銅鑼灣ST.PAUL CONVENT &跑馬地ST.PAUL CATHOLIC

mtkdc

銅鑼灣ST.PAUL CONVENT和跑馬地ST.PAUL CATHOLIC，你們會選哪間？請提供理由，謝謝幫忙！

mickfan

st paul convent la中學ok學朮ok,不過st paul catholic 學費平D所以通常長大后適應力強D

chunheimama

原帖由 mtkdc 於 11-6-5 09:42 發表
銅鑼灣ST.PAUL CONVENT和跑馬地ST.PAUL CATHOLIC，你們會選哪間？請提供理由，謝謝幫忙！

St Paul Convent

dahchonghong

會選跑馬地。

redkoni

原帖由 mtkdc 於 11-6-5 09:42 發表
銅鑼灣ST.PAUL CONVENT和跑馬地ST.PAUL CATHOLIC，你們會選哪間？請提供理由，謝謝幫忙！

聖保祿系龍頭是St. Paul's Convent,你能夠負擔12年學費,想課程更加有彈性和多元化,將來到外國留學等等,揀Convent絕對正確,如果不想有學費負擔,有細妹,仍能接受傳统教學,St. Paul's Primary Catholic這條升學線也是相當不錯,小六有過佰人(包括部份Band2)升上直屬中學,比較Marymount,小六只有60-70%(Band1 only)能夠升上直屬中學,Catholic對師妹相對較有人情味,喜歡精英制又會揀Marymount,各適其所.

chunheimama

原帖由 redkoni 於 11-6-5 13:04 發表

聖保祿系龍頭是St. Paul's Convent,你能夠負擔12年學費,想課程更加有彈性和多元化,將來到外國留學等等,揀Convent絕對正確,如果不想有學費負擔,有細妹,仍能接受傳统教學,St. Paul's Primary Catholic這條升學線也是 ...

絁對同意呀!

三間都識人讀緊, 情況同你講的差不多.

mtkdc

十分多謝大家的寶貴意見.
其實我有個大仔現在讀緊私校，有點兒覺得讀私校的學生太過重物質及喜歡比較，而當年個仔在統一派位時竟派到第7志願的學校。個女在自行收生階段又只得5分，所以沒有同她報學校。本來想個女直升原校小學(st paul's con.)，所以都忘記了在一月時去遞表參加大抽獎，但家人堅持一定要幫個女玩大抽獎，在2月時，我去了教育局提出申請參加大抽獎，幸好有關部門批准我申請。因我的校網並沒有太多好學校，所以，當時在甲部只填一間，乙部又填一間，而難得個女真的可以跨區抽中間津校，所以個心好似有些想讀津校！

redkoni

原帖由 mtkdc 於 11-6-5 16:05 發表
十分多謝大家的寶貴意見.
其實我有個大仔現在讀緊私校，有點兒覺得讀私校的學生太過重物質及喜歡比較，而當年個仔在統一派位時竟派到第7志願的學校。個女在自行收生階段又只得5分，所以沒有同她報學校。本來想個女直升原 ...

"咁有緣份"也是考慮因素.

4001cc

我覺得你已決定好了. 不過又唔甘心放棄.

redkoni

原帖由 mtkdc 於 11-6-5 16:05 發表
十分多謝大家的寶貴意見.
其實我有個大仔現在讀緊私校，有點兒覺得讀私校的學生太過重物質及喜歡比較，而當年個仔在統一派位時竟派到第7志願的學校。個女在自行收生階段又只得5分，所以沒有同她報學校。本來想個女直升原 ...

我不敢說"讀私校的學生"太過重物質及喜歡比較,我只會說香港有些家長和學生太過重物質及喜歡比較,我覺得Catholic的校風是灣仔校網最好之一,選校還要配合子女的特質,這兩間的特色分別很大,那間較適合令千金你自己會清楚.

mark2006

原帖由 redkoni 於 11-6-5 21:08 發表

我不敢說"讀私校的學生"太過重物質及喜歡比較,我只會說香港有些家長和學生太過重物質及喜歡比較,我覺得Catholic的校風是灣仔校網最好之一,選校還要配合子女的特質,這兩間的特色分別很大,那間較適合令千金你自己會清 ...

I observed that many students from those elite schools are sitting Benz to home and using iphone. They have already skipped many steps and  enjoy an above average modern life.

redkoni

原帖由 mark2006 於 11-6-5 22:50 發表

I observed that many students from those elite schools are sitting Benz to home and using iphone. They have already skipped many steps and  enjoy an above average modern life.

Yes, there is no doubt that children who come from rich and well educated families have already skipped many steps and enjoy an average modern life. But I do know some of them have been sent to non-elite schools as well.  The author of "The high price of materialism" says a need is something a person either desires or wants that is essential to their survival, growth and functioning. If these psychological needs are unsatisfied, materialism is often the result. What makes some people materialistic? 1.Young adults from divorced families frequently become materialistic. 2.If the child was raised in a poor family, they are likely to become materialistic. 3.Children attending schools with poor discipline and frequent fights, vandalizing by other students, and general defiance of authority were more likely to become materialistic than children attending well organized and highly disciplined schools. 4.People from poor nations are more materialistic than those from rich nations. 5.People who watch a lot of TV are more materialistic than those who don't....

So I believe that materialistic students are likely coming from all kinds of schools, not only from elite or private schools.

[ 本帖最後由 redkoni 於 11-6-6 02:26 編輯 ]

SCKnight

Wow!!
I have family members studied in St Paul Convent, the school has good facilties and high requirement on Kids moral development.  School fee is a consideration, but if family can afford, St Paul Convent is a good choice.

pluto_yuen

If u consider at the acedemic level, Must be ST paul convent. But if consider about 校風, students from St paul catholic is more humble in general.
If i were u, i would pick ST paul convent

DeeDeeY

In both SPC and St. Paul Catholic, students need to work hard.  If your girl is familiar with the environment of ST. Paul (Causeway Bay) and have made many friends in SPK, my opinion is that she will be happier in SPC,why bother to switch her to another school if both schools need same effort?

St. Paul Catholic is a half day Chinese primary school, but SPC is a full day English school, so just ask yourself what do you want.

花花公仔

唔知兩間學校的工課量是點?