我終於找到個好的教琴老師 - 課外活動

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	272

21^#

發表於 05-3-17 09:50 |只看該作者

Re: 我終於找到個好的教琴老師

亞美

Would you please pm me the details, thank you.

Mandy23

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	2077

22^#

發表於 05-3-17 11:53 |只看該作者

Re: 我終於找到個好的教琴老師

亞美

Would you please pm me the details, thank you

烏龍媽媽

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	245

23^#

發表於 05-3-17 12:00 |只看該作者

Re: 我終於找到個好的教琴老師

Ah May,

Would you pls PM the information for me pls? TKS!

ManManma

Rank: 2


	30

24^#

發表於 05-3-17 17:36 |只看該作者

Re: 我終於找到個好的教琴老師

Please also PM me the information.
Thanks

li_manchi

Rank: 2


	55

25^#

發表於 05-3-17 17:56 |只看該作者

Re: 我終於找到個好的教琴老師

亞美,

可唔可以講下你所講既教授,收既學費係幾多呢?
我有個學鋼琴學到好高級既朋友, 佢老師都係系大學度教既教授, 我朋友識既教授都唔少, 佢話我知呢d教授級人馬收既學費大約係$800-$1200(以每小時計), 而且唔係好多教授肯教小朋友, d小朋友首先要經過面試, 睇下個小朋友有幾聰明, 天資有幾高後, 先考慮收定唔收, 更絕不會上門教添.

亞美

Rank: 2


	82

26^#

發表於 05-3-17 18:43 |只看該作者

Re: 我終於找到個好的教琴老師

可能收費是因人而異,他是剛來香港,我知佢一星期來香港數天,最近集中在某處教考校際及亞洲賽的學生,老闆收的學費不少.
我仔仔是初學,他也先考慮他對彈琴的興趣才決定教,他是比較重視基礎的建立.
我大仔個小提琴老師最初來港時也是要上門,去學校...但到學生多時,才不上門,現在會揀學生呢,只要唔練琴,好快佢唔教你.

daufungma

Rank: 2


	59

27^#

發表於 05-3-17 22:11 |只看該作者

Re: 我終於找到個好的教琴老師

在瀋陽大學音樂系畢業

即係degree之馬,煲多30年都未係professor啦.
professor響一堆doctor入便都未必有1個啦.
professor 閒閒地7 8皮個月啦,駛乜上門教呀?
真係"教授課程"就係"教授"咩!

今個暑假會來香港某大學教授課程

係咩U d課程先?係咪FTdegree course先
香港某大學d課程...HKU SPACE又係, CU校外又係喎, BU持續進收都係喎, open U parttime course都叫u喎
幾百蚊上10堂,仲要唔駛MASTER都教得,music course好多種, 教music therapy個d連樂器都唔駛識彈都教得tim啦.

老師來指點....以為了得....任料...句式...

係有好多國內"term" law.

係sell咪堂堂正正sell law, 唔駛"角色扮演"喎 :evil:

ahlai

Rank: 2


	71

28^#

發表於 05-3-18 18:23 |只看該作者

Re: 我終於找到個好的教琴老師

Dear Daufungma,

何必動氣，其實好多媽咪都知是甚麼一回事。不過，既然你開了話題，我都多咀講下我自己知道的情況給各位有意找綱琴老師的媽咪參考下。

我自己小朋友的老師是外國大學畢業，有碩士學位，佢可以教八級琴和樂理。教一級都要收$500 一個小時，我要去佢道學。一般在琴行的老師本身只有八級diploma ，所以只可以敎到五級 (但其實好勉強 )，你地去問下琴行d 人都知，所以一分錢一分貨是不變定律。

我的一個朋友，在浸大(不是校外部)教的，真是教授，佢收$900 教45 分鐘，不會上門。正如 Daufungma 　說，雖然是我個老友，但佢都是沒有耐性教我個小朋友。西琦祟子小姐收＄1,500　一個小時指導小提琴，但要有介紹人和要有七八級琴藝。

國內來的老師，注重技巧(甚至於過份做作)，個人意見多是缺乏感情，每章樂曲是要由個心來感受才可以發揮出該篇樂曲的精髓。

學琴的目的，除了技巧以外，個人認為　musicianship　更重要。

我不是要開筆戰，如果有得罪的地方，希望各位原諒。　　

亞美

Rank: 2


	82

29^#

發表於 05-3-18 18:40 |只看該作者

Re: 我終於找到個好的教琴老師

只是一個個人分享而已,何必這麼多猜測?我的中文會考只是剛合格,若果用詞寫句不當,請見諒.
可能我的孩子用生本課程,我不時都在家溫習,久而久之被感染吧!只是習慣用書面語,就當我是說普通話的人,實在太過獎了.
我相信做媽媽的,都是希望為兒女找最好的,我覺得好,對於別人來說可能一文不值,但總歸我們嘗了這好處,與人分享而已.

多謝各位媽媽給的意見.不如另立新題目,分享一下大家如何鼓勵子女有恆心地參加課外活動,不會中途放棄.相信你們的經驗會給我們帶來激勵.

CSL123

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	162

30^#

發表於 05-3-18 22:23 |只看該作者

Re: 我終於找到個好的教琴老師

I know that Hong Kong Academy for Performing Arts is now recruiting piano students from aged 5 or above. You may download the application form from www.hkapa.edu. The brilliant Cheung Wai Ching is also under the tuition of Ms. Wong Yee Lun. The tution fee is $5,000 per semester. I also apply the piano courses for my two sons.

I believe that there are many excellent piano teachers there.

LittleKay

Rank: 2


	63

31^#

發表於 05-4-9 12:03 |只看該作者

Re: 我終於找到個好的教琴老師

CSL123,

Can you tell me how to apply because I can't download the form, is it too late to apply now? Please help.

kaka0814

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	1101

32^#

發表於 05-4-9 23:24 |只看該作者

Re: 我終於找到個好的教琴老師

CSL123,

Do you know you still have to pay for the pravite tution fee? To what I know, Miss Cheung is paying $1200/hr to Ms. Wong for piano lesson, while people say Ms. Wong is charging less to her.

My friend was graduated from APA junior, he had to pay $800/hr/lesson, and required to have 4 lesson at least in a month. So please don't think you just have to pay $5000, that's just for the ensemble, aural lesson and theory lesson, but not including pravite tution.

Music is the art of thinking with sounds. –Jules Combarieu

哈里波特

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	1031

33^#

發表於 05-4-9 23:44 |只看該作者

Re: 我終於找到個好的教琴老師

Junior program $22,000/year including private tutor 1 hr major subject & 2-3 hrs for aural, theory, performance.....etc. So, why the parents still need to pay private tutor. As per APA's instruction, it is written on the application hand book, if you join their program, you MUST NOT learn outside.

kaka0814

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	1101

34^#

發表於 05-4-10 00:11 |只看該作者

Re: 我終於找到個好的教琴老師

My friend learnt in APA Junior Section, yes, APA offer tutor, and you must learn with their teacher, but still, you have to pay the teacher!!

I dun know whether they have changed for these regulation, but they really paid the tutors and most of them are charging very high!

Music is the art of thinking with sounds. –Jules Combarieu

CSL123

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	162

35^#

發表於 05-4-10 19:18 |只看該作者

Re: 我終於找到個好的教琴老師

LittleKay,

Sorry to reply you so late. You may phone APA at 2584 8644 direct. My friend told me that APA accepts late application.

CSL123

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	162

36^#

發表於 05-4-10 19:23 |只看該作者

Re: 我終於找到個好的教琴老師

kaka0814,

Does $22,000 tuition fee for 30 lessons? So, when the 30 lessons is completed that I have to pay for the tutor?

By the way, how to find Ms Wong Yee Lun for private tutition if I am willing to pay her for $1200/hr or more?

Thanks.

kaka0814

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	1101

37^#

發表於 05-4-11 01:25 |只看該作者

Re: 我終於找到個好的教琴老師

My friend said the $22,000 tuition is only for Aural, Ensemble / Orchestra, History and Theory. He had paid for his major instrument lesson for over 8 years until he reach 18 years old.

My another friend was Ms. Wong's students before when she was young. But she said Ms. Wong usually don't take pravite student out of APA, as she had already being very busy. But if you got her contact, I guess you could still ask whether she will be interested to teach. of course, you are a must to PUSH your child to learn, as she will push all her student in music, and require you guy to practise it hours a day.

Lastly, don't think any "REAL" musician will be given out lesson if you could pay them. $1200 to them is not a great deal, they would rather save some more pravite time, and that's only the price of Cheung Wai-ching, who can get so many prize for her!! I guess normal people would have to pay $2000+ for one lesson, and you are required to take at least 4 a month. Though I believe you are rich, but still a lot...

Music is the art of thinking with sounds. –Jules Combarieu

肥肥人

Rank: 2


	38

38^#

發表於 05-4-11 01:48 |只看該作者

Re: 我終於找到個好的教琴老師

Dear CSL123,

My elder daughter is APA Junior Student, major in Violin. There are really many gd teachers in APA. But好難好難考入去, even u are willing to pay, Miss Wong 都唔係個個肯收，但u can find her graduated pupil teach your child first, then will be more easy to enter into APA, coz her pupils are all excellent pianist!! If u hv any questions, pls PM me, let me see if I can help u

kunggi201

別墅

Rank: 4


	571

39^#

發表於 05-4-11 11:00 |只看該作者

Re: 我終於找到個好的教琴老師

ahlai 寫道:
國內來的老師，注重技巧(甚至於過份做作)，個人意見多是缺乏感情，每章樂曲是要由個心來感受才可以發揮出該篇樂曲的精髓。學琴的目的，除了技巧以外，個人認為　musicianship　更重要。

我有同感。雖然國內也有很多鋼琴家和名師，但其他的，大部份都有這個情況（過於注重技巧）；現在多了很多國內來的鋼琴家，個個都被人吹噓成「名師」，實際那一個才是名師，家長要小心去查證，不要人云亦云。

我絕對沒有歧視國內音樂家的意思。個人認為，「音樂無界限」，能多見世面多吸收各國風格的，才能培養musicianship，香港人是，國內人也是，甚至是歐洲音樂家亦都是，沒有去過其他地方學習的，視野只限在本土的「音樂家」，只會教出音樂感窄狹的學生。

哈里波特寫道:
Junior program $22,000/year including private tutor 1 hr major subject & 2-3 hrs for aural, theory, performance.....etc. So, why the parents still need to pay private tutor. As per APA's instruction, it is written on the application hand book, if you join their program, you MUST NOT learn outside.

Checked with APA over the phone. Yes, Junior progamme $22000/year cover BOTH private tutor AND group sessions. APA offers many different programs, of which some include private tutor, but some require extra fee for private tutor. So, it depends on which program the kids join.

Question: 有沒有家長知道　"

re-Junior programme" 每年收多少鋼琴學生？謝謝！

fong媽