港大同學會與陳守仁, 很難取捨! - 小一選校

Rank: 4


	909

2^#

發表於 09-11-27 13:04 |只看該作者

You may first ask yourself whether you will be satisfied if your kid studies at HKUGA college for secondary school. Then, think about the chances of your kid getting admitted by a secondary school better or worse than HKUGA college after studying in PLK TSL.

If I were you, locations would be the last concern.

原帖由 acwchiu 於 09-11-27 12:21 發表
港大同學會
好處: 近 (幾個港鐵站) 及有一條龍中學
不好處: 中文教學

陳守仁
好處: 英文教學
不好處: 遠 (要過海) 及沒有直屬中學

大家可否給些意見呢? ...

acwchiu

民房

Rank: 1


	14

3^#

發表於 09-11-27 13:23 |只看該作者

Thanks gingerale.

Totally agreed but the problem is I don't know if HKUGA college is a good secondary school or not as there is no track record on public exam.

In addition, do you have any idea about the overall English standard for the students in HKUGA Primary School?

Tsun Tsun Daddy :-)

Jack0128

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	1195

4^#

發表於 09-11-27 13:59 |只看該作者

acwchiu,

HKUGA is better in your case. Don't worry .
Nobody got the public exam result, because it's a new school. After finish primary school, you can apply for a better one, which don't force you to College.

waiwaibaba

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	141

5^#

發表於 09-11-27 14:11 |只看該作者

原帖由 acwchiu 於 09-11-27 12:21 發表
港大同學會
好處: 近 (幾個港鐵站) 及有一條龍中學
不好處: 中文教學

陳守仁
好處: 英文教學
不好處: 遠 (要過海) 及沒有直屬中學

大家可否給些意見呢? ...

If I were U, I will choose HKUGAP w/o doubt

1. save travelling cost and time
2. thru -train - this is very important - it relieve yr pressure in the primary yrs. Also it is very important to study both primary and secondary with consistent style and characeristics. What's the use if U spent 6yrs in TSL with 1 style and end up studying a famous secondary with another style?
3. I believe graduates from HKUGA college will have advantages in applying to HKU

Rank: 4


	909

6^#

發表於 09-11-27 14:21 |只看該作者

waiwaibaba,

I am afraid the following point doesn't make any sense. If it were the case, I am sure HKUGA would be the most popular DSS school in HK, much better than DBS, DGS, SPCC, etc.

"3. I believe graduates from HKUGA college will have advantages in applying to HKU"

If the same logic applies, graduates of HKBU WKF will have advantages in applying to HKBU, graduates of Lingnan school will have advantages in applying to LU, etc? Through-train to university, sounds pretty good!

原帖由 waiwaibaba 於 09-11-27 14:11 發表

If I were U, I will choose HKUGAP w/o doubt

1. save travelling cost and time
2. thru -train - this is very important - it relieve yr pressure in the primary yrs. Also it is very important to study ...

Rank: 4


	909

7^#

發表於 09-11-27 14:31 |只看該作者

To play safe, HKUGA is an obvious and easy choice.

"I don't know if HKUGA college is a good secondary school or not as there is no track record on public exam".

But this is a risk you need to take and nobody has the answer now-well, unless you believe that HKUGA students do have advantage in HKU applications.

English standard is no doubt higher at TSL where all subjects except Chinese are taught in English.  TSL students will have no need to get adjusted to english teaching in secondary schools.  Of course you need to take the risk of not getting into a school that is better than HKUGA college (but its standard is still up in the air).

Transportation is an issue- if it takes too long to travel.  But I guess you can always move.

原帖由 acwchiu 於 09-11-27 13:23 發表
Thanks gingerale.

Totally agreed but the problem is I don't know if HKUGA college is a good secondary school or not as there is no track record on public exam.

In addition, do you have any idea abou ...

Charlotte_mom

王國長老

Rank: 14

醒目開學勳章王國長老


	58861

8^#

發表於 09-11-27 14:51 |只看該作者

hkuga學生英文水平ok的, cr評價亦好, to be fair, 一定係唔夠TSL英文水平高, 我自己覺得HKUGA中文同英文比較都幾平均
HKUGA會讀得輕鬆d, 因為有一條龍中學, 我女小4, 現階段都會有家長心大心細(多數係比較叻既一小撮, 想更上一層樓又怕讀得辛苦........係要掙扎下架喇), 好似我呢d, 中規中矩, 唔好煩了, 預左直升
我見中學版既討論, 似乎外來生想考入hkuga college, band one會順利d, band two都要睇埋overall表現了, 話好勁咩, 又未至於, 不過不失啦, hkugac教法同小學一樣, 都係活動同重理解, 要自己去搵資料, 有d傳統學校學生上到去都要d時間適應的
hkugac考hku有著數?? 我都想........

暫時未有f.6學生, 係咪真係interview有著數, 我都唔知, 不過hkuga(我指港大畢業同學會)係一個背景好強既機構, o係辦學方面的確係俾左好多support的, 例如我女小4, 今年有個programme係同外國學生交流, 有video conference同一系列既堂, 仲可以去西班牙home stay tim!

原帖由 gingerale 於 09-11-27 02:31 PM 發表
To play safe, HKUGA is an obvious and easy choice.

"I don't know if HKUGA college is a good secondary school or not as there is no track record on public exam".

But this is a risk you need to take ...

bobee

Rank: 4


	573

9^#

發表於 09-11-27 14:59 |只看該作者

回覆 1# acwchiu 的文章

definitely HKUGP unless you want to play the school hunting thing during P.6. For P1, proximity to school is very important. Asking them to travel so long to school would be a torture and waste of time too. to me, both schools deliver pretty much qualified students.

iwff

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	3728

10^#

發表於 09-11-27 17:26 |只看該作者

我朋友個女讀緊TSL 小六, 佢都煩緊找那一間中學, 因為她的女兒成績中規中矩 ,英文是不錯的，但中文就唔係咁好，中英文唔得平均，係屬於ＢＡＮＤ２頭學生。我朋友說TSL聯系的中學顏寶玲愈來愈收緊TSL的學生人數，每年收生不多，所以佢打定輸數。現在都係四圍去聽直資中學的簡介會，會讀返直資中學，因為我朋友擔心津校個女唔適應。

我仔仔都以為佢會直升香港大學呀

，我都想所以叫佢比心機讀書。部份港同的小學畢業生（最ｔｏｐ個班）都升了去出名的津校，讀得都好好的。我朋友個女就係去了聖潔靈中學，ｄ同學仔以為佢係國際小學升上去，因為她的英文發音好正，普通話亦講得很好。

iwff

waiwaibaba

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	141

11^#

發表於 09-11-27 17:55 |只看該作者

原帖由 gingerale 於 09-11-27 14:21 發表
waiwaibaba,

I am afraid the following point doesn't make any sense. If it were the case, I am sure HKUGA would be the most popular DSS school in HK, much better than DBS, DGS, SPCC, etc.

"3. I beli ...

I do not think my point "doesn't make any sense". Bear in mind that universities have absolute discretion on student admission providing that the
students meet min admission standard and nowadays factors other than public exam results are becoming more and more important. Of course, just how important such factor is remain to be seen. Correct me if I'm wrong, I think HKU, the university itself, does provide support / assistance to HKUGA college and it works to the advantage of the university by increasing the bonding and affiliation of the university, its alumni and school founded by the alumni.

Charlotte_mom

王國長老

Rank: 14

醒目開學勳章王國長老


	58861

12^#

發表於 09-11-27 17:59 |只看該作者

當然有bonding/affiliation
不過講advantage就暫時太遠了

(btw, 我女已經覺得自己讀緊港大, 我都無佢咁好氣!)

原帖由 waiwaibaba 於 09-11-27 05:55 PM 發表

I do not think my point "doesn't make any sense". Bear in mind that universities have absolute discretion on student admission providing that the
students meet min admission standard and nowadays ...

silvia_ng

伯爵府

Rank: 8 Rank: 8


	19613

13^#

發表於 09-11-27 21:54 |只看該作者

比我一定選近屋企。小學學習功課多，如果係陳守仁玩完校隊 / 課外活動，返到屋企都唔洗做功課+ 溫習呢。

陳守仁放學3:30, 未計課外活動。

catcatmom

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	4494

14^#

發表於 09-11-27 22:18 |只看該作者

港同係一間好活既學校, 小朋友讀得好開心, 公司同事個小朋友在此校升中了, 但就覺得中學學費加得好勁, 當年係二千蚊多d, 想同個博出面中學, 但不知banding, 所以轉唔到, 而個仔又話唔想轉, 要同番同學一齊.

聽另外一個媽咪同我講過, 有位好內向小朋友入了港同, 成個人活曬, 開心曬.

但佢由一間普通地區小學轉入, 佢講過: 港同係中,數教得唔錯, 但英文差過佢以前間普通小學好多, 原因無問, 只聽佢甘講.

1116

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	233

15^#

發表於 09-11-28 11:00 |只看該作者

原帖由 iwff 於 09-11-27 17:26 發表
我朋友個女讀緊TSL 小六, 佢都煩緊找那一間中學, 因為她的女兒成績中規中矩 ,英文是不錯的，但中文就唔係咁好，中英文唔得平均，係屬於ＢＡＮＤ２頭學生。我朋友說TSL聯系的中學顏寶玲愈來愈收緊TSL的學生人數，每年收生不多，所以佢打 ...

選港同較稳陣，不用驚足6年！

chunheimama

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	3466

16^#

發表於 09-11-28 11:08 |只看該作者

原帖由 acwchiu 於 09-11-27 12:21 發表
港大同學會
好處: 近 (幾個港鐵站) 及有一條龍中學
不好處: 中文教學

陳守仁
好處: 英文教學
不好處: 遠 (要過海) 及沒有直屬中學

大家可否給些意見呢? ...

If I were u, I will choose 港大同學會
好處: 有一條龍中學, 近.
至於英文方面, 上高小時會加強, 準備函接英中(簡介會時說的)

[ 本帖最後由 chunheimama 於 09-11-28 11:13 編輯 ]

Rank: 4


	909

17^#

發表於 09-11-28 14:14 |只看該作者

真是不明白﹐ 難道為了子女的將來﹐用六年的時間栽培他們考到一家有名氣﹐有GOOD TRACK RECORD 的中學不值得麼﹖
難道一條龍中學一定好的嗎﹖ 雖知這間不是DBS﹐ DGS﹐SPCC﹐YINGWA等有保證的學校﹐是一條龍還是一條蟲﹐以後才知道。
難道為了家長自己12年的輕鬆﹐學校是怎樣都不重要嗎﹖ 如果浸大XX附屬學校和嶺大XX附屬學校可以肯定讓你們子女一條龍到大學畢業﹐你們會為了自己16年的安逸而甘心讓他們去讀嗎﹖

mamimummy

Rank: 4


	595

18^#

發表於 09-11-28 15:28 |只看該作者

如果人人都用這種心態去讀一條龍學校, 那麼成龍定成蟲, 就進社會更高下立見, 一調龍學校亦比這種心態慮死.

原帖由 gingerale 於 09-11-28 14:14 發表
真是不明白﹐ 難道為了子女的將來﹐用六年的時間栽培他們考到一家有名氣﹐有GOOD TRACK RECORD 的中學不值得麼﹖
難道一條龍中學一定好的嗎﹖ 雖知這間不是DBS﹐ DGS﹐SPCC﹐YINGWA等有保證的學校﹐是一條龍還是一條蟲﹐以後才知道。
...

CFaHB

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	289

19^#

發表於 09-11-28 16:50 |只看該作者

如果係我, 我會唸

1. 地區
2. 校風
3. 成績

港同的一條龍優勢 (??), 反而不是考慮之列

bk 亦有人提過
入一條龍學校, 未有 track record
12年安全直上, 唔知出面 standard
只以為自己好ok, 讀得好開心
直至考公開試 .....

咁 p6 將學生分 banding
都係想分學生能力施教
天資唔同
同一班房, 直係好難教的
有人一講就明, 通晒,
有人講 10 次都唔明
分開教
對大家都好 (band 1 2 /3 學生/ 老師)

如果我小朋友係成績 band 3 學生, 我絕唔想佢一條龍同 band 1 學生同班, 反之亦然

一條龍
是為左公平 (?)
逃避競爭

上大學, 咪一樣睇你有幾多分, 先可以入讀邊間大學, 入讀邊邊科

原帖由 mamimummy 於 09-11-28 15:28 發表
如果人人都用這種心態去讀一條龍學校, 那麼成龍定成蟲, 就進社會更高下立見, 一調龍學校亦比這種心態慮死.