教育王國

標題: St Paul Boy vs 高主教 [打印本頁]

作者: larry007alex 時間: 10-11-15 10:30 標題: St Paul Boy vs 高主教

大家請幫忙分析兩家小學,哪一家比較可取, 謝! 如果大家要選擇, 會選哪一家呢!

作者: artroboy 時間: 10-11-15 10:53

St. Boy:
1) 中小 (英文不弱)
2) 直資
3) 有直屬中學一條龍
4) 男校
5) 普教中.
6) 較活動一 d 教學..(好似)

RC:
1)英小
2) 私校
3) 有直屬英津
4) 男女校
5) 普教中
6) 小學出名嚴但近年呈分試好. (以前小學是津校時成績差異比較大d,現時轉私校後總體表現上升中....
7) 在 net 12 網, 升中應該可享靚網優勢.,另他的中學部亦位於 net 11 靚網.

我都諗緊....

作者: gobbys 時間: 10-11-15 11:07

did u got offer letter from St. Paul Boy ?

原帖由 larry007alex 於 10-11-15 10:30 AM 發表
大家請幫忙分析兩家小學,哪一家比較可取, 謝! 如果大家要選擇, 會選哪一家呢!

作者: larry007alex 時間: 10-11-15 11:33 標題: 回復 3# gobbys 的帖子

沒有, 希望明天收到信.

作者: larry007alex 時間: 10-11-15 11:35 標題: 回覆 3# gobbys 的文章

祝大家好運.

作者: larry007alex 時間: 10-11-15 11:36 標題: 回復 2# artroboy 的帖子

十分難選擇

作者: artroboy 時間: 10-11-15 11:52 標題: 回復 1# larry007alex 的帖子

actually, 我 like St. Boy 多過RC. 唔好問我點解, 純粹個人喜好...冇解

作者: karen55407 時間: 10-11-15 11:55

當兩間都咁好時，我會揀直資學校，因為資源豐富，嚟緊St. Paul仲有新校舍。

作者: CHP 時間: 10-11-15 11:56

same here.

原帖由 artroboy 於 10-11-15 11:52 發表
actually, 我 like St. Boy 多過RC. 唔好問我點解, 純粹個人喜好...冇解

作者: larry007alex 時間: 10-11-15 11:58 標題: 回覆 7# artroboy 的文章

明白, 多謝意見!

作者: SaSaMummy 時間: 10-11-15 12:13

For secondary, St Paul is better than RC.
For primary, I think both schools are good.

原帖由 larry007alex 於 10-11-15 11:58 發表
明白, 多謝意見!

作者: YChan.Family 時間: 10-11-15 20:07

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: larry007alex 時間: 10-11-15 21:30

我 got waiting 係 st. paul boy, 所以我不用煩了, 我會專心讓小兒到RC. 謝!

作者: rayvonne 時間: 10-11-16 08:58

聖若瑟英文書院是在中西區, but RC 小學是在灣仔區, 那麼RC可以抽聖若瑟英文書院嗎? 請指教

原帖由 YChan.Family 於 10-11-15 20:07 發表
I really think both are the good schools.
Base on the performance & academic record in this five years; RC secondary have a big improvement than last 10 years! And the RC secondary also stay in Band 1 ...

作者: ysnmama 時間: 10-11-16 09:11

兩者選一. 我會選St. Paul's College Primary. 因St. Paul之名.

作者: mhddm 時間: 10-11-16 09:43

RC : Percentage of students with 14 points or more from the best 6 subjects : avarage 5x%
But, 2008/2009 (best year): 74.3%
; 2009/10 (last year): 55.2%

作者: diversity 時間: 10-11-16 12:27

原帖由 mhddm 於 10-11-16 09:43 發表
RC : Percentage of students with 14 points or more from the best 6 subjects : avarage 5x%
But, 2008/2009 (best year): 74.3%
; 2009/10 (last year): 55.2%

所以成績概野真係一年講一年, 好難用一年成績去决定一間學校的banding, track record 和成間學校給予的全人發展才致為重要..

作者: Student123 時間: 10-11-16 12:34

St Paul Boys is famous of so many medical doctor graduates.

作者: milkonline2 時間: 10-11-16 12:42

Then I will say RC is famous of many investment and financial expert. I know many friends from cuhk business adminstraion is graduated from RC. Hoewever I don't think that is a important consideration at this stage.t

原帖由 Student123 於 10-11-16 12:34 PM 發表
St Paul Boys is famous of so many medical doctor graduates.

作者: diversity 時間: 10-11-16 13:05

原帖由 Student123 於 10-11-16 12:34 發表
St Paul Boys is famous of so many medical doctor graduates.

Is that so?? I happen to know 3 brothers who are all SPC graduates, 2 are surgeons and 1 is dentist.

作者: artroboy 時間: 10-11-16 14:45

hi milkonline,

Please don't be too sad, waiting list doesn't mean no hopes, "knock the school door " is still worth for your son and daughter if you reli like RC. good luck~!

原帖由 milkonline2 於 10-11-16 12:42 發表
Then I will say RC is famous of many investment and financial expert. I know many friends from cuhk business adminstraion is graduated from RC. Hoewever I don't think that is a important consideration ...

作者: mhddm 時間: 10-11-16 15:34

同意。數字只作參考，而且不是每間學校都會提供這此數據或只提供當年最好的。而不應看單一年和單一方面或單一數據。

原帖由 diversity 於 10-11-16 12:27 發表

所以成績概野真係一年講一年, 好難用一年成績去决定一間學校的banding, track record 和成間學校給予的全人發展才致為重要..

作者: milkonline2 時間: 10-11-16 15:42

You are so lovely! Thanks for your advice and we are trying our best! Hope my son can be the classmate of your son in next year!!!

原帖由 artroboy 於 10-11-16 02:45 PM 發表
hi milkonline,

Please don't be too sad, waiting list doesn't mean no hopes, "knock the school door " is still worth for your son and daughter if you reli like RC. good luck~!

[

[ 本帖最後由 milkonline2 於 10-11-16 15:44 編輯 ]

作者: season_sincere 時間: 10-11-16 18:08

St. Paul's boys is better in my opinion, but the boys are much more competitive and confident. And I think the competition is higher than RC.

作者: AhiruNoPekk 時間: 10-11-16 22:50

真係完全唔知應該點揀, 可否比d意見?
唔知應該選擇RC or SPC?
請問應該點揀?很怕選錯?
有offer的家長, 你哋係咪會go ahead?
可否分享吓?

請問St. Paul Boys 小學升上中學的機會有多大? 小學搬咗去cyber port之後係屬咩區?係南區or 中西區?

原帖由 season_sincere 於 10-11-16 18:08 發表
St. Paul's boys is better in my opinion, but the boys are much more competitive and confident. And I think the competition is higher than RC.

[ 本帖最後由 AhiruNoPekk 於 10-11-17 00:46 編輯 ]

作者: fredkong01 時間: 10-11-17 08:24

I also face this difficulties, I dun know how to choose too.

I think they belong to "Southern district" after moving to cyberport, therefore, it will not belong to Net 11 and 12 anymore. losing the advantages in selecting good secondary schools, like King's

作者: milkonline2 時間: 10-11-17 09:14

st Paul boy is many parents ' dream school. I don't know why you still think of so many things if you get the offer. I cry and depressed when my son is being rejected. Some of my friends also........

作者: Irenewee 時間: 10-11-17 09:26

I will choose St Paul Boy, the new school is very nice and big...

作者: Chingding 時間: 10-11-17 09:28

I think you all would not believe that my fd select SFA over St Paul boys last year. He said SFA is English whlist SPB is Chinese and also the admission rate to University for SPB is not so good.

I think RC is also English. You could consider in this aspect lor.

作者: tszfungmama 時間: 10-11-17 09:42

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: diversity 時間: 10-11-17 09:49

原帖由 Chingding 於 10-11-17 09:28 發表
I think you all would not believe that my fd select SFA over St Paul boys last year. He said SFA is English whlist SPB is Chinese and also the admission rate to University for SPB is not so good.

I ...

Mind you that SPCC is also a Chinese primary school by definition. It's not just the broad definition that counts, one needs to look into details of the level of Eng taught and the overall Eng speaking/reading environment. I think the Eng level of St Paul Boys is not low at all comparing with any prestigious schools. One should get prepared for that.

作者: Almond. 時間: 10-11-17 10:06

I have the same feeling with you. For me, I will never hesitate if my son got an offer from St Paul boy.

原帖由 milkonline2 於 10-11-17 09:14 發表
st Paul boy is many parents ' dream school. I don't know why you still think of so many things if you get the offer. I cry and depressed when my son is being rejected. Some of my friends also........

作者: Chingding 時間: 10-11-17 10:18

原帖由 diversity 於 10-11-17 09:49 發表

Mind you that SPCC is also a Chinese primary school by definition. It's not just the broad definition that counts, one needs to look into details of the level of Eng taught and the overall Eng speak ...

Oh! I totally agreed with you. The comments were given by my fd only.

Actually, I don't know much about the two schools

作者: AhiruNoPekk 時間: 10-11-17 12:09

我都好想知佢哋的中學成績係點, 但SPB沒有向外公佈中學的成績, 請問如何可以知道中學的程度和ranking?
近年好似多人講佢中學下滑, 唔知係咪真?
相反RC近年好似進步不少? RC中學好似ranking上都唔錯wor...

fredkong01你會點揀?

原帖由 Chingding 於 10-11-17 10:18 發表

Oh! I totally agreed with you. The comments were given by my fd only.

Actually, I don't know much about the two schoolsops:" />

作者: YChan.Family 時間: 10-11-17 12:55

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: YuHangMum 時間: 10-11-17 13:34

中學部個程度, 以我了解一d都不差, 近年接手的校長是非常有心去辦學, 學校相當鼓勵學生出國留學, 所以有d學生會在before考會考前已經走了! &今年中學部開始不再收派位生, 即全數收生由學校決定, 我相信過幾年中學部的ranking一定有所提升!

原帖由 AhiruNoPekk 於 10-11-17 12:09 發表
我都好想知佢哋的中學成績係點, 但SPB沒有向外公佈中學的成績, 請問如何可以知道中學的程度和ranking?
近年好似多人講佢中學下滑, 唔知係咪真?
相反RC近年好似進步不少? RC中學好似ranking上都唔錯wor...

fredkong ...

作者: fredkong01 時間: 10-11-17 13:59

AhiruNoPekk,

I personally prefer St. Paul's boy. their pupils are more pure and disciplined. Though it is a chinese primary school but the secondary school is in English, and i believe that their eng. standard is not low as we thought.

(To think in another way round, can we ensure that the english standard of english primary school must be good, except it is DGJS or DBSPD)

作者: Student123 時間: 10-11-17 22:21

Nowadays, after the 2008 financial crisis, most people in the world i.e.US, even HK ( Lehman Bond) hate those monetarial guys (mind is only flooded of making money out of laymen investor aged >70)

原帖由 milkonline2 於 10-11-16 12:42 發表
Then I will say RC is famous of many investment and financial expert. I know many friends from cuhk business adminstraion is graduated from RC. Hoewever I don't think that is a important consideration ...

作者: Student123 時間: 10-11-17 22:29

Most schools love to admit Drs' kid (mean your grandson, if your son is a Dr) rather than financial experts.
Dr parents can help school directly for medical opinion & help (for school staffs & students/ other parents). And most Drs help people or give advise for fee. Not like solicitors or finacial experts, mostly they charge.
Also Professional vs non-professional, diff social status.

原帖由 milkonline2 於 10-11-16 12:42 發表
Then I will say RC is famous of many investment and financial expert. I know many friends from cuhk business adminstraion is graduated from RC. Hoewever I don't think that is a important consideration ...

作者: milkonline2 時間: 10-11-18 00:16

I don't think that kind of issue is worth to discuss in this topic. meaningless........ and I don't think schools only consider the background of parents.

原帖由 Student123 於 10-11-17 10:29 PM 發表
Most schools love to admit Drs' kid (mean your grandson, if your son is a Dr) rather than financial experts.
Dr parents can help school directly for medical opinion & help (for school staffs & student ...

作者: AhiruNoPekk 時間: 10-11-19 09:34

Hi Fredkong01,
我估我可能會選RC, 係因為宗教問題.
但其實我都好唔捨得SPB, 我會聽埋25號的briefing先決定,
到時我會放返個比其他家長, 等佢哋唔駛咁担心.
多謝你的分享. :>

Hi Fredkong01,

原帖由 fredkong01 於 10-11-17 13:59 發表
AhiruNoPekk,

I personally prefer St. Paul's boy. their pupils are more pure and disciplined. Though it is a chinese primary school but the secondary school is in English, and i believe that their eng ...

作者: Winnietao 時間: 10-11-19 12:20

原帖由 artroboy 於 10-11-15 11:52 發表
actually, 我 like St. Boy 多過RC. 唔好問我點解, 純粹個人喜好...冇解

我都係

作者: YChan.Family 時間: 10-11-21 14:48

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: PoorParent 時間: 10-11-21 20:45

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: diversity 時間: 10-11-21 23:48

原帖由 YChan.Family 於 10-11-21 14:48 發表
You may can check with this record:

中西區分析

中西區有9間官津學校, 唔係band1英中就係band3中中. 男校英中以英皇同聖若瑟較top, 上年聖若瑟14分有75.92%而英皇就67%. 高主教比聖類斯較好, 前者屬band1中(上年 ...

It's interesting to see your repeating copy & paste information. So how would you rate RC with the 09/10 result being only 55.2% got 14 points or more? As said, it's rather pointless to use just 1 or 2 years' result to rate the overall banding of a school. There are so many things, apart from exam result, to justify the 'level' & 'class' of a school.

作者: sherrychi 時間: 10-11-23 12:35

請教大家, 爸爸是高主教舊生, 兒子是否一定收?

作者: Student123 時間: 10-11-24 16:47

Time to choose between SPCPS vs RC

作者: andrewpapa 時間: 10-11-25 11:04

aiya, this so-called "report" again.

I am not defending SPC here. But I want to say again....

Banding is not applied to neither primary school nor secondary school. It only applied to Primary 6 students who are joining the application of Form 1.

I have sent the gov't article in other thread already. And I will not do it here again

You can have your own banding idea and share with others. But not put it as report.

作者: 好一個爸爸 時間: 10-11-25 11:44

""中西區仲有兩間抽獎直資""

SPC 係抽獎直資???

作者: AhiruNoPekk 時間: 10-11-25 11:58

sorry, what is "抽獎直資"?

原帖由 好一個爸爸 於 10-11-25 11:44 發表
""中西區仲有兩間抽獎直資""

SPC 係抽獎直資???

作者: fredkong01 時間: 10-11-25 22:25 標題: 回覆 10# AhiruNoPekk 的文章

Thank you for all your comment. We will not register Raimondi this Saturday and release the place to those who is waiting. Good luck to you all.

作者: Student123 時間: 10-11-26 09:55

Many Christian parents are against Catholic schools.
Ah…… under the same God though with different value & practice
As far as it is not a deviant religion. Parents should put kids’ prospect at the first ranking

原帖由 AhiruNoPekk 於 10-11-19 09:34 發表
Hi Fredkong01,
我估我可能會選RC, 係因為宗教問題.
但其實我都好唔捨得SPB, 我會聽埋25號的briefing先決定,
到時我會放返個比其他家長, 等佢哋唔駛咁担心.
多謝你的分享. :>

Hi Fredkong01,

...

作者: HuiTung 時間: 10-11-26 10:52

原帖由 Student123 於 10-11-26 09:55 發表
Many Christian parents are against Catholic schools.
Ah…… under the same God though with different value & practice
As far as it is not a deviant religion. Parents should put kids’ prospect at the ...

According to a recent speech of the SPC’s principal, the school has a lot of F.1 students coming from Raimondi this year (no.1 on the list apart from SPCPS).

作者: AhiruNoPekk 時間: 10-11-26 15:23

好多謝你呀!好感動!我好想喊!
我呢個星期唸咗好多嘢, 問咗好多人, 分分秒秒都在想這2間小學.
好怕自己揀錯, 好大壓力, 前一天堅決選 A校, 下一天又決定B校, 不斷的變, 好多好多人知道我真係唔知點揀, 比咗好多方面的意見我, 好多謝大家.好感動.
其實, 自問不是一位很虔誠的教友, 但仍然很有內疚加自責, 好似好對唔住好多嘢.
選RC是因為內心好過d, 選SPB是因為學校地點十分方便.
整個考慮過程令我對2間學校的認識加深了很多, 我只可以說2間都是好的小學, 有好的老師, 學生品行好.
多謝SPB有一個簡介會.

原帖由 Student123 於 10-11-26 09:55 發表
Many Christian parents are against Catholic schools.
Ah…… under the same God though with different value & practice
As far as it is not a deviant religion. Parents should put kids’ prospect at the ...

作者: Teresa 時間: 10-11-26 15:28

原帖由 rayvonne 於 10-11-16 08:58 發表
聖若瑟英文書院是在中西區, but RC 小學是在灣仔區, 那麼RC可以抽聖若瑟英文書院嗎? 請指教

可以, 當"他區"去抽. (參考"中學概覽")

作者: gobbys 時間: 10-11-26 15:33

After attending the SPC briefing yesterday, I think I'm making a right choice for my son.

作者: Teresa 時間: 10-11-26 15:42

原帖由 AhiruNoPekk 於 10-11-26 15:23 發表
好多謝你呀!好感動!我好想喊!
我呢個星期唸咗好多嘢, 問咗好多人, 分分秒秒都在想這2間小學.
好怕自己揀錯, 好大壓力, 前一天堅決選 A校, 下一天又決定B校, 不斷的變, 好多好多人知道我真係唔知點揀, 比咗好多方面的 ...

So, which one do you choose finally?

作者: Student123 時間: 10-11-26 16:03

It is my pleasure to help you & your kid out.

Actually many of my Christian friends even didn't apply Catholic schools, but they are now regret because they have no offer on hand for their kids.

Just like Christian have to be fall in love or get marry with Christain (rather than Catholic). But Catholic is more open mind in this fields ( both education & marriage)

Ah! why parents' religious belief post on their kids' future education/ propspect
是邪教便是

原帖由 AhiruNoPekk 於 10-11-26 15:23 發表
好多謝你呀!好感動!我好想喊!
我呢個星期唸咗好多嘢, 問咗好多人, 分分秒秒都在想這2間小學.
好怕自己揀錯, 好大壓力, 前一天堅決選 A校, 下一天又決定B校, 不斷的變, 好多好多人知道我真係唔知點揀, 比咗好多方面的 ...

作者: lilyma 時間: 10-11-26 16:14

我兒很文靜，上年有幸成功考入聖保羅，想不到小朋友小一生活那麼開心愉快，無論學業或社交上都有很大進步。若你的小朋友被這所小學取錄，請認真考慮，不要輕言放棄。

作者: AhiruNoPekk 時間: 10-11-26 16:18

Thanks for all your information.
I have replied you in pm. Thank you so much.

原帖由 Teresa 於 10-11-26 15:42 發表

So, which one do you choose finally?

作者: AhiruNoPekk 時間: 10-11-26 16:55

多謝 lilyma 鼓勵. 希望你的兒子不斷進步.
基本上我們都可以說已make up our mind, 多謝!
我們會選擇SPB, 好多謝大家.
好多謝這裏BK家長的無私pm分享.

原帖由 lilyma 於 10-11-26 16:14 發表
我兒很文靜，上年有幸成功考入聖保羅，想不到小朋友小一生活那麼開心愉快，無論學業或社交上都有很大進步。若你的小朋友被這所小學取錄，請認真考慮，不要輕言放棄。 ...

[ 本帖最後由 AhiruNoPekk 於 10-11-26 16:57 編輯 ]

作者: kenfu 時間: 10-11-26 18:46

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: PoorParent 時間: 10-11-26 18:49

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: fredkong01 時間: 10-11-26 19:17

原帖由 AhiruNoPekk 於 10-11-26 16:55 發表
多謝 lilyma 鼓勵. 希望你的兒子不斷進步.
基本上我們都可以說已make up our mind, 多謝!
我們會選擇SPB, 好多謝大家.
好多謝這裏BK家長的無私pm分享.

AhiruNoPekk,

Received your PM. We also choose SPB. Then our son will be classmates lar. Good.

作者: kitshek 時間: 10-11-29 02:19

點解仲有咁多人覺得Paul Boy係Dream School？

無錯，Paul Boy個名以前係好響，但而家中學部成績真係跌到慘不忍睹，你睇睇佢自己公佈嘅2009年入大學成績：

http://www.spc.edu.hk/docs/news_from_spc_10.pdf (29頁)

入讀六大(港、中、科、理、浸、城)加嶺大只有33.8%，屬Brand 2中等水平。唔好以為係因為好多人去外國升學，因為六成幾人要讀Asso / High Dip.

單計中西區排尾四，唔好話高主教，聖類斯都開始拋離佢，Paul Boy而家只係好過聖士提反堂同樂善堂等Brand 3學校。

作者: fredkong01 時間: 10-11-29 08:25

kitshek,

thanks for your information. In fact, we also notice that the academic performance of St. Paul's college (secondary section) has been dropping these few years. However, we do admit that the primary section is good, we cannot ensure what it will happen after 12 years, the performance of secondary section will increase (or might drop) after 12 years.

What we focus on at this moment is " primary section is good".

作者: Camom 時間: 10-11-29 10:18

原帖由 fredkong01 於 10-11-29 08:25 發表
kitshek,

thanks for your information. In fact, we also notice that the academic performance of St. Paul's college (secondary section) has been dropping these few years. However, we do admit that the ...

Agree very much! We are now choosing a suitable primary school for our kids which we have confidence in. No one knows what the education system will be after 6 years. On the other hand, why not thinking in a positive way that the college may have improvements after 6 years? You still have the right to choose if you don't want to stay at the college after 6 years.

[ 本帖最後由 Camom 於 10-11-29 12:12 編輯 ]

作者: artroboy 時間: 10-11-29 12:12

其實大家都知 St. paul boy 係 drop 咗, 特別近年成績係好明顯.

但以前佢都唔係一線名校呀, 老實講, 當年Net. 11, 佢都係同 St. louis & RC 係同一個 Level, 最出名係 St. pual co-ed , but st. louis 比佢 drop 得仲快之麻

, 反而 RC 近年好積極.

but 以牌子名黎講, St. pual boy 都仲係比人聽落去好聽 d.

無計.

作者: 好一個爸爸 時間: 10-11-29 12:18

原帖由 kenfu 於 10-11-26 18:46 發表

嚴格來說, 基督教可視天主教為異端, 只不過天主教在香港夠大, 無基督教的人敢出聲, 你想香港有十字軍嗎?

基督教 : 耶和華是獨一真神 ; 天主教 : 有聖母, 聖保羅, 聖彼得, 聖..... 這些 "聖 "不單是名稱咁簡單, ...

唔明, 香港D St. Paul's 咩咩物物唔係基督教o架咩????

作者: 好一個爸爸 時間: 10-11-29 12:20

仲有點解你講天主教時, 連天主都唔提, 都幾特別喎!

作者: kenfu 時間: 10-11-29 12:22

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: artroboy 時間: 10-11-29 12:27

But RC can choose other band one schools at Net. 12 in next 6 yrs. (申報. 我己 give up 咗 RC)

原帖由 kenfu 於 10-11-29 12:22 發表
RC and St Paul Boy's HKCEE result are not good around 40-50% in points 14.

If you choose their primary school because of having secondary school, you will have a great fear of their academic performa ...

作者: kenfu 時間: 10-11-29 12:30

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: KK07 時間: 10-11-30 09:26

This may be out of the topic here, but your statement really catch my attention. For interest, I read some articles regarding the background history of them and I feel your saying seems not really reviewing the fact. Copied for yr reading...
基督教，是一個相信耶穌基督為救主的一神論宗教。基督教、佛教、伊斯蘭教是世界三大宗教，估計現在全球共有15億至21億的人信仰基督教，佔世界總人口33.32%。[1][2]。最早期的基督教只有一個教會，但在基督教的歷史進程中卻分化為許多派別，主要有天主教（天主教的中文名稱乃借用中國神話中的天神──天主。中文也意譯為公教、羅馬公教。以梵蒂岡聖座為領導中心，以羅馬教皇為教會領袖的天主教也是所有基督教教派中第一大教派。）、東正教（此名也意譯為正教。以君士坦丁堡普世牧首為首，但實際各國正教教會目前仍是獨立運作的。正教是基督宗教中的第二大教派。）、基督新教（中文又常稱為基督教）三大派別，以及其他一些影響較小的派別。中文的「『基督』教」一詞時常是專指基督新教，這是中文目前的特有現象。
基督教可以指宗教信仰的內容，也可以指所有基督教教會的總和，或者所有基督徒的總和。這三者不能完全分開但又有一定的差別，在使用時如果能仔細辨明，可以避免一些不必要的爭論。

If the above saying is correct, what we usually say 基督教schools in HK are those actually belongs to 基督新教. And 基督新教were split from 羅馬天主教hundred years ago. (My 基督新教小學宗教老師told me) So, your statement "基督教可視為天主教的異端.."is very very misleading.
PS I am not a 教徒

原帖由 kenfu 於 10-11-26 18:46 發表

嚴格來說, 基督教可視天主教為異端, 只不過天主教在香港夠大, 無基督教的人敢出聲, 你想香港有十字軍嗎?

基督教 : 耶和華是獨一真神 ; 天主教 : 有聖母, 聖保羅, 聖彼得, 聖..... 這些 "聖 "不單是名稱咁簡單, ...

作者: KK07 時間: 10-11-30 09:32

Apologize that my copying of the article became garbage, for lazy persone as me, I'll, of course, not going to type them.....if you are interest, just check more info. about 基督新教as in my last message.

""If the above saying is correct, what we usually say 基督教schools in HK are those actually belongs to 基督新教. And 基督新教were split from 羅馬天主教hundred years ago. (My 基督新教小學宗教老師told me) So, your statement "基督教可視為天主教的異端.."is very very misleading."

作者: lugano 時間: 10-11-30 16:58

原帖由 artroboy 於 10-11-29 12:12 發表
其實大家都知 St. paul boy 係 drop 咗, 特別近年成績係好明顯.

但以前佢都唔係一線名校呀, 老實講, 當年Net. 11, 佢都係同 St. louis & RC 係同一個 Level, 最出名係 St. pual co-ed , but st. louis 比佢 drop 得仲快之麻 , 反而 RC 近年好積極.

but 以牌子名黎講, St. pual boy 都仲係比人聽落去好聽 d. 無計.
...

原帖由 kitshek 於 10-11-29 02:19 發表

點解仲有咁多人覺得 Paul Boy係 Dream School？

無錯，Paul Boy個名以前係好響，但而家中學部成績真係跌到慘不忍睹，你睇睇佢自己公佈嘅 2009年入大學成績：

http://www.spc.edu.hk/docs/news_from_spc_10.pdf (29頁)

入讀六大(港、中、科、理、浸、城)加嶺大只有33.8%，屬 Band 2中等水平。唔好以為係因為好多人去外國升學，因為六成幾人要讀Asso / High Dip.

單計中西區排尾四，唔好話高主教，聖類斯都開始拋離佢，Paul Boy而家只係好過聖士提反堂同樂善堂等Band 3學校。 ...

我很認同呢兩位家長, Statistical data proves……

我的小兒剛考入了聖保羅男校小一, 看到聖保羅男校中學部升大學的成績, 心情都有點兒那個, 主觀願望當然希望將來聖保羅男校整體有所進步 (See Pg. 29頁)

http://www.spc.edu.hk/docs/news_from_spc_10.pdf

Total : 71人 (2009 to 2010 form. 7 學年)
入讀八大(港/中/科/理/浸/城/嶺大/樹仁) 有 26人 (36.6%)
入讀海外大學有 12人 (16.9%)
入讀Asso / High Dip有 33人 (46.5%)

題外話, 我在 BK 另一個關於聖保羅男校的貼內,

St Paul Boys 簡介會: 大陸爸爸vs 香港爸爸 (Pg. 2, 3 and 4)
http://forum.edu-kingdom.com/viewthread.php?tid=2257381

我出左幾篇發言, 其中有點論點講關於"聖保羅男女"在香港人心中的名氣認受性高過"聖保羅男校", 都已經俾其他"聖保羅男校"家長插到我體無全膚 !!

[ 本帖最後由 lugano 於 10-11-30 17:32 編輯 ]

作者: artroboy 時間: 10-11-30 17:30

Sorry, 睇完笑咗...其實我都認同你d 講法....but 唔敢過去撑你...特別係我呢 d 考唔到既, 肯定比人插死.

原帖由 lugano 於 10-11-30 16:58 發表

我很認同呢兩位家長, Statistical data proves……

我的小兒剛考入了聖保羅男校小一, 看到聖保羅男校中學部升大學的成績, 心情都有點兒那個, 主觀願望當然希望將來聖保羅男校整體有所進步 (See Pg. 29頁)

http: ...

作者: season_sincere 時間: 10-11-30 18:09

Actually I want to point our that the standard of almost all prestigious schools in Hong Kong dropped in the recent years, due to some some governmental policies. And this is exactly why many brand-named schools changed to DSS a couple of years ago, so that they can choose some qualified and talented students, in order to maintain the 'high' standard.

In fact, studying in prestigious schools always give a better impression to other people, which helps boosting the confidence of the kids. Also, the network and bond is much stronger as students have good spirit and are regarded as a BIG family. And perhaps, they offer better resources and environment for the kids to grow and learn. These all certainly give benefit to the kids and help shape a good personalities of the kids.

More importantly, I have to point out that studying in prestigious schools never equals to having good academic results, as many of those famous schools usually admit all-rounded students, which means that some are strong in music, some are good at sports, some are academically excellence, and of course, some have good and supportive family background, etc. The schools probably admit different types of students who they think are suitable, to build a school with variety.

Just like DGS, which my daughters are studying in. It is a really good school and many parents love the school too. But I cannot deny the fact that not many students are really good academically, each of them has their own talents though. And also for DBS, a boy ranked number four in class got lower than 14 points in HKCEE, but he still got admitted back to DBS, and this is not the only case.

I believe that each kid has his/her own talents, and I really appreciate the school for giving each of them such a special and unique environment to grow. I am pretty sure that this is the same case for St. Paul's.

I don't think that statements or comments can once be made by simply judging on the school's academic results. If you are the type of parents forcing the kids to excel academically, I think that you'd better choose school focus purely on academics. But consider seriously of this is a good way to grow.

Also, parents should also play a role in nurturing their children. If your kids are going to study in some prestigious schools, do prepare that you actually have to pay more efforts in educating your kids, as teachers usually don't teach much. The teachers usually will guide the kids to learn, but not really 'teach'.

作者: lugano 時間: 10-11-30 18:56

原帖由 artroboy 於 10-11-30 17:30 發表

Sorry, 睇完笑咗...其實我都認同你d 講法....but 唔敢過去撑你...特別係我呢 d 考唔到既, 肯定比人插死.

謝謝你 Astroboy

其實今日的名氣 behind左唔緊要, 只要肯努力, 將來一定會進步, 有所提升, 呢種係我地香港人拼搏精神, core value, 跌低左, 咪起翻身, 真係好平常

有部份家長覺得我一比較兩間聖保羅, 可能 hit their nerve, 就話我十惡不赦, 又比較什麼什麼, 講真, 呢個世界, 沒有比較, 那有進步 ? 大家教小朋友, 都會話你上次拿 70 分, 下次都希望佢拿 80 分

我相信好多家長都帶小朋友參加什麼游泳/奧數/音樂比賽.......etc
呢 D 咪通通都係比較 !! 五十步笑百步......

[ 本帖最後由 lugano 於 10-11-30 19:05 編輯 ]

作者: diversity 時間: 10-11-30 20:48

我出左幾篇發言, 其中有點論點講關於"聖保羅男女"在香港人心中的名氣認受性高過"聖保羅男校", 都已經俾其他"聖保羅男校"家長插到我體無全膚 !!

http: ... [/quote]

我其實都吾想再講, 只是阁下在鄰帖帶我到這裡. 唉, 講左噉奈,尔究竟知唔知道尔被插 (用尔的語言)的原因呀!? 回應的有迈個在defend spc?? 阁下被插是因為尔表现出的自傲和勢利,特别是阁下将贵母校(self-claimed)与另一名稱相似的學校作比較時的那副嘴臉, 真教人覺得尔生出一對白x眼.唔該尔再看看motherotk的帖, 她/他正正説出重点所在, 請尔不要繼續捉错用神, 以為人地插尔的原因是為了defend spc, 本末倒置!!

作者: happyelimme 時間: 10-12-1 22:46

睇完, 你被插原因好簡單...
---你響spc嘅topic唔米講d讚美spc嘅說話, 只係1味實話實說又叫人去做街訪, 挑起parents嘅某條神經, 緊係比佢地狂插la
---你幾時聽人講過慈禧係會講道理? 只有佢鬧人/侮辱架姐, 但你講d佢唔like聽嘅野就唔可以

原帖由 lugano 於 10-11-30 16:58 發表

我很認同呢兩位家長, Statistical data proves……

我的小兒剛考入了聖保羅男校小一, 看到聖保羅男校中學部升大學的成績, 心情都有點兒那個, 主觀願望當然希望將來聖保羅男校整體有所進步 (See Pg. 29頁)

http: ...

[ 本帖最後由 happyelimme 於 10-12-1 23:49 編輯 ]

作者: gladdiesum 時間: 10-12-5 19:11

happyelimme這位喇沙媽來撐喇沙alum. 喇沙精神神聖不能褻瀆, 其他學校點講都得 !!!喇沙帝國萬歲 !!!慈禧萬歲 (不過吳知關佢mud事)!!
lugano話齋: 不喜勿插, 希望無挑起parents嘅某條神經

原帖由 happyelimme 於 10-12-1 22:46 發表
睇完, 你被插原因好簡單...
---你響spc嘅topic唔米講d讚美spc嘅說話, 只係1味實話實說又叫人去做街訪, 挑起parents嘅某條神經, 緊係比佢地狂插la
---你幾時聽人講過慈禧係會講道理? 只有佢鬧人/侮辱架姐, 但你講d佢 ...

作者: happyelimme 時間: 10-12-5 22:12

eee, 似乎我真係挑起某人條神經bor

真身去左邊呢?? 真身唔見得人??

要揾個10-12-5註冊得1分1個文章既a/c即時回post, 好急wor

.唔洗急bor, 用番個真身回post都唔怕架, 呢度d daddy mami, 多數都唔會(除左個別會員)侮辱人架!
st. paul boys萬歲!!!

st paul boys 好過st paul co-ed!!!

分身萬歲!!!

原帖由 gladdiesum 於 10-12-5 19:11 發表
happyelimme這位喇沙媽來撐喇沙alum. 喇沙精神神聖不能褻瀆, 其他學校點講都得 !!!喇沙帝國萬歲 !!!慈禧萬歲 (不過吳知關佢mud事)!!
lugano話齋: 不喜勿插, 希望無挑起parents嘅某條神經
...

作者: gladdiesum 時間: 10-12-5 23:16

eee, 轉太 ?

好難捉摸, 撐你又吳alright. 撐你wor

, 更要快

更要急

邊個侮辱你 ? 勞氣成禁 ?

原帖由 happyelimme 於 10-12-5 22:12 發表
eee, 似乎我真係挑起某人條神經bor
真身去左邊呢?? 真身唔見得人?? 要揾個10-12-5註冊得1分1個文章既a/c即時回post, 好急wor .唔洗急bor, 用番個真身回post都唔怕架, 呢度d daddy mami, 多數 ...

作者: happyelimme 時間: 10-12-5 23:49

你勞氣成點呀? 勞氣到唔敢用真身? 哈哈哈哈

原帖由 gladdiesum 於 10-12-5 23:16 發表
eee, 轉太 ?好難捉摸, 撐你又吳alright. 撐你wor , 更要快更要急
邊個侮辱你 ? 勞氣成禁 ?

作者: happyelimme 時間: 10-12-5 23:55

撐我?? 邊句撑我呀? 從閣下由註冊以來的2個文章裡, 我只能揾倒呢幾句萬歲句子與"撐"有關: 喇沙精神神聖不能褻瀆, 喇沙帝國萬歲 !!!慈禧萬歲
閣下所謂的"撐我", 嘅"我"係指咩呢?
到今天, 閣下似乎與a/c "diversity" 1樣, 仍然未攪清楚1個獨立個體, 與1個組織(e.g 辦學團體)嘅關係, 勸你攪清楚呢點先再揾分身上來自我撐場吧

原帖由 gladdiesum 於 10-12-5 23:16 發表
eee, 轉太 ?好難捉摸, 撐你又吳alright. 撐你wor , 更要快更要急
邊個侮辱你 ? 勞氣成禁 ?

作者: PoorParent 時間: 10-12-6 09:01

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: JoJo 時間: 10-12-8 09:27

版主按:
請各位能按主題發表而並非在這裡作罵戰.

如再有此情況, 違反版規者將會被禁言及封戶, 敬請注意!

[ 本帖最後由 JoJo 於 10-12-8 09:28 編輯 ]

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)