「普藝盃」2009 全港朗誦才藝大賽

iloveo

Anyone join this contest on 26 Oct, 09?  Any comment?  Fair or unfair?  After they announce the result, only the champian will go out (the champian is not in the same group with mine.  They seperate two groups even the same 比賽項目).  At the end, we do not recognize who are the rest of the kids that got the prize.

金毛B媽

我個囡參加 k1 比賽, 我個囡個組, 有好多小朋友都喊, 唔肯出聲, 有一些小朋友都要家長陪同一起朗誦, 我都覺得要值得鼓勵的, 畢竟得3 歲小朋友都可以出來比賽, 實在難得

不過, 結果令我有點失望, 因為我小朋友是很大聲, 有動作的, 心想入不到3甲, 優異獎都應該不難的, 好可惜, 未能入選, 反而哭的小朋友, 細細聲的, 沒有動作的小朋友入選了

[ 本帖最後由 金毛B媽 於 09-10-28 15:14 編輯 ]

Meganmom

i join too and almost same case with you...my daughter also have good performance on that day, even the whole classroom people have great claping their hand when finished (including the juryman also big clap hand)...but finally only the 優異獎 and when announce the winner....nobody have reaction...(of course except their parents)

The point is not my daughter can win or not, speech contest is "objective game", but the Juryman also have good rating at his immediate reaction...but after 10 mins "culculation" then seems suddenly changing, honest...a bit disappointed but we can's proven any. (beacuse the game rule is seperate room conducting, we can see all the group students performance)

Just wonder what happen inside and what's their standard, and call the organization can i "see" the other competitor's performance (as before we can order the DVD for event) then we can learn more and improve on next time. But they say that the DVD only show your son/ daughter's inside, you can't see any others?

Why? they didn't allow us to make record and claimed that they'll provide this services, then we belive and suppose the organization is reliable. iiiiiiiiii, nothing can say.

Just my experience sharing and pls. no need to "against" if i am say any wrong.

iloveo

You know they changed their name for every year.  Not like learning Kxx.  Maybe they received a lot of complaint every year too.  Next time, we need to be clear our mind.

On year 2007 is 2007 普通話才藝觀摩賽
On year 2008 is 2008 藝術交流大賽
On year 2009 is普藝盃2009 全港朗誦才藝大賽

金毛B媽

嘩....原來轉咁多名架, 我第一次參加呢個比賽咋 ?

下次要看清楚先好報名比賽呀

記得有一次, 壹週刊賣, 北大個比賽又係搵笨

有無人話我聽, 有邊一個比賽唔做馬架 ?

cottontail

我個囡都有參加, 佢係其他賽事都有贏, 唯獨這個比賽連優異獎都冇, 不要緊,但問題是比賽有造馬之嫌, 冠軍者係另一場都係冠軍, 佢 第一場比賽不是特別出色, 所以冇乜人留意佢, 但覺得有人比佢好, 第二場比賽有人開始留意佢, 但佢表現一般, 仲有少少"luk" 咀, 但結果又係佢得獎, 你話冇造馬就假架, 下次尼間野既比賽都都唔好攪我, 哂我錢同時間, 輸唔緊要, 最緊要比賽係公平, 輸得心服。

[ 本帖最後由 cottontail 於 09-10-30 01:01 編輯 ]

LittlePigmom

真係令人失望.

原帖由 金毛B媽 於 09-10-28 15:02 發表
我個囡參加 k1 比賽, 我個囡個組, 有好多小朋友都喊, 唔肯出聲, 有一些小朋友都要家長陪同一起朗誦, 我都覺得要值得鼓勵的, 畢竟得3 歲小朋友都可以出來比賽, 實在難得

不過, 結果令我有點失望, 因為我小朋友是很大 ...

Meganmom

"你話冇造馬就假架, 下次尼間野既比賽都都唔好攪我, 哂我錢同時間, 輸唔緊要, 出緊要比賽係公平, 輸得心服。" totally agree,  and i never enroll this organization. Waste my time and money...

chanel2009

If the competition is just under another name by "learning k--" then the winner must be some student who paid and took major courses at the center.

It's always been that way.

So annoying, wish this organization will go away, gives "competitions" and "education centers" a bad name.....

ruining the industry.

mrs_snoopy

其實都唔係..我今年都參加了learning kxx..小兒都取了個小獎.他都沒有參加其舉辦的比賽

[ 本帖最後由 mrs_snoopy 於 09-10-30 10:21 編輯 ]

iloveo

No.  I am not saying this contest was organized by learning kxx.  They are the different organization.  But I find the result is very unfair.  

BTW, I was told by some mummies that there are lots of winners are from 俊xx能發展中心.  I saw they took photos before the contest start between 俊xx and the organizer. Maybe we need to learn from this centre in order to get the prize next year.  Anyone can share if this is truth?

小豬脾

原帖由 iloveo 於 09-10-30 10:42 發表
No.  I am not saying this contest was organized by learning kxx.  They are the different organization.  But I find the result is very unfair.  

BTW, I was told by some mummies that there are lots of ...

其實個個比賽都唔fair架，個個評判要求都唔同。我的小朋友近期參加了幾個比賽，普藝盃在安排上已算最好。課室安靜，評判在比賽開始前已講明不可喧嘩，父母不可提小朋友。它確是將1大組的小朋友再分組，我們只能看見部份參賽者，有幸得獎的幾位小朋友都是我小朋友的分組，他們的表現真的不錯。評判雖是伯伯，評語也短，但比賽完了我去向他請教，他也樂於答我。

相比起幼兒藝術節，我覺得普藝盃已好好多。幼兒藝術節比賽那天的安排十分亂，比賽時課室十分嘈，工作人員講比賽規則時，坐在課室中至後排完全聽唔到，家長十分不滿。評判的準則一樣奇怪，夠大聲就可以得獎，朗誦得好不好也不要緊。頒獎更不知所謂。用blue tag貼起張banner，跟本不夠力，貼上就跌下來，連第三屆個"三"字都是即場做，剪三條長短一樣的白紙條，用黑筆油上去，難睇到不得了，最後才找來幾條顏色字條貼上去，因over-run，下一場的家長又擁入來，十分混亂。

去過幾個大小不同的比賽，自己也心裹有數，那些比賽較值得参加。

[ 本帖最後由 小豬脾 於 09-10-30 16:23 編輯 ]

1116

sabmar

原帖由 1116 於 09-10-31 08:49 發表

my son participated as well, he didn't get any prize. I thought the competition was quite well organised by the judge seems a bit tough on some of the kids, as far as his comments on those kids were concerned.

BigPig

咁相對今日既第一屆全港幼稚園才藝大賽已經好好, 今日由兩點等到三點幾先可以比賽, 仲要係續位小朋友入去比賽, 根本唔知其他小朋友既水準, 我覺得好似閉門造車咁, 得果十多個小朋友一組, 每日都係一分鐘, 都用左成兩個鐘去比賽, 真係安排混亂, 評判又無講comment.  好失望.

evon688

我囡囡今年係第一次參加 K3 組粵語朗誦, 詩詞
可能粵語組比較小人參加, 所以囡囡係 2 個項目
都得到獎項 (小組) !
呢次我覺得幾好嘅經驗 , 因為囡囡比較內臉,
為免佢臨陣怯場, 所以我係10月24號參加去
模擬比賽, 真如我所料佢真係怯場唔肯出去, 到佢
睇到其他小朋友表演時慢慢開始適應, 最後佢都
有出去做模擬比賽, 到比賽日時佢已經唔怕出去
比賽, 雖然今次只係得季軍同優異獎, 但係我已經
好滿意, 因為我唸住攞個經驗, 當然亞女係最開心啦 !

Furbymao

would you mind telling which studio did your daughter go for preparing for the competition?