偷步收生

KOKOMAN

我仔有同學在見完喇沙第一次後，學校打電話比家長話收，仲教佢填表將喇沙填第一志願，結果佢放棄註冊名直資。

櫺囹桼

司空見慣

u.sa.ha.na

櫺囹桼 寫道:
司空見慣

我都係咁話               

yuma

[size=small]為甚麼這些有關名校的資料多是從第三者得悉或聽回來？有沒有「第一身」的親身例子？

Piano2016

據了解喇沙跟本唔會用呢個方法來話比你個朋友聽話收佢，因不是每個校網都有得揀喇沙！如果沒有咁又點呢？仲有喇沙所要收的都一定經過second in，咁top嘅學校點會咁兒戲和無誠意只用電話通知你個friend呢？就算喇沙有信息比d家長話收佢地，佢都是想收一d最top嘅學生，相信很多學校都會咁做，所以也不用太驚小怪，亦不見得是甚麽偷步收生，因最終決定讀邊間都是家長自己選擇，你個friend講得比你聽，佢一定信得過你及希望你會為佢開心！  :  :

Fungmama

My son's schoolmate had the similar situation last year.  He was the top 3 since he was primary one.  He won lots of chess competition and with music background.  He decided to choose La Salle and had the chance to interview.  During the interview, the interviewer ask him whether he considered DBS.  If so, he don't need to go.  He told my son that he probably will get it.  At the end, yes, he is the F.1 student this year.

By the way, La Salle will hints the student with great potential and try to get the good student from DBS.

哈里波特

Last year, Marymount & Maryknoll also called the top students and ask them not to accept DSS / private school.

Ben2003

No big deal.  

KOKOMAN 寫道:
我仔有同學在見完喇沙第一次後，學校打電話比家長話收，仲教佢填表將喇沙填第一志願，結果佢放棄註冊名直資。

KOKOMAN

這樣對其他守法的津校便不公平，亦對一些可能有機會的學生不公平，因為若他們註冊了直資，津校又會多一些自行學位，可能真的要向教署或傳媒反映。

cooyee

如果倒轉來想, 學生都是一樣那班學生, 如果他(她)們不選擇直資, 直資又會多一些學位給後補生, 條數都係一樣.

遊戲規則就係這樣, 自行選校時, 父母或兄弟姊妹是校友就有分加, 等於父母或兄弟姊妹讀好學校, 仔女或其他兄弟姊妹就有機會讀好學校, 公平嗎? (因中學唔同小學, 唔使方便接送).

KOKOMAN

但唔係人人都交得起學費讀直資，既然直資可提早公佈，津貼學校也應一視同仁，其實兩者也有政府津貼。

cooyee 寫道:
如果倒轉來想, 學生都是一樣那班學生, 如果他(她)們不選擇直資, 直資又會多一些學位給後補生, 條數都係一樣.

遊戲規則就係這樣, 自行選校時, 父母或兄弟姊妹是校友就有分加, 等於父母或兄弟姊妹讀好學校, 仔女或其他兄弟姊妹就有機會讀好學校, 公平嗎? (因中學唔同小學, 唔使方便接送).

agoodfox

Fungmama 寫道:
My son's schoolmate had the similar situation last year.  He was the top 3 since he was primary one.  He won lots of chess competition and with music background.  He decided to choose La Salle and had the chance to interview.  During the interview, the interviewer ask him whether he considered DBS.  If so, he don't need to go.  He told my son that he probably will get it.  At the end, yes, he is the F.1 student this year.

By the way, La Salle will hints the student with great potential and try to get the good student from DBS.

Anyone knows what kind of "chess" counts in La Salle? Actually chess means 國際象棋, but local people always mix up the name with 中國象棋&圍棋.

Patrickyyc

KOKOMAN 寫道:
我仔有同學在見完喇沙第一次後，學校打電話比家長話收，仲教佢填表將喇沙填第一志願，結果佢放棄註冊名直資。

KOKOMAN, 你仔個同學有乜特長咁西利，可否講

familychan

唔守遊戲規則,都唔係第一次啦!

Patrickyyc

各有各做姐！

familychan

Piano2016 寫道:
據了解喇沙跟本唔會用呢個方法來話比你個朋友聽話收佢，因不是每個校網都有得揀喇沙！如果沒有咁又點呢？仲有喇沙所要收的都一定經過second in，咁top嘅學校點會咁兒戲和無誠意只用電話通知你個friend呢？就算喇沙有信息比d家長話收佢地，佢都是想收一d最top嘅學生，相信很多學校都會咁做，所以也不用太驚小怪，亦不見得是甚麽偷步收生，因最終決定讀邊間都是家長自己選擇，你個friend講得比你聽，佢一定信得過你及希望你會為佢開心！  :  :

或者果個細佬就係好top嘅學生,學校驚走寶呢!

ccspy

其實好多學校都會有意或無意俾左暗示，好似報完名之後，學校話只會見頭120位，然後收60位，咪即係已經通水話俾你聽有一半機會lo!

2bzmummy

報得自行既都係自己心儀架喇, 如果人地偷步話收左您, 真係開心都黎唔切, 唔駛擔心到七月呀 .....        

mimi1234

如果間中學肯通水比我知就好，個個家長都想啦！

AdaHo123

都唔明點解津校收生, 自行同搞珠唔係分開時段出結果.
好似小一入學咁, 自行同直資都收咗, 家長有得諗讀直資定津校, 同埋, 唔使個心攣攣亂到七月.
所以, 我贊成通水啊.