沙田區91校網的家長, 請給予意見

wendy_cheuk

各位沙田區91校網的家長:

大家好!我的兒子將於明年入讀沙田區91校網的小學, 哪幾間小學比較好呢? 請給予意見。萬分感激!

無知的媽媽Wendy

StParent

排名分別:
浸信會呂明才小學/浸信會沙田圍呂明才小學
培基小學/胡素貞博士紀念學校(上午) /保良局朱正賢小學
保良局蕭漢森小學
聖公會主風小學
沙田循道衛理小學/路德會梁鉅鏐小學（上午）

可參考:
明報06/07升小選校攻略

wendy_cheuk 寫道:
各位沙田區91校網的家長:

大家好!我的兒子將於明年入讀沙田區91校網的小學, 哪幾間小學比較好呢? 請給予意見。萬分感激!

無知的媽媽Wendy

lililee

StParent,

請問你用邊種方法將學校排名呢? 如按成績計的話,聖公會主風和沙田循道衛理,是不及路德會梁鉅鏐喔.

StParent

lililee,

The academic level, the school is very good.  But the relationships with the parents are not.

Last Year News :
太陽報網頁三百多名師生和家長昨前往香港路德會總部靜坐抗議，不滿校董會及 統局「強迫」路德 會梁鉅鏐小學的上下午校合併。該校上午校校長黃一明擔心兩校一旦合併，將 ... 三百多 名路德會梁鉅鏐小學上午校的師生及家長昨日前往路德會總部抗議，以對合併計畫表示不滿。
http://the-sun.orisun.com/channels/news/20051219/20051219030305_0000.html

cmama

My kid is studying in 保良局朱正賢小學.
Do you have any specific questions to ask?
See whether I can help you.
    

yammyma

其實家長既爭辯係關於上下午校升中派位既問題,今年升中改制,07合併已無問題,梁上比較谷學生,梁下教師就較後生,有衝勁,隨住合併,上午校年長老師退休,下午校年青老師加入,應該會辦得更好.

wendy_lwy

你地好, 我囝囝今年都要簡小一啦, 小兒係比較坐唔定同要remain 佢要留心既人, 所以老師既教學方法對小兒好緊要.岩岩聽到消息沙呂小開學走左廿幾個老師同一個主任, 當堂打個突, 其實本人心儀係沙呂小同朱正賢既, 老公就想沙呂小多d, 依家咁... 仲諗緊呀, 唔知大家有咩意見呢

October

cmama

聽人說朱正賢很谷, 而且如果不是精英班, 學校不會太著重的.

朱正賢老師有沒有愛心? 那一級開始有精英班.有沒有功課輔導班呢?

謝.

october

wendy_cheuk

Dear cmama:

我的第一志願是沙田第一城的呂明才小學, 但係我的兒子只有5分, 在自行分配學位能入讀的機會不大, 故想在統一派位篩選較好的小學, 排在前頭, 現我想知道朱正賢小學的老師有愛心嗎? 功課多不多? 是不是傳統教學? 競爭大嗎? 難入讀嗎?

Wendy

Tammy

我囡囡依家係胡素貞下午校讀緊三年級, 學校好好, 校風都好好, 有問題可以分享下呀 !

wendy_cheuk

Tammy

但係出面都話胡素貞上午校好過下午校, 你覺得或知不知道上、午校就教學、老師質素、程度等有何分別? 請分享你囡囡的情況, 好嗎? 以供參考, 謝謝!

Wendy

bkmummy

這真的是一個很大的問題, 我也在15/16中.

wendy_lwy 寫道:
岩岩聽到消息沙呂小開學走左廿幾個老師同一個主任, 當堂打個突, 其實本人心儀係沙呂小同朱正賢既, 老公就想沙呂小多d, 依家咁... 仲諗緊呀, 唔知大家有咩意見呢

cmama

October 寫道:
cmama

聽人說朱正賢很谷, 而且如果不是精英班, 學校不會太著重的.

朱正賢老師有沒有愛心? 那一級開始有精英班.有沒有功課輔導班呢?

謝.

october

I can answer some of your questions but not all since my kid is studying P1 only. The following is what I have posted in other similar topic:

My kid's studying in 保良局朱正賢小學 primary one. She enjoys going to school.

"谷" or not?
It depends on how you define it.
It's a busy school because it encourages both academic and extra-curriculum activities. Curriculum is in suitable level (not the one using P2 curriculum for P1). They have homework to consolidate what have learnt in varieties of ways. They don't have much copying. For example, only write 3 times for each words. It takes about 1 1/2 hour for my kid to finish the homework everyday. The time includes the complete process of referring to the student guidebook for what homework to do, finding out the correct pages to do, explaining the requirement of the homework, actually doing it and self correction. I expect her to finish it within one hour as she 's got used to the requirement of the teacher.
Again, she's busy but she's happy and has the motivation to learn.


'聽人說朱正賢很谷, 而且如果不是精英班, 學校不會太著重的'  -- I really don't know. But if your kid is smart, she will have lots of opportunity to develop her potential.


'朱正賢老師有沒有愛心?' -- She loves her teachers and also the NET. She said he's very funny. But I didn't really get to know her teachers very well.

'那一級開始有精英班.'
-- Sorry don't know. But absolutely not P1.

有沒有功課輔導班呢?
-- They have a notice today, inviting students especially those with poor family income to join the 功課輔導班 after school.


We are lucky that there are quite a lot of "good" schools in Shatin. But "good" in different aspects. What we need to do is to select the one suitable to your own beliefs and your kid's ability. Don't just blindly choose the popular ones. Better visit the school and talk to the principal and teachers and other parents.
All the best.

cmama

wendy_cheuk 寫道:
Dear cmama:

我的第一志願是沙田第一城的呂明才小學, 但係我的兒子只有5分, 在自行分配學位能入讀的機會不大, 故想在統一派位篩選較好的小學, 排在前頭, 現我想知道朱正賢小學的老師有愛心嗎? 功課多不多? 是不是傳統教學? 競爭大嗎? 難入讀嗎?

Wendy

Hi,
Please refer to my previous post for information.

是不是傳統教學?
I think is inbetween traditional and the activity based learning.

競爭大嗎? 難入讀嗎?
Many people got 5 marks but could not get in even in 1 st round.
I chose it as my 1st choice in the central allocation but also failed. My kid got in by knocking door.
But it should be easier to get in comparing with the two 呂明才小學.

Hope that information can help.
Cheers.

:

ling2301

下星期交form, 我仲未諗到揀邊間, 請在沙田讀書的家長比些意見   

Tammy

wendy_cheuk,

唔...用客觀的角度, 上下午班都好好, D 小朋友都算幾乖, 好守規矩, 有禮貌, 只係下午班 D 時間唔多好用囉, 因為我本身住粉嶺, 知道胡素貞係一間好學校, 所以咁遠都比佢出來讀.  英文方面, 都少少深架, 上下午校都係同一個外籍英文老師...不過聽 D 媽咪話上午班比較霸道, 如果放學有活動, 活動係由上午班用先...

課程方面, 小一小二功課量都 OK, 不過一到考試就比較辛苦, 要預早溫定, 小二英文考試要做兩個 COMPHENSION (UNSEEN) 個隻, 今年仲嚴左同要求高左.  依家小三, 我囡入左精英班, 功課多左, 呀囡話 D 老師惡左.

wendy_cheuk 寫道:
Tammy

但係出面都話胡素貞上午校好過下午校, 你覺得或知不知道上、午校就教學、老師質素、程度等有何分別? 請分享你囡囡的情況, 好嗎? 以供參考, 謝謝!

Wendy