想問慈雲山天主教小學發生咩事

wongja

老婆最近同我講個女(小三)d 功課多到做唔晒
日日十幾樣, 又要抄書

咁我開頭覺得小學多功課係無問題
問題係補習社call 我老婆問點解我個女個班d 功課多到咁離譜
(我有時間先scan 佢本手冊上黎)
最可笑係隔離班 無咁多功課

臨近大考一星期, 連要考既野都未教晒
日日十幾樣功課, 補習(做功課) 都補到七點, 有時仲耐過我收工番屋企

食完飯當 9:00pm (我老婆八點~八點半番到屋企) 開始溫
日日都溫書溫到十一二點


最慘係我個女天資唔高, 咁既功課量跟本就跟唔到
我同我老婆講叫佢試下同老師傾, 打比中文老師只係識哦哦哦
留言想約校長/副校長傾又完全無feedback

大佬，佢咁 label 我個女, 我個女第日點揀中學
攪到我個女晚晚喊住溫書, 對考試抗拒到不得了
我大女考試測驗科科唔合格
用盡一切方法佢都讀唔到

想問大家有無咩意見可以幫到手?
有無家長有 same situation?
我地可以點做?
衷心唔想她朝有一日到自己個女跳樓

thanks in advance.

longlokma

原帖由 wongja 於 13-10-31 發表
老婆最近同我講個女(小三)d 功課多到做唔晒
日日十幾樣, 又要抄書

唔太明，“佢咁 label 我個女, 我個女第日點揀中學“   什麼意思？如何“label”呢？

wongja

longlokma 發表於 13-10-31 10:08
唔太明，“佢咁 label 我個女, 我個女第日點揀中學“   什麼意思？如何“label”呢？



  ...

好多野的例如 d 考試刻意圈d 小錯例如字體寫得唔好五分一個 , 圈三四個就扣佢十幾二十分

隔離兩班d 功課都無咁多
人地多左時間溫書就緊係考得好d 啦

anyway 已經同社工傾左
睇下有咩消息

longlokma

原帖由 wongja 於 13-10-31 發表
本帖最後由 wongja 於 13-10-31 10:15 編輯

即是阿女全班也面对同樣问题？可同其他同班家長傾傾，一同约見校長商討

wongja

longlokma 發表於 13-10-31 10:21
即是阿女全班也面对同樣问题？可同其他同班家長傾傾，一同约見校長商討



  ...

因為工作關係暫時未有時間可以去同d 家長傾傾

MonkeyGirl

改正你當唔當一樣, 搵資料又當唔當一樣 ? 你試過見你個女做功課既情況係點 ?, 我唔知你女間學校多功課成點, 我女個間表面都好似好多, 如, 改正, read story book , 油顏色( 佢地每樣,都當一樣) , maths 功課, 都係 做 5 題, so 其實用既時間唔多..but  如果佢 做 下又 望下人地, 傾下計, 去 toilet , 食下野, 就可以用 5 hrs ... (我女以前返補習班, 做功課..做好耐...) 3 個 hrs都做唔曬

改字方面, 老師捉得緊, 係好事..我女間學校都係, 但中文老師有解釋, 所以我覺得ok ...其實佢地細細個養成正確中文既寫法係好事, 一開始寫錯, 真係好難改, 查字典都搵唔到啦..同埋第時公開考試, 改卷都會好緊..到時先知原來唔可以咁寫, 咪仲不值...

希望你唔會覺得老師有 label 你個 女啦 ..

cmir

if you think the school doesn't fit your daughter, why don't you consider to transfer to another primary school?

978212

你呢間近幾年係好多功課，抄寫工作紙都多，可以話係學校想上位所以谷啲勁

wongja

cmir 發表於 13-10-31 11:59
if you think the school doesn't fit your daughter, why don't you consider to transfer to another pri ...

problem is how the hell i could find another school to accept my kld who has nearly all exams failed ?????
i didnt say it's a 100% problem of the school, that's why i am asking what is going on...

wongja

978212 發表於 13-10-31 12:10
你呢間近幾年係好多功課，抄寫工作紙都多，可以話係學校想上位所以谷啲勁 ...

我準備等d 小朋友考完試下個禮拜上去同佢地d 老師傾

wongja

MonkeyGirl 發表於 13-10-31 11:43
改正你當唔當一樣, 搵資料又當唔當一樣 ? 你試過見你個女做功課既情況係點 ?, 我唔知你女間學校多功課成點, ...

我解釋唔到點解要抄書囉如果無左抄書, 應該會好番d

cmir

回復 wongja 的帖子

i am just thinking it may be the pressure who make your daughter can't perform to her best. She maybe scared at the exam

wister

樓主，聽你講嘅嘢我諗間學校應該唔係咁適合囡囡，慈天一向都係較谷嘅學校，所以功課多係不足為奇。長此下去，只怕你囡囡連學習嘅興趣都越來越少…

enidchiu

Exploit children's play time, risk losing children's learning motivation for the sake of school's reputation?  A P3 child should not live a life like this. Failing in all subjects is a big warning. Change environment and believe she can do much better.

marble2004

回復 wongja 的帖子

In fact, for me, it's not a problem at all if the teachers are strict (provided that they are reasonable).  I am also strict to my daughter.  If she doesn't write the stroke properly, I will consider it's a mistake (my experience...was not bad in studies BUT i did not (still don't) have good writing that this hindered and lowered the marks in my exam...)

Besides, i think  抄寫 is not bad because without practising, you can really forget how to write the words (both Chinese and English correctly).  If it's reasonable, then just consider this homework as practice.  Remember practice makes perfect.

enidchiu

Copy can be meaningful if the worksheets are well-designed.
Word by word copy from textbook is a lazy way to learn and the laziest way to teach.