九龍聖瑪加利男女中小學如何？？？

pok1996

囝囝派位唔好，　派左去ｂａｎｄ３最慘係校風唔好．　而家考左入九龍聖瑪加利男女中小學．　有無家長知呢間學校如何？　會唔會好難讀架？校風　＆　Banding ?

請賜教！

abmama

聽說她不是一間band 1 school,約band 1尾band 2 頭的學校。是不淺的,讀得不好是要留班的。
其實你的選擇也不多,一就是讀派左的band 3 school,或者這間。除非你孩子考到一間比這間還要好的學校。

catcatmom

我朋友日本人, 女兒讀陳守仁,舊年升中派位, 因成績唔好, 唔知選邊間, 甘我見佢無讀中文科,(讀法文),甘又去得邊?甘我叫佢填聖瑪加利, 佢話個list搵唔到, 李國寶等…就有.
聖瑪加利小學部d家長說中學已自行收生,甘可以控制收生質數, 佢唔冼政府比學生佢, 學生質素好d

原文章由 pok1996 於 08-7-12 00:32 發表
囝囝派位唔好，　派左去ｂａｎｄ３最慘係校風唔好．　而家考左入九龍聖瑪加利男女中小學．　有無家長知呢間學校如何？　會唔會好難讀架？校風　＆　Banding ?

請賜教！ ...

ceomum

Open day我有去聽講座這校給我的感覺不大好,可以用國際學校來形容些校,第一輪都考到此校都無諗過去讀,今年這校政府是有派位的不是100%自行收生,但係學生的質數我就不大清楚。

jcpsis

原文章由 pok1996 於 08-7-12 00:32 發表
囝囝派位唔好，　派左去ｂａｎｄ３最慘係校風唔好．　而家考左入九龍聖瑪加利男女中小學．　有無家長知呢間學校如何？　會唔會好難讀架？校風　＆　Banding ?

請賜教！ ...

Hi pok1996

I have exactly the same situation as yours.  I also want to know more about this secondary school !!!  (help)

jcpsis

原文章由 ceomum 於 08-7-12 11:12 發表
Open day我有去聽講座這校給我的感覺不大好,可以用國際學校來形容些校,第一輪都考到此校都無諗過去讀,今年這校政府是有派位的不是100%自行收生,但係學生的質數我就不大清楚。 ...

ceomum,

May I ask you why ...?!
What makes you feel this school is not good?

But anyways, as we have not much choice, so we have already register in this school.  Hope it's not that bad la ~

big-boy

pok1996:
My colleague have a daughter adopt by St.Margaret's S1 this year. His duaghter result is band 3. He didn't select all band 3 aided secondary school in Sham Shui Po because he saw so many times those school student are somkeing and speak fucking at bus station. Some worse case was fighting at the bus upstair. But St.Margaret student is OK, especially in conduct and English lesson.

pok1996

Thanks for all information provided by moms.

I hope really the conduct of students are good, as these two days my friend asked a teacher (Other school's Eng teacher), he informed that the school is good (Even now maybe better then 祟真）, because the school is agressive and want to upgrade their banding from the coming future.
The only I worry is not easy to study.

Actually my son was study in a famous Boy school in Mid-leavl of P. 6, Unluckly, he love to paly games (on line games) since P4 , P5 and made his exam result not good, so cannot direct promote to their Secondary School....  

Hope he can work hard at S. 1, now I am waiting HKBU Wong Kam Fai, I don't know which one is better.

原文章由 big-boy 於 08-7-13 11:47 發表
pok1996:
My colleague have a daughter adopt by St.Margaret's S1 this year. His duaghter result is band 3. He didn't select all band 3 aided secondary school in Sham Shui Po because he saw so many time ...

pok1996

yes, why ? ceomum ? Why like the international school is not good ?

原文章由 jcpsis 於 08-7-13 11:23 發表


ceomum,

May I ask you why ...?!
What makes you feel this school is not good?

But anyways, as we have not much choice, so we have already register in this school.  Hope it's not that bad la ~ ...

pok1996

Hello!  Your son / daughter is accepted by St Margaret ? Will study here ?

原文章由 jcpsis 於 08-7-13 11:21 發表



Hi pok1996

I have exactly the same situation as yours.  I also want to know more about this secondary school !!!  (help)

pok1996

abmama

唔該晒先, 咁 d banding 你係咪都係係 d 網友度打聽到架? 定係真架? 如果係 band1 尾我都願啦, 亞仔 d 成績今年真係差左, 點會有 band 1 頭學校收吖, 收左都讀死佢啦 !!!

原文章由 abmama 於 08-7-12 01:13 發表
聽說她不是一間band 1 school,約band 1尾band 2 頭的學校。是不淺的,讀得不好是要留班的。
其實你的選擇也不多,一就是讀派左的band 3 school,或者這間。除非你孩子考到一間比這間還要好的學校。 ...

jcpsis

原文章由 pok1996 於 08-7-14 00:04 發表
Hello!  Your son / daughter is accepted by St Margaret ? Will study here ?

re. pok1996

It's actually not my son/daughter.  It's my youngest brother.  

Btw, yes.  St. Margaret has accepted him.  He probably will study there this year ~

How about your son?  Still deciding?

big-boy

Dear pok1996:

"如果係 band1 尾我都願啦" - Yes, It should be a band1 tail school. But, you may wonder why it accepted band3 student for secondary one? I don't understand too. I just tell you the true what I knew. I 'GUESS' the school ranking is base on the HKCEE result. Maybe, the school can improvement it's student performance within five academic years.

pok1996

jcpsis,

My son is registered in St Margaret for S. 1 this year.
If HKBU Wong Kam Fai accept him maybe will consider, but now many people sounds that St Margaret is a good school, or I will just let him study here.  As a mother, only wish the son / daughter have a good education and happy life.

haha..... sorry, you are a Good Sister la.

原文章由 jcpsis 於 08-7-14 20:06 發表



re. pok1996

It's actually not my son/daughter.  It's my youngest brother.  

Btw, yes.  St. Margaret has accepted him.  He probably will study there this year ~

How about your son?  Still decidin ...

[ 本文章最後由 pok1996 於 08-7-14 23:56 編輯 ]

ceomum

jcpsis   pok1996


這只是當天給我的印象


那天去到學校已有一位老師同我們講唔讀中文唔緊要可以讀法文都得在參觀時又係不停又重覆講同一番話(中國人唔讀中文?)

成個講座個校董不停係台上吹名牌、又講間學校班學生捐錢有幾多幾巴閉好多學校無可能做到，講D野真係好唔務實!

在茶會時我問(唔記得係副校長定主任)政府派位係會派 bank 幾學生來貴校?(無記錯校長在台上話自行收生大約收60人,咁政府派位數目都唔會小過呢個數啦)個老師個態度好似唔想答咁仲同我講話話唔倒比我知!我個小朋友bank1尾唔通政府派好多bank3來我仲會去讀?

那天我有交表但只係當比小朋友多一個面試練習。最後都考入佢自己心儀直資中學。

pok1996

明白了, 死啦, 聽完都唔知點!

不過我去註冊個日, 個講解o既老師就好清楚咁講一般香港學生係會讀中,英文班. 而非華裔或在外國大而唔識中文o既就多數選法文,英文班, 因佢地好難上中文班喎.

其實有無 d 咩方法知道學校現已收生的大約成績狀況架?!
唔該！！！　仲有，有無人知如果同沙田王錦輝會邊間好ｄ？大家都係近年新直資．

原文章由 ceomum 於 08-7-15 00:10 發表
jcpsis   pok1996


這只是當天給我的印象


那天去到學校已有一位老師同我們講唔讀中文唔緊要可以讀法文都得在參觀時又係不停又重覆講同一番話(中國人唔讀中文?)

成個講座個校董不停係台上吹名牌、又講間學校班 ...

Viman

Hello all mother,

For me, very litte information on St.Margaret's & 王錦輝.

For me, I have chosen PLK Ngan Po Ling to my son as I heard more positive comments from friends, parents & teachers.

Hope this give another alternatives to all of you.

abmama

至於她的banding,我是聽我一位舊同事說的,
我的舊同事有一個朋友的孩子在英華,那孩子說有一天同他的老師傾計,老師說St Margaret 好快變band 1.

而她也有一位朋有的女兒在St. Margaret 小學,小學的英文程度很高,小二已有小五、小六的英語程度,我們估計這學校有自己的教育方針及方法,可以提升孩子的興趣及程度。

學校肯收你兒子,他一定有過人之處,如你所說,你的孩子是今年差了一些,那麼以前是好的。可能他的底子是好的,不用擔心,

原文章由 pok1996 於 08-7-14 00:08 發表
abmama

唔該晒先, 咁 d banding 你係咪都係係 d 網友度打聽到架? 定係真架? 如果係 band1 尾我都願啦, 亞仔 d 成績今年真係差左, 點會有 band 1 頭學校收吖, 收左都讀死佢啦 !!!

...

catcatmom

2yrs前參觀沙田培僑中學, 個briefing剛講完d家長們第一個問題就好心急地問, 貴校中一生係來自band幾? 這個問題係d家長最關心, 因自己子女係band1尾orband2頭都唔想"no"埋d band3生, 但羅校長話 : 我地收生標準唔係睇band幾既! 係睇個小朋友適5適合讀培僑. (其實培僑係好大部分收band 1.)

現聖瑪加利有60人自行收生, 即要60人派位抽入去,甘band3派到入去, 都唔出奇, 今年都有學生band2派位入九龍塘聖加英中, 學校不會有一部份band2, 而成個變成band2學校? 如聖瑪加利到自行收生階段都不會收band3生, 因佢有好大部份老師係外籍or abc, band3入到去, 聽都成問題.

聖瑪加利係一間好AGGRESSIVE既學校, 無需要擔心學術既問題. 反而擔心程度追唔上, 因另外一間深水涉直資係"初中教育"引起好大回應, 一科不合格, 不能升班, 不可補考.不知sm是否一樣.

而顏保0係英中, 但有家長之前投訴過, 佢個仔係讀國際小學, 因某些原因無讀國際中學(好似跟著仲有2個小朋友), 所以選顏保0,因佢可以唔讀中文, 所以中國人唔讀中文, 大有人在, 不必驚呀! 可惜入到去, 亞仔即投訴 : 不是說英文的, 老師係無問題, 最大問題係d學生, 佢地要求老師說中文.

原文章由 ceomum 於 08-7-15 00:10 發表
jcpsis   pok1996


這只是當天給我的印象


那天去到學校已有一位老師同我們講唔讀中文唔緊要可以讀法文都得在參觀時又係不停又重覆講同一番話(中國人唔讀中文?)

成個講座個校董不停係台上吹名牌、又講間學校班 ...

ceomum

原文章由 catcatmom 於 08-7-20 11:23 發表
2yrs前參觀沙田培僑中學, 個briefing剛講完d家長們第一個問題就好心急地問, 貴校中一生係來自band幾? 這個問題係d家長最關心, 因自己子女係band1尾orband2頭都唔想"no"埋d band3生, 但羅校長話 : 我地收生標準唔係睇 ...

如果當天個老師好似你咁解答我的問題我會明白和接受,但係...