唔知應該"驚"定應該"喜"--我個女係perfect pitch

jellomama

Congratulations, I think it's a blessing. It'll be so much easier for her aural test (part of the practical piano exam) in future. Would you consider letting her learning the violin as well? She'll have no problem tuning her own instrument then.

violetching

From my understanding, "perfect pitch" means the child can identify the note by stating whether it is "C", "C#" or "G" etc just by hearing, isn't it?
It will give an advantage in string or woodwind instrument but not the piano, because those instrument needs a good hearing and identify走音or not..  

Sindy

violetching 寫道:
From my understanding, "perfect pitch" means the child can identify the note by stating whether it is "C", "C#" or "G" etc just by hearing, isn't it?
It will give an advantage in string or woodwind instrument but not the piano, because those instrument needs a good hearing and identify走音or not..  

即係好簡單,係件樂器(鋼琴,小提琴,等等...)度是但彈一個音,佢就知係咩音.....有時佢會話比你聽,係介乎 b 同 c中間都未定,佢地未必唱得出,好似我女咁.....hehe,佢好似五音不全咁...hehe

violetching

    

Sindy 寫道:
[quote]
violetching 寫道:
From my understanding, "perfect pitch" means the child can identify the note by stating whether it is "C", "C#" or "G" etc just by hearing, isn't it?
It will give an advantage in string or woodwind instrument but not the piano, because those instrument needs a good hearing and identify走音or not..  

即係好簡單,係件樂器(鋼琴,小提琴,等等...)度是但彈一個音,佢就知係咩音.....有時佢會話比你聽,係介乎 b 同 c中間都未定,佢地未必唱得出,好似我女咁.....hehe,佢好似五音不全咁...hehe[/quote]

Sindy

好容易理解啫....hehe
有時仲未必要識唱都可以係perfect pitch的呀....例如,你叫佢掉轉身,你是但彈一個音,佢可以即刻,可能唔駛一秒,佢就係個琴度彈返出黎,呢個係辨音既能力.....唔關drmfsltd既事的,我女都唔係認呢兩樣野...佢係認cdefgabc......佢認drmfsltd可能係relative pitch....

Charlotte_mom 寫道:

Sindy
好彩係我女女老師係perfect pitch, 所以佢識點去解釋俾我個女聽(弊傢伙, 佢話初時係要多d時間去理解, 我仲報左11月考試tim, 都唔知佢點算.......)
唔好彩既係, 琴老師細個, 老師唔識教佢(因為老師聽唔到), 所以佢係學左琴十幾年, 開始學小提琴, 至慢慢"融會貫通"返, 所以佢話, 有sharp/flag音, 佢都係差d........
就係因為我女女走音問題嚴重, 老師至suggest佢唱既時候, 唱drmfs, 而唔係"啦啦啦啦啦", 點知就發現我個女原來係唱sltdr..........唔怪得之前學scale, 佢一唔專心想住drmfsltd, 就轉錯晒手指, 因為佢心裡面原來一直唱緊第2樣野..........

snoppy

what is the different of perfect pitch and relative pitch?

hellolanlan

剛才我試一試
我仔都可以完全聽到音, 佢講 cdefgabc, a#, g# ....
但係, 佢d琴彈得好爛   架 bor ....
咁點算呢 ?

Sindy

hellolanlan 寫道:
剛才我試一試
我仔都可以完全聽到音, 佢講 cdefgabc, a#, g# ....
但係, 佢d琴彈得好爛   架 bor ....
咁點算呢 ?

咪同我女一樣囉,對學樂器有幫助,但唔大,等於樂器中的小聰明.......hehe......我成日都覺得呢d係可以train,以前無咁高科技,就覺得係inborn........我識得周圍既小朋友,都機乎全部都識聽音.......


呀..有無試過最高八度同最低八度呀?我女呢d準確率無100%,亦都唔可以唔駛一秒答到...所以我覺得佢唔係inborn,係聽得多........仲有..最初聽小提琴時,佢話聽唔慣...所以我都好大疑問

neighbour931

其實係呢到見到好多唔同類型既case, 好多父母都都想自己個小朋友與別不同, 有細細個聽完首歌,自己彈番出黎既(唔知係單音定所有聲部, 不過我相信單音居多),  有d幼稚園已經識念乘數表, 仲有好多, 無論呢d係inborn 好, 唔係又好, 呢d'小技倆' 只係佔左我地學習生涯中一個很小的環節, 我舉一個比較實際既例子, '珠心算', 我相信很多小朋友都有學習, 從中亦得著好多成功感, 我唔會否定佢給與小朋友的運算成就, 但每有朋友問我意見, 我都不建議學習, 因為四式運算只係數學上的入門小小的環節, 無論你'珠心算' 冠絕全球也好, 到最後你只係一個'珠心算'專家, 唔係一個數學家, 而且'珠心算'並非 life long的技能, 到小朋友上中學的時候, 便要使用計算機和, 到時, 珠心算便留在家, '收藏'起來了. 音樂也如是, 聽音, 拍子, 手指靈活........一切都係基本要素, 有先天優勢固然值得心, 沒有的亦唔代表不能成功. 各位家長努力啦, 後天栽培比先天條件重要凡得多.

Sindy

做乜講我呀    

neighbour931 寫道:
其實係呢到見到好多唔同類型既case, 好多父母都都想自己個小朋友與別不同, 有細細個聽完首歌,自己彈番出黎既(唔知係單音定所有聲部, 不過我相信單音居多),  有d幼稚園已經識念乘數表, 仲有好多, 無論呢d係inborn 好, 唔係又好, 呢d'小技倆' 只係佔左我地學習生涯中一個很小的環節, 我舉一個比較實際既例子, '珠心算', 我相信很多小朋友都有學習, 從中亦得著好多成功感, 我唔會否定佢給與小朋友的運算成就, 但每有朋友問我意見, 我都不建議學習, 因為四式運算只係數學上的入門小小的環節, 無論你'珠心算' 冠絕全球也好, 到最後你只係一個'珠心算'專家, 唔係一個數學家, 而且'珠心算'並非 life long的技能, 到小朋友上中學的時候, 便要使用計算機和, 到時, 珠心算便留在家, '收藏'起來了. 音樂也如是, 聽音, 拍子, 手指靈活........一切都係基本要素, 有先天優勢固然值得心, 沒有的亦唔代表不能成功. 各位家長努力啦, 後天栽培比先天條件重要凡得多.

JP

Charlotte_mom & sindy>>

之前有老師identify到我細仔係perfect pitch, 大仔係relative pitch. 佢地學piano, 細仔perfect pitch冇乜幫助，反而佢sight reading 、節奏感、領悟力不及哥哥，所以哥哥彈得好D！

如果妳囡有學string都算行

Zoey

其實點先算係有 perfect pitch         ?    若果聽過一首歌, 可以自己彈番出黎 (不過只係一隻手), 咁唔知算唔算          ? 咁其實係咪好多小朋友都可以做得到        ?!

不過聽音好, 對弦樂既學習真係好有用, 尢其這些經常要調音既學器, 我覺得能夠用耳仔自己準確調好音的已經非常好.