用戶登入
用戶名稱:
密      碼:
搜索
教育王國 討論區 小學雜談 2000年9月出世後的千禧仔女, 會否讀多一年k2? ...
發新帖
查看: 1667|回覆: 18
go

2000年9月出世後的千禧仔女, 會否讀多一年k2? [複製鏈接]

Rank: 3Rank: 3


148
1#
發表於 04-11-30 12:06 |只看該作者

2000年9月出世後的千禧仔女, 會否讀多一年k2?

近期有數位2000年9月後出世的千禧媽咪, 也考慮讓他們讀多一年, 一來覺得同班中的大仔差dd, 二來避爭升上小學的學位, 大家覺得如何? 我囡囡是11月中出世, 是否真的讀多一年會比較好呢? :-|  :-|

Rank: 6Rank: 6


8330
2#
發表於 04-11-30 13:04 |只看該作者

Re: 2000年9月出世後的千禧仔女, 會否讀多一年k2?

芯朗:

我仔9月出世, 我個人覺得就冇乜必要讀多一年K2, 除非小朋友係學校完全追唔上課程, 而且我都冇打算揀選私校.

Rank: 3Rank: 3


239
3#
發表於 04-11-30 13:15 |只看該作者

Re: 2000年9月出世後的千禧仔女, 會否讀多一年k2?

煒良媽咪 寫道:
芯朗:

我仔9月出世, 我個人覺得就冇乜必要讀多一年K2, 除非小朋友係學校完全追唔上課程, 而且我都冇打算揀選私校.



Agree!!!

Rank: 2


64
4#
發表於 04-11-30 14:02 |只看該作者

Re: 2000年9月出世後的千禧仔女, 會否讀多一年k2?

My girl was exactly born in 9/00  I let her repeated  K1, because my dreaming school didn't accepted not enough 3 kids, so, last year, she studied in the other Kindergarten.
She is now staying in K1 but different school and that shool can direct promote to P.S.

Rank: 3Rank: 3


125
5#
發表於 04-11-30 14:03 |只看該作者

Re: 2000年9月出世後的千禧仔女, 會否讀多一年k2?

芯朗 寫道:
近期有數位2000年9月後出世的千禧媽咪, 也考慮讓他們讀多一年, 一來覺得同班中的大仔差dd, 二來避爭升上小學的學位, 大家覺得如何? 我囡囡是11月中出世, 是否真的讀多一年會比較好呢? :-|  :-|



芯朗 ,

我個仔都係11月中, 同某電視台同一日生日的! 如果repeat K2, 佢會唔會好悶? 又要睇下佢係咪真係慢過人好多? 我個仔比起大果D小朋友是BB少少, 有D野佢冇咁明, 有時唔知人地講乜, 好似跟唔倒咁, 係有D擔心, 例如有一次, 佢跟唔倒國語老師的指示, 俾佢鬧tim! 佢即時在學校喊, 回家又喊了幾晚.....睇倒呢D情況可能佢係細o左少少. 但係老師都話唔駛而家決定, 可以睇埋下學期, 到時或者好D呢. 其他媽咪又點?



Rank: 3Rank: 3


202
6#
發表於 04-11-30 14:22 |只看該作者

Re: 2000年9月出世後的千禧仔女, 會否讀多一年k2?

I think it need to depend to your kids, if he'she mature, then you can try.  But, if not, 勉強無幸福. 只會另小朋友辛苦
:-? ;-) 8-) :-P :-? ;-) 8-) :-P :-? :-P

Rank: 3Rank: 3


202
7#
發表於 04-11-30 14:32 |只看該作者

Re: 2000年9月出世後的千禧仔女, 會否讀多一年k2?

I think it need to depend to your kids, if he'she mature, then you can try.  But, if not, 勉強無幸福. 只會另小朋友辛苦
:-? ;-) 8-) :-P :-? ;-) 8-) :-P :-? :-P

Rank: 4


898
8#
發表於 04-11-30 17:21 |只看該作者

Re: 2000年9月出世後的千禧仔女, 會否讀多一年k2?

煒良媽咪 寫道:
芯朗:

我仔9月出世, 我個人覺得就冇乜必要讀多一年K2, 除非小朋友係學校完全追唔上課程, 而且我都冇打算揀選私校.


agree!

Rank: 3Rank: 3


273
9#
發表於 04-11-30 17:38 |只看該作者

Re: 2000年9月出世後的千禧仔女, 會否讀多一年k2?

我囡囡都係2000年12月出世, 我都無打算比佢讀多一年。
現在她都可以跟得上學校的課程。
唔好浪費她多一年時間。 :

Rank: 14Rank: 14Rank: 14Rank: 14

王國長老


5044
10#
發表於 04-11-30 18:05 |只看該作者

Re: 2000年9月出世後的千禧仔女, 會否讀多一年k2?

我個仔都係細仔,我無要佢讀遲一年因為整體上佢跟得上,而家佢已小學一年班,學習上問題不大。呢樣真係要睇番自己個小朋友既能力,有D細仔真係比較BB的。
我諗2000年家長都是擔心千禧年效應,因當年出生率高,撞著千禧又是龍年,將來升小、升中、考大學都是遇番同一大班人,多人爭是必然的事。我都識朋友是生龍尾仔,她兒子是多讀一年的,正正唔想一直都同一大班人爭,跟住的蛇年出生率低得多,攪珠都大D機會喇!

Rank: 5Rank: 5


4210
11#
發表於 04-11-30 22:02 |只看該作者

Re: 2000年9月出世後的千禧仔女, 會否讀多一年k2?

我個仔都係00年12月, 我見佢都跟到學校野課程, 所以唔會讀多一年K2啦!雖然讀多年, 係有好處!但係如果要佢留多年讀K2, 我個仔一定唔肯同埋我驚會hurt到佢, D同學仔個個升班, 你叫佢留班, 你諗佢會點諗?我諗會好唔開心囉, 而家d小朋友唔似我地當年咁(傻瓜瓜), 幾歲人仔已經有佢地既主意同思想!!     

Rank: 2


48
12#
發表於 04-12-2 01:40 |只看該作者

Re: 2000年9月出世後的千禧仔女, 會否讀多一年k2?

I personal think that it depends on your child ability. If your child is a boy, it is much better for him to do one more year. as in general, the overall development of a boy is 6 month behind a girl, so the small boy can't really complete with the girl, we can see the result of secondary school allocation, most girl can get into band 1 school, but boys...

Actaully, it is all depends our  parent how to educate our child, in general,  a child doesnot understand the impact what is repeat, so if u change your kid to a higher standard kiddy such as St. Theresa, the you child won't feel it is boring, as the standard of this kind of school is higher than some easy K3.

If we are talking about central allocation, I def sure the cahnace of get in good primary school in 2007 is much easier than 2006, as accordance to C&ED statistic, it had 54000 children in Y2K, but only 46000 in 2001, so the number of kids in 2001 is 8000 less than Y2k and 8000 is about 15% of total birhrate in Y2k.

Besides, we def sure kids are very happy in kindergarten, and they will have lot of pressure when they start P1, so if you want your child to have a happy childhood, u can let them to stay in kindy for one more year, otherwise, u can let them to start P1 in 2006.

Rank: 5Rank: 5


3610
13#
發表於 04-12-2 09:26 |只看該作者

Re: 2000年9月出世後的千禧仔女, 會否讀多一年k2?

Adrianmama,

I'm so happy to see that you have the same thoughts as mine!  Totally!  

Could please tell me how you got those statistics as I want to know the no. of boys and girls as well.  I've checked the website of the Statistics Bureau but nothing found.  Thanks a lot!
     

Rank: 4


503
14#
發表於 04-12-2 10:44 |只看該作者

Re: 2000年9月出世後的千禧仔女, 會否讀多一年k2?

我囡囡都是00年10月出生, 我個人認為每個小朋友的發展都不同, 但如果小朋友在學習上能跟得上, 認知方面也沒有問題, 其實就不用repeat, 如果repeat, 可能會對小朋友心理上有損害, 而且重覆學習一些她們認識的東西, 她們的學習動機, 就相對減低, 可能會很不專心。  

Rank: 5Rank: 5


1034
15#
發表於 04-12-3 17:50 |只看該作者

Re: 2000年9月出世後的千禧仔女, 會否讀多一年k2?

我個仔係00年10月出生, 唔會讀多年, 因為我先生是教小學的, 他講有很多校制賽事是限年齡參加, 只限同年小朋友, 例如 : 今年一年級賽事, 必須在1998年出生的小朋友才可參加, 如果你個小朋友係1997年出生就算讀一年級都不能參賽, 所以避免將來令到仔仔有參賽限制, 我地唔會要仔仔讀多年。當然唔會所有賽事都有此限制。

Rank: 4


537
16#
發表於 04-12-4 22:27 |只看該作者

Re: 2000年9月出世後的千禧仔女, 會否讀多一年k2?



我個仔都是2000/12月出生架.
如果派位唔好, 可否重讀k3

Rank: 4


898
17#
發表於 04-12-6 15:29 |只看該作者

Re: 2000年9月出世後的千禧仔女, 會否讀多一年k2?

rhythm 寫道:


我個仔都是2000/12月出生架.
如果派位唔好, 可否重讀k3


重讀K3當然可以啦, 不過, 就唔可以再參加派位了, 因為每位適齡小朋友只可以參加一次派位的。

Rank: 5Rank: 5


1365
18#
發表於 04-12-6 22:34 |只看該作者

Re: 2000年9月出世後的千禧仔女, 會否讀多一年k2?

My daughter was born in end of Oct. I've discussed with her principal. Her opinion is that: If you want your kid have an easier life in the primary school and also more confidence (as she would become the big sister in class), you should consider let her repeat either K2 or K3. I had never had the idea of "repeat" in such a young age, I thought it's a waste of time. But now, I would reconsider it given the real keen competition for those born in 2000. My hubby objected it as he thought our daughter could manage it and would consider repeat only when problem arises.
More opinions or experiences to share???
Thank you.

Rank: 4


674
19#
發表於 04-12-6 23:16 |只看該作者

Re: 2000年9月出世後的千禧仔女, 會否讀多一年k2?



我囡囡係蛇年尾, 咁到時攪珠又會多咗好多龍年repeat既小朋友一齊爭!  有冇人知呢兩年男多定女多?
‹ 上一主題|下一主題