請問..小兒K2,報考P1,剛考YLE Starter得14盾,應否放在portfolio?

kbsiu2000

如題, 請指教, 謝謝

thomasha

唔通你覺得15盾至值得放？

原帖由 kbsiu2000 於 11-6-25 00:23 發表
如題, 請指教, 謝謝

kbsiu2000

我之前聽朋友話有人真係咁, 都唔知係咪真, 所以想係度請教吓而已

thomasha

如果你覺得14盾唔夠好就唔放，夠好就放。真係樣樣要第一或滿分至放落portfolio，恐怕大部份o既portfolio都唔會超過兩頁紙。

原帖由 kbsiu2000 於 11-6-25 02:54 發表
我之前聽朋友話有人真係咁, 都唔知係咪真, 所以想係度請教吓而已

kbsiu2000

明白晒, thank you !!

kenmay

其實要看手上有幾多cert, 然後順次序排好(由最勁開始排), 不要給太多, 例如一大疊. 選幾張有代表性, 例如: 學術性, Art, 運動...

smsss

as far as I know, too many students got 15 shields for starters so personally I think that even put the cert with 15 shields is no use.  There are quite a no. of children can get 14 or 15 shields for movers in K3.

kbsiu2000

原帖由 smsss 於 11-6-25 17:25 發表
as far as I know, too many students got 15 shields for starters so personally I think that even put the cert with 15 shields is no use.  There are quite a no. of children can get 14 or 15 shields for  ...

不過小兒都冇乜CERT,所以14盾都會放

但係如果週街都14/15盾, 又真幾無奈, 考左都冇用.....唉

thomasha

點可以咁講，14盾o既成績已經好好，小朋友幾歲人仔咋。我個仔13盾我地已經好開心，仲大讚佢表現神勇，因為我地無o係外面上堂，全部自修+家長指引。

原帖由 kbsiu2000 於 11-6-26 00:40 發表


不過小兒都冇乜CERT,所以14盾都會放

但係如果週街都14/15盾, 又真幾無奈, 考左都冇用.....唉

kbsiu2000

原帖由 thomasha 於 11-6-26 00:45 發表
點可以咁講，14盾o既成績已經好好，小朋友幾歲人仔咋。我個仔13盾我地已經好開心，仲大讚佢表現神勇，因為我地無o係外面上堂，全部自修+家長指引。

...

同意...其實要小朋友考試,操PAST PAPER, 在自己年代根本是天方夜譚...所以我都有讚佢...坦白講其實我好滿意, 只不過是概嘆當今遊戲規則太複雜...

Ktfk

Agreed. Brilliant achievement already.   

I could never able to get such a score when I was a kid studying P2/P3. Of course, parents in that era were not as academic minded as today.     

If you check websites of some primary schools besides those top-notch, a P2 or P3 student attaning this score is regarded as school's honour and the name and result will be announed in the website.

I would sugest keeping this in your kid's portfolio.  ^^

HAW

I thinnk it all depends on what kinds of Primary you are applying.  For those which are really popular and famous one then I would suggest you dont put it in your portfolio.  Cause it might even have a negative effect.

Ving

願聞其詳

14/15=93.33

原帖由 HAW 於 11-6-26 14:58 發表
I thinnk it all depends on what kinds of Primary you are applying.  For those which are really popular and famous one then I would suggest you dont put it in your portfolio.  Cause it might even have  ...

milkonline2

下？14個盾no use? 我個囝都靠自己能力得到14個盾牌，我當時真的喜出望外，引以為傲! 不竟那是for小學生的考試! 我有個朋友的囝囝得到 13個盾 in mover, 她說還要報 Flyer, K3人仔報 Flyer??? 難道珍貴的童年就此渡過？香港的小朋友真的十分悲哀，我也變成了怪獸父母的一份子。。。

[ 本帖最後由 milkonline2 於 11-6-27 14:45 編輯 ]

ysnmama

自學沒出外上堂. 考獲starters 14盾很好吧. 有些上了堂也沒此成績的. 如果常常跟別人比較很難放下. 因為真的有不少考獲starters or movers14, 15盾的是有外出上堂的.

milkonline2

我囝囝自少對英文有濃厚嘅興趣, 喜歡睇英文故事書、英文臺電視, 喜歡主動與外國人溝通 (我一家人唔係用英文溝通架). 我無好似我朋友報嗰類型 course or 做 exercise 用黎應付考試, 我只係抱住俾個囝玩下、一試無防嘅心態, 出黎嘅結果真係嚇我一跳! Listening and oral 對於咁鐘意英文嘅佢可能無難度, 嗰一個盾扣咗喺 written 度! 我已十分滿足了!

原帖由 ysnmama 於 11-6-27 02:50 PM 發表
自學沒出外上堂. 考獲starters 14盾很好吧. 有些上了堂也沒此成績的. 如果常常跟別人比較很難放下. 因為真的有不少考獲starters or movers14, 15盾的是有外出上堂的. ...

[ 本帖最後由 milkonline2 於 11-6-27 15:15 編輯 ]