關於集團
集團品牌
presslogic-logo
廣告查詢
工作機會
用戶登入
用戶名稱:
密      碼:
搜索
教育王國 討論區 幼校討論 面試上家長應唔應該引導小朋友回答問題? ...
發新帖
查看: 1630|回覆: 18
go

面試上家長應唔應該引導小朋友回答問題? [複製鏈接]

Rank: 4


902
1#
發表於 12-10-19 08:22 |只看該作者 |倒序瀏覽 |打印
如果你知道小朋友係識答嘅,咁你哋會唔會引導下佢定由得佢自由發揮?會唔會扣分呢?
請指教!
   1    0    0    0

Rank: 5Rank: 5


3474
2#
發表於 12-10-19 08:42 |只看該作者

回覆:面試上家長應唔應該引導小朋友回答問題?

唔會,等老師引導佢



Rank: 6Rank: 6


5662
3#
發表於 12-10-19 09:17 |只看該作者
會, 扣分好過冇分, 因為老師的引導可能唔係每個小朋友都適合的, 如果嚇怕小朋友唔出聲仲慘...

Rank: 5Rank: 5


1557
4#
發表於 12-10-19 09:23 |只看該作者
非必要不作引導,讓他自由發揮,但做父母的應該輕描淡寫地做/說一點補鍋的行動/話。

Rank: 11Rank: 11Rank: 11Rank: 11

醒目開學勳章


46903
5#
發表於 12-10-19 09:27 |只看該作者
You shouldn't until it reach a point that it is necessary.  The timing is important.

The teacher should be the person to guide the children through the interview, not the parents.

點評

gwlam    發表於 12-10-19 10:00

Rank: 5Rank: 5


1990
6#
發表於 12-10-19 09:55 |只看該作者
iantsang 發表於 12-10-19 09:27
You shouldn't until it reach a point that it is necessary.  The timing is important.

The teacher sh ...

完全贊成!!...不過到現場時,有時真係太肉緊,唔知能唔能夠做到~~~

Rank: 11Rank: 11Rank: 11Rank: 11

醒目開學勳章


46903
7#
發表於 12-10-19 10:30 |只看該作者
pisontam 發表於 12-10-19 09:55
完全贊成!!...不過到現場時,有時真係太肉緊,唔知能唔能夠做到~~~
It's not difficult but often time nervousness will affect your judgement.

My advice is this: Throughout the process of the interview, usually the teacher wil be looking at the children during their conversation.  So, your help would not be considered welcome until a point that the teacher start to look at you.  This is a sign of body language that your help may be needed.

Hope this help!

Ian

點評

lyhv  SUCH A VALUABLE SUGGESTION!    發表於 12-10-19 12:31
AL1987  Ian, how about helping to translate the question from Chinese to English if my kid cannot understand what the teacher is asking about?  發表於 12-10-19 11:10

Rank: 5Rank: 5


2843
8#
發表於 12-10-19 10:37 |只看該作者
小朋友識當然俾佢自己答.
如果見到佢因為緊張唔開口答, 都可以睇下老師反應(不同學校/老師處理手法不同). 如對方會引導, 家長當然唔好再出聲. 但對方唔引導or引左但小朋友都無反應, 那麼家長應該做最後嘗試, 但切忌提水. 可試下重複老師問題並用鼓勵/獎勵方式誘導小朋友回答.

Rank: 6Rank: 6


5662
9#
發表於 12-10-19 11:07 |只看該作者
時機係好緊要, 適當o既時侯出手未必會有不良效果, 可能還會有更好的效果, 要靠自己掌握...

Rank: 5Rank: 5


2014
10#
發表於 12-10-19 11:19 |只看該作者
My experience last year was that with the top KG, teachers didn't really put much effort into guiding the child.  If the child didn't give the correct response, then the teacher moved onto the next question/activity.  
In situation like this, I wished I had stepped-in to give a little prompting, and to show that as a parent I habitually encourage my child in a positive way to try harder.  But, this is easier said than done.  Is 2-sec of dead air long enough?  If the teacher has intention of offering help, then a parent who intrudes is a pushy parent.  If the teacher simply moves onto the next question, then we may appear to be non-engaging parents with an unresponsive child.  Yes, timing is absolutely crucial.
Personally, I suspect that if parents are interviewed together with the child, the teacher wants to see how the parents interact with the child.  I don't think it hurts to show them a little.
If teachers want to see how the child responds independently, they would interview the child on their own (e.g. SPK).  If teachers want to give the child a bit of comfort, then the parents would sit in the same room away from the child (e.g. SMM)

點評

minirat  good catch!  發表於 12-10-19 16:53

Rank: 5Rank: 5


1990
11#
發表於 12-10-19 11:57 |只看該作者
回復 iantsang 的帖子

It really helps, thanks for your advice!!

Rank: 5Rank: 5


1990
12#
發表於 12-10-19 11:58 |只看該作者
回復 creamsicle 的帖子

Thanks for sharing the real case!!

Rank: 6Rank: 6


6511
13#
發表於 12-10-19 13:26 |只看該作者

回覆:creamsicle 的帖子

Good points!



Rank: 5Rank: 5


4457
14#
發表於 12-10-19 16:05 |只看該作者
Thanks for sharing !


175
15#
發表於 12-10-19 18:25 |只看該作者

回覆:面試上家長應唔應該引導小朋友回答問題?

thanks for sharing! very useful!!



Rank: 4


902
16#
發表於 12-10-19 21:26 |只看該作者
Thanks everyone for the input, you opinions are really valuable.

Good luck everyone!!

Rank: 4


644
17#
發表於 12-10-20 07:42 |只看該作者

回覆:面試上家長應唔應該引導小朋友回答問題?

上午考st cat 朋友what app 我話有朋友在那裡教,話千萬不要提示孩子,一提即零分,於是我唔敢提。一條牙刷問題糾纏了成分鐘,其他考找不同的也是錯,但我表現淡定不干預但用眼神去鼓勵孩子,最後答錯不少題目,以為死梗,最後有offer. My learning is that depending on school, some schools dont really expect a correct answer, they want to observe how parent and kid interacting in solving problem, hope parent guide their kids in thinking. Hope this give u another angle too.



Rank: 4


644
18#
發表於 12-10-20 07:43 |只看該作者

回覆:面試上家長應唔應該引導小朋友回答問題?

Sorry 打錯字,上年考不是上午



‹ 上一主題|下一主題
返回列表
發新帖