Which one is better, APS, KTS, HKUGAS or Creative PS

JJJC

My son has been enrolled by 4 primary schools in the coming 2006/7 academic year.  They are:
1. Alliance Primary School
2. Kowloon Tong School
3. Creative Primary School
4. HKUGAS Primary School

We live in Tsimshatsui.  

If you were me, which school would you choose and why?  Many many thanks.

Msma

2，1 ，3，4

CD

1.Kowloon Tong School
2.Alliance Primary School
3. HKUGAS Primary School
4. Creative Primary School

JJJC

Thanks Msma and CD.  Both of you picked KTS.  What makes it better than the other three in your view?  For me, I like it because it is an English teaching school and it is not expensive.  

kidvictory

I would prefer HKUGA rather than KTS primary school if the location and transportation is not the issue. (I don't know much about #1 & #3 schools)
The reason is so simple that HKUGA primary school has"whole-chain system", that is continuing with the international secondary school (adopting IB programme). So, you don't need to worry about later on.  For KTS, I would say the school is adopting traditional teaching approach (but there is nothing wrong with it, it really depends which teaching approach you prefer and which one is suitable for your child (above only my personal opinions).  Also, KTS does not have "whole-chain system."  

AdaHo123

kidvictory:
想請教咩野叫 "whole-chain system"? 係指有預計行 IB 的中學? 但根據 KTS 的升中派位資料, 除左3個畢業生派左去中中, 其他差極都可派到新成立的直資英中, 而呢d直資英中唔少都計畫行 IB 喎, 咁呢樣野係選 HKUGA 既理由咩
我認為除左地區, 教學方式可能係選 KTS 或者 HKUGA 最需要考慮既地方, 只不過係 HKUGA 想讀得好, 相信父母同小朋友的付出都唔會少.

Msma

但點解ＩＢ個　ＷＥＢ　無包　ＨＫＵＧＡ　呢　？

咁如讀ＩＢ，我會簡認受左個Ｄ學校嘮！　

無話佢唔好，但唔曉佢地想行邊種路，個小朋友第日出路會係點嘮！

我都有親人讀僅ＨＫＵＧＰＡ，都為呢個問題頭大！　係上返到中學。。。咁過後呢　？銜接乜呢　？考邊Ｄ公開試呢？

IJJK

Congratulations to you having some many choices for your kid! Four of them are with good reputations.

It really depends on what kind of kid you want him/her to be. APS definitely is a very traditional school with lots of tests and homework, that is also the reason why their graduates can go to all the band 1 good schools. KTS has more activities and relaxed. While HKUGAS, with more open-minded teachers and parents. The teachers' age are younger with higher academic background and no. of years of experience are much shorter. It's always with pros and cons. Traditional schools are always with more stable policy and curriculum, however, you might not like some of the teachers (without passion and work like semi-gov't job).

Anway, it is up to your expectation and the personality of the kids.

Msma

咁想問點解滬江維多利亞咁快就批左呢　？

我無話讀ＩＢ無出路窩，我姨生都係讀ＩＢ架　，我唔係話ＨＫＵＧＰＡ唔好，係好唔明點解有幾間學校，成日都話行ＩＢ但咁耐都未批呢？咁其實怕唔怕讀到中五都未批呢？到時咁會點呢　？

滬江維多利亞點解又批左呢？係因為校舍問題　？
　

monmantong

may i know where can we check the IB info, and which school was approved to use IB .

Msma

咁仲要等幾耐先批呢？

唔批對學生有無影嚮呢　？

咁與其都未批。。　不如簡間批左又行左好多年，好似有經驗係安全好多窩！　  

mfkhung

I am interested in VSA. May I know more about it? Please!

autumn

1, 3, 2, 4

Msma

我唔敢話滬江維多利亞係好定唔好，因係新校，都要幾年時間先有成績睇。

其實每樣評估都會有其存在原因同價值！Ｑ嘜保證有時都係有存在必要嘮！

再重申無話過ＨＫＵＧＰＡ　係唔好，希望你唔好誤會！

AdaHo123

IJJK 寫道:
Congratulations to you having some many choices for your kid! Four of them are with good reputations.

It really depends on what kind of kid you want him/her to be. APS definitely is a very traditional school with lots of tests and homework, that is also the reason why their graduates can go to all the band 1 good schools. KTS has more activities and relaxed. While HKUGAS, with more open-minded teachers and parents. The teachers' age are younger with higher academic background and no. of years of experience are much shorter. It's always with pros and cons. Traditional schools are always with more stable policy and curriculum, however, you might not like some of the teachers (without passion and work like semi-gov't job).

Anway, it is up to your expectation and the personality of the kids.

講既大致同意. 但子女係 APS 同 KTS 就讀的家長, 都讚老師有愛心, 呢點好過一般傳統學校.

JJJC

Hi Msma,

Can you let me why you like KTS better than APS and the others? Tks.

JJJC