Recognize Chinese characters in PN?

victoryu19

Am I the only one who thinks asking PN kids to read and recognize Chinese characters in school is ridiculous?

victoryu19

Maibubuu 發表於 14-1-14 10:45
Don't worry! I haven't even taught my almost 3 year old any Chinese character yet!! Just take it eas ...

Agreed with your view but the school is starting to teach the kids Chinese characters in PN.  I just feel like it is ridiculous.  Why can't the school just let the kids enjoy their childhood?

jonlyone

i think it also depends on the child's interest.my gal can read many Chinese characters, because she asks me to read to her everyday. our house has fai chun posted for Chinese new year and she asks me to read those as well.

Cutemom0808

victoryu19 發表於 14-1-14 10:13
Am I the only one who thinks asking PN kids to read and recognize Chinese characters in school is ri ...

只要不是揸準筆學寫就ok了

djmix

Exactly!!! I do think it's ridiculous.  The school is having assessment on them on recognizing Chinese characters.  I'm so not willing to force my daughter to memorize the characters.  
And I heard that they will start teaching the kids to write in K2 (not sure in English or Chinese).  I still think it's too early.  Sigh...how I wish the kids can have a free and happy childhood.

pandafood

放心，我仔學校下學期話要認字我都打左突。PN 姐，唔係呀嘛。仲要話怕我仔跟唔上。跟唔上咪跟唔上喇。

Jane1983

PN有d早，吾使甘急。

Patpatmom

教唔緊要，唔好又評核又要家長配合，然後又比壓力話咁樣上唔到 K1 就可以

ky201105

我都覺得教OK, 簡單好似: 人, 口, 門.... 都好易認,囡囡有時喺街度自己見到佢識O既字會講, 佢自己好滿足~

bubuG

原帖由 Patpatmom 於 14-01-14 發表
教唔緊要，唔好又評核又要家長配合，然後又比壓力話咁樣上唔到 K1 就可以

Agree

picture

原帖由 bubuG 於 14-01-14 發表
Agree

Agree too

miugube

其實PN小朋友要認中文字個人覺得ok, 我小朋友當年學校會一星期比1-2個中文字認識，連圖畫一齊教，好易入腦。出街時見到啲佢識嘅字佢會非常開心！仲不斷問我其他近似嘅字點讀。
想深一層，小朋友嘅記憶其實好「聲音化」同「圖像化」，家長覺得一、兩歲記英文字母好正常，但其實有好多中文字都係好少筆劃同形象化，佢地都係用同一方法input入腦（背誦同睇圖）。英文字易記係因為有「ABC」song唸口黃，中文字「大」「門」「口」係視覺形象化，小朋友一星期學一、兩個字都合理嘅。

yamin

原帖由 Patpatmom 於 14-01-14 發表
教唔緊要，唔好又評核又要家長配合，然後又比壓力話咁樣上唔到 K1 就可以

十分認同。我仔而家N班是用K1的課本，會教人、門、囗、衣、果、大、小。我仔是細仔，其實他認字和講方面是未能掌握到。學校的習作簿是在上課時做，是圖畫隔離有個相應的中文字，會叫小朋友為圖畫和字填顏色，當然他是畫到成板紙花喱花碌。我通常食完飯和他一起執執書包，揭揭習作。但他往往見到d中文字，他會指住問我咩黎架？我會答佢，say 魚。但有日令我好驚訝，返教會祟拜，程序表上有d經文，當中有個人字，d字好細粒，佢可以指到個字，表達到係人，佢發音不太正。所以俾小朋友咁細個expose to 中文字是冇壞，讓他們對中文字/圖像有興趣，又可以同大人有互動，唔錯吖。催谷與否，是家長的態度和決定，即使學校谷，家長也可以不跟從，或者不讀。但我知呢間學校，一路讀上去都幾谷，所以我也要考慮一下是否合適

sweetcandychan

其實睇下個小朋友, 如果佢有興趣及能力, 佢自然會學識.  最重要係唔好迫佢學, 佢冇興趣, 就由得佢, 唔需要成日問佢, 成日叫佢記, 但比佢接觸下冇壞, 到佢ready時, 佢自然會問你. 每個小朋友發展及資質唔同, 好難一概而論邊個階段先係最適合開始認字的時候.

小朋友咁細個, 認字唔係主要要發展的才能, 唔好只著重要小朋友認字,  但又唔需要覺得要佢認字就好似會害左個小朋友咁, 最緊要平衡多方面發展, 認字同發展創意及思考能力係冇抵觸

tiffany168168

I think it's ok. my son learnt 人, 水, 口, 山 already and he enjoyed going to school so much!

超班BB

其實我相信係冇問題的，從遊戲中學習佢地係好樂意的，小囡兒從2歳開始大約一年時間，佢已學懂六十幾個中文字，包括學、醫、鴨、雞等深字，識讀、解釋

vivianho35

我囡都有認字書, 我當遊戲玩, 佢玩得好開心, 而家識人, 手, 口, 地, 木, 大, 小, 月
我冇迫佢記, 係有一日佢係街冇端端指住個字話' 小' 呀, 我先知佢認得

fc926

其實小朋友記性好到你唔信，唔使心急提早至PN就學中文字,我的經驗是小朋友在K2時會突然間學識很多中文字，只要學校教得好，唔使提早谷。

MrBeast

真好難講，有fd 讀coupon kg 的pn, 也有個folder，入面有些簡單的字，eg, 大小上下，又認到wor.