聞校方向對學校有批評的家長施壓；但是學校眾教職員、老師工作繁忙，實沒有時間上來閱覽，根本可能不知BK的存在。

我只是一個家長，有時有較多機會去認識及瞭解臻美，知道為小朋友做了很多功夫，故此會跟大家分享，並沒有刻意的影响其他家長，亦不是刻意的維護臻美。

其實在BK一直對臻美有不少批評，有善意，真實的；有惡意，造假的。我亦不時提出另一方的觀點，與各家長分享，讓家長們從中判斷，以認識事實的真偽。

對言論施壓是很嚴重的，如果所言屬實，我亦會考慮我的小朋友的去向。

返回頂部

JSSL38

洋房

Rank: 2


	30

18^#

發表於 05-11-29 23:17 |只看該作者

Re: 真道 or 臻美黃乾亨好, 請問如何取捨？

網上點講都得，無名無姓，點知是我？如果知道是何人，才可以施壓。就算知道(BK洩料？)，我都用另一名，剷到上天喇！

返回頂部

pcpl

複式洋房

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	129

19^#

發表於 05-11-29 23:42 |只看該作者

Re: 真道 or 臻美黃乾亨好, 請問如何取捨？

JSSL38,

有道理

返回頂部

libch

民房

Rank: 1


	28

20^#

發表於 05-11-30 13:35 |只看該作者

Re: 真道 or 臻美黃乾亨好, 請問如何取捨？

Hi Mummy2000,

Thanks for your sharing. In fact, I agree that if there is an opportunity for the students to experience more than one campus school life during their primary school period is a good thing though the travelling distance is a big factor to concern.

最高瀏覽主題

有關我們
使用條款
免責聲明
私穩政策
廣告查詢

關閉安全驗證

真道 or 臻美黃乾亨好, 請問如何取捨？ [複製鏈接]