關於集團
集團品牌
presslogic-logo
廣告查詢
工作機會
用戶登入
用戶名稱:
密      碼:
搜索
教育王國 討論區 保良局陳守仁小學 陳守仁 vs 聖方濟各英文小學
發新帖
查看: 5606|回覆: 11
go

陳守仁 vs 聖方濟各英文小學 [複製鏈接]

Rank: 2


94
1#
發表於 11-6-23 20:26 |只看該作者 |倒序瀏覽 |打印
Both schools have good reputation in English. My son is admitted by both schools, how do you advise generally?

It seems that 陳守仁 is 多元化活動教學, not like traditional. How about 聖方濟各?

Placement of secondary school is also important, how?
   3    0    0    0

Rank: 3Rank: 3


272
2#
發表於 11-6-23 23:55 |只看該作者
恭喜你! 你的小朋友很叻呀! 事實上,兩間都非常出名!我個人應為如果你的小朋友一向用English學數,便應該揀TSL,因SFA的數學呈分試以中數為主。還有,另一考慮是SFA相對有很多功課......小朋友是否能承受? 最後,想想你將來的target中學,再參考這兩間小學的target secondary school入學率。那你便會有答案了。Either one都係公認的好小學,祝福你!

Rank: 4


721
3#
發表於 11-6-24 09:14 |只看該作者
Depends on your child's personality, talent and your preparation on paying how much effort.

TSL - P1 to 3 really easy, the Madarin is not good as they use local textbook (though it states it's mardarin version, but the written Chinese in these text book is very Cantonese). I do not think their Mandarin teacher is professional in choosing good Mandarin text books. When I prepare test and exam with my child at TSL Chinese, I felt really angry on their choice of Chinese text.

Written English is better than Spoken English (English learning is systematic, the curriculum is good, but the Native English Teacher are not good teachers!!).

Maths is ok and systemic in curriculum design.

Personally I think it's a good school with pretty good language curriculum design, but the outcome is not that good as I expected or what others said in the public.

I like the low key profile of the school and will not like other schools to push kids to join competitions or to highlight their competition results everywhere.

SFA not familiar with. I heard that they targeted on gifted children, if your child is gifted, then you can explore more on their program...not very sure!!

原帖由 minggrace 於 11-6-23 23:55 發表
恭喜你! 你的小朋友很叻呀! 事實上,兩間都非常出名!我個人應為如果你的小朋友一向用English學數,便應該揀TSL,因SFA的數學呈分試以中數為主。還有,另一考慮是SFA相對有很多功課......小朋友是否能承受? 最後,想想你將來的ta ...

Rank: 3Rank: 3


384
4#
發表於 11-6-24 12:23 |只看該作者
我亦要從這兩間學校2選1,sfa我認識多點,這學校給我相當大壓力,但相信跟小兒幼稚園的教授方法相似.反而tsl我不太清楚,正在收資料.

Rank: 5Rank: 5


1150
5#
發表於 11-6-24 13:29 |只看該作者
恭喜晒..你們的小朋友都好出色,盼望你們可以早日下到決定,把多出的學位放出來~~代所有等待學校的家長多謝2位!
原帖由 jojo1234 於 11-6-24 12:23 發表
我亦要從這兩間學校2選1,sfa我認識多點,這學校給我相當大壓力,但相信跟小兒幼稚園的教授方法相似.反而tsl我不太清楚,正在收資料.

Rank: 5Rank: 5


1963
6#
發表於 11-6-24 13:55 |只看該作者
For SFA is very pushing, it will be better if either one of you or the other have to be full time parent.

For TSL, sofar my boy loves it for the 1st year.

Rank: 1


16
7#
發表於 11-6-24 14:42 |只看該作者
for those parents their children still waiting for either TSL an SFA, you still have chance to get the "seat" only on 1-Sept because this is the deadline for them to make the final choice.

dont expect they will release the seat even TSL registration on 29-June onward or SFA the registration is done.

Rank: 4


721
8#
發表於 11-6-24 18:31 |只看該作者
Depend on how you define what is stressful and depend on your child's characteristics and you as a parent's education style.

TSL: I do'nt think TSL is activity based teaching. It's really traditional teaching format, including traditional curriculum and teaching styles, especially starting from P.4, they are really pushing, same as traditional schools. e,g, in P1-P3, the child can finish homework on average time of 30m to 45m. P.4. more than 2 hours sometimes, especially when there is compositions or creative writings.

The dictations in P4 is very long and much more difficult than before, need your full attention and concentration to work with the child on it.

If you want an activity based curriculum, CKY, creative primary school are the best curriculum design with well-trained teachers to carry out the philosophy of these kind of teaching. TSL teachers are not well-trained to carry out interactive teaching. They are good at traditional teaching.

The school emphasis on multicultralism, but in these 4 years of learning, I cannot see how the teachers trying to convey this kind of values to the kids or to the parents. They have this values, but not really well-trained to carry it out because they are not really well-trained on this area.

Despite of these limitations, I still see this a good school as the teachers are responsible, the school administration is well planned and well trained to be accountable to students and to parents. They have good foundations for education, but no surprise, but still worth to send children to come here!!

原帖由 jojo1234 於 11-6-24 12:23 發表
我亦要從這兩間學校2選1,sfa我認識多點,這學校給我相當大壓力,但相信跟小兒幼稚園的教授方法相似.反而tsl我不太清楚,正在收資料.

Rank: 8Rank: 8


19645
9#
發表於 11-6-25 00:11 |只看該作者
原帖由 xiximama 於 11-6-23 20:26 發表
Both schools have good reputation in English. My son is admitted by both schools, how do you advise generally?

It seems that 陳守仁 is 多元化活動教學, not like traditional. How about 聖方濟各?

Place ...


功課 SFA都唔係多架, 只係測驗考試多, 我有兩個朋友係入面讀, 話每個星期都有默書, 測驗好多囉。而且又教深一年既程度。

其實你睇下你想要D咩啦, 呢兩間學校比我感覺好唔同, 唔會咁難決定。如果話太相似就話難選擇JE...RIGHT?

Rank: 2


94
10#
發表於 11-6-25 01:58 |只看該作者
ssdiana,

Thanks your info especially the part on Chinese text book and teachers' qualities.

May I know Math class is using Cantonese or English to teach, and the text book is Chinese or English? If in English, how can my son convert 九因歌 from Cantonese to English?

Rank: 3Rank: 3


384
11#
發表於 11-6-25 11:14 |只看該作者
多謝大家意見!

xiximama
as I know, Math is teaching in English

Rank: 3Rank: 3


114
12#
發表於 11-6-28 11:54 |只看該作者
Your son is very smart, which kindergarten you let him to chose?
cause my daughter just wait list on TSL
‹ 上一主題|下一主題
返回列表
發新帖