GHS, SFA, APS 邊間好?

Imanyu

今日同幾個同事講開呢3間九龍區名私小，均各有所長，很難抉擇，討論結果如下，但我哋都係一知半解，有無家長可幫忙分析，女仔你會揀邊間？（暫不要考慮收唔收這問題）
GHS ∼ (優點）- 有中學，如成績OK升中不用煩。
           　　　 　- 英文學校
            　 (缺點)- 學費較貴。
             　　　　- 返半日（有些年級還要返下晝）
SFA ∼ (優點） - 學費平
                       　 - 程度高
　　　（缺點）- 校網英中男仔選擇多，女仔選擇較少（係　　　　　　　　咪得上智？）
APS ~ (優點）- 中學校網好
　　　　　　　- 校舍新，地點較好
            (缺點）- 中文小學     

martie

I choose APS.

Longman

除了上智，我都好想知女仔在SFA會有甚麼中學可選？

ebeltang

Longman 寫道:
除了上智，我都好想知女仔在SFA會有甚麼中學可選？

好似仲有德雅,銘賢,黃棣珊都係區內數一數二band one中學,
除左一d直資或私中外

G-Ma

I choose SFA, 學生英文好好, 學費平.  不過好難入.

mission

G-Ma 寫道:
I choose SFA, 學生英文好好, 學費平.  不過好難入.

Agree. SFA is much difficult to enter than GHS and APS. I heard quite a number of kids able to enter the latter two primary schools even though they are placed in waiting lists.

  

phoebe-lily

SFA is undoubtly a good school with cheaper school fee. But secondary school net of APS seem much better for girl.

Therefore, pls comment if it's good to choose SFA for girl.

G-Ma

我自己就覺得六年後d教改都唔知變成點, 今日九龍塘好似好多好嘅中學, 但可能過幾年就變晒直資中學(好似31網DGS咁), 咁宜家嘅優勢無晒.  所以會重點睇小學好唔好.

phoebe-lily 寫道:
SFA is undoubtly a good school with cheaper school fee. But secondary school net of APS seem much better for girl.

Therefore, pls comment if it's good to choose SFA for girl.

sosochui

mission 寫道:

Agree. SFA is much difficult to enter than GHS and APS. I heard quite a number of kids able to enter the latter two primary schools even though they are placed in waiting lists.

  

Same for SFA. Many children were called up in June for an interview. However, it's hard to be accepted in the 1st round. But, I don't think it so hard after June. Of course, it's not easy too.
Last year, my girl was accepted by both SFA & GHS. But I didn't register SFA. It's not because of which one is better. It's because GHS is a good school and it got a secondary school. However, if your child studying in SFA and want to enter a good secondary school. You need to be really top over the years. I don't think it's easy to do this. It's really hard and nervous to keep up a top rank. You know, I'm a lazy mum

cathycr611

Anyone can comment on which one to choose for girl, SFA or APS, if accepted by both school?Thanks

Lafuma

It depends on which secondary school you choose:
APS - Heep Hunn;
SFA - Sheung Chi.  

ChristyBBmama

Heep Yunn intake 19 girls from APS this summer, it's a very large number already. if you want to enter HYSS, your daughter need to be very top. Most of the parents in APS (girls) want their daughter go to HYSS.

Msma

唔好就咁話邊間難入d窩

sfa 一半收男生 一半女，收生當然比 gh小好多啦 !

cathycr611

Can you tell me which school is Sheung Chi?

Lafuma 寫道:
It depends on which secondary school you choose:
APS - Heep Hunn;
SFA - Sheung Chi.  

Snow

寶血會上智英文書院
HOLY TRINITY COLLEGE

cathycr611 寫道:
Can you tell me which school is Sheung Chi?

[quote]
Lafuma 寫道:
It depends on which secondary school you choose:
APS - Heep Hunn;
SFA - Sheung Chi.  

[/quote]

sadsam

看sfa個web... 佢地今年畢業女生只有50人, 不知是否收很少女生??

Msma 寫道:
唔好就咁話邊間難入d窩

sfa 一半收男生 一半女，收生當然比 gh小好多啦 !

Rosaline

我覺得宣小女生不一定要最top才可入協恩, 宣小女生比男生人數小, 約佔1/3多些. 以去年計, 百一小六生女生約佔40人, 但能派到考到名女校如協恩, 女拔, 瑪利諾, 聖保羅男女, 聖保祿也有25人, 入名校比率過半數, 其它派位相信也不差.

上智成績應不會比協恩差, 不過個人來說, 我比較喜歡協恩學校的環境位置校舍. 其體育在學界也出名, 發展較全面.

如不喜歡小朋友學樂器就不要選宣小, 要時間和金錢. 宣小在音樂培養方面十分出色, 學生大部分在小學已能打好音樂樂器良好基礎. 英文差少少在中學可容易追回, 但音樂樂器如在中學才學, 年紀較大難專注.

honeybbb

係咪即係男生讀SFA 會好D呢? 咁SFA 既中學校網有邊幾間好中學呢?  

Mandy2002

如果是女，當然選德望，唔使再煩升中。因其餘兩間在學業和課外活動方面家長都要跟貼。

sosochui

但係, 會唔會年年都只得40個女學生畢業呢, 前幾年好似冇咁少喎, 如果年年都只得40個女仔, 個ratio就梗係高啦, 但係如果有一半係女生(今年小一160+), 咁個ratio就---------, 好似今年19個入協恩都算多喎 如果話唔駛好top都入到協恩, 就有d奇怪囉, 如果年年入到宣道就有1/2機會入到協恩嘅話(依去年計), 咁應該好多女仔至係架 SFA個校網利男仔, 就話男多過女姐, 宣道個網咁利女仔, 點解又咁少女仔呢? 則聞去年高小重有d男仔去咗新小拔tim, 都咁少女仔---------?
不過, 我要講明, 我都認為宣道係非常好嘅學校, 宣道嘅學生亦非常出色, 不過d數字我就有d唔明囉

Rosaline 寫道:
我覺得宣小女生不一定要最top才可入協恩, 宣小女生比男生人數小, 約佔1/3多些. 以去年計, 百一小六生女生約佔40人, 但能派到考到名女校如協恩, 女拔, 瑪利諾, 聖保羅男女, 聖保祿也有25人, 入名校比率過半數, 其它派位相信也不差.

上智成績應不會比協恩差, 不過個人來說, 我比較喜歡協恩學校的環境位置校舍. 其體育在學界也出名, 發展較全面.

如不喜歡小朋友學樂器就不要選宣小, 要時間和金錢. 宣小在音樂培養方面十分出色, 學生大部分在小學已能打好音樂樂器良好基礎. 英文差少少在中學可容易追回, 但音樂樂器如在中學才學, 年紀較大難專注.