Urgent - Shatin Govt Primary vs Pui Kiu

longandhong

My son got the offers from both Shatin Govt Primary School and Pui Kiu College.  Has to make the decision asap so as to release the seat to those in need.

Please comment and advise.  Thank you.

小曳人

你識嘅人當中，有無讀緊呢兩間學校，你覺得自己鍾意邊間多d？
我身邊嘅，有唔少都話培橋好，亦有唔鍾意嘅 (我係其中一個，因為見過佢地d學生，連尊敬師長都唔識，仲蝦d KG學生，我見到都行遠幾步！)
坦白講，我都係target直資私小，如無心儀直資收，我要去抽獎，我都會揀沙小！

[ 本帖最後由 小曳人 於 11-7-14 15:32 編輯 ]

ok_ko

除了一津，一私，兩間理念好吾同。咁你有什麼要求先?

water-lily

我揀沙小, 升中派番去沙官中機會大D

agugi

我有家人讀Pui Kiu.

小朋友普英水平都好高。好愉快學習。幾smart.

但客觀地講, 見佢及幾個常見既同學, 都係比較"活潑"型。
吾好聽就"曳D"style....冇時停粗粗魯咁。

我麻麻地like.

longandhong

My elder son is studying at Pui Kiu.  But my younger son failed in Pui Kiu's second interview.  Luckily he was allocated to Shatin Govt Primary School.  I have very limited knowledge about this school.  Most of my friends said that this is a good school in Tai Wai.  But no one can tell me how good it is -  may be a certain %of students (esp from the 2 elite classes) can be sent to Shatin Govt Sec School.  I already registered it for my son and bought the books.  But I found that the contents of the P.1 books (such as Chin, Eng and Maths) are very easy (similar to that of K3 standard) --  Not sure if this is because of the honey moon period for P.1 students?  I also worry the pressure:  the competition among the students to enter into the “elite class” in P.4 – P.6 should be very keen.

Last Sunday morning, we received the call from Pui Kiu that my younger son was offered a place.  I realize that my sons shall be happy if they can study in the same school.   This is also more convenient to the parents.  Pui Kiu can provide a better language environment and more extra-curricular activities.  But when I can compare the public exam results of Shatin Govt Sec School with that of Pui Kiu, I have some hesitation to give up Shatin Primary.  My younger sister warned me that it would be very stupid to give up Shatin Govt Primary School.

josejandy

培僑幾錢學費？

longandhong

$2100 x 10 months

ok_ko

Hi, it depends on how you concern the public exams result. It is a hard decision.

My friend's kid is also studying in Pui Kiu. Kid is very happy.

原帖由 longandhong 於 11-7-14 15:25 發表
My elder son is studying at Pui Kiu.  But my younger son failed in Pui Kiu's second interview.  Luckily he was allocated to Shatin Govt Primary School.  I have very limited knowledge about this school ...

CP97

兩間都是很好學校,升中都很有保障,但我會揀沙官小學.