牧愛/陳守仁/真光/培道

lamba

我住紅磡 (net 35 ), 這幾間私小/直小, 你地會點揀?

1.牧愛 A.M. - $20,460 p.a. , 半日(下午有功課輔導班), 英語教學, 校舍細及舊,最近屋企, 小班教學, 升中成績過得去,
冇聯繫中學

2.陳守仁 - 全日, 英語, $12,000 p.a., 校舍新及大 (有泳池), 有外藉學生, 升中唔錯, 有聯繫中學 ( 顏寶玲, 不過唔知質素點 ), 課外活動多,小四開始精英班, 無宗教

續.......

lamba

3. 真光 - 中文,全日, $18,000 p.a., 有聯繫中學 ( 真光中學, 中文 ), 非常傳統學校, 升中成續一般


4. 培道 - 中文,全日, $16,000 p.a., 有聯繫中學 ( 培道中學 ), P.1-P.2 活動教學, 升中成績唔清楚, 校舍比較細


以上4間小學, 除陳守仁外, 升中時全位於同一校網!


謝謝!

lamba

還有就係己收左牧愛既acceptance letter, 如果牧愛比其他3間 ( 或任何一間 ) 好, 我地就唔使再去見這幾間 ( 或任何一間 ) 小學 !

不過牧愛英文係教高一級既, 而數學就教高半級!

但小女係年尾出世, 我又擔心佢係牧愛跟唔上咁深既課程 !

請大家比D意見參考, 多謝!

Fatty

洗嘜諗咁多呀! 等全部有結果先決定啦!

cooyee

I think it is easy to be accepted by 牧愛. A friend of mine told me today that she even did not know how to write the test paper during interview and she is also accepted by the school.

So better wait for other school results.

easy

Hi cooyee ,

Agree with you.

我甚少聽到not accept by 牧愛

好好爸爸

係啦...
都有越來越多人叫我唔好將牧愛當做最後決定住....
原因唔想講啦....

諗番去陳守仁交表時,見到佢地貼出去年升中結果,
當時迷信佢係自己一等一既首選學校,
所以印象中即使派位結果唔算太突出,都冇再認真睇落去...
請問各位有冇詳細記錄佢地升中派成點呢?

River2004

陳守仁收左就無得搏統一派位，如果對佢十足信心就無問題喇，但係本身校網好又對間學校有保留，咁就無謂犧牲個派位機會囉！

牧愛/真光/培道到七月派位後都仲有機，衣家唔洗咁頭痛！

木土土

因近年多了很多直資選擇, 好像有幾間老牌私校如牧愛都收生不足, 有殺校危機.

牧愛校舍實在太舊, 當年in 完已經唔考慮, 不過今年識人牧愛升中派到喇沙, 小學校舍唔好, 中學補番有餘

D.Fish

小兒9月23日將會去陳守仁interview, 雖然結果都是未知之數,但朋友們認為不值得為陳守仁而放棄攪珠,所以都不知道去不去好,不過,我想都是去了再打算,等佢收我個仔至算啦！

lamba

>>>> Fatty : 洗嘜諗咁多呀! 等全部有結果先決定啦!


Fatty, I want to know whether Good Shepherd is better than or at least comparable to the other 3 primary schools ? If yes,  then I would not have to bother to take the interviews of these 3 schools !

lamba

>>>> D.Fish : 但朋友們認為不值得為陳守仁而放棄攪珠,所以都不知道去不去好,不過,我想都是去了再打算,等佢收我個仔至算啦！


D.Fish, I also share the same thought with you !

But what will TSL think about you if you reject their
acceptance of your kids ?   

If we can decide now not to waste the chance of central allocation , then why do we bother to join the interview of TSL ?

lamba

>>>> 木土土 : 因近年多了很多直資選擇, 好像有幾間老牌私校如牧愛都收生不足, 有殺校危機.


木土土, are you talking about 牧愛 PM sachool ( which is a subsidized school ) ?

We are now discussing about 牧愛 AM school which is a private school !

Private school should NOT have the problem of 殺校 because it got no subsidy from the Government !

lamba

各位家長,

或者我改過個問題 :

如果現在牧學/陳守仁/真光/培道 都收左你地 D 兒女,
你地會點揀 ?

D.Fish

lamba,
其實我都有這樣的想法,why bother,但係

lamba

D.Fish, understand your planning !

May I ask you:  if these 4 schools accept your kid, which one will you choose and why ?

木土土

I'm talking about 牧愛 am private school. What I mean  殺校 is 自殺 (因收生不足, 私校會有financial problem).

印象中有 at least 2 private school (好似係伍華及聖士提反堂) decided not to accept new student and would close the school after current student graduated. A school with less and less students and teachers would affect the student's normal school life. Many students would try to transfer to other school before graduated.

lamba 寫道:
>>>> 木土土 : 因近年多了很多直資選擇, 好像有幾間老牌私校如牧愛都收生不足, 有殺校危機.


木土土, are you talking about 牧愛 PM sachool ( which is a subsidized school ) ?

We are now discussing about 牧愛 AM school which is a private school !

Private school should NOT have the problem of 殺校 because it got no subsidy from the Government !

River2004

如果現在牧愛/陳守仁/真光/培道 都收左你地 D 兒女,
你地會點揀 ?

我唔會揀陳守仁，因為唔想放棄派位機會。
如果派位唔理想，我會揀真光，因為真光中文教得好，又有聯系中學(一英一中)。

lamba

thank you river2004,

how would you rank the above 4 schools ?

sharon-ss

如果你係指九龍塘真光, 只係聯系火車站那間真光中學, 校內職員也不能肯定說直升上真光中學,

而且, 並不與窩打老道的真光英文書院有關係, 亦不能直入