鋼琴試

kantsoi

小兒剛收到二級試的成績 (MERIT)，跟老師相議要練一排歌書才考慮考四級，大約2006-2007年。但朋友的小孩與我一樣剛考完二級，但他的老師隨即給他學四級考試歌。

請問我的老師是不是DUMB 波鐘？我的心當然是想盡快考，目標是八級。請比意見。

kcarol

個人立場, 搏命彈考試歌唔係好事, 一年死練果3首考試歌, 小朋友就會除考試歌外, 乜都唔識, 最緊要係睇譜會好慢好慢

SandyMummy

Yes, very agree to kcarol.
The teacher may want to spend more time on your son's basic technique and other training (aural, sight reading) than just practising the 3 exam songs just for the abrsm exam..
As my daughter's teacher always said, a child who is really up to the standard of grading in the ABRSM exam, he/she should get high marks in all 4 parts of the exam, i.e. the 3 pieces, scales, sight-reading and aural.   Not only know how to play the 3 songs well.

kcarol 寫道:
個人立場, 搏命彈考試歌唔係好事, 一年死練果3首考試歌, 小朋友就會除考試歌外, 乜都唔識, 最緊要係睇譜會好慢好慢

kcarol

SandyMummy
個個家長好似你甘諗就好啦~~~ 不過依家好多父母都為小朋友升中, 都要小朋友細細個就做李雲

kantsoi

Thank you SandyMummy and KCarl.

Richard_Hui

Very much agree what kcarol said.

kcarol 寫道:
個人立場, 搏命彈考試歌唔係好事, 一年死練果3首考試歌, 小朋友就會除考試歌外, 乜都唔識, 最緊要係睇譜會好慢好慢

SandyMummy

kcarol,

I have even know a friend of mine, whose daughter is now grade 7 at the age of 9.5.   She is very well-known in her school because of her qualifications got in the ABRSM exam.. But in fact , her marks in grade 7 was just 103.....failed in the sight reading and aural parts.
She is always invited to play in the school music performance, but every time she can only play the exam songs, most funniest thing is if you give her any other pieces, she cannot play it at all !  
Do you think she is qualified to be a Grade 7 pianist ???

wewangwang

Kantosi,

我反而覺得你個老師正路的, 你朋友個老師就太急功近利. 其實邊個唔想快D考晒, 但都要有個底子, 級級都剩彈考試歌就真係過份D.

SandyMummy

Yes, before  I was pushing the teacher to jump to a highter grade in a short time. But now after understanding what is the best to my girl and to build up her interest and basic foundations in music. I will not give her any pressure or let her progress gradually.  
In my case, my daughter likes violin a lot and she can now practise on her own, doing her music theory homework.  The teacher said she is progressing quite fast and up to his satisfaction.  This is what I am grateful to see!

wewangwang 寫道:
Kantosi,

我反而覺得你個老師正路的, 你朋友個老師就太急功近利. 其實邊個唔想快D考晒, 但都要有個底子, 級級都剩彈考試歌就真係過份D.

kcarol

簡單黎講, SandyMummy你果個fd個女唔係學緊音樂, 係學緊彈音, 我成日同我d學生家長講, 學音同學音樂係唔同既, 前者膚淺好多, 彈晒d音出黎, 就當自己天下無敵。

功底打得唔好, 第日學上去, 要進步d d都要拎出好多好多努力, 係事倍功半; 功底打得好, 雖然起步會俾人慢, 但長遠落去, 會追番之前落後既, 甚至可以反超前, 最緊要係個底打得好, 會愈學愈快上手, 到最後其實係比人用少左時間!!

SandyMummy

It's absolutely true. My daughter is exactly the case you mentioned. Compared to other children, she learns slowly, but thoroughly.  And now she knows how to enjoy music.  The teacher will give her different pieces of music to play and she enjoys the ones she likes and will play them well.   
  

kcarol 寫道:
簡單黎講, SandyMummy你果個fd個女唔係學緊音樂, 係學緊彈音, 我成日同我d學生家長講, 學音同學音樂係唔同既, 前者膚淺好多, 彈晒d音出黎, 就當自己天下無敵。

功底打得唔好, 第日學上去, 要進步d d都要拎出好多好多努力, 係事倍功半; 功底打得好, 雖然起步會俾人慢, 但長遠落去, 會追番之前落後既, 甚至可以反超前, 最緊要係個底打得好, 會愈學愈快上手, 到最後其實係比人用少左時間!!

RMA

kantsoi,

不一定是好事，只是家長迫老師安排考四級，於是老師覺得非及早開始教考試樂曲不可。

你的老師是一個負責的人老師，放心。

kcarol

SandyMummy
放心啦, 就算你囡囡依家慢, 唔怕架, 培養到佢真係鍾意音樂, 將練琴變成樂趣, 甘佢唔會覺得pushy, 反而會比其他小朋友吸收得更好, 根基打得紮實, 第日就會快架啦, 千奇唔好見人地d小朋友快, 自己就心急埋一份, 甘樣好易因快得慢, 到時佢半桶水, 你仲喊到無謂。每個小朋友都有自己學習既步伐, 因循自己的步伐去學習, 先會有興趣, 有成功感。
musical sense 無得急, 得一個方法, 多接觸, 再浸淫多d時間, 日子有功, 自然會見到成效。