不要看Teletubbies???

BBChan

Dear All,

以下message係在綱上看到的, 真的嗎? 我囡囡好鍾意睇啊…仲比唔比佢繼續睇好呀??   

“得得B講的說話不好, 會敎壞BB, 因為得得B講的說話都不知道他們講什麼, 怕BB會學”


BBChan

ho_fish

我囡囡細細個時我已經比佢睇teletubbies, 雖然teletubbies係講bb話,但係小朋友好有共鳴,會跟住佢地發音,尤其睇到出場既bb,佢地會好興奮。

我囡囡家下2歲5個月, 非常多野講, 講既亦都係句子,佢知道當中想表達既意思。我覺得比小朋友睇呢套卡通完全無問題,問題係在於日常生活中,我地有無多d同佢地溝通。

sell2japan

完全同意　！！！！！！！！！！！！

ho_fish 寫道:
我囡囡細細個時我已經比佢睇teletubbies, 雖然teletubbies係講bb話,但係小朋友好有共鳴,會跟住佢地發音,尤其睇到出場既bb,佢地會好興奮。

我囡囡家下2歲5個月, 非常多野講, 講既亦都係句子,佢知道當中想表達既意思。我覺得比小朋友睇呢套卡通完全無問題,問題係在於日常生活中,我地有無多d同佢地溝通。

    

JackMon

我就唔會比我bb 看, 看電視太多, 會影響小朋友的集中力, 另外我不喜歡裏面的低b對話, 應該以正常的完整句子同小朋友說話.

sell2japan

But I found my baby learnt many words and sentences from TB, such as "What's that ?"and "This is a ball."which I have never taught her. Also, she likes watching "Sesamestreet" and learning many words from " Elmo's world". She is allowed watching the education programs not more than a hour everydays. Baby are happy following the daily schedule I prepared.       

pmama

我囡囡都好鐘意睇teletubbies, 雖然teletubbies講野都講BB話好似唔清楚咁, 但我囡囡家下未足兩歲, 都非常多野講, 講既亦都係句子, 我覺得比小朋友睇呢套卡通完全無問題, 問題出於個BB本身學習能力同講野能力好唔好, 還有在日常生活中湊BB的人有無多d同佢地溝通。

另外有好多人講男仔學講野比女仔差, 跟本就又係錯誤, 我見過有個男仔BB只有16個月大已經識成句句子同佢MAMA講!

熙媽媽

我都會比仔仔睇，佢講0野亦無mud問題。佢細個gei時候好鐘意睇，大大0下，佢自然揀第d節目睇，所以唔駛太擔心。

我好同意其他媽媽講，最緊要係大人同小朋友日常講幾多0野。我個仔仔每日可以睇不多於2小時電視，呢2小時睇gei全係芝麻街、熊叔叔等節目，佢由節目中學會0左好多0野，呢d係我意外收穫。其實芝麻街真係好值得睇，個仔仔睇0左都可以學到唔少0野。

其實，除0左以上gei批評，我介聽過有另外1個批評：男女角色混淆(因為佢0地可以一條裙輪流4個人著，tinkie winkie係男仔，但佢成日拎個手袋)，但係我又覺得唔係太大問題。

ho_fish

JackMon 寫道:
我就唔會比我bb 看, 看電視太多, 會影響小朋友的集中力, 另外我不喜歡裏面的低b對話, 應該以正常的完整句子同小朋友說話.

JackMon, 當然如你所說,看太多真的會影響小朋友既集中力,但最重要係大人懂控制時間, 半小時至1小時既電視節目係可以接受。至於卡通人名既對話,大人覺得佢低b啫,企o係小朋友既覺度睇,只要小朋友有共鳴,睇得開心便可以啦, 講真,有時大人諗既,講既並唔係完全啱既...

BBChan

Dear All,

多謝各位mammy 意見, 而家放心比佢繼續睇lu.

亦都好同意最緊要係分配時間及家長指引及多同孩子講話.  其實我都有同囡囡一齊睇, 仲同佢一齊睇一齊笑tim.  而且囡囡從中真係學到一D短句子&生字, 平時都會講番出lay.  有時同佢'king'偈 講番d劇情, 佢都好開心 (見佢開心, 我 'might' 開心law).  

BBChan

雨霖鈴媽媽

好多人話teletubbies口音唔正,bb睇左學埋講野
似低b多過學野.
我反而覺得佢變化不大,性格思想唔夠明顯(at least 比disney cartoon),我寧願俾disney channel 我仔仔睇...
我都o岩睇嘛........

Heihmom

我覺得冇所謂, bb　看得開心，又冇血腥暴力就ｏｋ啦！

BBChan

agreed

BBChan

Heihmom 寫道:
我覺得冇所謂, bb　看得開心，又冇血腥暴力就ｏｋ啦！

tt2001

我好同意幾位mami。
我仔細時比乜vcd都吾吾睇，後來朋友介紹TB，一開佢就happy到不得了。有段的時間replay又replay，大大下又睇下其他seasame street, richard scarry, preschool power, etc. 我吾覺得對學習做成任何礙。依家你叫佢睇tb都吾睇，"層次"太低la麻，依家至愛係Thomas，間中星版disney and others.

至於分辨男女，我冇諗過甘細要識分wor！係後來佢大D我地一路睇preschool power我順便教，好快就搞掂。

我都吾比我仔睇tv，主要係劇集，一來係(步)力，二來係那些情情峇峇，我有個ex-colleague比佢5歲女睇tv，睇到佢着晒迷，成日同媽咪"討論"邊個鍾意邊個，邊個應該同邊個結婚，又迷偶像(眾多)，呢D我會好鬼驚。

SweetieBaby

現今視會電視e個媒體係好難避免ge....父母要小心選擇,重質唔重量ge

不過"天視得得B"就可免則免la, 以前報紙登過外國有d國家禁左o架, 因入免經常出現一d冇意思的發音, 如果BB是在語言發展時期,會影響說話o架!!

charlene

最緊要係 ...... 家長指引.

ethaniel

Teletubbies is one of the best seller from BBC education, it is a very nice programme to watch from 1 months to 3-4 yer old.

My elderest which is 27 months now and he hated when he was a baby, showing very least interest in it. Now when I start playing it for my youngest since he is 6 months old(now he is 1 yr old), they both love it. My eldest understand more from the captioned topics like the band singing in the Nursery Rhymes. And they are so happy when telebubbies start dancing and giggling. My youngest is influcened by the eldest to start moving and clapping his hands.

My eldest whic his 27 months old and he is trying to sing the words which the band was singing like the "Hickory, Dickory and Dock, the mouse ran up the clock" which is amazing with the moving of the body as well.

I do agree it is all depends on how you want the babies learn it form the programme....