小一會唔會要留班?

Ah-Faye

亞女成績唔好,班主任之前叫我要有留班o既心理準備......
好驚呀有d人話佢只係嚇下我,小一唔會留班......
有無人可以解答下我呀好擔心呀

daisy17772

原帖由 Ah-Faye 於 11-6-16 01:10 發表
亞女成績唔好,班主任之前叫我要有留班o既心理準備......
好驚呀有d人話佢只係嚇下我,小一唔會留班......
有無人可以解答下我呀好擔心呀 ...

有 ka!  But how marginal is your girl?  And which month was your girl born in?  Looking from another angle, repeating may not be bad if she really struggles.  Some kids do grow less mature than others , and HK school system favours those kids who are more mature.  But these mature kids are getting less advantages once they are in upper primary.  If your girl could gain more solid in the main subjects during lower primary, she could perform better in later years.  

How about you give the teacher a call to see how she goes with her final exam?  At least you could prepare for the outcome, and plan ahead to help your kid to better equip during summer.

With our endurance and acceptance, our kids would sooner or later fulfill their potential.

Don't give up!

[ 本帖最後由 daisy17772 於 11-6-16 01:39 編輯 ]

Ah-Faye

daisy17772,多謝你o既回應.....

我都會打比老師問下,睇下點樣可以幫到亞女.....
其實我睇到亞女進步左ga,佢可能真係比較遲熟d la....進度好似係比別人慢 but she was born in June,唔係細女黎ga......
anyway,thanks for your support!
we'll never give up

[ 本帖最後由 Ah-Faye 於 11-6-16 02:09 編輯 ]

karen55407

間間學校唔同，但老師講明有留班可能，即表示你間學校有留班制。我呀女同班有一個留班生，佢成績今年好好，全班中上。好好幫吓呀女喇！小朋友可以進步得好快。

原帖由 Ah-Faye 於 11-6-16 01:10 發表
亞女成績唔好,班主任之前叫我要有留班o既心理準備......
好驚呀有d人話佢只係嚇下我,小一唔會留班......
有無人可以解答下我呀好擔心呀 ...

宇晴軒

唉!我都好驚,囡囡都係P1,數學肥左

真係有D估唔到

希望唔駛留班

SEI

As far as I know, some primary schools request pupil to pass 3 subjects(Chinese, English, Maths), if there is anybody could not pass either 1 subject, school will ask the pupil to re-exam, this is the final chance, otherwise, this pupil will be request to stay for 1 more year of P1.

I hope your daughter can get the good result, good luck !!!

瑩瑩老豆

小二我見過有人要留班.

原帖由 Ah-Faye 於 11-6-16 01:10 發表
亞女成績唔好,班主任之前叫我要有留班o既心理準備......
好驚呀有d人話佢只係嚇下我,小一唔會留班......
有無人可以解答下我呀好擔心呀 ...

Johorma

我地學校試過留10幾個啊,你都米話唔驚.

原帖由 Ah-Faye 於 11-6-16 01:10 發表
亞女成績唔好,班主任之前叫我要有留班o既心理準備......
好驚呀有d人話佢只係嚇下我,小一唔會留班......
有無人可以解答下我呀好擔心呀 ...

kianmama

我朋友個囡~中/英/數全部唔合格都唔駛留~所以唔駛擔心

amy625

中,英,數唔合格都唔駛留 ,咁樣升上去對小朋友都唔好啦!基礎都打唔好

kianmama

同意!!但好多小學都照比學生升......

如果喺我小朋友, 我會寧願留班打好基礎, 但我朋友唔會要求學校留班, 面子問題

YolandaTam

我哋嗰代, 呢啲人有個名堂, 叫"直昇機".

amy625

原帖由 kianmama 於 11-6-16 16:58 發表
同意!!但好多小學都照比學生升......

如果喺我小朋友, 我會寧願留班打好基礎, 但我朋友唔會要求學校留班, 面子問題

不過咁,除非係讀私校,如果唔係讀政府的,你想留班都唔係容易架

karen55407

我呀女學校聽講話舊年有六個小一留班生和一個離校，啱啱考完試，好似全班都有幾個合資格留班。

daisy17772

原帖由 amy625 於 11-6-16 18:26 發表


不過咁,除非係讀私校,如果唔係讀政府的,你想留班都唔係容易架

Well, 'cause they just ask the child to exit the school when the results are not improved in the following years!

Ah-Faye

原帖由 Johorma 於 11-6-16 15:10 發表
我地學校試過留10幾個啊,你都米話唔驚.

唔係咁恐怖呀.....

whywhywhywhy

其實學校肯俾小朋友留班係一件好事，否則勉強升上去對小朋友都唔好。我見有個小朋友就係學校無留班，年年考尾几都照升班。後來咪升中入左band3中學！可能係年年慣左考得差，功課每升一年就深一年，咁佢更加唔識，讀書越來越無心機，中學老師話佢d數得四年班程度。如果一直有得升班但結果係咁邊個想！
樓主最明白你個女實力係你自己，到底佢係未出力定係真係未能追上，你要分得好清楚！未出力可以谷，能力未及就真係可能考慮讀多年等佢完全明白小一課程先上小二會好啲！
聽人講四年班開始課程會同頭三年好唔同，所以係升四年班前一定要學會學校頭三年的課程，否則會讀得更辛苦！不要灰心，每條路都行得通的！

jilin1960

如果小朋友盡了力成績卻不盡人意﹐留班未必是件壞事﹐要看小朋友發了幾成力。現在的學校教授知識就像吃快餐﹐管你吸收多少﹐所以基礎不好﹐以後真是難追。

如果你小朋友沒去補習班﹐建議你給小朋友報一下坊間的公文中 英 數﹐這類的補習可以幫她打下好的基礎﹐必要的時候﹐真是要操練一下﹐每天反復的練習﹐雖然煩悶﹐但有助于她一步一步掌握基知識。我不是公文老師呀﹐只是覺得對于基礎不好的小朋友﹐可以有規律的幫她把基礎打好而已/

中英數常

想請問各位，如果要留班，最好喺幾年班之前？

amy625

原帖由 jilin1960 於 11-6-17 08:35 發表
如果小朋友盡了力成績卻不盡人意﹐留班未必是件壞事﹐要看小朋友發了幾成力。現在的學校教授知識就像吃快餐﹐管你吸收多少﹐所以基礎不好﹐以後真是難追。

如果你小朋友沒去補習班﹐建議你給小朋友報一下坊間的公文中 英 數﹐這類 ...

agree.我見囡囡留班D同學仔,這幾年科科都有字八字頭,所以留班唔一定係壞事。