華英或上智好

ritawong

如題

u.sa.ha.na

of course 華英 la     

一施奶

請問上智是否甚麼問題?請告知

u.sa.ha.na 寫道:
of course 華英 la     

youma

何謂[好]?

若看2005年會考平均摘A率:
華英 : 0.68A
上智 : 0.93A

若看2005年高考平均摘A率:
華英 : 0.42A
上智 : 0.15A

入U率:
華英 : 84.4%
上智 : 95.6%

課外表現則各擅勝長

ritawong

Dear Youma,

謝回覆, 請問0.42A,是否即42%的人取"A", 請教道.
另華英盔否宗教學校.

weweroxy

華英基督教, 上智天主教.

youma

ritawong 寫道:
Dear Youma,

謝回覆, 請問0.42A,是否即42%的人取"A", 請教道.
另華英盔否宗教學校.

0.42摘A率即平均每人取0.42A (例如100名中五生共取42個A.); 並非 42%的人取"A".

Yes, 華英是基督教學校.

ritawong

Dear Youma,

謝回覆, 但為甚麽在2005年高考上智比華英差那麽多, 而入U率, 上智又比華英好呢? 希望你不會介意我太多問題.

bycy

請問華英是女校還是男女校？謝謝！

Dragonite

男女校

lovelypowerpuff

因為上年文科班好多人炒左hist or c.hist 所以入唔到u拉低左個入u%~

mini_mini

上智既入u率一向都唔錯, 雖然d 學生o係今界a level唔係拎得太多a, 但都有好多學生入到u~

youma

ritawong 寫道:
Dear Youma,

謝回覆, 但為甚麽在2005年高考上智比華英差那麽多, 而入U率, 上智又比華英好呢? 希望你不會介意我太多問題.

I am sorry I don't know the exact answer for your question. You are better to ask the parents of these 2 schools about the reasons. However I want to add some points.

1.        In 2004, Holy Trinity (上智) has eight elites (尖子) entering local universities from F6 through 拔尖計劃 (Wa Ying had 2 尖子 only in 2004). These elites could skip F7 and did not sit for HKAL Exam. That may be one of the reasons why Holy Trinity got weaker results in the HKAL in 2005.  

2.        The % entering universities (入U率) of a secondary school may not be proportional to its % of getting “A” in HKCEE. In fact, a student can still have good chance to university if he/she has some sort of BBBCCC results (preferably including Eng and Chin) without "A" in HKCEE.  Getting "A" is nice to have but not a must. In other words, on the average sense, Holy Trinity may have quite a good proportion of F7 students eligible to universities, despite its % of getting "A" was less than Wa Ying in 2005.

3.        Having said that, we should bear in mind that different schools have different interpretation of  "入U率". For example, some schools count  overseas universities but some do not. Besides, we may be also concerned which universities the grauduates mostly go to. Hence, this "入U率" is for reference only. Personally I am not  too serious about it.

ritawong

Dear youma,

thanks.